r/Flute • u/HarmonySteps • 4h ago
Buying an Instrument Advice Sankyo CF 201 vs. Altus A9 vs. Burkart Resona 150 (with B-foot) for a petite high school student?
Hi everyone,
My daughter (who is petite and starting music high school/ with regular competitions) just play-tested several step-up flutes, and we would love your advice on her impressions before making the final decision. She needs a B-foot for her program. She already ruled out full solid-silver flutes (too heavy for her right now), and she also tried Muramatsu and Haynes, neither of which clicked with her.
That left these three finalists:
- Sankyo CF 201: She loved how effortlessly the sound comes out—she literally said she feels like she "doesn't even have to blow" to get a clear, immediate tone.
- Altus A9 (formerly 907): She really liked the warm tone color, but she felt the flute was noticeably heavier in her hands compared to the others. This flute she loved the most but weight is minus for her.
- Burkart Resona 150: She liked the ergonomics and how comfortably it sat in her hands, though we know the mechanism is semi-handmade/step-up compared to Sankyo and Altus.
Given that she is petite, needs a B-foot, and will be practicing 1.5–2 hours a day, we are leaning heavily toward the Sankyo CF 201 (with Offset G and Split E mechanism)
Finally, what are your general long-term experiences with the Sankyo 201, especially since full solid-silver flutes are currently too heavy for her?
Now she has Yamaha jfl 372 with c-foot.
Thanks so much for your help!