r/FoodNYC • • 5d ago Diamonds are Forever Bravo

Guide For the last minute folks: NYC Thanksgiving Pie Spreadsheet

Post image
90 Upvotes

Hi there!

I created a spreadsheet for all the stragglers (myself included) ofThanksgiving Pie pre-orders in NYC. Sadly, NYC favorites Four and Twenty Blackbirds is sold out. Don't fret there are plenty of other options. If an item is sold out, I'd recommend visiting in person to see if any pies are available. I'm mostly familiar with Brooklyn and Manhattan bakeries so they are predominantly featured. If there are any others, please feel free to message me.


r/FoodNYC • • 6d ago

Weekly Reservation Transfer Thread

4 Upvotes

Please read the rules before commenting. Also, any type of "looking for a reservation" request is NOT ALLOWED.

  1. This thread is the only place on the subreddit for transferring restaurant reservations. If you make your own thread, it will be removed.
  2. You may transfer reservations for below or equal to face value (plus all taxes and fees) ONLY. You must clearly state both the price you paid and the price you're looking for in the post. Gouging will not be tolerated.
  3. You can only transfer reservations that are nonrefundable, ie, you cannot cancel them without forfeiting your money. If you have a refundable or free reservation and you can't make it, cancel it with the restaurant.
  4. The only reason we're allowing transfers is so people don't have to forfeit expensive pre-paid meals. If you want to buy a reservation, you are not one of these people. No posts asking to buy reservations.
  5. The mods of /r/FoodNYC accept no responsibility for these transactions. Tock and Resy both allow transfers on the website - if someone tells you otherwise it's a scam. Do your own research on your transaction before handing over any money to a third party. Check with the restaurant, check account ages, meet in person if feasible.

Note that this thread is reposted Sunday evenings.


r/FoodNYC • • 6h ago Bravo

Discussion At the risk of blowing up some favorites, here are my most underrated spots in the city.

305 Upvotes

*Disclaimers

1. "Underrated" is not the same as "totally unknown." These are places that seem to me to be under-patronized and under-hyped relative to how good they are. That said...

2. It's hard to know with full certainty how 'popular' a spot is, so I'm basing this off of how busy they were when I've gone, review counts on Google/Yelp/Beli, follower counts on Instagram, and how much I've seen them talked about here, then comparing that to how popular I personally think they deserve to be.

Lillo Cucina Italiano

The inspiration for this post. Husband and wife shop, maybe 6 tables, cash only. I've walked in at 630p on a Saturday when the weather was perfect. Pastas are insanely good; Veal tortellini is white wine sauce and lobster ravioli made me stop and say "wow," literally every time I took a bite. Prices are substantially better than other places with similar quality. Hours are somewhat limited.

Taqueria El Gallo Azteca

Probably overlooked because it's on Staten Island, but I think maybe the best tacos in the city and my wife (from Houston) agreed. Really cannot go wrong - every meat was excellent.

Lamoone Bakery

Recently getting a little more attention, but still underrated. The basque cheesecakes here are out of this world good, particularly the black sesame, though I would not sleep on the pandan which is also excellent. Lots of seasonal/rotating flavors. The lady who runs this place is amazing, and for whatever it's worth, the shop is very charming.

Slicehaus

L'Industrie alum pumping out some of the most balanced slices with light, crisp but chewy crust. I go probably once a month and have still never had to wait in line here.

Hay Hay Roasted

I prefer it over Wah Fung for roast duck and roast pork and it is a similar value (higher price but for larger portion) with no line whatsoever when I've gone.

B'Artusi

L'Artusi sister restaurant, so somewhat popular, but I've been able to get a same-day Saturday table for 4. Seems that people mostly come for drinks, but they actually have probably the best lasagna in the entire city (Yes, that includes Don Angie).

Virginia's

I can't think of another place selling a burger this good that you can just walk into or get a last minute table most days. Tied for my favorite in the city (with 4 Charles), if you are someone who is an absolute glutton for the rich and savory - one who dreams of bathing in bone marrow and caramelized onions - then you will love it.

Pop's Pizza of East Village

Old school, simple, and delicious. Basically empty every time I've gone, though has lots of Google reviews, so maybe more popular than I realize? Either way, this is what Joe's wishes it could be and yet it gets a fraction of the recognition.

Dolly's Coffee Shop

The honey bun is a maximalist experiment in just how pillow-y and gooey you can make something, and possibly the best sweet baked good in the city. Focaccias are superb and their breakfast sandwiches rule. Maybe somewhat popular based on Instagram follower count, but the only time I've seen a line there is right at opening, which is crazy for what is IMO a top 5 bakery in the city.

Philomena's Pizza

Probably a victim of location, but the plain and pepperoni slices are as good as anywhere, and I'm not sure how more people aren't dropping in as an easy stop off the 7 train.

Beijing Dumpling House

A good amount of online reviews, but basically empty when I went, and I feel it really doesn't get the attention it deserves. Duck sesame pancake is insanely good. Noodles and dumplings are very solid. Such an easy stop off if you are on your way to/from JFK, and recommend spending your money here if you have the time vs blowing it on overpriced airport food.

Joe's Italian Deli

Not sure how Casa Della gets all the attention in the Bronx when Joe's is as good as it is. To me, this place is second only to Defonte's (which is untouchable perfection) for the best Italian deli in the city. Get any sandwich with cutlets and it will be a winner.

Smashed

Probably controversial because it's a chain, and somewhat talked about, but for me this is probably the best smash burger in the city, and (at least the West Village location) is always a ghost town for some reason.

Liu Liu Sheng Jian (formerly PanBao 66)

This is a fairly popular spot in the New World Mall food court, but it is still not nearly popular enough. After just spending a week in Shanghai eating every last pan fried pork bun I could, my wife and I agreed that we didn't have a single one we liked as much as these. Value is off the charts, and despite a line typically, wait times are short. Again, it is popular, but really should be getting the level of attention that somewhere like Mei Lai Wah does.

Food Lovers Halal

In Jersey City, and slightly more expensive than some trucks, but the lamb over rice is the best in the city for my money. They sometimes skimp on white sauce a little, but that's easily fixed by asking for more, which they will happily give you.


r/FoodNYC • • 7h ago

Review Otway Bakery for the first time, good god! There's a mini- Otway empire over here!

Post image
113 Upvotes

This place is over by where Clinton Hill, Bed Stuy and Crown Heights converge. Gojuchang squash pastry. A flavor riot. One of those dishes where every bite you go "Hmm?...Mmmmmmmm."

I've eaten at their restaraunt down the block, Otway, before and was very impressed so I had to try it out. Check out both, ya'll!

https://www.otwaynyc.com/


r/FoodNYC • • 3h ago

Photo Ayam - great chicken rice, nasi lemak, and murtabak at this halal Thai-Malay family-run shop (Long Island City / Astoria)

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

Ayam - Google Maps Page

Ayam’s website - menu page (mains are $14-15, specials $15-17)

Combo chicken rice with steamed chicken and fried chicken - steamed chicken was tender and fried chicken was very crispy. It comes with a spicy fermented ginger sauce that really kicks up the flavors and a very comforting chicken broth. 

Also really enjoyed the nasi lemak (coconut rice, fried chicken, crispy anchovies, peanuts, sambal, boiled egg, and cucumber) and murtabak (ground chicken stuffed egg pancake served with pickled cucumber and onion relish), which I don’t see as often on menus.

The people working here are very nice!


r/FoodNYC • • 2h ago

Question is xian famous foods still good? visiting & want to try

39 Upvotes

i've been wanting to try but most of the things i've found on here are from 3+ years ago, wanted to see if it's still as good


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Question Old timer looking for old timer pizza, surprised at how much the city has changed

66 Upvotes

I lived here 20+ years ago and you could pop into any old Italian guy pizzeria and get a basic delicious slice anywhere.

Took the kids to Joe's last night and it's not what I remember at all.

Any suggestions on pizza places that are cheesy, greasy and not burnt (I know this is divisive in the pizza community)?

I've scoured the group previously before setting foot back in NYC. We're off for bagels and I've got my fingers crossed that these haven't changed too much.

Have a wonderful day everyone!


r/FoodNYC • • 22h ago

Review Just had an unbelievable meal at Tripoli (family-owned spot in Brooklyn) and I was practically the only customer there

Thumbnail
gallery
401 Upvotes

Not affiliated with them at all and definitely not an influencer, just had a great meal here and felt like I had to say something because seeing the dining room completely empty was quite depressing.

I tried Meat Sampler Plate, Shish Barak, and Kunafa and everything wad amazing!

There are so many mediocre places where people wait an hour because of TikTok hype, it’s wild to me that this place is sitting empty.

Do your thing NYC, show them some love.

https://www.tripolirestaurant.com/

https://www.yelp.com/biz/tripoli-restaurant-brooklyn-2

Edit: Added links


r/FoodNYC • • 9h ago

Question Need to buy a $150 gift card, can you recommend from this list?

Post image
12 Upvotes

Chase Saphire Reserve #150 credit expires before I'll have a chance to use it in-person, so these are the places a gift card purchase will work. Any and all opinions welcome, and I like everything. thanks In advance.

Hawksmoor is the only one I've been to and thought it was decent 7/10


r/FoodNYC • • 8h ago

Question Help ID'ing an Italian restaurant in the East 50s that had a huge line last night

8 Upvotes

I was walking with my family in Midtown last night, trying to get away from the Rockefeller Center mob scene as quickly as we could after one of my kids attended a birthday there. Somewhere in the east 50s between 5th Ave. and 2nd Ave. we passed a restaurant with an extremely long line outside.

I have no real interest in going there, but I'm very curious about what the restaurant was and what the hype is about. Now I'm searching Google Maps and streetview and can't find it.

It was:

- Somewhere between 52nd and 57th St. and between 5th Ave. and 2nd Ave.

- A relatively humble looking (from the outside) Italian place with a red neon light in the window and a longish name

- On the north side of a relatively soulless Midtown-y feeling street, not a spot with a lot of other restaurants and stores around

- Probably recently TikTok'd or something

I'm *pretty* sure we stayed on 52nd from 5th to Lex but there's a chance we bent north to 53rd at some point. We definitely walked north a block or two on Lex before stopping at the Shake Shack at 54th and Lex. From there we went east again to 2nd, but I'm not sure what street we took.

It seems like it should be very easy to figure out but I'm struggling.


r/FoodNYC • • 20m ago

Question Looking for Suggestions on Tasty Restaurants to Dress Nicely in?

1 Upvotes

My best friends and I have been going through a rough time lately. We've decided to go out to a nice dinner this weekend. I want to take them to a restaurant where the food is not only very good, but we can also dress ourselves up.

A classy girl's night out. I considered Casa La Femme but the reviews were mixed.

Any recommendations are welcome! We love Greek, Thai, Spanish (all kinds- Dominican, Mexican, Columbian etc), and soul food most!

Anything else is fine too, we're not picky at all!


r/FoodNYC • • 4h ago

Question Looking for the best Banana Bread in the city (unique flavor combinations)

2 Upvotes

Hello fellow foodies, I had the most delicious tea infused banana bread (I want to say Earl grey infused), but I can't remember which bakery or restaurant it might have been. Any ideas? Otherwise just recommendations for your favorite banana bread in the city would be great.


r/FoodNYC • • 3h ago

Guide Floral like peaceful and authentic cafes with history in nyc

1 Upvotes

I went to Rossa, a Mexican owned cafe, two weeks ago and that aesthetic is so grounding. They had their little tables and couches, but it picked up around 11am (as expected). Would anyone know of more options to a peaceful space and perhaps with some genuine history, like the owners or location?


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Adda Butter Chicken Experience reservation deposit

Post image
48 Upvotes

I've been trying to get the butter chicken experience reservation at Adda and looks like they removed the ability to book for it online through Seven Rooms so I reached out to them via email.

They responded to me with this, and $150 per person seems insane to me. I know that they always took a deposit to book the experience, but wasn't it like $42 per person or something. $150 seems insane.

Has anyone actually done this experience that can tell me how it was for them?


r/FoodNYC • • 5h ago

Question Planning a group coffee / brunch meetup 10 people+

1 Upvotes

Hello! I was wondering if anyone has a suggestion of a place in Manhattan for coffee or brunch that has a lot of tables so it would not be a bother if I tried to bring 10 people on a Sunday morning. I also am planning this for January so post holidays.

including price ig 😭 like average nyc coffee prices like $10 for a latte vibes


r/FoodNYC • • 21h ago

Photo Restaurants Open on Thanksgiving 2026 That Are Worth It

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

I did the research so you don't have to. I wish I was staying in NYC for Thanksgiving, these seem so yummy and no family drama lol


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Vents and Complaints Is it just me or does TSQ bagels really skimp on their schmear

12 Upvotes

I’ve been going to TSQ bagels for a while now (it’s the closest bagel shop to where I live), and over the last few times I’ve felt that whenever the amount of CC is ridiculously small for that price. This almost always happens whenever I do a bagel + CC with an add on (usually avocado)


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Discussion dinner at iara: enjoyed everything and a truly unique menu

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

lots of talk about iara with its recent opening (but if you haven't heard, helen rosner has written a piece on it recently) and i was able to have a great dinner!

TLDR: unique and exciting food i hope others can also try, but not desperately craving a second next visit

iara is very ingredient forward; all the staff are eager to explain every dish and the space is decorated on-theme as well. loved sitting there and just watching everything.

as a party of two, we left perfectly full -- not stuffed, but not thinking of food except for the meal we just had.

we had the following dishes (score/5):

  • pão de queijo (4/5)
  • grilled picanha pastel (3/5)
  • caranguejo na moranga (4/5)
  • moqueca (5/5)
  • baby picanha skewer (4/5)
  • tapicoa fries (5/5)
  • cassava cake (5/5)

the portions are decent, and you could definitely order 2 mains like the moqueca (tilefish soup) and 12oz picanha con fritas without exploding.

i was very skeptical seeing everyone rave about the steak and tapioca fries, but i after having the mini version in the baby picanha skewer special, i do regret not committing to ordering the actual picanha con fritas. the live fire really brings out the smoky seasoning and aroma of their steak. the meat is super soft and the fat cap isn't overwhelming or wrapped in sinew. the tapicoa fries are truly unique with crispness and chewiness, and the acai "ketchup" (there's no ketchup) was addicting with its acidic and sweet glaze.

the moqueca came with two small bowls of rice and two small filets of tilefish. the first bite of everything together was really memorable. reminiscent of a malay/sporean laksa with the creaminess. but there's an extra layer of funk and earthiness that made it really interesting. definitely a must order.

the squash and crab with parmesan seems like a strange combo but it rounds out well with the herby oil dressing. admittedly it does become a mush without textural contrast aside from the seeds.

pastel was just ok. the pastry was more interesting than the filling which was a bit dry. but the accompanying sauce was amazing.

pao de queijo is a goated bread to begin with so no notes; they executed it very well. a more gluttonous me would have ordered 2 (or just ordered the other bread) to dip in all the sauces and juices of the other dishes.

cassava cake was excellent. the caramel has a nice stickiness and subtle bitterness that balances well. the cake has flakes of coconut in it, which i enjoy but others may not. ice cream had an amazing tang to it that really balanced everything out. but the plate this came in and the spoons they gave were awful choices in terms of eatability.

amazing vibes, friendly service. didn't feel rushed by the time limit despite waiting a bit for the mains to come out. also the house hot sauce is amazing!!

bill came out to around 250 total but this was a really unique menu that i would recommend people try. not dying to run back and eat it again but i can definitely see myself stopping by alone just to have a picanha con fritas at the bar.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question The GOAT of NYC Lunches - is it still a thing out there?

Post image
284 Upvotes

About 20 years ago there were these (I think Mongolian) places where you would grab a styrofoam container and fill it up with raw ingredients. It was like beef, pork, vegetables, noodles and sauces.

You would hand it to these guys who cooked it on this huge round flattop. Then you would take it up to pay and it was based on weight. I would legit fall asleep on my desk afterwards. And no matter how much you crammed in there it was like max 12 bucks. I hope this is still a thing?


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Now that corkbuzz is gone - where to get low markup champagne?

16 Upvotes

What are best places for “relatively” low wine markups- corkbuzz “sell at retail” was amazing - what else is out there? Not a question about low price, happy to buy the good stuff, but rather about the mark-up/selection ratio. The question is about champagne, but obviously wine is of interest as well


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Mis Latinos, tell me about your favorite Sancocho and where to find it.

10 Upvotes

I’ve only had Colombian Sancocho and love it. Want to try some different kinds with the weather about to get colder. Open to anywhere in Manhattan or Queens. Thanks!


r/FoodNYC • • 2d ago

Review Comfortland's "Black Friday" is a fully-loaded planet of a sandwich

Thumbnail
gallery
224 Upvotes

https://hellocomfortland.com/

Their "Black Friday" interpretation of a Thanksgiving sandwich seems to be more well known than some others, but I'd never tried it before. When I went to their LES location last year, I only found their excellent Thanksgiving egg rolls--not sure if I was too early, or if that location just didn't have the sandwich that year. Anyway, it did this year, so I was finally able to cross it off my list. (I should mention that they're running both the egg rolls and the sandwich at the same time!)

Fried chicken, chicken sausage stuffing, red cabbage slaw, cranberry, and spicy mayo on a brioche bun. This is a packed boulder of a sandwich, and I knew I'd be dealing with leftovers. It's a loud sandwich, too: the two main flavors at work here are the salty fried chicken and the sweetness of the slaw and cranberry, and they balance out like they're supposed to. The stuffing gets a little lost in the mix but is still very tasty on its own, and the mayo provides yet more richness. One thing I'd forgotten about Comfortland is that they always have out a handful of random hot sauces, and if you like things spicy, this sandwich is a good candidate for those.

I was puzzled about the brioche bun, because that's probably the worst kind of bun to use for a dense, heavy sandwich like this. I'm always annoyed when I see it used for burgers. It falls apart, and practically vanishes after refrigeration and reheating (and there's no way I was going to finish this in one sitting). You don't need the sweetness of brioche here either, since that's covered by the slaw and cranberry. A standard NYC kaiser roll would work very well, though I'm sure a restaurant would want a more "luxe" bread. There are better options here.

This might be my last Thanksgiving sandwich for the year. I was thinking about trying Poulet Sans Tête's WV location this weekend, or seeing if I could snag Court Street Grocers' sandwich (which has sweet potato and sausage gravy!), but the other side of all this sandwich sampling is that I'm kind of poultried-out, to the point where I'm not even sure I'll do turkey for the actual holiday. Right now I just want a pile of nachos or a bowl of curry or something.


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Does Fairway sell "mixed peel" (British dried citrus peel for Christmas pudding)?

4 Upvotes

I know they sell a lot of British stuff but do they sell that?


r/FoodNYC • • 1d ago

Question Where can I find Turkish mercimek/isigolin in NYC?

3 Upvotes

Everyone loves the grill, why not, I’m nuts about the mercimek/isigolin corbasi. Where does it good? Bodrum has a decent lentil soup but it doesn’t quite scratch the itch. Help a former resident of Germany out.