r/ForgottenIsland • u/Wumbolo83 • 21h ago
| Theories The day they met Spoiler
My theory is that either Jo or Raissa doesn't exist and is an imaginary friend.
While watching the scene revisiting the principal's office, I thought the reveal would be that Raissa was Jo's imaginary friend. Now upon re-reading the transcript of that scene, I feel Jo could also be Raissa's imaginary friend.
This would be a heavy topic for a children's film (as it would imply delusionally believing an imaginary friend is real) but it would be consistent with the story. Maybe it would've helped with the popularity, like the less child-friendly film The Lion King and a finale episode from Amphibia. It would mean we have an unreliable narrator, but it would be more plausible in real life than Nakali existing.
The way the final memory being revisited was the day Jo and Raissa met seemed to me set up for such a reveal. The dialogues and scenes appear like they would if it was going to be revealed. Jo had been bullied by her classmates and probably had no friends, so in real life she would've likely imagined fictional friends. In that scene Raissa tells Jo, "Without you, I don't think I'd have any friends, let alone my best friend." This kinda means that Raissa also hasn't had any friends.
I really like how FI explores friendship in a unique way, so this is just an attempt to discuss some of these themes that I believe deserve a discussion.