I'm increasingly frustrated by the enormous gap between what Freemasonry claims to teach and how so many Freemasons actually behave.
We belong to an institution that speaks endlessly about brotherly love, relief, truth, tolerance, integrity, charity, self-improvement, and the moral duties we owe to one another. The symbolism is beautiful. The philosophical teachings can be genuinely profound. The rituals invite us to examine ourselves, confront our imperfections, and become better human beings.
And yet, sometimes I wonder whether most of us have learned anything from them at all.
Just look at this subreddit.
How often do we see brothers complaining about the moral mediocrity of their fellow Masons? About the complete lack of commitment in their lodges? About brothers who do absolutely nothing while a handful of exhausted members carry the entire burden of keeping the lodge alive? About people who love wearing the regalia, collecting titles, and being addressed by impressive-sounding names but somehow disappear whenever there's actual work to be done?
How many posts have we read from brothers who are simply burned out? Men who joined Freemasonry looking for fraternity, meaning, and personal growth, only to find themselves compensating for everyone else's irresponsibility?
And that's just the organizational dysfunction.
Recently, we've also seen people who aren't Freemasons sharing experiences of racism involving members of the Craft. And frankly, it's not as though openly discriminatory attitudes are particularly difficult to find in the comments of this very subreddit.
Then there's the astonishing hostility that emerges whenever a woman initiated into another Masonic tradition dares to participate in a discussion here.
You don't have to recognize women's Freemasonry as regular under your jurisdiction's rules. You don't have to agree with its legitimacy. But how on earth does that justify treating another human being with contempt?
Since when did defending Masonic landmarks require abandoning basic human decency?
It's remarkable how quickly some brothers can go from lecturing others about tolerance and brotherly love to behaving like playground bullies the moment someone challenges their understanding of what Freemasonry should be.
And then there's the internal politics.
The gossip. The petty rivalries. The personal vendettas. The obsession with offices and recognition. The little circles of influence. The backstabbing disguised as concern for the institution. The brothers who preach virtue in the temple and engage in the most disgraceful behavior the moment they step outside it.
Sometimes it feels as though Freemasonry has perfected the art of providing beautiful moral language to people who have absolutely no intention of living by it.
And perhaps what frustrates me most is the emotional imbalance of it all.
You give Freemasonry your time, your energy, your intellectual commitment, your affection, your loyalty, and sometimes a significant part of your personal life. You genuinely believe in the possibility of building something meaningful with other people who supposedly share your ethical aspirations.
And what do you get in return?
Sometimes genuine friendship, certainly. Sometimes extraordinary experiences and people who really do embody the principles of the Craft.
But far too often, you get disappointment, exhaustion, indifference, hypocrisy, and the bitter realization that the people calling you "brother" may not be particularly interested in behaving like one.
And no, I don't expect Freemasons to be perfect. That would contradict the very premise of working on the rough ashlar.
But there's an enormous difference between being an imperfect human being genuinely trying to improve and being someone who uses the language of virtue as a substitute for actually practicing it.
Being a rough ashlar is not a lifelong excuse for refusing to pick up the tools.
What bothers me is that we seem to have normalized this contradiction. We accept that lodges are full of petty politics, that brothers will let each other down, that discrimination is just something we have to deal with, and that the few people who actually care will eventually burn themselves out trying to keep everything together.
And somehow we're supposed to regard all of this as an unfortunate but inevitable part of the Masonic experience.
Why?
If our rituals, symbols, and teachings are supposed to transform us morally, shouldn't we be asking some very uncomfortable questions about why that transformation so often seems absent?
What is the point of spending years studying the virtues if we cannot demonstrate them in our relationships with other human beings?
What is the point of calling someone a brother if that word carries no meaningful ethical obligation?
What is the point of building a symbolic temple of humanity if we cannot even build a lodge where people treat one another with dignity?
I still believe there is something extraordinarily valuable in Masonic philosophy. In fact, that's precisely why all of this makes me so angry.
I'm not disappointed because I expected Freemasonry to be perfect. I'm disappointed because I expected Freemasons to take Freemasonry seriously.
And increasingly, I find myself wondering whether the greatest obstacle to the ideals of Freemasonry is the behavior of Freemasons themselves.