r/GTA6unmoderated • • 19h ago

I die inside a little every time my morality level drops for killing enemies in main missions.

Like how does it make any sense that I can get ambushed by 100 gang members all shooting at me, but If i shoot back and kill them, I get a a message saying I'm being too aggressive? It's just completely unnecessary, and takes a lot of the sandbox aspect of GTA away.

In a vaccuum, this is like a 9/10 game. But as a GTA game, it feels like a 6/10.

2.3k Upvotes

795 comments sorted by

588

u/CoolWhipLuke 19h ago

Aside from the debate about whether it should exist in GTA: The morality system is way too aggressive. There shouldn't be a penalty when you're attacked first.

157

u/MakavelitheDon71 11h ago

Also people die in gunfights, not every killing shot was intended or an execution

148

u/Propaslander 10h ago • Bravo

Luckily my non-lethal shotgun blast to the abdomen which left them face down in the ocean didn't affect my morality at all

But hey if I headshot that Columbian cartel member who attacked me first then I am irredeemable

17

u/catcuddlezzz 5h ago

Right, if I shoot their limbs into oblivion (it take a lot of bullets to try to get a “good guy” rating) I let them bleed out slowly and painfully, prolonging their suffering until they die, and that’s good, but a quick death to the head, is bad.

And they’re gang members trying to kill me

I like that there is a system of this, but some of the calls made, make me scratch my head

29

u/BedRiddenWizard 9h ago

Holy fuck I've been hunting and headshotting Kingfishers without a second thought.

36

u/Joaaayknows 9h ago

Go pet dogs. It reverses it. That’s my wife’s contribution to my playthrough

12

u/Adventurous_Dark5127 6h ago

has anyone tried saying howdy to the townsfolk and releasing fish?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/voujon85 8h ago

Colombian*

8

u/wookieesgonnawook 7h ago

No no, he's from DC.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

36

u/i_t_d 12h ago

it's similar to defending yourself in V Online against mk2 monkeys - you get bad sport for that lol

40

u/Toni-Roni 10h ago • Bravo

Someone else explained this in another comment, it’s not a penalty when you’re attacked first. There’s 3 categories you get points towards, Hardened, Psycho, and Professional. When you kill people in self defense you get points toward the “Hardened” category, which make sense. Even killing people in self defense would definitely “harden” you over time. Killing innocents for no reason gives you a true penalty, points towards Psycho.

21

u/bigweb52 10h ago

Not true . Just did the hospital escape and every single person is trying to kill me . Any of them I killed out right got me a psycho emoji . I’m in a Fn wheel chair trying to escape .

33

u/YelloPerson 9h ago

I'm pretty sure you shot the civilians who are running around if you're getting psycho points. Some of them were hard to distinguish

9

u/notdragoisadragon 9h ago

or killing enemies on the ground writhing in pain

14

u/Either-Swimming-3761 8h ago

Ghost of yotei taught me to end their suffering

11

u/5ma5her7 10h ago

"But have you considered just git gud?"

Seriously, I am god damned playing a GTA, not Ready or Not.

6

u/AlexeiFraytar 7h ago

Even in ready or not plenty of people including me want to mod out the "wow you cant just execute people" dumb rule. I dont care about the S rank, but can my teammates wait until the court martial to execute me when i step out of line?

8

u/DivineSisyphean 10h ago

I’m curious about this. I’m a ways past that now, but killing people there didn’t give me points towards “psycho”.

Are you sure they were counted as such?

5

u/Colley619 5h ago

Nope, you were shooting civilians in the hospital if you got the psycho emoji.

2

u/whendoesOpTicplay 5h ago

Bruh and when you’re in the ambulance I was trying to shoot the tires, but the aim-assist defaulted to the cops heads 😂 no fair

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/5ma5her7 10h ago

Same, the only game I knew that ever used a similar system that your morality is being lowered for attacking people actively killing you is Metro series.

But even for them, killing bandits (as long as they are not surrendered) is still morality neutral.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Gta6MePleaseBrigade 1h ago

I accidentally hoped on a separate bike than Lucia during a mission and it took me half an entire chapter to get it back up only for it to stay down permanently for the game glitching and killing him and registering it as me running him over somehow despite me being off the bike we were on. What a shit show.

2

u/JaggedEdgeRow 7h ago

There’s only a penalty for that if you’re at the professional tier on the morality system.

Anything below that there’s zero penalty for self-defense.

1

u/mrking944 4h ago

I got the message when I was driving my boat through swamp lands and birds weren't getting out of the way fast enough 😅 They need more non lethal and stealth options to balance out the morality.

1

u/atreyu84 10h ago

It's not a penalty.

→ More replies (34)

90

u/Relevant_Mail_1292 19h ago

Affects your ending apparently btw

107

u/knightofsparta 14h ago

That’s straight up bullshit lol why am I penalized for killing enemies in missions.

43

u/Propaslander 10h ago

I'm penalised for animals running into my fucking car too

13

u/5ma5her7 9h ago

"Have you considered driving slower?"

3

u/Colley619 5h ago

You’re not. Everyone is just misunderstanding because they want to complain. Killing enemies gives you the “hardened” status only, which doesn’t result in the “bad” ending. The game doesn’t considering killing enemies bad whatsoever.

→ More replies (40)

5

u/44dqm 8h ago

well thats fucking terrible

→ More replies (2)

81

u/GreatHateCampaign 10h ago

The whole system sounds weirdly restrictive for a GTA game

31

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 8h ago

Especially because non lethal is so half baked. There aren’t nearly as many tools to succeed.

9

u/GreatHateCampaign 8h ago

Reminds me of Dishonored. The game punished you for playing lethal, but didn't provide you very many interesting tools to play that way and the game was arguably more boring to play that way, especially since the tools of lethality were more plentiful and interesting

5

u/DollarAmount7 7h ago

And the dismemberment was so satisfying. I loved using the wire trap things to turn people into piles of body parts lol

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JohnIsKillNo 7h ago

Yeah but I feel like that's almost kind of the point of the narrative in Dishonored. Do you stay dishonored, chopping up all your enemies? Or do you take the harder, slower way and let them live. Does that make sense?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/luchajefe 9h ago

They must have pulled it from RDR, but... there's a reason it belongs there and not here.

4

u/2017Champs 6h ago

The dumb part is even Red Dead doesn’t punish you for killing enemies during missions unless it’s one of those important cut scene decision making events. It’s so dumb how restrictive the game is with killing enemies.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Colley619 8h ago

It’s not restrictive at all. You can do all the things you could normally do and more. OP misunderstands the criminal profile tracker and it’s not their fault; rockstar did not explain it well enough. You are totally fine killing gang members and the game does not punish you for it.

5

u/Snowballz3000 7h ago

But it’s not, because you don’t get punished for it at all. You can play how you want

6

u/sapphoseros 7h ago

Exactly. In a way it’s the opposite of restrictive because it makes your psycho behavior have a larger impact on the actual game, making your gameplay matter more. I don’t think they designed the game to make a psycho playthrough any less fun than the alternatives, but the fact that the label exists makes people feel like the game is punishing them

→ More replies (7)

1

u/maratonininkas 7h ago

The stupidest thing is that you can overtake a car wrong and they start shooting you. Meanwhile you must follow these stupid rules and sneak around everywhere... The amount of times i died just because i hit someone and then failed to escape their roadrage.....

It's like the world is GTA, but the gameplay is Metro redux

1

u/Dancing-Sin 6h ago

It’s not.

18

u/TmeltZz 9h ago

My only compliant about this game is this stupid system.

180

u/Attacking_Yoshi 13h ago edited 6h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I wonder if people dont fully understand the morality system. I haven't dug into it im depth yet but it doesnt feel like the sliding scale of high/low honor in red dead. It seems to act more as a triangle scale between "hardened", "psycho", and the good one i don't remember the name of.

Shooting and killing gang members that come after you? More hardened points, playing with animals and doing kind things for strangers, more good points, run over 80 pedestrians and blow up the town = more psycho points.

The game isnt saying youre a bad person for fighting back and robbing hostile gang folks. But it is saying your characters are becoming more and more used to violence and killing to those who come after them.

Edit: after reading through some extra comments and bring bold enough to Google info on GTA 6. Theres actually 5 criminal indicators not just 3. So jts a pentagram scale instead of a triangle.

72

u/Comosellamark 11h ago

Violent psycho, hardened criminal, and professional

18

u/JellyKidd1066 10h ago

Don't forget the final one, Irredeemable

5

u/Comosellamark 10h ago

Haven’t gotten that one lol

5

u/Ajaxmass413 7h ago

You get irredeemable for going full psycho all the time. And they mean irredeemable, it's permanent for the rest of the playthrough.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Attacking_Yoshi 11h ago

So is it Professional points you get for interacting with animals and the what not? Thank you for reminding me the name

27

u/Comosellamark 11h ago

You get it for non lethally knocking out enemies

9

u/darkoblivion000 8h ago

Starting to sound more like hitman than gta lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

36

u/Massive-Tower-7731 12h ago

If this is true, it would make a lot of sense. Killing of any kind, even in self defense, should harden you even if it's acceptable non-psycho behavior.

20

u/Skyhawk_85541 11h ago

The system is a combination of lethal vs non lethal and measured vs measured force. Like during a robbery if someone pulls a gun on you and starts shooting youre punished less for killing them than if they were unarmed and you killed them. In the same way you are rewarded more for not harming a shop keeper at all as opposed to kneecapping them or knocking them out. Its all measured force mixed with morality and im not sure why people are having trouble understanding it

→ More replies (10)

8

u/Attacking_Yoshi 12h ago

I'll double check when I get back home today, because I saw a pop up yesterday while playing that Psycho and Hardened points are granted for different things and you get different bonuses depending on which state youre currently in. Like psycho status granted, I think, a focus bonus on headshots

→ More replies (1)

17

u/anxietywizard 11h ago

It doesn't even sound like a "morality" system, it's more of a style tracker 

5

u/Alternative-Roll-112 9h ago

That's exactly what it is. There is no morality, you are a criminal. It just tells you what kind of a criminal you are, and a lot of people are mad that the game is correctly telling them they are psychotic. If you want the game to label you a professional, act like one.

5

u/murderously-funny 9h ago

Except it effects your ending and you only get the best ending if you have enough of the good boy points

5

u/Carbon_Paste 7h ago

what is the best ending without spoiling it LOL -- seems like its just a different cut scene at the end? and the cops are more aggressive and dont let you surrender but they never used t let you surrender anyway? its weird people are worried about the record in GTA lol go blow shit up who cares about surrendering and who cares about the cut scene at the end I dont give an F if they end up happy or not its a fake story LOL i wantto blow shit up and go on cop chases not hold hands and go grocery shopping --- F THE RATING IGNORE IT AND DO WHAT YTOU WAHT if anythign when I see the psycho rating it encourages me to blast away more LOL

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Intelligent_Car_9877 6h ago

Only irredeemable effects the ending. And the main difference between each of the levels is how cops react to you, and what you get focus for. When you're hardened, you get focus for stealth kills. When youre Violent Criminal, headshots get you more focus.

The morality system is low impact, especially when you consider to get irredeemable, you have to go out of your way to kill a lot of people and animals, particularly cats and dogs.

2

u/TheForeHeadbaybay 7h ago

I dont think it does. The tip bar literally said it just affects response from cops and how they treat you at star levels.

As far as I know, the relationship between the 2 is the only thing that has an outcome on certain cut scenes

3

u/ChristopherRubbin 7h ago

I think the only one that might impact the ending is irredeemable but I could be wrong

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/yun6mako 9h ago

Having it effect your endings is way too far. I shouldn’t have to hold back in the cinematic set piece firefights just so I can get the good ending. The endings should be based on story based choices alone. This game already has enough tedious busy work to do outside of the “walking on eggshells” type combat system they implemented. In past GTAs these action set pieces felt like a reward for all the slow walking busy work we have to put up with, and now it just feels like more busy work for anyone who wants a happy/good ending. Just one of many stupid decisions they made on this 7/10 game that should’ve been an easy 10.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/vogel927 12h ago

I’m starting to think that the main story, and how everything you do connects back to it, is just too complicated for some people to follow.

16

u/Fire_and_icex22 11h ago

No, it's not, it's just that this isn't what GTA players were expecting in the least

→ More replies (11)

3

u/Attacking_Yoshi 12h ago

If I discount the people that just post false info to generate views, I truly believe many people bad mouthing the game are either adopting others opinions as their own. Or played the first hour and turned it off.

I feel like these are the same groups of people that said RDR2 was to slow.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dealyllama 10h ago

But I want to be professional and they say it's possible so not letting us be that is a bit saying you could be a better person if you jump through whatever hoops are required.

Problem is those hoops are totally unclear and baddies have a disturbing tendency to bend over such that body shots suddenly turn into head shots. On top of that body shots sometimes are just fatal in a way I still don't quite understand. I go back to OPs question, why are they even counting these fights against us. There are waves of people trying very hard to kill us; why are we being called less than professional for stopping them?

I get it's a somewhat self imposed lack of fun but they're building in reinforcement that's just confusing and in some ways for me anti-fun.

2

u/Attacking_Yoshi 10h ago

I mean... I hear what your saying. In my view if the interaction has turned fire fight im past the point of worrying about body shots vs hesdshots. If my shots connect and the enemies drop non fatally then sweet.

Now I havent figured out a reliable method tk stick up shops and keep control without getting swarmed by cops by the time ive got the loot and ready to go. Robbed a pawn shop last night with 3 store clerks and 1 customer. Tried to intimidate the clerks to drop their guns by aiming at the customer. Didn't work.

They all opened fire, had to kill all 3, gunshots got called in and at that point I probably shouldnt have wasted time trying to grab anything and should have written it off as a lost cause.

But I stayed. Gave the cops enough time to post up out front blocking my car, tried to escape through the back and split up but the cops had time to set up road blocks, spike traps, and a helicopter. All because I took too long.

The system wasnt flawed or to difficult to understand. I took a risk and it didnt work out. Eventually the shop will regenerate, I'll be able to try again but instead of going through the front and holding them up. I now know theres a back door, I know theres cameras and an alarm I can turn off in the office and I can do it all before going in to get the jewelry and cash.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TheNastyNug 10h ago

This is exactly how it works, it’s not a morality system, it’s tracking what kind of criminal you are. Are you a psycho that kills everyone? A hardened criminal that kills and maims, or a professional who knocks people out or incapacitates them?

3

u/Rodmeister36 6h ago

I feel like a true professional in this industry would kill them, but I get your point

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Attacking_Yoshi 10h ago

Honestly I dont know if there is a chart in game that shows where you land but if there was it would make it so easy to explain. Your not punished... Just adopting a different style momentarily.

Ive been able to get through a few gang operations quietly and get away with all the loot and no cops... Just wish I knew of an easier way to deal with groups quietly

2

u/Botcher23 8h ago

Go to the main menu > Jason + Lucia and you can see current profile. Go to the start menu and select Help to find where it details the different profiles, their meaning, pros/cons. Influences several things

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Biggem64 7h ago

Yeah I like to think it’s more just like an icon that indicates your play style more than rdr2 honor system

1

u/Skyz-AU 5h ago

I've killed lots of people but I don't think I've ever gotten anything worse than hardened, as unsatisfying as not executing sometimes is i just avoid it.

1

u/ScoobyWithADobie 4h ago

Close. You get good points and then you get points for professional criminal, hardened criminal, violent criminal and psycho.

Psycho points only for unnecessary violence. Like shooting an already taken out person, killing innocents, knocking people out and burning them alive etc.

Professional and hardened have this beige/yellow devil icon.

Violent the purple one.

Psycho the pale purple nearly grey one.

Too much psycho and you become irredeemable which means you can’t raise the level again and cops show no restrain and just fire to kill.

1

u/Mmaibl1 11h ago

You can just shoot them in the legs/shoot the tires/etc. The shooting reticle flashes yellow when they have been incapacitated

→ More replies (7)

15

u/JPLoseman 14h ago

lol not so much the morality, but I went into the gun store to stock up because I was going to hit one of the Kolt bros places. As I was coming out, they pulled up and jumped me. I ran back in the gun store. They said "alright we'll come get you". They all come in and start shooting at me. I take them all out and the damn gun store owner shot and killed me after!

87

u/edg3rrrR 19h ago

The system is absolutely ridiculous. What is more ridiculous is that the ending you get in the story is based on your morality level.

1

u/ExoticBamboo 2h ago

Why do you want the good ending? The story js supposed to finish with a bad one, but if you really care it's fine that they force you to play in a certain way

0

u/DJ_RealDyl 11h ago edited 7h ago

They already explained this. Your ending is influenced but it isn’t good vs bad endings. It’s influenced by your savings towards your child, your morality, and the individual choices you make. You can still have a “good” ending by being a hardened criminal and vice versa. It isn’t black and white

5

u/ninjablaze 8h ago

If you’re locked into the psycho status, you are also hard locked out of the only good ending.

6

u/Maleficent-Fox7513 7h ago

Ure confidently wrong. U get locked out of the only good ending if ure a hardened psycho 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Mygwah 7h ago

The savings for your child? Jesus fucking christ. What has this franchise become?

2

u/hotboii96 3h ago

You just pray to God Cyberpunk sequel deliver. GTA as we all know it have been compromised

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Historical-Jump 5h ago

shut up incel /s

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Toni-Roni 10h ago

Someone else explained this in another comment, it’s not a penalty when you’re attacked first. There’s 3 categories you get points towards, Hardened, Psycho, and Professional. When you kill people in self defense you get points toward the “Hardened” category, which make sense. Even killing people in self defense would definitely “harden” you over time. Killing innocents for no reason gives you a true penalty, points towards Psycho.

9

u/UrNixed 9h ago

that was just their theory, not necessarily how the system works.

-5

u/-Soggy-Potato- 15h ago

Worked fantastically in Rdr2

62

u/BingusMeister7 15h ago

Yeah because killing enemies didn’t affect your morality, and also they gave you a couple opportunities near the end of the game to dramatically raise your morality with just a few choices so you could get the good ending

37

u/you-can-kiss-my-axe 13h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

Also, a morality system makes infinitely more sense in RDR than GTA to begin with since "Redemption" is in the title and the climaxes in both games are all about Arthur and John leaving their outlaw lives behind them.

GTA on the other hand has always had 'you can do cartoonishly evil shit all the time and get away with it as long as you don't die/get arrested' as its biggest appeal. Being a violent, ruthless criminal IS the game. Even a more sympathetic protagonist like Vic and Niko have to be violent thugs because they have to do it for the sake of their families.

8

u/5ma5her7 10h ago edited 9h ago

Same, GTA is always about freedom. You can just do whatever bullshit you want out of the story and suffer zero consequence from them. (As long as you don't get killed or arrested, hell, even you get killed or arrested, you at most lose all your weapons and a few hundred bucks).

Even gta4, the previous most choice based entry of the series, doesn't judge your morality at all for your choices, apart from the deal/revenge one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/SolemnEmberGames 10h ago

RDR2 was about redemption, literally in the name.

GTA is about crime and informally about being a violent psychopath.

Two different themes

8

u/Proof-Resolution-942 12h ago

Sure but they’re different games. GTA’s core themes for decades have been reckless violence and unrelenting satire. This system puts a damper the latter. Whether you like it or not is a matter of preference but it’s undeniable that it has changed the feel of the game.

4

u/SenorPinchy 10h ago

The game vastly overvalues the morality of shooting a dude three times in yellow spots. That's the immersion killer of this system for me.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ElGoddamnDorado 7h ago

If I wanted to play an RDR game, I'd play one.

12

u/Edgerusher63 12h ago

Yeah, lets compare red dead REDEMPTION with GTA. People like you are the problem of gaming today.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/BaerMinUhMuhm 5h ago

Its ridiculous that there are different endings depending on how you play the game? Multiple endings is a bad thing now?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Totoronyx 13h ago

There are like 10 endings or something. I dont ignore the system.  I do my best to play how I would. If i hate an ending I guess I can try again. 

5

u/ninjablaze 8h ago edited 5h ago

Kinda. There’s really only 3 and half. With the half added to the third one being the only good ending. And you can get permanently locked out of it with a locked in psycho status.

1

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 8h ago

99.9 is the same either way. I’ll just watch the post credit scene on YouTube assuming that’s all it is

54

u/Ok_Complaint1379 19h ago

The thing is they can't even patch it because it impacts the game's ending. I hope when the PC version comes out we can mod it so it doesn't fucking matter.

69

u/Zuuey 18h ago

They absolutely can patch it, they can make certain enemies flagged to not trigger a morality loss.

Or if they don't want to do that they also can make self defense in itself not trigger morality losses.

Many simple ways to fix it imo.

5

u/Ok_Complaint1379 18h ago

It still doesn't fix the issue that your actions in free roam are still going impact the campaign.

6

u/WhatIfThatThingISaid 13h ago

So just save the game and do your free roam massacres and then reload the save. Not hard. 

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

1

u/murderously-funny 9h ago

Litterally all they need to do: “hostiles don’t trigger a morality loss unless you brutalize or execute wounded enemies.”

You go John wick cleaning, precisely, and quickly popping heads only on hostile targets and active threats? Congrats! Your set for the good ending!

You go Trever Philips mass murdering, brutalizing bodies, blowing off limbs, and generally being a psychopath? Bad ending!

14

u/SatisfactionMoney255 10h ago

Plug everyone in the face, the characters don't deserve a happy ending. The kid is better off without them.

7

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 8h ago

This is my approach too. Even on the good path they should not be parents lol

6

u/Fazlija13 12h ago

Literally one of the few complaints I have about the game, too aggressive and when you get to one point you cannot return it back

1

u/HighEyeMJeff 11h ago

That's not how it works. The indicator you see doesn't tell you that you are going down a path.

It reflects the ACTION you just did. If you walk down the street and blow off someone's head with a shotgun the game says "hey thats some psycho shit" and shows you the psycho icon. Keep doing that and you go to psycho profile.

Kill gang members shooting you? It shows the hardened icon. Kill an already incapacitated gang member? Might show psycho maybe if you throw a molotov on them or something but only violent if you shoot them in the head with a revolver.

3

u/Used-Persimmon-367 10h ago

Nah, there is a third option. Professional, Hardened, and Irredeemable. The game says being too bad for too long and you’ll turn Jason and/or Lucia irredeemable. It seems once irredeemable, it can’t be changed, and the game warns this will have an impact on story/endings.

16

u/Much-Background9397 10h ago edited 10h ago

I agree, I'm loving the game but I'm not a fan of this Criminal Profile System, it feels like R* wanted RDR2's Honour system, but it feels WAY too aggressive at pushing the player to play this unnatural non-lethal playstyle when it makes very little sense and that playstyle is kinda...uninteresting if that is all you play as.

...Like, if the game wants you to play less than lethally, I'm never gonna use stuff like Grenades, Rocket Launchers or weapons that aren't highly precise, high damage so I don't accidently kill a bunch of goons.

I'm in Missions where hordes of enemies are indiscriminately shooting at me first with complete disregard to the civilians around me, the game pretty much punishes you for not playing unnaturally and going for quick efficient lethal takedowns.

Imagine John Wick getting a stern talking too after shooting each unnamed henchman after shooting them in the head after they came at him with a shotgun...

6

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 8h ago

For me it’s a lot easier to just embrace the dark side and not give a fuck. I don’t know the endings but I just assume we aren’t getting our kid back and most likely both die a tragic death. It seems fitting to go down in a storm of bullets.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/GuldursTV90 10h ago

This is my biggest gripe with GTA 6. The system is disgusting and goes against the very idea of ​​GTA. I want to be a force of chaos and a destroyer of civilians.

3

u/ToddBung 6h ago

Literally nothing is stopping you from doing that though, except for the color of the dumb little face that pops up every once in awhile.

2

u/GuldursTV90 5h ago

Apart from the punishing ending of the game, it's really nothing.

3

u/AgitatorsAnonymous 4h ago

Bonnie and Clyde were gunned down in a vehicle, by the Feds, without exiting the vehicle and with no warning. This happened because they were psychopaths. Rockstar is telling the exact story they want to tell.

2

u/OutsideGanache3449 2h ago

You want to be a force of chaos and a destroyer of civilians and be celebrated at the end with a good ending?

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Beaniepie9859 19h ago

I'll preface by saying I genuinely LOVE the game but the netflix level writing and little tiny details like this is what stops it from being the GOAT for me. 

Luckily there's so much in the game I love, usually I can't look past bad writing and characters but I am still having a blast and enjoying it more than 5. 

3

u/ashif1233 10h ago

the game is packed with content and super fun but i can’t take the story seriously, some characters are funny but that’s it

→ More replies (1)

10

u/vektorog 13h ago

i'm just glad it isn't too hard to recover it. like i got jason from psycho back to non-lethal in a handful of missions and side quests

35

u/DogManDogDayz 14h ago edited 10h ago

Thats my views of this game also.

If this wasn’t a GTA game, Id literally call it one of the best 3rd person, open world shooters ever created.

But as a GTA game, all of this morality nonsense bores the hell out of me. 

→ More replies (11)

4

u/feldoneq2wire 13h ago

Grand Theft Aura

4

u/AmphibianInner1646 6h ago

rockstar should have made headshots less satisfying if they don't want me doing it

10

u/SLO_LionHeart 9h ago

Looks like I wont play the game then. I hated RDR2 because of chore simulator and honour system.

9

u/JPLoseman 14h ago

Are people actually paying attention to the morality?

12

u/Solid-Interaction726 13h ago

I am primarily because the endings are partially tied to it

1

u/i_t_d 12h ago

Jesus Christ, I was so sure I can do my favourite GTA things in next GTA that is fuck hookers inbetween of flying Scramjet all around and doing goofy stuff

→ More replies (13)

6

u/thehealer1010 11h ago

Oh, so now the developer also tell gamers how to player their game properly, and breathing behind their neck while waving the moral banner?

6

u/FastEstablishment269 10h ago

Can't wait for PC to come out and all the mods that fix this morality system, or even remove it altogether.

2

u/Maleficent-Fox7513 7h ago

Add a mod that replaces Lucia with Mai Tai Shirley and I’m set. 

6

u/throwaway69764 10h ago

I hated this in RDR2 already. Like you accidentally trample someone with your horse because the movement is clunky as hell on PC without a controller, and then the game sends waves upon waves of bounty hunters and sheriffs after you to tank your honor into the ground

morality systems just don't pair well with sandbox games, it's like if Minecraft punished you for killing villagers or something

3

u/tico_liro 14h ago

Me on the other hand, even tho I disable an enemy, I do the check shot after, just to make sure.

3

u/Creative-Type9411 10h ago

it will ruin your ending im sure

3

u/hellraiserk 4h ago

As someone who is the world's worst driver in literally any game that puts me behind the wheel, and who has made it through every GTA game since 3 by just accepting that I WILL be the city's most wanted hit and run bandit...this system is brutal lol.

3

u/MomMentallyAbusesMe 3h ago

Playing gta 6 is like eating a steak at a restaurant you often go to, except this time the steak was updated without your knowledge to be made of veggie meat, and you have judging vegans as waiters that judge you not caring about the animals when you ask them why the meat isn't meat this time around. Oh and you have to tip them extra cause of trauma you inflicted on them by daring to ask a question, and you're banned from eating there too after. And when you get home you find out all the food in your house was replaced with meat alternatives and you dont have a say in what you want to eat anymore. 

14

u/DarthMoonKnight 10h ago edited 7h ago

Literally nobody asked for Grand Theft Redemption. This system actively kills the fun and does not belong in a GTA game.

We need a toggle that allows us to just switch it off. It just sucks.

Edit to fix a typo.

3

u/CoolWhipLuke 7h ago

This game needed two simple things:

  1. A "pause relationships" button (like in GTA 4- call it what you like)
  2. Some kind of item where violent actions or good actions don't influence rep (like Red Dead's Bandana)

Would have totally avoided several game issues and R* has done it before.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/x2iLLx 19h ago

Yeah just passed that mission, that system sucks.

13

u/Dependent_Ant3211 13h ago • Bravo

I like the system, I did a mission where I was carjacking a car to sell, and in the mission the dog came out barking at me when I slim jimmed in, the owner came out to yell at the dog barking, and saw me in the car, and ran after me, it was a woman in her 50’s and when I turned to get away she grabbed the handle and fell forward, under the rear wheel, and I ran over her head despite trying to avoid that. I got penalized for it, I actually felt really bad for her, and if I had been more “professional“ I could have been more careful.

as much as people say it penalizes you for being reckless, it also rewards you for being careful, and adds an element of depth other gta games lack. I have the option now to be a non psycho gta character with that decision having lasting effects.

18

u/Global-Register5467 13h ago

Yes, and in that situation it makes complete sense. But when a truck full of enemies suddenly blocks the road and opens fire on you the second you get close I don't feel bad for killing them and don't think I should be penalized for it.

Killing people for walking down the street should absolutely tank my morality. Killing someone who was actively trying to kill me first should not.

4

u/Dependent_Ant3211 12h ago

it doesn’t tank your criminal profile to shoot people who are shooting you too. you do more jobs freeroam where stealth/non lethal force are totally viable, stealing cars, robbing stores/people, etc, and even if you shoot everyone going after you in story missions you still end up professional just by the free roam jobs.

my rule is don’t outright murder civilians or shoot cops who are just doing their jobs, and i dont care if I shoot gang members or people shooting at me, and I’m still rated professional.

4

u/RyahTheBlack 12h ago

This, I only struggled to maintain professional in chapter 1, as soon as I hit chapter 2 ive maintained professional and wasted a ton of criminals

3

u/5BabyTurtle 11h ago

You’re not penalized. The game reacts to how you handle it and tracks it. That’s it.

3

u/Michael00131 10h ago

But there are different endings right? Or do they no relate to that specifically? Don’t ruin it in your answer lol I’m pretty early

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/CottonJohansen 12h ago

If this is the one I’m thinking of: you can use dog treats to stop the dog from alerting their owner. I will always appreciate these small details

7

u/EquivalentPassion167 11h ago

Throw the ball to distract the dog

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/NotPatricularlyKind 12h ago

Somebody didn't throw the mini football for the doggy, unprofessional indeed.

2

u/tremble_lip 10h ago

Well rounded summary.

1

u/Blastoisealways 12h ago

Just pat the dog and it lets you steal the car

1

u/adjective_noun_23 9h ago

When I was around 8 I saw a guy get his head ran over by a car. I have ptsd.

1

u/BaerMinUhMuhm 5h ago

She came out with a shotgun for me. I shot her in the face. Was "penalized" for it. Didn't care.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Necessary_Stuff4624 11h ago

Hey don't you dare say anything bad about rockstar

5

u/Klutzy_Anybody_1487 12h ago

Honestly this might be unironically the best game ever made, not just 9/10 but somehow it just completely misses the point of gta.

3

u/ashif1233 10h ago

they could have named it something else but then it wouldn’t have made 3.79b in day one

1

u/JournalistOk9266 10h ago

Have you actually played GTA where are people getting this nonsense idea that GTA is unfettered chaos? I feel like a lot of you just heard about GTA and think you know what it is.

10

u/0t0her0 10h ago

People would pick up chain saws in the og vice city and run around and chop random people up. That was like a good 60% of the game.

Unfetted chaos is why the game is famous

→ More replies (14)

2

u/DeeDee_GigaDooDoo 7h ago

I'm convinced that the vast majority of criticism along the lines of "this isn't GTA" is coming from people who have never played anything except GTA online or at best only the GTA V storyline. Every GTA game has fairly clearly had a story that outlines that violence and your actions have consequences. The free roam people are used to is not the same as the story.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/Wildest12 10h ago

Bingo. The game is good as a game but its not a good GTA game.

It makes me not want to be a criminal sometimes and just enjoy the world, then it makes me rob a lady's scooter and she breaks her hip chasing me or forces me to do coke lol

1

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 8h ago

The dissonance gets worse as you do more and more crazy missions then are asked not to kill anyone outside of them.

2

u/TakasuXAisaka 12h ago

It's the honor reputation system. It also affects the ending you get based on your reputation

2

u/Archonixus 5h ago

The flying fk is a morality meter doing in grand theft auto? Has it become Return that auto??

2

u/GoldenColossus55 5h ago

Morality system in a fucking GTA game is a brainded retarded decision and devs should be ashamed

This isn't RDR idiots

2

u/Prudent-Result1057 11h ago

Agreed that’s literally fucking retarded just like how they have it limited to where you can use your gun like I get you guys wanna play it safe because of the LGBTQ mob and how sensitive they are and you can’t say or do anything, but you literally can’t even do that in normal night clubs

2

u/Connect-Ant-2081 11h ago

I agree, the idea of the system is good, but the implementation of it is a bit skewed.

9

u/ashif1233 11h ago

the idea isn’t good, not for a GTA game

3

u/Propaslander 10h ago

Doesn't make sense. Especially in missions where you're attacked by mobs/cartels or are attacked first in general. The morality system needs a tweak for sure

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Other_Stomach2620 12h ago

Almost like they knew if you got into gun fights the performance would tank so they discourage it 

1

u/Poor_Culinary_Skills 11h ago

I don't know why everyone keeps calling it a morality system. It's not and it never claimed to be

1

u/murderously-funny 8h ago

Because it judges you for defending yourself and actiosn yot take outside of story missions

1

u/BEALLOJO 8h ago

Not a morality system brother

1

u/Alimakakos 8h ago

Just go back to the five stars, either the cops are on my ass or not....

1

u/Colley619 8h ago

It’s not a morality system, it’s a “criminal type” sort of tracker and it’s not like RDR2 where “bad pushes it left” and “good pushes it right.”

There are like 5 different types and instead of pushing left and right explicitly, certain actions pull them to specific types. For example, killing nobody pushes it towards professional, and killing in self defense pushes it towards hardened. Killing in self defense does not continue pushing it towards the more “psycho” styles. Both professional and hardened are basically the “normal” types which you would probably describe as the good ones.

It’s a system that isn’t explained well and is too complex to not be explained, but the bottom line is you are totally fine shooting gang members.

1

u/ScheduleDifferent970 7h ago

I don't cause it's a video game! One NPC got disrespectful so punched the shit Outta them and threw over the third floor in a mall 😂

1

u/Inevitable_Round_978 7h ago

That is the thing I hate most about RDR 2

1

u/Realistic-Dot6141 6h ago

Dude ignore it and play how you want its gta you can be a criminal psycho thats a badass name like what? The morality lvl? Jfc

1

u/BAN1SH3DB3AST 5h ago

Worst feature in GTA6 BY FAR. Love the game, but rn I feel like I am walking on eggshells because I dared defend myself. Feels bad man.

1

u/NatureEfficient7416 3h ago

gta used to be the most fun thing ever. vice city, san andreas and the iv expansions are the best video games ever! this thing was made by woke, faggot bitch cunts that have no idea what people are pissed about

1

u/BAN1SH3DB3AST 2h ago

I am currently at violent (was at psycho) and trying to work my way back up. Since I don't want to be locked out of good endings AND focus bonuses AND the ability surrender to police AND the having cops try to arrest me at a one star wanted level, I am going through every battle in the lamest way imaginable by only shooting people in their limbs. Game makes me feel like I am walking on eggshells. The game gives me all of these cool tools for combat but then does everything it can to discourage me from using them.

"I want to use these molotovs or explosives."

Nope, that will make me psycho/irredeemable.

"I want to use high powered weapons to blow peoples melons off."

Nope, psycho/irredeemable.

"Ookay, how about a melee weapon."

Nope, psycho/irredeemable yet again.

Worst part is I haven't killed a single cop yet and have only killed a handful of civilians. Pretty much every one I have offed has been a Kingfisher, ya'know, the psycho hillbilly swamp-dwellers that feed people to pigs amongst other heinous things. Yeah, R* wants me to believe that I am a worse person for delivering harsh justice to someone like that. Total bs. RDR2 did this type of system way better. Kill bad guys? No bad karma. Kill good guys? Bad karma. As simple as it should be. GTAVI on the other hand has completely convoluted that simple system. It feels awful now.

1

u/sureyouknowurself 2h ago

It’s not a GTA game, plain and simple.

1

u/BloodRedVoid814 2h ago

Anyone who actually thinks this is “bad” needs to either turn their min/max gamer brain or America brain off lol

This obsession with getting the “right/good” ending is killing your actual immersion in games. You’re supposed to play your way.

And if you don’t think there’s a difference between defending yourself with your fists vs a gun vs executing someone you’ve already maimed then I’m sorry but you are genuinely warped in the head.

1

u/Stunning-Nature-9700 2h ago

Use focus to target knee caps and elbows pistol whipping works too

1

u/28_Z0MBIE 28m ago

It's all supposed to even out based on your actions outside of the mission.

0

u/Joppewiik 19h ago

I have a tip for you. Stop caring about the morality system. I don't, and I'm not getting screwed over by the game for doing so.

11

u/Dukenstein12 14h ago

The problem is they tied the canon good ending to playing this game like Shenmue. I don’t get what the fuck they were thinking with that

4

u/Meb78910 13h ago

Shenmue was ahead of its time. lol 😂

4

u/rmrehfeldt 9h ago

It was developed by Gen Z’ers. Older GTA(Pre 5 DLC) was developed by older generations.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)

37

u/CoolWhipLuke 14h ago • Bravo

"Just ignore the morality system"

"Just ignore the boring missions"

"Just ignore the mandatory relationship system"

How much of this game am I supposed to just ignore in order to enjoy it bro

10

u/SolemnEmberGames 10h ago

The entire cope is that "the game is amazing because of all the stuff you can do, except most of it is terrible in which case don't do it instead of complaining". Very cake and eat it too

4

u/5ma5her7 9h ago

For me it's just wait till it's on Steam and on history low.

→ More replies (24)

17

u/baddogkelervra1 14h ago

That’s just willful ignorance, not an enlightened perspective. If people get railroaded into a bad ending because they played the game in a way that was fun, it will sour them on the whole experience needlessly. It’s silly enough to penalize the player for being a maniac in a GTA game, but if they absolutely must, it should be restricted to civilian/cop deaths. Penalizing the player for killing gang members rather than pulling off trick shots to disarm them is just stupid.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/mrbkkt1 9h ago

so..watching all the reviews. basically:

Graphics and audio 10/10
Gameplay 5/10

Storyline 1/10

I should wait until it's 50% off until I buy, correct? Since I obviously can't buy any used copies.

2

u/ItsEaster 6h ago

No. The game is great. The story is probably a 7 not a 1. The people complaining about the story have often made it obvious they haven’t gotten past the first chapter of the game. The game isn’t perfect but the bigger flaw it has is that it’s been a victim of culture war bs.

2

u/OddPerformance5017 5h ago

How has the game been a victim of so-called "culture war bs"?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/No_Reserve_2010 6h ago

its not that bad i think its such a hit or miss for people. you might like it a lot more than bad online reviews. i think there is wasted potential in a lot of areas but the game is still good enough to be played right now.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/GiblertMelendezz 6h ago

I love the story. And the gameplay is the most varied out of all the gtas now.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/ChanceEstimate6291 11h ago

Just wait until Chapter 2. I guarantee like 80% of people will stop playing.

1

u/WatercressContent454 10h ago

Your post is too aggressive and oppressive! apologize NOW or you willl lose your social rating!!!1!

0

u/fuzzyedges1974 10h ago

It doesn’t seem to me like a “morality rating” so much as what type of criminal I am turning into. There’s the slick “pro” criminal on the left, the “hardened” criminal in the middle, and the Trevor - I mean “psychopath” on the right. At least that’s how I’m viewing it. Like a crime reputation meter.