For every ridiculous postcomplaining about "wokeness" and their equality asinine rebuttals, the third most common gripe seems to be the Criminal Profile system. Spcifically, how stupid, limiting and "unfair" it is. But much like the two competing sides in one gamings dumbest ever debates, this complaint is also rooted in a deep misunderstanding of the issue itself - whether that be how the system works, what the point of it is, or both.
Just quickly on the point of it all. For a number of equality invalid reasons, players can't let go of the idea that it's a ranking system. However the widespread misconception that "Professional" is best and everything else sub par is simply not how it works. Your Criminal Profile is not a grading or a judgement of any kind, it's an accurate assessment of your gameplay experience.
There are no "punishments" here either. In fact, each Criminal Profile rewards the type of play that' has earned the label. For those with Professional and Hardened profiles, a focus boost is earned through non lethal takedowns and good deeds. For Violent or Psycho, it's headshots. Admittedly, those deemed Irredeemable do not receive a Focus boost. Instead, they get the insane, chaotic playthrough they want. Everyone wins.
The other justification for this line of thinking is the belief that there are "good endings" and "bad endings" tied to your Profile. But says who? Never mind these things are entirely subjective, the idea of tailoring ones entirely playthrough in pursuit of them is ridiculous. A good story should end in a way befitting of the journey one took to get there. And in a hundred hour game, is that not more important than a 5 minute cutscene that doesn't really fit? There's no good or bad endings in a story told well - only fitting ones.
Fortunately, the absurdity of spending countless hours curating an artificial Profile is entirely needless, even if that's your bizarre prerogative. Most people are aware of what contributes to your Profile, however few have considered the weighting and have instead convinced themselves they'll be punished for doing what the game tells them to do. Really?
The mass slaughter of legitimate enemies has no real bearing on your Profile whatsoever. If you were to take down a thousand gang members, all of who were out for your blood, and kept the Civilian, Law Enforcement and Domestic Animal casualties to a minimum, you will have the "Hardened" Criminal Profjle. Ie - your a hardened veteran, extremely capable and not one to mess about.The Professional profile is for those who opt for the Solid Snake style approach - stealth and restraint. One is not objectively better than the other - they're completely different approaches.
If your bloodlust is a little more indiscriminate and your care little about collateral damage, you're going to appropriately be labelled as Violent or even psycho depending on the levels of mayhem you cause. I dare say most peoples playthroughs in previous franchise entires would fit into one of these two categories.
A review at PC Gamer ended their playthrough with 500 Weapon (read = "intentional") Kills and 744 incapacitations. Their bodycount included 17 Civilians and almost 200 members of Law Enforcement, yet their Jason and Lucia both still ended up with "Professional" Criminal Profiles. Meanwhile, I currently have a far greater ratio with 68 Weapon kills (plus 10 attributed to vehicles) and 131 Incapacitations. However with only 7 Civilians and 16 cops vs only 53 enemies, the weighting of who I've killed impacts me far more, and thus my Profile is currently Hardened.
So you'll see, there is nothing at all preventing you from mowing down the hordes of bad guys the game throws at you. Not that there should have been anyway, but you get the point. No playstyle is being punished and there's nothing unfair about any of this. If you want to get an idea for yourself, note which types of kills are highlighted in your individual character Crime stats. Those are what make an impact.
TLDR - just play the game as you would anyway ffs. Worst case scenario you get the ending you're supposed to.
source used - https://www.pcgamer.com/games/grand-theft-auto/gta-6-criminal-profile-honor-system-explained/