In October 2023, I purchased a 65-inch LG OLED G1, originally retailing for around $2,200, on clearance for approximately $450. I also purchased a 5-year Geek Squad Protection Plan.
Recently, the TV developed dead pixels and started randomly shutting off. A Geek Squad technician inspected it at my house and approved a replacement.
Since the G1 is discontinued, I was told I’d receive a comparable TV. However, Best Buy claims their system limits me to my original $450 purchase price.
Here’s where things get confusing. They were willing to offer me an LG B6 OLED as an upgrade, despite it costing significantly more than what I paid. However, when I requested a G-Series replacement to maintain similar performance and features, that was completely off the table.
I also reviewed Best Buy’s Geek Squad Protection FAQ, specifically the question “Is there any coverage limit?” It states:
“For products purchased on or after October 7, 2019, they are covered up to the regular retail price found on the receipt at time of purchase, regardless of discounts.”
Additionally, the Geek Squad Protection Terms & Conditions, Section 7(c), discusses replacing a covered product with one of “like kind, quality and of comparable performance.”
However, Section 7(b) discusses reimbursement toward a comparable replacement, with limits tied to the original purchase price. I understand these are separate provisions, which is why I’m questioning whether an actual comparable replacement is possible instead of store credit.
I’ve gone back and forth with multiple representatives and Geek Squad supervisors, but none have been willing to help resolve the situation. They repeatedly tell me, “Systematically, we can only do what you paid for.” I’ve now escalated the issue to Best Buy corporate and am awaiting a response.
I’m not demanding $2,200 in credit or necessarily the latest G6. I simply want a TV comparable in picture quality, features, and performance to my original G1.
My questions:
Does Section 7(c) allow a comparable replacement even when reimbursement is limited under Section 7(b)?
How does the FAQ’s “regardless of discounts” statement apply to my situation?
Why offer a B6 upgrade but completely rule out the G-Series?
Can corporate override these limitations, or has anyone successfully dealt with something similar?
I’d appreciate insight from current or former Geek Squad employees!