One question I've been thinking about while working on an AI video product is how much planning creators actually want before they start generating videos.
When making an AI short film, I see two common approaches.
The first is to write the complete story upfront, define the characters and visual style, organize the scenes, and then generate the shots. It gives the project a clearer structure, but there's a risk of spending too much time planning scenes that might not work visually.
The second is to generate one interesting scene first and let the story develop through experimentation. This feels more flexible, but maintaining a coherent narrative can become difficult as the number of scenes grows.
We've been exploring this problem with the Creative Agent / AI Video Agent in Wizstar AI. The idea is to let creators start with a basic story concept, describe the genre, characters, visual mood, and approximate duration, then develop those details into a scene structure and shot plan through conversation.
I'm one of the product creators behind Wizstar AI, and I'm trying to understand whether this workflow solves a real problem or simply adds another planning step.
I'd really appreciate feedback from startup founders, AI builders, and people working on creative tools:
- Would you prefer an AI tool that helps plan the entire project, or one that lets users generate and refine scenes immediately?
- Is story planning a meaningful pain point for AI filmmakers, or is visual consistency a bigger problem?
- What would make an AI creative assistant genuinely useful enough that you'd keep using it?
I'm not trying to claim we've found the perfect approach. I'm sharing a product problem we're exploring and would genuinely value honest opinions, especially from people who have built or used AI creative products.