A few days ago, Basket Case was randomly stuck in my head despite not hearing the song in months, so I randomly decided to listen through Green Day’s entire discography.
PRELUDE
(Feel free to skip if you just want the reviews)
I listened to Green Day plenty in middle school and early high school, though I was never a giant fan. The last release I followed was 21st Century Breakdown. By that point, I was getting deeper into metal, playing guitar, and moving beyond any sort of pop-tinged music like this, so I basically abandoned the band after that and haven’t heard anything new since, though I’ll occasionally still listen to some older songs.
Because of my personal tastes, I’m likely biased towards their more uptempo and heavy songs. Just so you have an idea of where I’m coming from, my favorite genres are technical death metal and progressive death metal. I always tend to dislike ballads (with one exception I found), and I enjoy the more progressive, ADHD-style songs that go all over the place. I also have little to no concern with lyrics; I only care about the vocals insofar as they fit in the music as another instrument.
So it took me two days, but I listened through their full discography and rated everything (including each song, but that’s too much to include here).
The scale I’m using here is 0-100, with 50 being an average album. This is not school where a 60 is a fail; a 60 means above average.
1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours - 55
I know this is technically a compilation, but I have little enough to say about each part that I may as well throw it into one. You can’t expect too much out of most bands’ demos and pre-release work, so I went in with low expectations, which left me partially impressed. While this isn’t any of their best material, it’s better than I thought it would be, and I’d be willing to give it a few more listens.
There’s a bit more punk rock here than their later pop-punk sound, which is interesting to hear, although they definitely execute their later style better.
Best songs:
- At the Library
- Going to Pasalacqua
KERPLUNK - 60
For their first “real” album, they’re still working out some kinks in their sound, but the end product is good enough for an early 90s debut. There are enough strong songs here to hold their weight and drive the album, but there are also some really awful songs (Dominated Love Slave, for one) that drag it back down once it gets going. The original version of Welcome to Paradise is basically the same as the Dookie one, maybe just a little sloppier, which doesn’t hurt with this type of music. Kind of surprised they decided to actually re-record it for the next album.
All in all, a solid album. Not spectacular, not weak, and more good than bad. In looking at play counts on Spotify, I’m kind of surprised how low a lot of these songs are, because I think anyone who enjoys Dookie would enjoy this one too.
Best songs:
- Who Wrote Holden Caulfield?
- Welcome to Paradise
- One of My Lies
DOOKIE - 87
Now here is where they really figure everything out. Dookie starts leaning a little harder into the pop side of “pop-punk,” but there are still some songs that are primarily punk. One thing that hurts this album is the beginning of it. On most albums, you want a strong 1-2-3-punch to draw listeners in and get them invested in the rest of the album. I don’t feel that here, and Burnout, Having a Blast, and Chump are all some of the weaker songs on the album. But from track four onwards, you can’t go two songs in a row without hearing something great. And there’s a reason Basket Case is such a popular song, it’s basically the definitive pop-punk song that every band after was trying to replicate.
Overall, a great album, with a couple weak points that don’t ruin anything. If someone asks you “What does Green Day sound like?” this album is the answer to that question. Dookie forms the basis for the band’s sound that they work in and around for most of the rest of their career.
Best songs:
- Basket Case
- Longview
- When I Come Around
- She
- Emenius Sleepus
INSOMNIAC - 76
This one is a little tricky to rate, because it’s a solid album the whole way through, but there aren’t really any big standout songs besides Brain Stew, although I was pleasantly surprised by Panic Song, because it’s not one I remember at all from listening to the band when I was younger. This does seem to be their heaviest album, which is right up my alley, but some of the songs end up blending together and sounding too similar, especially near the start of the album.
But out of 14 songs on the album, there are at least 8 I would consider “good” (in addition to the ones below, that’s Jaded, Bab’s Uvula, Geek Stink Breath, and Walking Contradiction). So it’s a thoroughly enjoyable album, and it works better as a single piece to listen the whole way through, instead of listening to individual tracks.
Best songs:
- Brain Stew
- Panic Song
- 86
- Brat
NIMROD - 67
A little weaker than the previous two albums, but still solid, this one lets off some of the heaviness and high tempos that Insomniac injected in. It’s also just a bit too damn long for this type of music. And, like Insomniac, there’s only one true standout track (Hitchin’ a Ride), but a lot of solid songs.
I was absolutely taken off-guard by Take Back. A Green Day song with screaming? I don’t know what genre you call it (hardcore, crossover thrash, something like that?) and although it wasn’t really an amazing song, I had never heard anything like that from Green Day. Platypus is another interesting one, almost D-beat, very unlike normal Green Day.
Another solid album; the high points are lower than Insomniac, but even my least favorite songs (Redundant and Walking Alone) are stronger than the best songs on some later albums.
Best songs:
- Hitchin’ a Ride
- Nice Guys Finish Last
- Platypus (I Hate You)
WARNING - 53
Now this is where I start having issues. Minority is an absolutely awesome song, but that’s about everything I get out of this album. They clearly wanted to experiment with some folk aspects, and it works for the bridge in Minority and parts of Misery, but I have trouble finding much else where it helped add to the music. The only reason this ears above a 50/average is because Minority is so good.
Unlike some of the later albums, there isn’t anything especially egregious here, but neither is there much to latch onto. Much of the album comes off as generic Green Day pop-punk with the tempo dropped and the distorted guitars swapped out for acoustic or very lightly distorted guitars, which dims the energy. Better choices in the production department may have done much for this album.
I think they learned the wrong lesson from the popularity of Good Riddance, and just toned almost everything down, throwing shit at the wall to try to replicate that song. Like this was meant to be their new “accessible” album, which failed to actually be accessible.
Best songs:
AMERICAN IDIOT - 95
Now here it is. The album I listened to dozens of times in middle school and high school. It holds up just as well as I remember. On an earlier album, I mentioned having a strong 1-2-3-punch to open an album. This one absolutely nails it, and each of those three songs has their own distinct identity, all instantly recognizable.
I think Jesus of Suburbia conditioned me to get into prog metal eventually. The first time you hear this song, if you’re not familiar with this type of music, it will feel all over the place, random sections that shouldn’t be in the same song together. But it turns out to be an absolute epic, and that’s probably why I got into bands like Between the Buried and Me shortly after, with their ADHD-ass genre switching epics.
The only real complaint I have with this album is that the momentum gets halted in place on certain songs. Are We the Waiting, and Give Me Novacaine are the biggest offenders, and each are followed by awesome songs. This was a problem on the original version where songs are combined, because I had to sit through AWTW to get to St Jimmy, and sit through Novacaine to get to She’s a Rebel. Thankfully, the new anniversary edition has fixed this by fully splitting each song into its own track.
There’s a good reason this album is considered so iconic. I can fully understand a fan preferring Dookie, especially if you’re more into punk, but this album has just about everything you could ask for, and most of Green Day’s best songs are all right here in one sweet package.
Best songs:
- Jesus of Suburbia
- Holiday
- American Idiot
- St Jimmy
- Letterbomb
- She’s a Rebel
21st CENTURY BREAKDOWN - 65
So this is where I stopped listening to them very much in high school. I will say, this album is better than I remember, although it does exacerbate one of the issues I had with American Idiot, which is the placement of low-energy songs killing the momentum. And some of the songs which seem meant to be high-energy (notably Know Your Enemy), are just bad. With that being said, the slower/softer songs and sections are executed better than they were on Warning and AI, and there is more of a progressive structure within several songs here. I even enjoy the intro, Song of the Century, whereas I would usually end up skipping a song like that on most albums, and the callback at the end of the album is extremely satisfying
You can really feel the length of this album, and I think three or more songs could have been cut altogether. The best song on here, Viva la Gloria, would rank somewhere in the middle of American Idiot’s tracklist, and some sections of the album drag on without reprieve.
If you’re really into their soft/slow or acoustic/songs, I can see loving this album. 21 Guns probably plays that part better than any other song in their discography, and there are several others that I imagine are probably popular, but that’s just not my thing, unless it’s buildup to something better.
Best songs:
- ¡Viva la Gloria!
- 21st Century Breakdown
- ¿Viva la Gloria? (Little Girl)
- Murder City
¡Uno! ¡Dos! ¡Tré! - 25
From here onwards, this is the first time I’m hearing each of these albums.
Like the first release, I’m ranking this as one album, because I don’t have a lot to write, nor much positive to say. There is only one song in this entire trilogy that I legitimately enjoy. There are a lot of mediocre songs, and even more bad songs. I do not like any of these albums. They’ve largely dropped the punk from “pop-punk” at this point, and when it does remain, it’s not executed all that well. When a song manages to be catchy, it also somehow ends up boring or repetitive, and there are just too many forgettable tracks here.
I am honestly surprised that I managed to keep my attention focused long enough to make it to Dirty Rotten Bastards, which is a legitimately good prog-rock/pop-punk song hidden near the end, reminiscent of some of the better songs from 21CBD.
Tre is probably the “strongest” of the three albums, with Dos being the weakest, but this should not have been a triple album. They easily could have picked 10-12 of the best songs and made an average album.
Best songs:
REVOLUTION RADIO - 62
Okay, this one is a bit of a relief. After a steady decline, they bounce back a good bit here. The album starts off extremely boring with Somewhere Now, which I don’t understand why they put as the opening track. But then we get Bang Bang, which is probably the single best song they’ve released after American Idiot. Classic Green Day, pure energy, this song would have fit perfectly well on AI. The title track is also decently strong, a little more of the poppy-alt that dominated 21CBD, but strong nonetheless. Surprisingly, I actually enjoyed Still Breathing as well, probably the first ballad in their discography that I have any desire to return to.
There is a little wonky issues with the mix here, with the volume being inconsistent between and even inside songs, and the vocals sometimes being covered up, but it doesn’t affect anything too much.
I will criticize that this is very much a “single” album–those three songs were the whole point of the album, and most of the rest is filler, though I get a little enjoyment out of Bouncing off the Wall and Too Dumb to Die as well. But definitely a massive improvement over the triple album, and they actually sound like Green Day again.
Best songs:
- Bang Bang
- Revolution Radio
- Still Breathing
FATHER OF ALL - 15
Nope. Spoke too soon. What the fuck is this? Billie Joe Amstrong’s mid-life crisis recorded into an album? While they’ve had points where they sound like a different band before, this album sounds NOTHING like Green Day at all. I can’t even recognize Billie Joe’s voice on a lot of tracks. Not only are none of the songs good, most are intolerable, the worst being Oh Yeah and Junkies on a High. The only song I would ever choose to listen to again is Sugar Youth, and even that one is below mediocre. Almost as bad is the fact that they desecrated the American Idiot cover art with this piece of shit.
Every time an album like this comes out of any band, some fanboy will inevitably retort, “It’s their music, they’re allowed to experiment as much as they want!” Yup, they sure are, and I’m also allowed to call it out for being complete bullshit.
I feel generous giving this a 15. But I’ve heard albums that are completely unlistenable, and this isn’t at that point, but I will certainly never listen to it again.
Best songs:
SAVIORS - 50
Alright, that’s…better…but still not great. Like some other albums I’ve been lukewarm about, there isn’t really any standout song here, but nothing is as bad as Father of All or Uno Dos Tre either. Strange Days Are Here to Stay reminds me a bit of an older-school Green Day song, and the opening track is pretty decent too, but not much else stands out to me.
This album was about as “safe” as they could have possibly gone. They took a swing on Father of All and spectacularly missed, so they retreated to safe territory here and took no chances. That makes it “good enough” for the average listener, but it also prevents anything great from coming through.
Best songs:
- Strange Days Are Here to Stay
- The American Dream is Killing Me
- Coma City
Overall Album Ranks
- American Idiot - 95
- Dookie - 87
- Insomniac - 76
- Nimrod - 67
- 21st Century Breakdown - 65
- Revolution Radio - 62
- Kerplunk - 60
- 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours - 55
- Warning - 53
- Saviors - 50
- Shenanigans [didn’t review] - 47
- ¡Uno! ¡Dos! ¡Tré! - 25
- Father of All - 15
Best Songs Overall
- Jesus of Suburbia
- Basket Case
- Holiday
- Brain Stew
- Longview
- Minority
- American Idiot
- Bang Bang
- Hitchin’ a Ride
- Welcome to Paradise