This is mostly directed at Anet as I have no other means to contact them, I donāt really want to discuss this, I just wanted to test the recent thief changes and give my opinion on them.
My in Game Accounts:
muon.1630 (Main: MĆŗon) and Jana.6831 (Main: Josteinn) (we might have crossed paths)
I have a combined ~25k hours on thief, mostly Core D/D thief, but I have played all other specs and weapons. From December 2013 until May 2024 Iāve played mostly WvW. Iāve recently come back to test the changes made to thief.
Prologue: At launch thief was designed to be an assassin: Dip into the fight, do damage, vanish (stealth) or step away. Thatās what the stealth was for and thatās why thief is so squishy. Daredevil was a step in direction brawler, and every elite after that (initially) was a ranged brawler ā the new concept now clashes with the core trait lines which still have to be taken.
Weāve also seen people complain about thieves and especially thief stealth no matter whether or not other classes (Mesmer, Engi, Ranger) also have stealth and/or the same amount of stealth and are also hitting just as hard, so I think itās important that YOU (Anet) figure out what you want thief to be (one philosophy), consider what is fair and then stick to it. Donāt make a complete overhaul because of some complaints from people who donāt play thief, which then destroys the classās āintegrityā.
What I think of the trait lines Iām using:
Shadow Arts needs a complete rework. A lot of the traits do nearly the same thing and the whole trait line struggles with its intended purpose: Survivability. (Donāt take away cloaked in shadows again though, please). Maybe add something that softens the blow while in stealth, and/or add more condi removal, e.g. ā2 conditions removedā instead of now one and/or maybe Grandmaster āRemove all conditionsā or āRemove all conditions that have 3+ stacksā, and/or ramp up the heal and so on. That of course also depends on the current state of the game, it might need to be tweaked in the future, but that depends on what direction balance is supposed to go.
Iām happy with Critical Strikes, also the Twin Fangs rework is really nice, you know who itās intended for and designed it to benefit them the most, Iād love to see more traits like that.
Iām also happy with Deadly Arts, but I only use it in PvE.
Trickery is okay I think.
In general itād be nice to have more Condi removal, so either in SA or T.
Other Stuff:
4s Reveal: I play D/D thief intuitively = I usually donāt have a combo (besides CnD and Steal) or a real plan, I react in that moment. Therefore the reveal 3 s in PvE (and until 1-2 years ago in all game modes) and now 4s in WvW is really bad as it messes up the one thing I need to play D/D thief: Timing. Either make it 4s everywhere, or return to 3. And if 4s maybe compensate for that as right now Thief is the only class whoās had recent major changes and with that itās tendentially under powered compared to most other classes.
Deadeye: I tried Deadeye D/D, but since my playstyle is āI react to whatever situation IN that situationā itās not really suitable for me to waste Initiative in order to build up malice. I also canāt deal with the marked thingy. Thatās actually what kills me the most when facing a deadeye. I get that it somewhat made sense when Deadeye was all ranged, but itās still super annoying to me. Also: Itās no good that Core D/D and Deadeye D/D follow other rules like āvalid path to targetā and the CnD Steal combo is waaaay more lenient on Deadeye D/D. A weapon set should always have the same mechanics, no matter the trait lines.
Stealth attack cooldown: Is that really needed anymore? Or at this point in time, as most blocks appear to have a time duration and donāt falter after a single hit.
Powercreep of the past 2,5 years: Granted, Iād still need time to get back into WvW and be as confident as I used to be, BUT: Thereās been significant power creep in the past 2,5 years and Iād like to highlight one particular fight which is synonymous for all fights Iāve recently Ā won, no matter what class Iāve fought. It was an elementalist, donāt ask me what weapons, all I know was Ā they were busy popping Ā up all shields they had, not all of them block but a lot of them do, so I couldnāt use my CnD, had to stay out of range as they did a lot of damage on top of the blocks. That fight lasted maybe 2 mins (120s), I was stealthed for maybe 10 s, and out of range for 100 seconds. That is the opposite of what the D/D playstyle is supposed to be, Iām supposed to stay mostly in range and use CnD to stealth and reposition. Neither is possible anymore and leads to these passive but somewhat comical fights.
Quickness: Whenever anyone gives me quickness it messes up my timing and usually kills me as my CnD and Steal combo will fail. Either give an option to not have it applied to oneās own character, or readjust the timing under quickness, so that my combo wonāt miss, or restrict quickness, as itās far too common anyway and I do wonder why people are apparently ok with a small group being able to have a 100% uptime of all boons and quickness, which is a nightmare to fight against.
Shortbow needs a rework: Consider whether or not all the initiative cost increases are still needed as a lot has changed. Also if being able to port is a general problem, or if it is a core characteristic of thief and should therefore be mostly preserved.
What made the S/P changes necessary btw? It was my go to weapon when I wanted to do Bounties as thief has very little CC (another idea for SA or T, maybe T as SA doesnāt have much use in PvE ā btw fun fact: Did you know that back in 2013-2015 I used to have one build for PvE and WvW? It worked, I think SA used to have a damage multiplier, stacks of might, back in the day.)
Also: Keep on tracking whether or not everything with the hit frames is ok. Iāve recently had a bug in which PvE mobs who were running away from me couldnāt be hit with Heartseeker although in range. Reported it twice about a month ago, was still in game last time I checked, but I didnāt check right now. Easiest to test it is to use Skull Fear while standing exactly at the mob and Heartseeker right after ā you should still be in range, but will never hit. That doesnāt apply to WvW as far as I could observe it, but there were also instances where I missed although I was in range. But Iāve recently also came across CnD and Backstab occasionally not hitting while in range (PvE). I know that it affects everybody in game, but Ā itās easiest to observe on a D/D thief as that spec is so restricted. And Ā since that is an indirect nerf = fixing that alone would make D/D a lot better.
I would have loved to make more specific suggestions, but put my focus mostly on what I know doesnāt make sense within core thief itself, the rest is dependent on how other classes and/or thief elites perform. I hope this still helps though.
Thanks for reading,
Jana
Ps: A huge thanks to the players who knew I was back, knew why I was back and let me get into WvW again. Appreciated =)