I’ve put over 18 hours into Extract so far, and unfortunately, I’ve found the experience to be extremely unrewarding. There are some genuinely interesting ideas here, but many of them feel poorly implemented or actively work against what makes an extraction shooter enjoyable.
- Looting
Looting is extremely tedious. As it stands, the best strategy seems to be picking up everything that isn’t nailed down. To me, that isn’t a looter shooter; it’s a cleanup simulator, which isn’t exactly what I want from a gun game.
Looting should be about making meaningful decisions: managing limited storage, prioritizing valuable items, and weighing risk against reward. Instead, the current system encourages collecting as much random junk as possible.
The chippers are a great concept, but their implementation leaves a lot to be desired. Most of the time, there’s simply nothing valuable enough on them to justify the risk involved in obtaining them. They should feel like exciting opportunities for high-value loot, not another disappointing pickup.
- Guns
For a game centered around firearms, the lack of worthwhile gun loot is honestly disappointing.
There are only a handful of locations per run where you might find a gun, and roughly 80% of the time, it’s a derringer or a breech-loader. I understand that weapon variety will improve as more guns are implemented, but the sheer number of derringer variants already feels excessive.
Many of them are borderline reskins of one another, which comes across as an easy way to inflate the weapon count rather than provide meaningful variety.
I feel the developers should have either delayed release until a wider selection of firearms was available or, at the very least, reduced the number of nearly identical low-tier weapons cluttering the loot pool.
Finding a gun in a gun game should be exciting. Right now, it rarely is.
- Extracting
The extraction system is probably my biggest issue with the game.
The concept of gradually upgrading your ability to extract with more items is interesting, but its execution is fundamentally flawed.
Not being able to reliably extract with the personal equipment you brought into a run makes it incredibly difficult to justify bringing your own gear in the first place. Instead, you’re encouraged to use one of the subpar premade kits because there’s little reason to risk anything better.
This completely undermines one of the most important aspects of an extraction shooter: risk versus reward.
Bringing better equipment should be a calculated risk. You invest more upfront to increase your chances of surviving, completing objectives, and securing better loot. But why would I bring valuable equipment when I already know I probably won’t be able to extract with it?
My proposed solution would be to keep the limited extraction system for newly acquired loot while allowing players to extract with the equipment they originally brought into the raid.
This would preserve the existing progression system while making personal loadouts worth using.
As it stands, the extraction system doesn’t start feeling particularly rewarding until the third and fifth upgrade levels, which makes the early progression unnecessarily frustrating.
- Puzzles
When designing puzzles or environmental obstacles, there should always be an in-raid solution or some form of bypass.
I’ve encountered several situations where this doesn’t seem to be the case, but the most obvious example is the security gate in Offices.
In certain configurations, the only apparent way through is to tank shots from the turret and hope you can reach the door before dying.
Other versions of this same obstacle feature alternative routes, such as ventilation shafts, which is exactly how these encounters should be designed.
Every configuration should offer some kind of solution, whether that’s disabling the turret, finding an alternate route, or solving an environmental puzzle.
Forcing players to absorb damage simply to progress isn’t engaging difficulty. It’s frustrating design.
- Maps and Progression
The maps themselves leave a lot to be desired.
Much of the environment consists of repetitive hallways or enormous, dark rooms with very little visual interest. There’s not much to distinguish one area from another, and exploration quickly becomes monotonous.
I could overlook some of this if the progression system didn’t force me to repeatedly play through the same early levels just to reach the more rewarding areas.
This becomes especially frustrating later in the game, when you’re essentially speedrunning the first two levels just to reach somewhere with worthwhile loot.
Once again, this undermines the risk-versus-reward philosophy that extraction shooters are built around.
Players should have the option to enter more dangerous areas in exchange for the opportunity to obtain better equipment. Alternatively, they should be able to choose a safer location, like Bunker, with the understanding that the rewards will be less substantial.
That should be a meaningful player choice, not something forced on you by the progression system.
Final Thoughts
Extract has some genuinely promising ideas, but after 18 hours, I feel like too many of its systems actively discourage the kind of gameplay an extraction shooter should encourage.
Looting prioritizes quantity over value, gun variety is disappointing, extraction discourages bringing personal equipment, puzzles sometimes lack reasonable solutions, and map progression forces unnecessary repetition.
The biggest recurring problem is that the game consistently undermines its own risk-versus-reward mechanics.
I want to feel excited about finding valuable equipment, nervous about risking my own gear, and rewarded for surviving difficult encounters. Instead, I often feel like I’m collecting junk, using disposable kits, and rushing through repetitive environments just to reach the parts of the game that might actually be rewarding.
There’s a solid foundation here, and I genuinely hope these systems improve as development continues. But in its current state, Extract feels more tedious than rewarding