r/HarryPotterBooks • • Dec 20 '25

Mod Post Content policy reminder: all content must be relevant to discussion of the written Harry Potter books only (no discussion of movies, TV shows, stage plays, video games, narrated dramatisations, etc.)

74 Upvotes

Just to make things clear, we will not be discussing the new HBO show on this subreddit, and discussion around the new full-cast audiobook dramatisations must be focused on the contents of the story, i.e. discussions on the voice actors, production, soundscapes, etc are outside the scope of the sub.

This forum is devoted to discussion of the Harry Potter book series, and associated written works by J.K. Rowling. We focus only on the written works of J.K.Rowling; specifically the seven novels, three in-universe book releases (Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, Quidditch Through the Ages, and The Tales of Beedle the Bard, as written and illustrated by J. K. Rowling for the Comic Relief U.K. charity), and the original Pottermore articles. We do not allow content centered around any other form of HP media (no movies, TV shows, stage plays, video games, narrative dramatisations, etc.)

Any off topic content will be removed.

When asking yourself "is this type of content allowed?" The simplest way to find your answer is to look at it this way: in this subreddit, the movies, TV shows, stage plays, and video games don't exist. They were never made, and there's no reason they should ever be acknowledged in any way. Is this because we have a vendetta l against them? Not at all! We are simply a very specific space, with a niche focus.


If you have any questions you can send us a modmail message, and we will get back to you right away.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2h ago

Deathly Hallows What was Dumbledores portrait doing during the Battle of Hogwarts?

10 Upvotes

We know he was was absent from his portrait when Harry looks at Snapes memory, and was present after all it was all over. But the rest of it? Why didn’t he try to counsel Harry like he counselled Snape all year? Or was he hiding from him to avoid unnecessary distraction?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 4h ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #81

11 Upvotes

Good morning! #81 is ready! Have fun!

As a reminder what this is and how it works:

Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.

Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

  1. Snape made them all nervous, breathing down their necks while they tried to remember how to make a Forgetfulness potion. The Philosopher’s Stone - Chapter 16: Through the Trapdoor
  2. “I did not say that, nor will you ever hear me say it,” Dumbledore replied quietly.  The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 37: The Lost Prophecy
  3. “Don’t waste your breath!” yelled Harry, his eyes screwed up against the pain in his scar, now more terrible than ever.  The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 36: The Only One He Ever Feared
  4. “What ’appened to staying undercover?”  The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 2: A Peck of Owls
  5.  And without a backward glance at Harry, Filch ran flat-footed from the office, Mrs. Norris streaking alongside him.  The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 8:The Deathday Party
  6.  Apparently his nerves couldn’t stand the sound of the word “broomsticks” in his living room. The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 3: The Invitation
  7. “A Muggle and a fool . . . very like your dear mother. The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 33: The Deatheaters

r/HarryPotterBooks • • 18m ago

Chamber of Secrets Moaning Myrtle plot hole

3 Upvotes

It just occurred to me how unlikely it seems that Hogwarts teachers of Dumbledore’s calibre never thought to ask the ghost of the girl who was killed by Slytherin’s monster exactly how she died???

It wouldn’t have taken much to figure out the whole basilisk + toilet angle the moment Myrtle revealed she died after looking at a pair of “great big yellow eyes.”

It also seems HIGHLY unlikely that staff were outright unaware of Myrtle becoming a ghost, especially considering she spent several years haunting her bully within the school itself.

Pretty obvious plot hole IMO


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2h ago

Discussion Bertie Botts Every Flavour Beans

2 Upvotes

Reading the books and especially the philosopher's stone you wonder how each bean tastes. Like I could feel it in my mouth reading the text. Wonder what flavours there would be if it was based in today. Matcha would be one lol. Thoughts?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 14h ago

Chamber of Secrets Favorite Character

10 Upvotes

Gilderoy Lockhart


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 12h ago

Theory What do you think is the genetic basis of magic?

3 Upvotes

It's quite clear that magic is hereditary, but it's not clear exactly how that works. Is the trait monogenetic (one gene) or polygenetic (multiple genes)? If it is indeed genetic then that would imply there was a first wizard. How far back did they live?

I would point to the fact that squibs can see ghosts and dementors and get past anti-muggle wards (magic perception vs magic use), as evidence that magic is a complex polygenetic trait. magic use => magic perception, but magic perception =/> magic use.

It seems like the union of a muggle and wizard/witch has a very high chance of producing a magical child, so the trait is certainly dominant and resilient (I believe JKR has confirmed this), but if it turns off for whatever reason, it tends to stay off for a long time. That's how squibs who blend into muggle society end up having magic resurface generations later as "muggleborns". If that's the case, are a muggleborn's ancestors able to perceive magic like squibs can? Or does magic perception also go away with subsequent generations?

My theory is that muggleborns pop-up with the union of two muggles who both have squib ancestors, for whom there is a high likelihood of the child being magical. That's why both Dennis and Colin Creevey ended up being wizards, while Lily was a witch but Petunia wasn't. That makes more sense to me than the notion of a muggle child or child descended from a squib having a small chance to randomly and spontaneously develop magic.

This is all assuming that the basis of magic is genetic, physical, but how could a physical part of the brain, just synapses and neurons, give a person the ability to rewrite reality with their mind?

Another option is that the magical factor in the blood is intangible - metaphysical. This can explain the more complicated and less logical mechanics of magical inheritance. You wouldn't be able to identify a magical gene, but there would be common genes between witches and wizards that were inherited from their common ancestors, alongside magic, though not being linked to magic.

When magic disappears in a squib, magic perception persists as an "echo" in their lineage, gradually weakening over the generations until two descendants of squibs, in whom magic has completely faded, have children, and there is a high likelihood of magic being sparked back into them.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 11h ago

Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (companion book) Was Boggart identified?

2 Upvotes

I have no idea, if I missed it since I only listened to the audiobook, but the explanation for Boggart was not provided.

Maybe the book itself is not complete, I didn't even check if there's an explanation for a Thestral.

But to know if Boggart was just wizard made, or an ancient creature, that info could have been cool.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 18h ago

Discussion Book set recommendations

7 Upvotes

Not sure if this is allowed but I’m hoping to buy my boyfriend a set of the Harry Potter books for Christmas. I want a good deal on a pretty shelf trophy set. Does anyone have recommendations on pretty books that will look good on his shelf, but are not $250? I hope to stay between $40-160.

Thanks in advance!!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Harry’s massive dung-bomb order

11 Upvotes

Looking for any interpretations / theories here:

In OotP, saturday the first weekend of term, Harry get’s up before the crack of dawn, to write a letter to Sirius. He walks up to the owlery before most people are even crawling out of bed, and posts the letter before he’s accosted by Filch. Apparently Argus has received a tip-off that Harry is about to place a massive order for Dung bombs, and he demands to see the letter.

Given how the story progresses, it seems most likely that Umbridge orchestrated this, either by tipping off Filch herself, or by finding some round-about way of doing it, all in the aim of getting her hands on Harry’s letter. My big question is, how on earth would Umbridge know Harry was on his way up to the owlery that morning? How would she know he’d write anyone at all?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #80

13 Upvotes

Numba 80! Number is gettin up there! Enjoy!

As a reminder what this is and how it works:

Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.

Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

  1. “Your father and Bill are on their way, Ron, I’ve sent them both owls and they’re thrilled,” she added, beaming. The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 9: The Woes of Mrs. Weasley
  2.  “It’s the first day of the holidays, remember?” said Ron, watching Harry closely. The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 11: The Firebolt 
  3. “I was jokin’ — jokin’!” he added hastily, seeing the looks on their faces  The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 37: The Beginning
  4. “If I don’t, all the Slytherins will think I’m just too scared to face Snape.  The Philosopher’s Stone - Chapter 13: Nicolas Flamel
  5. “Since when did you give me permission to do anything?” The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 25:  The Seer Overheard
  6. “And everyone knows I’m almost a Squib.”  The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 11: The Dueling Club
  7. Peeves flipped over and grinned at Dumbledore from between his own legs. The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 8: Flight of the Fat Lady

r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Order of the Phoenix One week of daylight at Hogwarts

68 Upvotes

I was reading through OotP once again, and noticed this passage, where Ron and Harry are trying to catch up on their homework the weekend after their first week back at Hogwarts:

“They spent the whole of Sunday in the common room, buried in their books while the room around them filled up, then emptied: It was another clear, fine day and most of their fellow Gryffindors spent the day out in the grounds, enjoying what might well be some of the last sunshine that year.”

It just struck me that one week in (ca. Sep. 7), they’re already saying goodbye to the sunlight… As I’m from a very sunny place, I forgot how dreary English weather is, and I was shocked that they’re already saying goodbye to good weather until the late spring/summer.

Edit: I didn’t realize Hogwarts was in the Scottish highlands, I had always assumed somewhere in northern England — my bad! I did not catch the Peebles mention in CoS.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 11h ago

Discussion What are they?

0 Upvotes

Whenever there's a mention of christmas in the books, it always irks me, to think if the people of Wizarding World are christians / catholics as they keep on celebrating christmas, exchanging gifts on christmas day, greeting each other.

So are they christian?

Do they even go to church?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Discussion Learning To Love HarryXGinny Again

45 Upvotes

I feel like besides the obvious ship of RonXHermione, this is close to i think one of the closet ''controversial'' ships of the series. Overtime, i just feel like i've seen way more people just flat out shit on them as a couple, and i can't lie, i kinda like thought about it as well. I used to think their relationship really wasn't developed as much, most of their bonding was shown off-screen, ginny just wasn't right for him, these complaints have been there forever, HOWEVER! On my last re-read of HBP, it just clicked for me, and i really just started to grow on them, ALOT.

One of the things i used to think and i feel like it's a common criticism is that, harry's infatuation with her pretty much just comes out of nowhere, like he see's her kissing dean and immediately he's on smoke. To me, i think that's realistic, you kinda just wake up sometimes and realize ''oh this person i know for a long time, i think i like them now!''

I feel like their seeds are planted way before HBP as well, i think back to this scene in OOTP

“I wish I could talk to Sirius,” he muttered. “But I know I can’t.” More to give himself something to do than because he really wanted any, Harry unwrapped his Easter egg, broke off a large bit, and put it into his mouth. “Well,” said Ginny slowly, helping herself to a bit of egg too, “if you really want to talk to Sirius, I expect we could think of a way to do it. …” “Come on,” said Harry hopelessly. “With Umbridge policing the fires and reading all our mail?” “The thing about growing up with Fred and George,” said Ginny thoughtfully, “is that you sort of start thinking anything’s possible if you’ve got enough nerve.” Harry looked at her. Perhaps it was the effect of the chocolate — Lupin had always advised eating some after encounters with dementors — or simply because he had finally spoken aloud the wish that had been burning inside him for a week, but he felt a bit more hopeful.

It's obviously telling that all of his friends he could've confided in, he chose to speak to ginny and not ron or hermione as you'd expect. It's a small scene for sure, but one that i think works really well, it's one of my favorite Hinny moments definitely.

I also love the idea that harry starts to fall in love with more because she starts playing quidditch and stuff, which idk i find funny. I think he really starts to fall in love with her, or develop his feelings in this scene in HBP.

“Fancy trying to find a compartment?” “I can’t, Harry, I said I’d meet Dean,” said Ginny brightly. “See you later.” “Right,” said Harry. He felt a strange twinge of annoyance as she walked away, her long red hair dancing behind her; he had become so used to her presence over the summer that he had almost forgotten that Ginny did not hang around with him, Ron, and Hermione while at school.

Again, these are all small scenes, but i think they plant the seeds of their relationship and doesn't make it feel like it just comes out of left-field. Again, there's alot more, but i think this scene specifically just how shows how open he is willing to be to ginny. It's like you compare the way he speaks to cho and it's he's nervous and stuff like that, whereas with ginny it doesn't even register to him at all. It's because they just have this sort of understanding, especially in this next scene.

She met Harry’s gaze with the same hard, blazing look that he had seen when she had hugged him after winning the Quidditch Cup in his absence, and he knew that at that moment they understood each other perfectly, and that when he told her what he was going to do now, she would not say, “Be careful,” or “Don’t do it,” but accept his decision, because she would not have expected anything less of him.

To me, that in particular is what i think harry appreciates about ginny the most, the fact that without even saying anything, he knew she would accept him leaving on his mission, that is what draws him to her so much. Which is also why i think HarryXHermione wouldn't work, because i don't see them connecting well at all, contrast this to HarryXGinny and they're pretty much soulmates man.

He chanced a glance at her. She was not tearful; that was one of the many wonderful things about Ginny, she was rarely weepy. He had sometimes thought that having six brothers must have toughened her up.

Is it me? Or is that harry's subconscious taking a dig at cho for being too whiny or whatever.

In conclusion, i think HarryXGinny are one of the best couples of the series. It kinda feels like an unpopular opinion, but hey! It's this fandom! Pretty much every opinion is unpopular. But what are your thoughts on HarryXGinny, do you think they deserve to be with each other? Or are they better off alone? Or are you one of those goblin people who really think that Harmione should've been canon /s LMK!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 1d ago

Hardback Books Box Set Gryffindor House Edition question

6 Upvotes

Can anyone with the Hardcover Gryffindor House Edition tell me what they look like without the dust covers? I've only seen one without a dust jacket and it was black. Are the others the same? I'm looking for a hardcover set with an understated unified look, so I'm hoping they all look the same.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #79

18 Upvotes

Mernin’. It’s time for 79. Enjoy!
As a reminder what this is and how it works:
Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.
Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

  1. “Remember that shriveled-up arm Malfoy had?” The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 7: The Slug Club
  2. “Nonsense, Petunia, I never went hungry when I was at Smeltings,” said Uncle Vernon heartily. The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 1: The Worst Birthday 

3. “What a lovely game, I don’t think!” The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 13: The Very Secret Diary

 4. “You didn’t do that . . . you can’t have done . . .” The Goblet of Fire - Chapter 35: Veritaserum

5. “Dumbledore’s coming back!” several people yelled joyfully. The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 16: The Chamber of Secrets

6. “In fact, I think it’s best if you don’t . . . yes . . . well, I’ll be off.” The Prisoner of Azkaban - Chapter 3: The Knight Bus

7. “I feel great at the moment, though,” said Harry, looking down at his clean, unblemished hands. The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 35: King’s Cross


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 2d ago

Underage magic

2 Upvotes

I had a thought while listening to THBP for the first time since reading it when it came out. Dumbledore tells Harry that the Ministry cant tell if an underage wizard had done magic, only that magic had been done. How then, did the ministry Know it was Harry who did the patronus in book 5? He's the only magic user in the area, so they assumed? If he was seen, wouldn't the dementors have been seen as well? Whats to stop death eaters from popping around little whinging all summer doing spells getting him in trouble

Let me know if I missed something, it's been a long time since I've read these, although I think I read them 5-6 times when they came out


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Deathly Hallows Ron and the Deluminator

20 Upvotes

I know this topic has popped up here couple of times before, but I just wanted to put it out there again. I read through the deathly hallows again and the part where Dumbledore’s will is read out loud. When it came to run, the will is very specific in saying that Ron will always come back. If you think about it, this is such an extraordinary foresight by Dumbledore. How did he know that Ron would run out on Harry and Hermione while they’re on the run and would want to go back to them immediately? How can the Deluminator even listen into Harry and Hermione’s conversation? And the orb that goes into run to take him directly to Harry and Hermione, how does that work? It’s also such an extraordinary piece of magic by Dumbledore. I know we don’t have the exact answers for the questions I posted, but re-reading makes me appreciate Dumbledore’s powers even more.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Can you guess the book and chapter? #78

23 Upvotes

Seventy eight and still young. Probably. I mean, I still enjoy making these.

As a reminder what this is and how it works:
Below are 7 sentences from the 7 HP books. I use a random number generator to pick the book and chapter, then hand pick a sentence that I think is decent. Not too long, too short, too obvious ect.  *** There MAY be repeated books in a set, but there will not be repeated chapters in a set. So there COULD be two from The Philosopher’s Stone, but they would be from different chapters! ***
Scoring your points: It is 2 points for guessing the book, and 1 point for guessing the chapter, for a total of 21 points. It is obviously harder to guess the chapter than the book, but not everyone even cares to remember the chapter titles in the first place, which is totally fair and valid. So chapter titles are just a bonus point.
Below are the sentences and the answers hidden behind spoiler tags! These are fun to make, and I intend to make quite a few more if people keep enjoying them!

1. “So what if I am?” said Hermione coolly, though her face was a little pink. The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 16: In the Hog’s Head

2. “I suppose you just let it out for exercise and —” The Chamber of Secrets - Chapter 13: The Very Secret Diary

3. “I’m getting an hour in before breakfast every day.” The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 31: O. W. L. 

 4. “S’no wonder Dumbledore’s angry with Sn —” The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 19: Elf Tails

 5. “Ministry-loving, family-disowning, power-hungry moron,” said Fred. The Deathly Hallows - Chapter 30: The Sacking of Severus Snape

 6. “Sorry!” yelled Harry, as Dean and Seamus roared with laughter, and Neville picked himself up from the floor, having fallen out of bed. The Half-Blood Prince - Chapter 12: Silver and Opals

7. He smirked as Malfoy sniggered and said in a carrying whisper, “Some people got D’s?” The Order of the Phoenix - Chapter 15: The High Inquisitor


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Half-Blood Prince Something that's always bugged me about the Department of Mysteries in OotP

29 Upvotes

I’ve been re-reading Order of the Phoenix and keep getting stuck on the Battle of the Department of Mysteries.

The Department of Mysteries is supposed to be one of the most restricted, high-security areas in the entire Ministry. It holds insanely sensitive and dangerous stuff, the Hall of Prophecy, the Time Room with all the Time-Turners, the Brain Room, the Death Chamber with the Veil, etc. This is the kind of place you’d expect to be locked down hard, especially at night.

Yet a group of teenagers and twelve Death Eaters basically walk in, fight their way through multiple rooms, smash shelves of Time-Turners, and cause total chaos with almost no immediate resistance or alarm response. The place feels weirdly empty and unprotected for something that important. Even the rotating room and the general layout don’t seem to slow anyone down much once they’re inside.

I get that it was night and that the Death Eaters had probably cleared some of the usual security beforehand, but it still feels off. For a department full of the wizarding world’s biggest secrets and most dangerous magical research, the actual defences feel surprisingly thin.

We can say Fudge was a terrible Minister, but surely there was still some other branch or department responsible for Ministry security? When a place like that gets attacked, you’d expect some kind of automatic warning system or reinforcements to show up. The fight with the Death Eaters went on for a while, and then the duel between Dumbledore and Voldemort and still almost no response. It’s hard to believe a dozen people (plus a few teenagers) could just take over that much of the Ministry with so little pushback.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Deathly Hallows Taboo

21 Upvotes

When the Deatheaters/Ministry made the name Voldemort as taboo, so that whoever spoke it they could put a trace , why don't they put a taboo on Harry's name so that they could capture the Order of the Phoenix members and the PotterWatch?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 4d ago

Voldemort could’ve saved the diadem if he’d paid attention to Draco’s plan

105 Upvotes

Voldemort could’ve saved the diadem if only he’d cared about what Draco was up to instead of just using him to punish Lucius for his fuckup in OotP.
Voldemort thought he was the only one who knew how the Room of Requirement worked. At least the part where you could hide things.

Had he paid even a little attention to Draco’s plan, he would’ve known that Draco had been going in and out of the room throughout the year, and eventually managed to bring a bunch of Death Eaters into Hogwarts through it at the end of HBP.

If Voldemort had given enough of a shit to actually listen to Draco’s plan, he would’ve realized the room wasn’t nearly as secret as he thought it was and could’ve moved the diadem somewhere else.

He might’ve just shoved it into the Lestranges’ vault alongside the cup. Either way, the diadem wouldn’t have been at Hogwarts, and the Battle of Hogwarts probably wouldn’t have happened the way it did.


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Deathly Hallows Deathly Hallows First Read Through!!

34 Upvotes

I'm currently sipping raspberry cranberry tea with a Christmas candle burning and the Ravenclaw common room playing as ambience on my TV whilst reading chapter 20 of the Deathly Hallows for the very first time. Not a bad way to spend an evening. 😌 Dealthy Hallows is a lot different than I expected but not in a bad way! Hope everyone else is having a great day!


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Discussion Did Dumbledore slander Merope Riddle?

21 Upvotes

To be clear, this is not a post to bash Dumbledore. I am not trying to disprove anything Dumbledore said. To be fair, Dumbledore admits that a lot of what he is telling Harry is guess work and never claims he, or his deductions, are infallible. His deductions are logical though, and end up being true most, if not all of the time. His reasoning skill borders on clairvoyance, as I saw a redditer put it. However, while most of his reasoning is guided by facts, interviews, and research (theories to suit facts), there are things, or at least one thing, he guesses about that could not possibly come from any reliable source.

He says that Merope Riddle bewitched Tom Riddle, either using a love potion or spell to make him her husband (he leans more toward love potion). What is Dumbledore's evidence for saying this? What reliable source could he possibly have used to get any facts about this matter? Merope was dead long before his investigation of Voldemort could have started, her brother and father were in azkaban when this would have happened, and Tom Riddle Sr and his parents were dead before Tom graduated Hogwarts. I suppose it is possible Dumbledore tracked down the Riddle family first due to being curious about young Tom, and got some information, but I find that incredibly unlikely because that would mean Dumbledore sent Voldemort back to the orphanage knowing he had a living relative. Possible, but I don't buy it. So who does that leave as a source of information? Village gossip which is notorious for being exaggerated and inaccurate?

So, there is no reliable 1st, or even 2nd hand witness as to how or why voldemorts parents got together. But here are the facts that Dumbledore could extrapolate from.

1st, Merope was abused and miserable and had a crush on Tom Riddle. Source-Bob Ogden

2nd, Merope was poor and not very attractive. Source-Bob Ogden

3rd, Tom Riddle was rich and handsome and seemed to have a girlfriend of sorts. Source-Bob Ogden

4th, Marvolo and Morphin were in azkaban when Tom Riddle and Merope ran away together. Source would be ministry records for azkaban and possibly Morphin's memory

5th, Tom Riddle abandoned Merope and returned to his parents' home at some point after Merope was pregnant, but before Tom was born. Young Tom was then born at wools orphanage and Merope died alone and penniless. Source-Morphin, Voldemort, and Wools orphanage.

5.5 He claimed to be bewitched, which everyone assumed meant she lied about being pregnant with his child or something like that. I count this as a half one because there is no reliable source for this claim. Village gossip is the only way this claim could have reached Dumbledore's ears.

6, Tom Riddle killed his father and Grandparents, likely for revenge for abandoning him, and framed Morphin. Source-Morphin and Voldemort.

7... is a magically powerful number.

Anyway, based on the above facts, Dumbledore's theory is that Merope offered Tom a cold drink on a hot day, spiked it with love potion, and ran off with him under her thrall. She got pregnant with Tom, started to believe the lie she was living that Tom loved her, or at least thought he would stay for the baby, but he did not. He left her and she died giving birth to their child. Tom on the other hand returned to his parents and, not wanting to sound crazy talking about witchcraft, he made something believable up.

This is a plausible theory. It is based on the assumption that the only way an ugly poor girl could get someone rich, handsome, and in a relationship to ditch the pretty girl and marry her instead was through love potion (proof that Dumbledore did not read shoujo). It is also based on the possibility that Merope's magic would've gotten stronger with the absence of her abusers. Not sure if this is a documented phenomenon, but it sounds legit and can kind of be seen with Neville to a degree.

But this is a theory based on bias against an ugly depressed girl, and bias in favor of the innocence, or the implicit victimhood, of muggles.

Here is an alternate theory that could just as easily be true as Dumbledore's.

Tom Riddle Sr was a cad. The woman he was with dumped him for his roguish behavior, and merope found out and comforted him. Or he sought her out as an unprotected naive female. He found her convenient to play around with, but didn't want rumors to start in the village, so he took her away and had his fun. She became pregnant, and not wanting to deal with a kid, he abandoned her. Her heart was broken and the rest we know.

I am not saying this is what happened, but based on the actual evidence, it very well could have.

None of this affects the plot. None of this excuses or changes how evil Voldemort is. But, the love potion theory, with only circumstantial evidence to back it up, is a bit slanderous toward a girl who could just as easily have been the victim of a cad of Jane Austen proportions.

Thoughts? Did I miss something? Is Dumbledore infallible and Merope is a kidnapper and a rapist? Or is she a victim of a lascivious entitled jerk?


r/HarryPotterBooks • • 3d ago

Discussion Another ill-advised attempt to fix the game design of Quidditch

9 Upvotes

Preamble: I don't think Quidditch being a poorly-designed game matters much for the story. It serves the purpose it's meant to for the narrative so this discussion is just for fun.

Firstly, I think everyone understands the problem with the game so no need to go into it, other than to simply state it as: none of what happens in the game matters except for the seekers, and also that a seeker down >150 points should never catch it.

I've seen a few suggestions for how to fix the game, but a lot of them are not satisfying to me. I think it's important to keep the fundamental dramatic element of the game, which is that catching the snitch is what wins the game.*

So, with that premise, I had this idea: What if the score of the game, which the remaining twelve players are playing, somehow determined how easy it was for the seekers to catch the snitch? With magic this could be done in almost any way, but dumb examples would be that the snitch moves towards the seeker of the winning team, or the seeker on the losing team somehow is slowed down compared to the other.

It would mean there's an actual incentive in the game to score points, as it would actually affect that team's win probability. It would also provide a dramatic mechanism for a "comeback" where the losing team seeker despite the odds manages to catch the snitch. In the present game, you could be down 50 but still just as likely to catch it as the other one.

Firstly, do people like the idea? Secondly, what would be a satisfying mechanic for how it would happen, so like how the "snitch-advantage" actually be put into action?

*Yes, the book features a quidditch game where catching the snitch loses the game. I think it's clear that if the game was real, this would never actually happen.