r/HayDay • u/Random_Name_122 • 2h ago
[Idea/Concept] The "Traveling Tinker / Factory Vendor" (Pay-Per-Slot Custom Rental Machine) - Duplicate machine alternative
We already know about the Hay Day machine bottleneck at higher levels, and Supercell doesn't want to keep giving us duplicate buildings like the second Sugar Mill back in 2021. Honestly, I understand why adding permanent duplicates isn't an optimal solution because it creates a slippery slope (if a second Dairy is released, people will immediately ask for a second Sauce Maker, a third Feed Mill, and so on).
Supercell clearly wants us to engage in social trading like the Daily Dirt (which, in reality, is mostly filled with botted wheat and iron/coal) or our Neighborhoods. And personally, I just don't like the concept of running a baby farm.
So, what is the concept?
Basically, it’s a new NPC who has the ability to temporarily duplicate any of your machines as a rental in their workshop. Unlike Tom’s forced 24-hour timer or Rose and Ernest’s scheduled shifts, with this NPC you pay per slot—for example, choosing a contract of 3, 6, or 9 slots. Whether you rent 9 slots to make Bread in 45 minutes or Jelly Beans that takes 9 whole days, it doesn't matter because you are paying for the slots, not the time.
How It Works (Core Mechanics)
- Pay-Per-Slot (Not Time-Limited): As mentioned, it doesn't matter if your queue takes 45 minutes or 9 days. As long as you paid for the slots, they remain yours until the items are finished and collected.
- Selective 3–9 Slots Unlocked Upfront: No diamond upgrades required. Once you sign the contract, your chosen slots (3, 6, or 9) are immediately open, unlike a brand-new machine. The contract simply stays active until all items have been produced and collected, after which the rental shuts down until you sign a new contract.
- Normal Production Timers (It’s Not Tom): You still provide your own raw ingredients, and the items still take their full, normal cooking time to finish. This keeps Tom’s instant-delivery niche completely safe while giving players a fair, balanced way to double their output.
- Functions Just Like the Real Machine: Collecting items from this rental grants full production XP, counts toward Derby tasks and event quests, and contributes to your main machine's 3-Star Mastery hours (unless workshop finally here).
- Access to Unpurchased Machines (Catch-Up Mechanic): For mid-game players who haven't saved up enough coins to buy a newly unlocked, expensive machine, this gives an alternative way to craft required items rather than getting soft-locked on orders. (or when you stuck first couple day because machine is on building) this is actually very big deal
Because of how this is designed, it should primarily use coins—or if Supercell wants to monetize it, maybe add a small diamond fee specifically for the highest 9-slot tier. The pricing should scale based on a percentage of the machine's original cost plus player level scaling, so it isn't broken for lower-level players and still encourages them to buy the real machine eventually.
"Wait, doesn't this sound like a coin loss? How do you make money if you pay too much to make the product?"
Yes and that is exactly why it’s designed this way.
This feature should unlock around Level 60+, which is when production bottlenecks become a real issue. And yes, this feature is not meant for making profit; it’s meant for keeping your production lines moving to make more items and gain XP. Even then, you aren't really "losing" money spending coins here isn't much different from sinking coins into buying a permanent machine; it's just an upfront investment. That’s also why players have to think strategically about what is actually worth crafting in those slots.
More importantly, this is a huge deal for high-level players. Once you unlock every machine, coins become practically useless except for decorations—and let’s be real, in the current state of the game, almost all new decorations cost real money, diamonds, Farm Pass, event currencies, or gacha crates. The game rarely asks for coins anymore outside of the classic OG golden series decorations. This would be a perfect coin sink for veteran players who just want to burn excess cash to level up faster.
Why This May Works?
- For Supercell: No extra buildings cluttering farm layouts, Tom's diamond value remains untouched since the rental still requires wait times and raw materials, and massive amounts of late-game coin inflation get wiped out naturally.
- For Casual & Mid-Game Players: A stress-free, coin-based safety net when you're behind on buying machines—zero timer anxiety since the contract waits until all your items are done (no need to set 2-hour alarms like with Tom).
- For End-Game Veterans: Finally, a meaningful and productive way to burn millions of dead coins in exchange for faster production and XP.
What do you guys think?