r/Hemingway • • 20h ago

Where should I go next with Hemingway?

12 Upvotes

I have been slowly reading Hemingway's bibliography. Last year I read the Old Man and The Sea and loved it. For a few months now I had been on and off reading the collection "The Short Stories: The first Forty-Nine Stories" and while not every single short story was a banger. I found all the Nick Adams short stories to be really good and I loved "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber".

What should be the next novel of his I should try? I am interested in For Whom The Bell Tolls, mostly because the Spanish Civil War is one of my favorite historical periods.


r/Hemingway • • 23h ago

Find Hemingway more tiring to read than something more flowery

2 Upvotes

I think because of the simpler language, more effort and space of my limited bandwidth can be put into visualising, given understanding is instantaneous.

Unsure how to feel about this though given I love interesting words but I feel like the scenes possible to draw are more varied precisely because of the simpler, LEGO like prose, when everything is made of smaller building blocks, the resolution is higher if you get what I mean.

Maybe big words are of limited use practically because of the increased strain on memory and decreased exposure to them, leading to more formulaic imagery given the stronger associations these words will have. It’s like downloading a modified asset into a video game that may not blend well, given the reader’s limited experience with the word.

Alternatively you could argue that more information/association dense, obscure words allow for more information to be stuck into the limited memory of the reader even at the cost of a deceased ability for the writer to ‘shape’ the image and more required of the reader and their associations.

To conclude big obscure association dense words -> less resolution and granularity of imagery given human memory constraints, balanced by potentially richer, denser imagery given they can use existing mental library of a reader built up by other works (idea being that common words associations are diluted)