r/HighStrangeness
•
u/bortakci34
•
2d ago
•
1
1
Paranormal How does a two-year-old recall the carrier, wingman, and final moments of a Navy pilot killed in 1945?
At just two years old, James Leininger began waking up screaming from terrifying nightmares of a burning plane crash. Before he could even read, he was shouting specific details in his sleep: "Airplane crash on fire! Little man can't get out!"—along with names like Natoma and Jack Larsen. When his mother once pointed to a toy plane in a store and called it a regular bomber, the toddler immediately corrected her, saying it was a Corsair, and later pointed directly at a photo of Iwo Jima in a book, insisting that was where his plane had been shot down.
His skeptical father, Bruce, decided to investigate to prove his son was simply making things up. What he uncovered in military archives and veterans' reunions stunned the entire family: USS Natoma Bay was a real WWII escort carrier, Jack Larsen was a real pilot who had served on it, and a 21-year-old pilot named James M. Huston Jr. had indeed been shot down in flames over the Pacific near Iwo Jima on March 3, 1945—his body and aircraft never recovered. Even more remarkably, records of the boy's statements—including an unaired television interview recorded before the family ever identified Huston—documented these exact names and crash details in advance. When James later met Huston's surviving elderly sister, Anne, the specific personal memories he shared left her convinced she was speaking with her lost brother.
While skeptics have debated whether subtle cues or museum visits could explain parts of the story, the documented timeline of a toddler naming a specific carrier, a fellow pilot, and the exact circumstances of a 1945 death before any records were found remains one of the most unsettling reincarnation cases ever recorded.




128
u/nightman21721 2d ago •
this is being investigated by UVA health
363
u/SpyCats 2d ago
I love this story. If you haven’t already done so, read up on the work of Dr Ian Stevenson. He did an exhaustive study of children who claimed to remember past lives. His conclusions give scientific evidence that reincarnation is very real.
22
u/Rawrmeow_ 2d ago
This topic is really fascinating to me. If you haven't read it yet, Surviving Death by Leslie Keane goes through this case and a couple more at the very beginning of the book. Super interesting!
68
u/RobHonkergulp 2d ago
A few years ago I was woken up by the sound of my very distressed wife sleeptalking in a foreign language. It sounded Eastern European, Polish or maybe Russian. She doesn't remember this and only speaks English. It only happened once but it did make me wonder about reincarnation.
18
u/korevmorlader 1d ago
The timeline presented here leaves out a lot of important context that makes the story far less watertight than it sounds.
- The Corsair discrepancy: James insisted he flew a Corsair, which is the plane he saw during an earlier trip to the Cavanaugh Flight Museum in Texas (where they also had plenty of WWII Pacific books and videos). However, the USS Natoma Bay didn't carry Corsairs - James Huston was flying an FM-2 Wildcat when he was shot down.
- The unaired TV footage: Bruce Leininger had already started researching the Natoma Bay months before ABC News filmed them in late 2002. In the actual footage, James isn't spontaneously rattling off historical facts; he's mostly giving "yes/no" answers or vague replies to leading questions from his parents.
- His father's "scepticism": Despite always being framed as a hard-nosed sceptic, Bruce's own book mentions he was reading up on past lives early on, while his wife Andrea believed in reincarnation from the start and took James to a past-life therapist when he was still a toddler.
- Meeting Huston's sister: By the time they tracked down Huston's identity and met his sister Anne, James was already five or six years old—several years after the initial nightmares. The parents had also corresponded with Anne by phone and letter before the in-person meeting, meaning personal details could easily have been shared and inadvertently passed on to James beforehand.
There's no real suggestion the parents set out to pull a deliberate hoax, and it's an interesting story regardless, but once you look at the actual sequence of events, parental reinforcement and confirmation bias explain it much better than past-life memories do.
89
u/TheAngryCatfish 2d ago
Watching him talk about it in his 20s is wild, because while he says he doesn't remember having those memories, and says it's more his parents story than his, he still gets all choked up and teary eyed when he talks about the death of this WW2 aviator. He is far from the only case of past life "memory" either. There have even been cases where young children had enough information from these "memories" that their parents were able to track down the extant relatives of the person from this "past life" so to speak. It's all very interesting, The Atlantic had a whole wrote up years ago about the research being done in this area, strictly regarding young children with these so-called memories, that typically lose those "memories" after the age of 5 or 6
53
u/-Glittering-Soul- 2d ago
Why do so many blurbs get posted on this subreddit without any sources or citations?
27
u/Big_Meech_23 2d ago
As someone not in tune with this story or topic. Couldn’t this child have some other anomaly or special memory? For instance he heard something on the radio about the story and somehow at a very young age retained the info causing him nightmares? The response to that would be oh that’s impossible. Yeah maybe but seems more plausible than this. There’s large groups of ppl out there that claim they remember things clearly from when they were 1 or 2 years old. Hell there’s ppl that say they remember their mom talking to them while they were in the womb. The dad may say I was never exposed to this story so how could my son have been exposed. Well maybe you had it on the radio in the garage and you weren’t paying attention but the kid was. Again I have no idea, just being devils advocate.
13
u/dumbcunt33 2d ago
His story is documented on the Netflix show "Surviving Death". It's fascinating
42
u/MNFuturist 2d ago •
World population didn't even hit ONE billion until 1804. Now it's over eight billion. Where are all the new people coming from if everyone is reincarnated?
22
u/SuckItTrebeck15 2d ago
Wasn’t this story on the Netflix show Surviving Death too?
11
u/scrumbob 2d ago
This is a common enough phenomenon (albeit not usually to this level of specific detail) that it’s definitely worth studying further
18
u/Waydarer 2d ago
Samsara.
9
u/WalkerTimothyFaulkes 2d ago
Before his father identified any of this, James Leininger was signing his airplane drawings as "James III". James Huston was a junior. If he really was reincarnated, then James Leininger would indeed be "the Third" James, which I always found to be another interesting detail.
I love his story. I watched it on Surviving Death on Netflix. Some people want to poopoo his story, but I believe it.
48
u/number1dipshit 2d ago
I don’t really believe in reincarnation, but my girl does have a very weird story about watching a holocaust video school and freaked out when she saw a group of people she felt like she knew personally. And she will NOT watch anything about WWII with me because if it.
No other weird things tho.
8
u/webdeveler 2d ago
I have a feeling kids who are recalling past experiences are tapping into consciousness threads. I don't think it's a person being reincarnated. It seems suspicious that most of these "memories" are from relatively recent people and also all the experiences are human. No one ever remembers being a koi fish in feudal Japan.
Violent deaths also seem to stand out more to kids who have these memories. So time, intensity, and similarity seem to be factors in past life recollections.
7
u/LimpCroissant 2d ago
Maybe people who have alien experiences and high intuition/psychic abilities, reincarnated from a non-human being.
13
u/yesds 2d ago
I'd be curious to know if the children maintain the same interests and personality as the person that they have memories of.
18
u/3pinripper 2d ago
How? It’s either reincarnation, or we all have access to information floating in “the ether” (or whatever) and little bro pulled it out of there.
6
u/RedAirRook 2d ago
The book about this case is called "Soul Survivor."
6
u/MerrillSwingAway 2d ago
This entire thread is great!
6
u/Immediate_Donkey_140 1d ago
I went through some military training with this guy a few years back and when we found out his story it was all we talked about for days. Nice kid.
13
u/dou8le8u88le 2d ago
Im convinced it’s a thing. There’s just so many examples like this.
9
u/TexasGriff1959 2d ago
I've read a bit about this one. Spooky damn story.
8
u/Andynonymous303 1d ago
In all my life i will never forget the time our son told both of us that he saw us and his sister before he was born and chose to become a part of our family. Wife and I looked at each other and I nodded.. and then I showed her this exact story. Yes it was a very weird experience and that was not the first time my son has surprised me with sentences like this.
4
u/GringoSwann 2d ago
Cycle of reincarnation...
4
u/Gloomy-Hat1842 2d ago
There are plenty of stories like this. Check out the work of Ian Stevenson at the University of virginia. He studied it scientifically for quite a while. A lot of cases of India but we have about plenty in the states also.
4
u/twistedstance 2d ago
The book ‘surviving death’ by Leslie Keane includes this story. It blew me away, as did the other examples it included.
4
u/SublimeRapier06 2d ago
If I recall the story correctly, when his mother showed him the model plane she said, “Look! It has a big bomb underneath it.” He replied back, “No, mommy. It’s not a bomb. It’s a dwop tank.” <little kid pronunciation>
12
u/deckard1980 2d ago
Its the simulation overwriting data
3
u/Born_Medicine_5932 1d ago
The Navy Pilot used to exist in the same spot on the hard-drive that the 2 year old exists when he came online. Fragments of the Navy Pilot existed until they were eventually overwritten by the boy's new experiences.
2
u/psychesoul 2d ago
I was just watching about this on yt. Ky Dickens has an episode about this in her channel telepathy tapes.
2
u/Walterwhiteboy 2d ago
It would be awesome if there was a good podcast about this
2
u/Consistent_Low2080 2d ago
The correct is l don’t know.
2
u/oncall66 1d ago
Consciousness is not local. Our brains are like radios that receive a very narrow band. Sometimes signals get crossed.
2
u/FuckYouVeryMuch2020 1d ago
One of theories that Joe McMoneagle had was that reincarnation didn’t simply mean when you die, you come back as a newborn human somewhere else. Joe believes that when you come back, you might come back into 8 bodies, some male, some female, some ethnic, maybe at different ages too. The logic holds because if we are all just fragments of the divine, maybe the divine wants to see how all these different versions of “you” handle various situations from different walks of life. Maybe that kindred spirit is actually you, lol!
8
u/LongDead_Roadkill 2d ago
I worked as an educator and with kids for 20 years, my concern is with adult interpretation of what the kids say. Kids say something some weird, the adult goes looking for something that matches, then the untrained adult asked leading questions or otherwise skews any data collected before an actual researcher can get involved and by that time the kid is unintentionally primed with some info. Remember facilitated communication, how it turned out to be communicator interpretation in the vast majority of cases? This might be like that.
I grew up in a community where the adults pushed past life experiences on to the kids, they really wanted us to tell them about our past lives “before we were old enough to lose our ability to recall them”.
4
u/unknownmichael 2d ago
For anyone interested in the subject of reincarnation, I highly recommend the new season of The Telepathy Tapes Podcast. It currently has six episodes out and focuses on various cases of reincarnation including touching on the one in this post.
Just listened to the whole season while I was driving all day yesterday. Fascinating stuff.
3
u/sharkbomb 2d ago
the same way that psychics work. vagueries that refine in response to positive reenforcement.
1
u/YSOSEXI 2d ago
I hope it's bs, no chance I wanna come back......
1
u/murdermeMickey 1d ago
Maybe time doesn't move in one direction
1
u/Purple-Cable-4512 1d ago
It's called a FAMILIAR SPIRIT
1
u/Catch_022 21h ago
The issue for me is that there is no independent verification - we are going on what the parents said that the kid said.
If the kid 100% said these things then wow.
1
u/StatisticallySassy17 3h ago
I believe in reincarnation. Our fears are somehow tied to our past lives.
Drowning, driving over bridges. It just makes my heart pound, makes my hands sweaty. I freak out.
1
u/MissInkeNoir 1d ago
Ohio State University philosophy professor Steven M Brown shared a 45 minute lecture presenting all his favorite evidence for reincarnation phenomena, I bet you'll get a lot out of this. https://youtu.be/qDjuDtlvsJ8
-5
u/corvus66a 2d ago
Plan’s razor says it is Mitch more likely the parents “build” this story than it was actual reincarnation. There is no point that couldn’t come from them somehow. The other famous story about the boy as former Hollywood manager is a little better but also no prove.,
-2
u/smashfinger 2d ago
toddler distinguishing corsair vs bomber without prior exposure? nah.
0
u/Current_Teaching7572 2d ago
Same way Travis won the He12man trophy. He HIM