There was a video floating around the internet in the late 90s of Hynek talking to a bunch of engineers at lockheed. The subject was a tictac shaped craft which he had a cross section diagram of covering a blackboard. They didnt talk about the propulsion or power system in this short clip, but he did mention "the head is in the rear". "Head" being the bathroom. He also mentioned we would have these craft "in a decade or two".
In 2015 the CIA declassified a 1998 document that said that when the Air Force was openly, publicly studying UFOs in Project Blue Book and related projects, about half of UFO reports turned out to be secret military projects. The Air Force and CIA were very concerned that calling a UFO report "unexplained" would draw attention to it. So their policy was if they knew it was secret military aircraft, they would cook up an explanation, however ridiculous in the hopes that the general public would write it off. The declassified memo doesn't explicitly say this, but this is probably where a lot of the really ridiculous "ice crystals that show up on radar as a high-altitude craft" or "swamp gas...in the middle of the desert" explanations came from.
Kelly Johnson seeing something in the sky that he didn't know about does give me some pause. He would have had unparalleled insight into defense aerospace tech. But even he was not omniscient about black projects. Anything at Lockheed would have been in his purview, but other companies like Northrup and Convair were also testing exotic aircraft. The Navy was also in aerospace at the time and pretty insulated from the Air Force. This sighting is weird as hell, but it does have the hallmarks of a UFO report that turned out to be some secret squirrel test platform.
But the file also has signs that it wasn't super well investigated which is also weird because of the credibility of the witnesses. There were ebbs and flows of investigative rigor in the investigations. This would have been not long after Cpt. Ruppelt left Project Blue Book, so probably a point when the Air Force was more in a "nothing to see here, move along" period. Which could also explain why it doesn't seem to have been particularly well-investigated.
Interestingly, even though a lot of the sightings were explainable, they still had hundreds of sightings that remained unexplained. This included hundreds of radar-visual sightings. And the declassified memo suggests that these unexplained sightings were probably not secret military aircraft.
Awesome comment. I’m a big proponent of UFOs are real, and they’re ours.
90s person calling Air Force: “I saw something in the sky, a flying triangle! Should I worry?” “What’s that? You saw a flying triangle? Definitely not an intercontinental ballistics delivery system. Definitely aliens”
If even a portion of Mirage Men (2013) was true then they actively spread rumours and lies for sake of cover of secret projects.
I'm a published author and I was working on a nonfiction book about the history of UFOs. I kind of gave up when I reached the Bennewitz Affair because once the AFOSI started active counter intelligence operations there's just no hope of getting at the truth from that point on. Like I'm not fully convinced Doty wasn't just a pathological liar who happened to work for the Air Force. Like I believe he pushed Bennewitz over the edge but I'm not sure if that was his day job or just a hobby. A lot of the details of the Beenwitz Affair come from Doty and he is literally, by his own admission and as a key point of the narrative, a professional liar.
Air Materiel Command had different objectives that AFOSI. They kind of swung back and forth between "nothing to see here" and wanting to wash their hands of UFOs and being really convinced there was something really weird going on. If you dig into the history, there their disposition was more about the behind the scenes politics that the evidence.
A lot of my own beliefs about UFOs come from the statistics that Project Blue Book collected. Hynek and others have pointed out patterns in the published statistical analysis that don't support the official conclusions of Project Blue Book. In their final publication, Project Blue Book Special Report Nº14, the Air Force published a statistical analysis of all the files from Projects Blue Book, Grudge, and Sign. The report's conclusion downplays it, but after you filter out the explained sightings (including a bunch of U2s, SR-71s, and Skyhooks), there were still hundreds of unexplained cases. These cases tended to be the best investigated cases.
I personally think that most UFO reports are explainable but that there is some weird phenomenon at the heart of it. But this mythos with abductions, crop circles, and crash retrievals, has made it next to impossible to tease apart in a meaningful way. Unexplained doesn't mean "space aliens" but there does seem to be something genuinely bizarre going on.
If you liked Mirage Men, you should try to track down Shades of Gray (2009). It's about Gray Barker, one of the writers who popularized several famous UFO cases. It goes into his psychology and how he liked to make stuff up when he was in certain moods. He had a hand in creating the legend of the Philadelphia Project.
It's kind of hard to find; I think the production company went out of business not long after. But if you can find it, it's one of my favorites and it's in the same vein as Mirage Men, but from a very different segment of the mythos.
I agree fully about Richard Doty being an unreliable narrator regardless of how much you believe of what he says. His own admission is that he’s a professional disinfo agent/liar. So why is he telling any more or less truth now? lol
Thank you for the recommendation! I appreciate it.
I lean towards break away civilizations and black tech being most likely given we already have civilization and tech. I’ve always been open to the idea humans made flying saucers at least 100 years ago.
One thing I can never get over is how advanced the SR-71 looked for its time. It could have been designed today and still look advanced and futuristic ... and that thing was designed in the 60s?
Skunkworks is a wild bunch. I really think they could have pulled off something like the tic tac today.
If any of us said "I read an anecdote from an insider relaying a sighting he claims he had," we'd get 100% shit on. Kudos for getting the clicks a "here's my take," worker needs, Shermer.
19
u/Pixelated_ 22h ago
This reminds me of J. Allen Hynek starting out as a massive skeptic to then become a full believer after he examined the available evidence.
17
u/Sparky_Valentine 1d ago
In 2015 the CIA declassified a 1998 document that said that when the Air Force was openly, publicly studying UFOs in Project Blue Book and related projects, about half of UFO reports turned out to be secret military projects. The Air Force and CIA were very concerned that calling a UFO report "unexplained" would draw attention to it. So their policy was if they knew it was secret military aircraft, they would cook up an explanation, however ridiculous in the hopes that the general public would write it off. The declassified memo doesn't explicitly say this, but this is probably where a lot of the really ridiculous "ice crystals that show up on radar as a high-altitude craft" or "swamp gas...in the middle of the desert" explanations came from.
Kelly Johnson seeing something in the sky that he didn't know about does give me some pause. He would have had unparalleled insight into defense aerospace tech. But even he was not omniscient about black projects. Anything at Lockheed would have been in his purview, but other companies like Northrup and Convair were also testing exotic aircraft. The Navy was also in aerospace at the time and pretty insulated from the Air Force. This sighting is weird as hell, but it does have the hallmarks of a UFO report that turned out to be some secret squirrel test platform.
But the file also has signs that it wasn't super well investigated which is also weird because of the credibility of the witnesses. There were ebbs and flows of investigative rigor in the investigations. This would have been not long after Cpt. Ruppelt left Project Blue Book, so probably a point when the Air Force was more in a "nothing to see here, move along" period. Which could also explain why it doesn't seem to have been particularly well-investigated.
Interestingly, even though a lot of the sightings were explainable, they still had hundreds of sightings that remained unexplained. This included hundreds of radar-visual sightings. And the declassified memo suggests that these unexplained sightings were probably not secret military aircraft.
5
u/Dreamstatesuz 21h ago
The first craft I ever saw looked exactly like this depiction. Made my heart palpitate.
5
u/usps_made_me_insane 19h ago
One thing I can never get over is how advanced the SR-71 looked for its time. It could have been designed today and still look advanced and futuristic ... and that thing was designed in the 60s?
Skunkworks is a wild bunch. I really think they could have pulled off something like the tic tac today.
5
u/DieKaiserVerbindung 19h ago
If any of us said "I read an anecdote from an insider relaying a sighting he claims he had," we'd get 100% shit on. Kudos for getting the clicks a "here's my take," worker needs, Shermer.
3
u/scienceworksbitches 20h ago
great to see he actually was a proper skeptic after all! i was into his stuff (no homo) before i had to except that there is more going on.