r/HistoryWhatIf • • 33m ago

What if Turkey joined the Warsaw Pact instead of NATO?

1 Upvotes

Post inspired by u/Lakkea on r/Alternate


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1h ago

What if, after the Fall of France in June 1940, Britain made peace with Hitler because the UK and US viewed Stalin’s USSR as the bigger threat?

0 Upvotes

Assume that following the Fall of France in June 1940, the British War Cabinet (perhaps led by Lord Halifax instead of Churchill) decides that Nazi Germany is a manageable European power, while Stalin’s Soviet Union represents the real existential threat to the West.

Britain signs a negotiated peace with Germany—accepting German dominance on the continent in exchange for keeping the British Empire intact and lifting the naval blockade. Both the UK and the US then pivot to viewing Hitler as a useful bulwark against communism, withholding Lend-Lease from the Soviets and perhaps even providing Germany with trade, oil, or diplomatic backing when Operation Barbarossa begins.

How does this change the course of the war and the post-war world? Specifically:

  1. Could the USSR survive Operation Barbarossa without Western Lend-Lease and with Germany fighting a one-front war?
  2. How does the Pacific War play out if the US has no European theater to worry about?
  3. If Germany defeats or cripples the USSR, what does the resulting Cold War between a dominant Nazi Europe and the Anglo-American bloc look like in the late 1940s and 1950s?

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 11h ago

What if Germany had kept control of Namibia after World War I?

5 Upvotes

Namibia was one of the handful of German colonies in sub-Saharan Africa prior to World War I.

In 1915, the armed forces of the Union of South Africa seized control of Namibia from the Germans and made Namibia a protectorate of South Africa. It would not be until the signing of the Versailles Treaty in 1919, though, that Germany gave up control of Namibia.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 14h ago

What if Abraham Lincoln accepted a division of war elephants from the King of Siam, and it inspired future presidents to import megafauna to the US?

5 Upvotes

Suppose in 1862, instead of a single pair of elephants, the King of Siam suggestsgifting a division of war elephants, and appropriate trainers to the United States. Abraham Lincoln accepts, and attach them to the Army of the Potomac at the Battle of Antietam. Depending on the results of the battle, Lincoln either decides they aren't worth it and releases them, or after the Civil War his successor decides to release them in a suitable habitat somewhere in around southern Missouri, northern Arkansas, and the Ozark region. Decades later, when the bill to release hippos in Louisianna crosses Theodore Roosevelt's desk, he happily signs it, along with a few similar bills. Like releasing bengal tigers in the Florida Everglades to control the wild boar population, releasing african lions in California to address the deer population, and releasing emus in Texas for farming. What is the impact on America's ecology, and history?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 13h ago

What if the US went ahead with Project Iceworm despite all the warnings?

1 Upvotes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Iceworm

What impact does this have on the cold war?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 20h ago

What if the USA did the Belt and Road Initiative instead of China?

2 Upvotes

In light of the this sub’s rule against posts taking place within the past 20 years, my Headcanon depicts this occurring sometime between January 1, 1991 and December 31, 2005.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 17h ago

What if the Western Allies had allowed German military aircraft development to continue after Nazi Germany's surrender?

1 Upvotes

Under the terms of the agreements reached at Yalta and Potsdam, the Allies agreed that Germany would be forbidden to engage in work related to the armaments industry, and that included military aircraft development.

The Junkers EF 126, EF 131, and EF 132 programs had not progressed beyond the design phase at the end of the European theater of World War II, but the Soviets let Junkers engineers to continue with these projects, culminating in initial test flights of the EF 126 pulsejet-powered ground attack aircraft in the Soviet-occupied zone of Germany and test flights of the EF 131 in the USSR.

The Messerschmitt P.1101 prototype was nearly complete when American GIs overran the factory in Oberammergau where the P.1101 had been manufactured. However, the Americans neglected to let the P.1101 be completed and test flown in Bavaria.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 20h ago

What if the veneration of the Virgin Mary was never widely adopted in Christianity?

0 Upvotes

First, some historical context:

It seems that there was not a significant amount of focus on Mary by "Jesus followers" in the 1st and 2nd Centuries. Most surviving information we have outside of the Biblical cannon seems to only talk about her as part of the debate over Christ's humanity. It was not until the 3rd Century that the Proto-Gospel of James and several other devotional texts showed up that gave her the elevated status of Theotokos (God-bearer). It was at the Council of Ephesus in 431 that the mainstream Church officially endorsed the veneration of the Virgin Mary.

So, how different would things be if the Church never officially supported Marian devotion or even declared that the practice was heresy?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 22h ago

What would happen if llamas somehow disappeared into Eurasia from ancient times?

0 Upvotes

how this would change history and agriculture, especially in mountain societies


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 18h ago

What if: Britain surrenders alongside France during WW2

0 Upvotes

Whether it be through the complete destruction of the BEF at Dunkirk, or British policitians like Halifax having their way and negotiating for peace, what would WW2 have looked like without the UK involved post-1940?

Assume the invasion of Russia and Pearl Harbour still happen as they did in OTL.

Would Germany declare war on the US and vice versa as they did in OTL after PH?

Without the Britain and The Commonwealth nations to provide support, what does war in Russia look like? How would North Africa go (Would the Germans demand access to British oil fields?)

Edit: I'm unsure of what sort of surrender this should be (e.g unconditional or conditional), pick one that would seem reasonable.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What if the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth was never formed?

4 Upvotes

While there was personal unions beforehand, Poland and Lithuania weren’t united until 1569


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

Challenge: Have the American Civil War happen earlier

15 Upvotes

The original version of this challenge had a grammar error. This is a redo.

In our timeline, the American Civil War started on April 12, 1861.

Your objective is to create an alternate series of events that lead to the American Civil War happening BEFORE 1861 (The year 1861 is the cutoff date).

You must examine the following question: What sorts of OTL events would need to be altered or prevented in order to trigger the American Civil War on any date between January 1, 1790 and April 12 1861 (April 12, 1861 is the cutoff date)?

Rules: You are allowed to involve other countries and you are allowed to have the trigger be over something other than or instead of slavery


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

How would American slaveholders back in the day react if you told them that the 44th president of the United States would be Black—and that he’d get reelected for a second term?

0 Upvotes

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What if Interent and social media existed already during WW2?

2 Upvotes

I wonder how Internet would look like then? How Axis and Allies countries and citizens would have interacted online? Would have been a curious sight.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if the Nazis simply didn't attempt to start a second World War ?

107 Upvotes

I just watched a video about how there was no way in hell the Nazis could have every won WWII, and I left me wondering "what if they Nazis could tell there was no way for them to win that and they just don't ?" Obviously this would be very out of pattern for their behavior and wouldn't have been a decision they would have made considering their whole thing is fascism and fascism has to either eat someone else or eat itself and their whole goal was to show a strong Germany again, but I still wonder.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What if Jesus of Nazareth was a woman?

0 Upvotes

Does basically nothing change? Are christians suddenly much cooler with women in general? The Catholics must certainly be ok with female priests now right?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

How long could the Mongol Empire have feasibly lasted if it hadn't splintered apart?

12 Upvotes

Title


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 1d ago

What would a Post-Communist flag of the USSR have looked like?

0 Upvotes

Let’s say the USSR successfully survives the 1990s and transitions into a multi-ethnic, semi-democratic state with competitive elections (somehow).

With communism no longer the official ideology of the USSR, would the USSR have kept its old hammer and sickle flag? If not, what would a post-communist flag for the Soviet Union have looked like?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What If West Germany was Annexed by France & East Germany was Annexed by Poland

0 Upvotes

West Germany (Part 1), East Germany (Part 2)

Back in season 1, What Could Have Been looked into a timeline where after WW2, instead of the US, Great Britain & France turning their occupied German territories into the quasi-sovereign nation of West Germany, most of the land was just given over to France.

First France just claimed the Southern regions of the territory that it was controlling as its own. Spoils of war. Then the UK & the US decided that occupying fragments of a broken & devastated Germany just weren't worth it, so they handed most of the land over to France.

How will the German people of this new Eastern France fair? How will they be treated? Will they assimilate? Will they rebel? Will France change them? Will they change France? Tune into What Could Have Been to see what might have happened in a timeline where France annexed West Germany after the war.

In Season 2, we revisited this timeline to talk about how instead of the Soviet Union having it's occupied zone become the quasi-sovereign nation of East Germany, it was instead given to & annexed by Communist Poland.

Seeing the bulk of the Western half of Germany going to France & not wanting any trace of Germany to exist after the second world war, the Eastern regions of Germany were incorporated into Poland, a country that suffered heavily at the hands of Germany in both world wars.

With the Eastern German territories now the region of West Poland, how did the history of Eastern Europe play out in this timeline? How will the German people of this new Western Poland fair? Will they embrace Communism? Will they try to restore Fascism? How will they be treated? Will they assimilate? Will they rebel? Will Poland change them? Will they change Poland? Will they try to flee West? Will the Soviet Union still fall?

Tune Into What Could Have Been to find out what might have happened if West Germany had been Annexed by France & East Germany had been Annexed by Poland.

What Could Have Been is a sci-fi podcast where your host interviews alternate versions of himself from across the multiverse to find out how different decisions, actions & events might have changed the course of history. Listen to the stories of alternate timelines from a world where the Space Race never ended, to a world where France annexed West Germany after WWII, to a timeline where North America is being ripped apart by a new Faultline, to a timeline where humanity was contacted by aliens in the early 70s. Listen to what happened in these wild timelines & find out What Could Have Been.

NSFW (due to language)

Episodes - 22

Spotify, Apple, Deezer, PocketCast, Goodpods, Acast & Many More

You can also Follow What Could Have Been on Bluesky or here on Reddit.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if the 1.1M Soviet force, air armies, and 62nd Army from Operation Uranus were available in June 1942 to block Case Blue head-on?

2 Upvotes

Instead of retreating across the steppe and fighting in the ruins of Stalingrad, what if the Red Army had the full Operation Uranus force (1.1M+ men, ~900 tanks, 13,000 artillery pieces, three upgraded air armies, and Chuikov’s 62nd Army) deployed right on the Southern/Southwestern Front in June 1942 to meet the freshly re-equipped Wehrmacht head-on?

A few questions I’m curious to get your thoughts on:

  1. The Initial Clash: Could the Soviet air reinforcements and deep defensive lines blunt the summer 1942 Luftwaffe and Panzer spearheads in open terrain, or would German combined-arms doctrine still force a breakthrough?
  2. An "Early Kursk": If the Soviets absorb the initial shock and stall Army Group South in eastern Ukraine, does this essentially become a 1942 version of the Battle of Kursk—a brutal slugfest that breaks Germany's offensive capability a year early?
  3. The Strategic Irony: Paradoxically, would both sides actually be "better off" in the short term? The USSR saves millions of civilians and the Donbas/Caucasus, while the Wehrmacht avoids the total annihilation of the 6th Army and its Axis allies—potentially creating a much tougher German defensive wall in 1943 and prolonging the war.

How do you see this playing out tactically and strategically?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

Challenge: Have a fringe ideology become mainstream in Turkey

1 Upvotes

Your objective is to create a plausible alternate timeline where a fringe ideology becomes mainstream in Turkey.

Rules:

  1. In light of the sub having rules against scenarios occurring within the past 20 years, your scenario must happen by 2006.
  2. You are allowed to pick a real fringe movement or make one up.
  3. Your fringe movement must gain considerable support in the Turkish government (or at least the Turkish people).

r/HistoryWhatIf • • 2d ago

What if Jim Jones wasn't evil?

0 Upvotes

Let’s assume that the pastor and cult leader Jim Jones wasn’t evil, but rather a simple utopian socialist who took his congregation to Guyana to live in a commune—where no one was coerced into either going or staying.

Could Jones have acquired land suitable for cultivation? Would being less cult-like and more committed to communal ideals have led to his arrest or murder?


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 3d ago

Challenge: Have Taiwan and Mainland China switch places

2 Upvotes

Your objective: Create a plausible series of events in which the Chinese Civil War ends with Mao's Communists losing and fleeing to Taiwan instead of Chiang Kai-Shek and the Nationalists in our timeline.

Your proposed scenario must address the following question: What kinds of OTL events would need to change or be prevented entirely to make such an outcome possible?

Author's note: I'm not talking about swapping places Geographically.


r/HistoryWhatIf • • 3d ago

What were the biggest border changes that would’ve happened in the last 80 years?

6 Upvotes

Ever since the establishment of the UN, it is illegal to invade and conquer other regions. Some of the more popular border chances were usually forms of decolonization (like colonial Africa or Soviet Union breaking into multiple independent countries)

However was there a scenario where an invasion was almost accepted or a unification between two states?