Looking for some advice for how to proceed here because I am totally lost. I don’t know how I should proceed but I generally have a bad gut feeling about the recommendations and I feel it is a scenario where they have a hammer and everything looks like a nail.
Useful context:
- bought this home in Great Lakes region this year
- home is 18 years old
I had a hairline crack in my 18 year old home’s poured concrete foundation in the unfinished part of my nation that I noticed for the first time ever started seeping the last time we had a few days of steady rain. It was maybe 6-12 inches long, horizontal, and maybe, maybe the width of a human hair or two. As soon as rain stopped, 1 hour later it dried right up. I ordered a DIY polyurethane injection fix kit but ultimately I decided this crack was way too small for this but I wanted it fixed. So I called a local basement waterproofing company with 4.9 stars on google. They send out a guy today same day I call to take a look at this microscopic crack I want to seal to get it over with
This crack was about 4-6 inches directly below the window sill of the glass block window in my basement. I bought this house earlier this year and with it I inherited a very large stamped concrete patio that is probably DIYd. It seems they poured the patio and then decided for some reason to cut it into 2 rows of 6 5ft by 9ft blocks. Well the row closest to my house is terribly sloping towards the foundation. It has been heavily caulked against the foundation in all places except for where for some reason the patio butts right up against said block window.
I had concrete levelers come out and I am scheduled to get my patio sloping away from the house very soon. Patio guys confirm that yeah, it’s dumping water towards foundation and that’s no bueno.
The waterproofing guy arrives, I show him my patio for context. We go downstairs, and the whole thing unravels.
I show him the crack and he gets his laser level out. Starts doing stuff. Gets the moisture meter out. I ask what the instruments are for and he starts explaining. He shows me the laser level being held vertically along the problematic wall has the line hitting part of basement wall and not the floor. Said the level was dying and I could only see it for about 2 seconds at any given time. He shows me this moisture meter reading “60”
All the way up the wall. Then he sees the previous owners epoxy/poly filled vertical floor to ceiling cracks. I pull back some of the vapor barrier, I reveal some more. Then the video comes out with the full commentary of how homes are built with drainage around the foundation etc. he points to some discoloration in the concrete all along the border of the basement where the floor meets the wall and says thats a sign that “water has been here!” (I go in the basement to work out every day and I’ve not seen water there once). side note is that the original owners of the home who sold it to us only disclosed ever repairing two cracks. There are probably 4 or 5 sealed vertical cracks we discovered. He said those all seemed more or less harmless.
He tells me there’s hydrostatic pressure all along the wall, and his instant assessment is that my patio has nothing to do with it. So fixing it with levelling is pointless.
Only this “WaterGuard” indoor French drain system will fix it. He spends 30 minutes measuring my entire basement perimeter and quotes 30k for the full perimeter which includes replacing the drywall 3 feet up the wall ($8k) in the finished portions of my basement, which is roughly half the perimeter. The longest continuous measurement of my home is 36 ft btw, it’s a rectangle more or less probably 36x25ft or something. The most problematic is the wall that runs the entire length of my stamped concrete patio (again, based on the moisture meter…) and he proposed also just doing this system along that for $12k. That includes drywall replacement again for the part of my basement that’s finished. They replace the drywall with some nonsense “inorganic” something btw.
Anyways this is where I’m at, and I don’t really know what to do. I plan to have a few more businesses come out and take a look. I don’t even know if I should bother to get the patio properly leveled anymore. I just am very skeptical of this assessment mainly because:
- this really small crack is so close to my patio and it stops as soon as rain stops. If it were such bad hydrostatic pressure wouldn’t it seep for long time after?
- these people only install this WaterGuard system. They don’t seem to do anything else
- i am skeptical that using this klein moisture meter he had in this way, even if it was on masonry mode, is indicative of anything.
I’d really appreciate advice, and also someone to tell me if my gut feeling of skepticism is well-founded or delusional (really appreciate honesty!)