So after asking the sub, I decided to read the first 4 stories of tKiY. I decided to review each book as I go, both from a perspective of personal enjoyment and my background in psychology and sociology. So yes, this will be "woke" and yes, you are free to stop reading if that discomforts you. Anyway, lets begin.
I was caught offguard with the 1920s setting. Funny how they even did 30 yrs into the future stories before sci fi became a thing. I can only assume that most of its inaccurate since I'm not a history buff, but it doesnt really detract from the story and I was amused. Also, "we got rid of bigotry and intolerance and now only kindness reigns" being in the same paragraph that calls blacks "n*gros" and describes the active exclusion of foreign Jewish people, restrictions of immigration, and the tightening of naturalization. Pretty easy to be kind and charitable when you got rid of all the people who don't look like you.
The story itself is pretty engaging, even more engaging than lovecraft's work. I find a lot of lovecraft is characters constantly talk (actually being narrated doing) about the horrors and being unnerved every step of the way even before the actual horror hits. It feels overdramatic and reflective of lovecraft's own paranoia. Here we see the characters actually interacting, and instead of being told about the horror, we have to piece it together through the interactions and thoughts of an unreliable narrator.
Speaking of said narrator, Hildred is interesting in many ways. We know from the moment Hildred says he's totally fine and mentally stable that he's completely full of shit. But I like how the story slowly reveals how mentally unbalanced he really is. (An aside, the fact that he casually throws TKIY into the fireplace after he got bored of it is hillarious. A good bit of foreshadowing of how he goes to extremes.) I liked how we know he has some negative feelings towards his cousin, but not exactly what till towards the end. And Louis reveals how he's actually been a shut in for 4 yrs. From my interning experience, my clinical supervisors would sometimes refer to close sources of a client to get a better idea of who they really are if the client has an unrealistically flattering outlook on their actions, especially when they are refusing to take accountability.
But now I start putting on my woke glasses and make some criticisms. This story was written in the 1890s and deals with mental illness, so eugenics talk creeps its way in. The average modern reader wouldn't see this connection, both because of the alt history setting and how deeply baked in ableism is in our culture. First off, the novel makes a connection between disability and the criminality associated with followers of the King in Yellow. We have Hildred, who becomes "mentally deficient" (either meaning he gained an intellectual disability or is mentally ill) after his fall. During that time, there was a belief that individuals of low iq or mentally ill were more likely to commit crimes. Of course, this lead to the sterilization, institutionalization, and murder of countless intellectually disabled and mentally ill patients from the 19th to mid 20th century. I bring this up because there was literally no reason to attribute Hildred's criminial insanity to head trauma when TKIY is literally right there. The book caused an epedemic of madness, its not to hard to go from "average guy reads the book of evil" to "I must kill to establish my place as the rightful heir of Carcossa". And we have Mr Wilde, who is noted to both have physical abnormalities and eccentric behavior. The linkage of physical disability to evil isn't new, the thought was/is that the more conventionally unattractive you are, the more evil. This applies to any trait not deemed the norm in a culture (search up why witch's have big noses). It was a cheap way to reinforce the status quo and still is, we just dont recognize the eugenicist origins. We see 3 people affected by TKIY here, and the fact that the 2 with pre-existing disabilities puppet the one who was fine until he read the book is noteworthy.
The lethal chamber too, is rooted in negative eugenics. Whats interesting though is that it is a choice offered, not imposed, by the government. The issue of consent didn't start peering its head until later (cough the nazis cough). H.G. Welles, a noted eugenicist, had to acknowledge this. I find Vance's end reflects HG Welles implication, he's a man whose desires are at war with his conscience and valiantly chooses to end his life than take the life of others. Not saying that self-sacrifice is inherently ableist, but put in context, seems to point towards the eugenic side of things.
I know I shouldn't be disappointed by this, but I am. From the french quote at the beginning I thought it would be more insightful/sympathetic to the mentally ill. I related heavily to Hildred's hatred of certain terms for mental illness/disability used dispargingly and the awkwardness that happens when you bring up your personal experience with it to others. I didn't want this to make Hildred a good person, but in the end his hatred was meant to reinforce the status quo. He hated the terms not because of how they were used, but because he didn't want to be associated with the label at all.
Beyond that, I was confused with everything regarding the in universe TKIY book and history. I didn't know what exactly the effects of the second act was, how Wilde was able to trace a history between the Castiganes and TKIY, what the importance of the Yellow Sign was (it doesn't seem to brainwash people), and how Wilde could control ppl through their reputations. Or even how he and Hildred met. Some of it has to do with pop cultural osmosis but I hope most of my questions will get resolved with the other stories. Certain mysteries, like how Hildred got that crown, I like not being answered because it makes the lives of the characters more distant and believable.
Also, the ending was stupid. None of the good guys die and all of the bad guys do hooray! It cheapens the tension built.
I still enjoyed reading the book, I gave a lot of critique but I think how any reader should approach a story, especially one this old.