r/IndianModerate • • 6h ago

THE DETENTION ROOM 〔zqanon〕

1 Upvotes

**An Apocryphal Tale of Civilisation, Status, Manners and the Peculiar Difficulty of Getting Invited to a Table**
An original work of satirical fiction.
**Chapter One: The Room**
There was a room somewhere in the world where every nation had been sent to detention.
Nobody knew precisely why they were there. Some claimed it was for historical misconduct. Others insisted it was a misunderstanding. A few argued that the teacher was biased.
The room was arranged much like the library in The Breakfast Club. There were desks, uncomfortable chairs, a clock that appeared to have stopped, and a large notice on the wall:
YOU ARE NOT HERE BECAUSE OF WHO YOU ARE. YOU ARE HERE BECAUSE OF HOW YOU BEHAVE.
Naturally, nobody read it.
The Americans occupied the largest area. They had pushed several desks together, were talking loudly, and had already decided that the room would benefit from a little reorganisation. One had brought a flag. Another was explaining that the detention system would work much better if it were privately managed.
The British sat towards the back, looking faintly embarrassed to be there. They had brought tea, complained about the temperature and quietly judged everybody else’s behaviour.
The French had taken the seats nearest the window. They were discussing philosophy, art and the general decline of civilisation. They had not yet decided whether the room was worthy of their presence.
The Germans had arranged their chairs in straight lines and were trying to establish a timetable.
The Italians had somehow turned a small disagreement about seating into a lively conversation involving food, family and hand gestures.
The Scandinavians were sitting quietly, wondering why nobody had thought to make the room more comfortable.
The Japanese were already organised, polite and quietly observing everything.
The Koreans were comparing achievements, qualifications and career prospects. They had also noticed that the Japanese were doing rather well and were determined to do at least as well, preferably better.
The Chinese occupied a substantial section of the room. They were watching, listening and taking notes. They seemed in no particular hurry to explain themselves.
The South-East Asians had settled into smaller groups. Singapore was keeping everything orderly, Vietnam was quietly getting on with things, Thailand was trying to keep the peace, and Indonesia was wondering why everyone was making such a fuss.
The Russians sat apart, looking unimpressed by the entire exercise.
And then there was the Indus Delegation.
They arrived late.
Not fashionably late. Just late.
They entered noisily, moved several chairs without asking, and immediately began explaining that the room would be considerably less interesting without them.
One of them announced that their civilisation was among the oldest in the world.
Another explained that their country was destined to become a superpower.
A third began discussing how unfairly their people were treated by everyone else.
The British looked at the clock.
The teacher had not yet arrived.
**Chapter Two: The Indus Delegation**
The Indus Delegation was an interesting group.
There were some genuinely impressive individuals among them. One was a brilliant mathematician. Another was a successful entrepreneur. A third was a thoughtful, charming young man who had spent years building friendships across different cultures.
They were perfectly pleasant.
Unfortunately, they were seated alongside several people who seemed determined to make life difficult for everybody.
One member spoke almost continuously, regardless of whether anyone was listening.
Another treated every disagreement as an insult.
A third was convinced that the rest of the room was jealous of his country’s population, history and economic potential.
Whenever somebody challenged him, he responded with a lecture about ancient achievements.
Whenever somebody changed the subject, he brought it back to historical injustice.
Whenever somebody asked him to lower his voice, he accused them of prejudice.
The British leaned towards the French.
“Are they always like this?”
The French shrugged.
“One cannot generalise about a people.”
“Quite,” said the British. “But one can certainly generalise about that particular table.”
Across the room, one of the more reasonable members of the delegation looked increasingly uncomfortable.
He had hoped to make friends.
Instead, he was spending most of his time apologising for people he barely knew.
**Chapter Three: The Popularity Contest**
At lunchtime, the teacher announced that everyone would be allowed to choose their own seating arrangements.
This caused considerable excitement.
The Americans immediately invited the British, although they spent much of the meal disagreeing about politics.
The British joined the Europeans, who were already arguing about the correct way to prepare lunch.
The Japanese and Koreans sat together, although they occasionally competed over whose country was doing better.
The Chinese had their own table, where conversation was calm and businesslike.
The South-East Asians formed a pleasant group, with Singapore quietly making sure that everybody had enough food.
The Russians sat alone.
The Indus Delegation approached the largest table.
“Can we join you?”
The Americans looked at one another.
“Sure,” said one.
The delegation sat down.
Within minutes, the conversation had become a discussion about how much influence the delegation deserved, how unfairly it was treated, and why everyone should acknowledge its importance.
The Americans tried changing the subject.
The British tried making a joke.
The French tried introducing a philosophical argument.
Nothing worked.
Eventually, one of the Americans said:
“Look, we’re happy to have you here. But perhaps we could talk about something other than how important you are?”
The delegation looked offended.
“Why are you threatened by our success?”
Nobody answered.
The delegation returned to its own table, convinced that it had been deliberately excluded.
One of the quieter members stayed behind.
He had been enjoying the conversation.
**Chapter Four: The History Lesson**
The teacher finally arrived.
He was an elderly man with a tired expression and a remarkable ability to make people feel uncomfortable simply by looking at them.
“Today,” he announced, “we are going to discuss history.”
The French immediately sat up.
The British looked nervous.
The Americans looked bored.
The Germans opened their notebooks.
The teacher wrote three words on the board:
HISTORY. POWER. RESPONSIBILITY.
“Every country in this room has a history,” he began. “Some have built empires. Some have been invaded. Some have colonised others. Some have been colonised. Some have suffered enormously. Some have inflicted enormous suffering.”
The room fell quiet.
“But history is not a permanent personality.”
He turned towards the British.
“You cannot spend the rest of your life expecting everyone to admire you because your ancestors once controlled a quarter of the world.”
The British nodded.
“Fair enough.”
He turned towards the French.
“Nor can you expect everyone to appreciate your sophistication simply because you once produced some extraordinary philosophers.”
The French looked mildly insulted.
He turned towards the Americans.
“Nor can you assume that being powerful makes you universally admired.”
The Americans shrugged.
Then he looked towards the Indus Delegation.
“And nor can you expect people to be impressed by the age of your civilisation, the size of your population or the potential of your economy if your behaviour towards them is unpleasant.”
There was silence.
The delegation looked furious.
“But our history!” one protested.
“History is important,” replied the teacher. “But it is not a personality substitute.”
**Chapter Five: The Question of Manners**
The following day, the teacher announced a practical exercise.
Each group would be judged on how well it managed to coexist with the others.
The criteria were simple:
Respect for shared spaces.
Consideration for other people.
Willingness to listen.
Ability to disagree without becoming hostile.
Contribution to the room.
The Germans immediately produced a scoring system.
The British suggested that the criteria were rather sensible.
The French argued that the exercise was reductive.
The Americans asked whether the results would be published.
The Japanese quietly began tidying the room.
The Koreans volunteered to organise the materials.
The Chinese offered to provide the equipment.
The Scandinavians improved the seating.
The South-East Asians made sure that nobody was left out.
The Russians questioned the legitimacy of the exercise but completed it anyway.
The Indus Delegation objected to the criteria.
“Who decides what constitutes good manners?” one asked.
“Everyone else,” said the teacher.
“But that is subjective!”
“Yes,” replied the teacher. “Social life often is.”
The delegation argued that its customs were different.
The teacher agreed.
“Different customs are perfectly acceptable. But there is a distinction between being different and being inconsiderate.”
One of the delegation’s more thoughtful members nodded.
He had been trying to explain exactly that for some time.
**Chapter Six: The Mirror**
On Friday, the teacher placed a large mirror at the front of the room.
“Today,” he said, “you will each describe how you believe the others see you.”
The Americans went first.
“Confident. Innovative. Powerful. Sometimes a little loud.”
The British followed.
“Polite. Witty. Occasionally pompous. Perhaps a little too attached to the past.”
The French said:
“Intelligent. Cultured. Occasionally difficult.”
The Germans said:
“Reliable. Efficient. Perhaps somewhat rigid.”
The Italians said:
“Passionate. Sociable. Sometimes chaotic.”
The Scandinavians said:
“Reasonable. Calm. Occasionally a little self-satisfied.”
The Japanese said:
“Disciplined. Respectful. Sometimes difficult to understand.”
The Koreans said:
“Ambitious. Hard-working. Perhaps a little too concerned with comparison.”
The Chinese said:
“Patient. Capable. Strategic. Sometimes misunderstood.”
The South-East Asians offered a variety of answers, most of which were rather modest.
The Russians said:
“Strong. Difficult to intimidate. Perhaps not particularly approachable.”
Then came the Indus Delegation.
“We are misunderstood,” said one.
“Envious of others,” said another.
“Victims of prejudice,” said a third.
“Destined for greatness,” said a fourth.
The teacher waited.
“Anything else?”
Nobody spoke.
“How do you think people experience you when they actually meet you?”
The delegation looked at one another.
One of the quieter members finally answered.
“Sometimes, perhaps, we make it difficult for people to get to know us.”
The teacher nodded.
“That is a much more useful observation.”
**Chapter Seven: The Dance**
On the final afternoon, the teacher announced that the detention was over.
Everyone was free to leave.
But before they did, he asked one final question.
“If you could choose any country in this room to spend a week with, which would you choose?”
The Americans chose the British, because they enjoyed the arguments.
The British chose the French, because they enjoyed the wine and the arguments.
The French chose the Italians, because they enjoyed the food and the arguments.
The Germans chose the Japanese, because they appreciated the organisation.
The Japanese chose the Scandinavians, because they appreciated the quiet.
The Koreans chose the Americans, because they enjoyed the energy and opportunities.
The Chinese chose Singapore, because they appreciated the pragmatism.
The South-East Asians chose one another, because they already got along rather well.
The Russians said they would prefer to travel alone.
Then the teacher looked towards the Indus Delegation.
“And you?”
“We would choose everyone,” one replied.
“Why?”
“Because everyone should want to spend time with us.”
The teacher paused.
“That is not quite how friendship works.”
“But we have so much to offer!”
“Then offer it.”
“We have a great history!”
“That is interesting. Tell people about it.”
“We have a huge population!”
“That is a statistic.”
“We have enormous potential!”
“Then realise it.”
The teacher looked around the room.
“People do not become your friends because you tell them they should. They become your friends because they enjoy being around you.”
The quieter member of the delegation smiled.
He had finally understood.
**Chapter Eight: The End of Detention**
As everyone left, the room became quiet.
The teacher remained behind, looking at the empty desks.
He picked up a piece of paper that had been left on the floor.
It was a note from one of the Indus Delegation’s more thoughtful members.
It read:
I think we sometimes confuse recognition with respect. We want people to acknowledge our history, our potential and our achievements. But perhaps we should spend more time making sure that the people we meet actually enjoy meeting us.
The teacher smiled.
He pinned the note to the wall beneath the original notice.
Then he added one final sentence.
Your ancestors do not make you admirable. Your population does not make you popular. Your potential does not make you successful. And being offended that people do not like you is not a substitute for giving them a reason to.
He switched off the lights and closed the door.
Somewhere outside, the nations were already arguing again.
The Americans were discussing leadership.
The British were making jokes.
The French were criticising the architecture.
The Germans were organising the next meeting.
The Japanese were quietly getting on with their lives.
The Koreans were already planning how to improve.
The Chinese were thinking ten years ahead.
The South-East Asians were having dinner.
The Russians were pretending not to care.
And the Indus Delegation was explaining to anyone who would listen that the whole exercise had been unfair.
The teacher sighed.
He had a feeling they would all be back next week.
THE END.
© zqanon | Original satirical fiction


r/IndianModerate • • 10h ago

Meta Has anyone seen this unpack video? What are your views around it?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 1d ago

Yusruf pathan land case

5 Upvotes

Look at the timeline:

Yusuf Pathan won the 2024 Lok Sabha election on a TMC ticket, opposing the BJP.

In June 2026, he broke away from TMC and joined a group of rebel MPs that aligned with the NDA.

The Gujarat government approved the land allotment in August 2026.

In November 2026, the BJP-controlled VMC General Board approved it.

It does look like favouritism to me. What's your views and opinion about it? Is there a bigger chapter to it?


r/IndianModerate • • 2d ago

Meta The bigots and racists are just raging today... they think the Minister can snap her fingers to change the gender imbalance... LoL

0 Upvotes

I triggered so many fascists in the original OP... LoL I opted to engage by pointing out that the Minister of Immigration can not control the gender of the applicants, nor can she suddenly snap her fingers and make more females appear. The many "replacement candidates" showed up in full force with their usual BS rants. Hilarious how easily these "tough guys" are so easily triggered.


r/IndianModerate • • 3d ago

Sitting on lap, this statement needs this much attention or RW is just taking advantage of it?

Post image
11 Upvotes

Mr. Gandhi has made a remark which seems funny but innocently funny, it was an expression but the kind of attention media is giving to this instead of real issues is not call for what’s your thoughts guys?


r/IndianModerate • • 3d ago

Meta Freedom of speech - The irony

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 4d ago

Meta Reserved category students score lower GPAs because they struggle to compete with GC students. It's not caste discrimination.

22 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 5d ago

Meta What can be done to make people trust elected government officials more?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 6d ago

Ask india thread.

0 Upvotes

Are you a pronatalist or Antinatalist?


r/IndianModerate • • 6d ago

Meta Did India reach Orwellian dystopia

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 6d ago

BJP or Congress

8 Upvotes

Vote with HONESTY and please share your opinion.


r/IndianModerate • • 6d ago

Meta Kishan Reddy questioning where Congress is getting its money from is quite ironic. 😂

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 6d ago

Meta Social media firms should be held accountable for normalising hate against India

Post image
8 Upvotes

I usually just steer past the usual vitriol and cesspool of hatred that is the social media. But every now and then I report comments or profiles which are openly racist. We all know how Tik Tok was used by Chinese streamers to set narratives against India. The whole Bangladesh slums depicted as Delhi fiasco. Tik Tok and X are gone case, it’s full of bots and Chinese propaganda accounts. meta and other social media firms promptly act on a report if it’s against any other race particularly blacks and Latinos and other religion Particularly Islam but completely shuts its eyes towards India and Hinduism. Shouldn’t they be held accountable by the Indian govt for these double standards


r/IndianModerate • • 7d ago

Meta What are some good things India is known for worldwide (and should be known for).

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 7d ago

Meta Street dogs issue in india

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

The post proposes encouraging the adoption of Indian native dog breeds by reducing the popularity and demand for foreign breeds through stricter regulations on illegal breeding, higher taxes on imported/foreign dog breeds, and promoting Indian breeds in households. The aim is to explore whether this approach could help address India's growing street dog issue.


r/IndianModerate • • 8d ago

Reputable Source JNU prof Akoijam, at centre of sexual harassment row, gets 3 Congress poll posts in Manipur

Thumbnail
theprint.in
9 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 8d ago

Meta India will run by majority’s choice only

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 9d ago

Meta What's your opinion on this?

12 Upvotes

What's your opinion on the majority of comments on the post in r/surat subreddit?


r/IndianModerate • • 9d ago

Meta When will this language and state politics will get over?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 9d ago

Is this coming true?

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/IndianModerate • • 9d ago

Forget trying to become a superpower

5 Upvotes

I honestly think India needs a serious cultural and intellectual awakening. Sometimes I look at our society and wonder how we expect to become a developed country when so much of our public life is still dominated by religious dogma, superstition, blind traditionalism and an unwillingness to question anything.

One thing I find particularly frustrating is how we treat the ideas of our elders. Just because something was believed by our parents, grandparents or ancestors doesn't automatically make it right. Respecting your elders does not mean accepting everything they say as unquestionable truth. Previous generations got plenty of things wrong, and it is our responsibility to challenge those ideas rather than blindly pass them down to the next generation.

We need to learn to think for ourselves. Question traditions. Question religious authorities. Question politicians. Question everything. No idea should be immune from criticism simply because it is old, culturally significant or religiously sacred.

This is essentially what the Enlightenment was about: reason, scientific inquiry, individual liberty and challenging established authority. I think India desperately needs to embrace that spirit.

And where are our priorities? We have millions of people struggling with poverty, inadequate education, poor healthcare and a lack of opportunities. In many of our cities, people cannot even breathe clean air. Yet our public discourse is constantly consumed by religious disputes, temples, mosques, historical grievances and communal politics.

I'm particularly critical of the BJP and its brand of Hindu nationalism, but this problem goes beyond one political party. No government should be promoting or favoring any religion. India should have a strict commitment to secular governance. Practice whatever religion you want, but the government should stay out of it.

Look at the number of Indians who leave the country to study, work and build their lives elsewhere. There are approximately 18.5 million Indian-born people living abroad, according to mid-2024 estimates. Obviously, not everyone leaves for the same reasons, and many maintain strong connections with India. But I think we should seriously ask ourselves why so many people look outside their own country for opportunities and a better quality of life. Why shouldn't they want to return? Why can't we build a country where people actually want to stay and raise their families?

I want to see an India that invests in science, research, education, public healthcare and poverty alleviation. An India where children are taught to think critically instead of simply memorizing textbooks. Where scientific achievements are celebrated, where merit matters, and where people aren't judged by their religion or community.

We need to stop romanticizing the past and start building the future.

Our ancestors lived in the circumstances of their time. We live in ours. We shouldn't be obligated to inherit their prejudices, superstitions or outdated beliefs. We should be willing to reject them when reason and evidence demand it.

I don't want India to abandon its culture or heritage. I want India to progress beyond the things that are holding it back.

A prosperous nation requires an educated, healthy and rational population. It takes a strong and healthy society to build a prosperous future. And until we start putting reason before religious dogma, education before ignorance, and development before identity politics, I fear we'll keep wasting an enormous amount of our potential.


r/IndianModerate • • 10d ago

Meta Questions I would genuinely like Sonia Gandhi to answer:

Post image
0 Upvotes
  1. What was your role when LK Advani raised the Bofors issue? What was your relationship with Ottavio Quattrocchi, and why did the controversy remain unresolved?
  2. Why was former PM PV Narasimha Rao politically sidelined by the Congress leadership? Why were his last rites not conducted in Delhi with the honours traditionally accorded to a former Prime Minister?
  3. If Dr. Manmohan Singh was the Prime Minister, why were so many major political decisions perceived to be coming from 10 Janpath rather than the PMO?
  4. Why has the Congress party repeatedly opposed or questioned changes to FCRA? What is its position on transparency and foreign funding?
  5. Why did Rahul Gandhi choose Wayanad as his Lok Sabha constituency in 2019? What were the political considerations behind that decision?
  6. What exactly was the Congress party's position on key decisions concerning the Indian Armed Forces and national security?
  7. What are the questions surrounding the DLF controversy, alleged political connections, and the reported links involving Deccan Herald? Will the party provide transparent answers?
  8. What was the Congress leadership's relationship with the LTTE, and are there unanswered questions about the political circumstances surrounding Rajiv Gandhi's assassination?
  9. How does Congress justify its approach to minority appeasement allegations? What is its distinction between minority welfare, constitutional secularism and vote-bank politics?
  10. Why was the concept of 'Hindu' or 'saffron terror' introduced without solid proof or concrete evidences?

r/IndianModerate • • 10d ago

Who runs Indian Cities?- Real Reason why Indian Cities are such a Mess.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

This video is a must watch !


r/IndianModerate • • 10d ago

Meta Maharashtra changed cooperative rules after Mahayuti lost Gokul 13–12 — is this a dangerous precedent regardless of which party does it?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes