r/IndiansRead • • 42m ago

Book-Club Book Club Recap #01 | The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka

2 Upvotes

We had a really interesting discussion on Kafka’s - The Metamorphosis, and what started as a conversation about the book soon turned into a broader discussion about identity, alienation, family expectations, and human relationships.

A few interesting perspectives came up:

* Reading Kafka during COVID made the themes of isolation and alienation feel even more relevant.
* We explored how different cultures view family responsibilities, especially when someone becomes dependent on others.
* Even those who hadn’t read the book brought fresh perspectives to the conversation.

Leaving you all with something to think about:

Was Gregor’s family really cruel for abandoning him, or were they just trying to survive?

Would love to hear what you all think! Thanks to everyone who joined. Looking forward to more such conversations!


r/IndiansRead • • 6d ago

What Are You Reading? Weekly Reading & Discussion Thread! November 15, 2026

4 Upvotes

What are you reading? Share with us!

If you are looking for recommendations, then check out our official Goodreads account and filter by your favorite bookshelf.

---

Also feel free to:

  • Share informative or entertaining articles, videos, podcasts, or artwork.
  • Start discussions or engage in a collaborative storytelling game: write the first sentence of a story and invite others to continue it.
  • Talk about your reading goals & challenges or share your favorite quotes, trivia questions, or comics.
  • Share your academic journey or been studying lately? Completed any assignments or read an interesting textbook or research paper? We’d love to hear about it!
  • Provide feedback on how we can make the subreddit even better for you.

---

Check the links in the sidebar for our scheduled or community related threads & recommendations.

Our twitter account: https://twitter.com/indiansreadR

Our discord server: https://discord.gg/KpqxDVRzea

Happy reading! 📚📖


r/IndiansRead • • 7h ago

Discussion Little Secrets by Jennifer Hillier

Post image
2 Upvotes

has anyone read this book? the end wasn't unexpected or anything but it was a nice read


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Now Reading My current read

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Now Reading This cold & cloudy weather of Kolkata calls for another horror story read. Are you reading anything scary?

Post image
15 Upvotes

Tonight I decided to reread one of my favourite classic horror stories, The Wendigo by Algernon Blackwood. I first listened this story in YouTube in the year 2019 & I absolutely loved it, just as I loved another of Algernon Blackwood's masterpiece The Willows. What made me fall in love with it is how well written the story is & how amazingly the atmosphere for the story was created. No doubt Algernon Blackwood was a master storyteller & The Wendigo is one of the finest creation among classic horror stories. The Wendigo is a malevolent creature from the traditional folklore of the Indigenous people of North America. In their Indigenous tradition, Wendigo is the embodiment of winter, famine & greed.

While there are so many different short stories of Wendigo all over the internet and many can be found in Reddit too, I can say this undoubtedly that none of those comes even close to this masterpiece, and none of those even has that creepy atmosphere that Algernon Blackwood created with his writing. It is just an immense talent to create something so magical, something so creepy & bone chilling withing 50 pages or even less than that. Very few in the history of horror literature was successful in doing so & Algernon Blackwood was definitely one of them.


r/IndiansRead • • 10h ago

Now Reading Belonging - A Journey of Love by Sonia Gandhi

Post image
0 Upvotes

Started this today. Any suggestions for better reading?


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

Suggest Me My reading list of Oct/Nov. Suggest me another four for December!

Post image
69 Upvotes

Same as title


r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Now Reading This is the fastest I have ever completed a book.

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/IndiansRead • • 1d ago

Book-Club Kafka, Chai & Existential Dread | The Metamorphosis - Nov 22, 8 PM

Post image
32 Upvotes

Hello, fellow bookworms! ☺️

Your Sunday evening just got a little more existential!
We’re meeting on 22 November at 8 PM to discuss The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka on our Discord channel and we’d love for you to join us.

Whether you’re discovering Kafka for the first time, rereading the novella, or have read it before and want to exchange interpretations, everyone’s welcome!

It’s a short read (77 pages) so there’s still time to jump in. No literary expertise required. Just bring your curiosity, your opinions, a cup of chai, and perhaps a little existential dread.

So, who’s joining our little Kafka gathering this Sunday? P.S. No spoilers in the comments, please. Let’s save those for the discussion!

Happy reading! ❤️


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

Review 👁️⚖️🌍On the Equality of Things - Carlo Rovelli {...Equally Empty is the World!} Review

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Premise:

It teaches anti-foundationalism (or Emptiness essentially, but in Physics and Morality) with examples from latest scientific ideas from space, time, matter, quanta, morality, consciousness etc. Subjectivism is hence, concluded to be the only reasonable scientific idea given the evidence currently, according to Rovelli.  

Structure of the Book + Short summary:

1. Relational structure of Reality

- Concepts are products of experience, which is very limited, never absolute. Properties are attributed (mistakenly) to things themselves, instead of their relations with other things. Eg. Speed of a train. 

- Niels Bohr's words rephrased: "properties of a physical system can't be considered independently from the interactions through which these properties manifest themselves, or from systems to which they manifest themselves." 

- Every interaction leaves a trace. {Locard, anyone? 😆}

- Quanta: contextuality, probability, granularity. Double slit experiment simply says this - the electron doesn't have a definite position as long as it's not interacting; Wigner's friend problem is a good illustration (still mindboggling)

2. From Inside the Circle: 

- Knowledge: How we (subject) possess information about the world(object). This information is necessarily embodied in some physical configuration. This includes errors, hence uncertainties. Famous fable of the Dreaming Butterfly. 

- Max Born's statement on the root cause of all evil. In Buddhism and Vedanta too, I think, it's Ignorance, Desire to Attachment to certain ideas. Partial certainties is what we have, and it's really good enough for the world to reliably work and continue upon! 

- The adherence to Ultimate Absolute Reality is, in Rovelli's terms, "projections of a psychological or cultural anxiety, extrapolations produced by fears of creatures..." - what Devdutt calls "Mythology" - Humans are insecure, hungry and afraid. So they come up with stories, symbols and rituals (myths) which help them cope. {I recently read Devdutt's book, so comparison was imminent}

- Circularity: "Circularity is a problem for those who aim to find an ultimate foundation from which everything follows linearly".

- Page 43 presents I think Rovelli's weakest argument - (argument by personal incredulity?) "...we would have found it by now" - that's a dangerous slope I think - For a scientist no less! 

3. Spacetime

- Time: Stone is a process. Events==> Process. Time Dilation: "Duration between 2 events depends on the path between them." Space: a relationship between things/events. Newton's 'true space' is a version of Einstein's Gravitational Field which diffuses and oscillates, moves and is moved by the masses/energies of all other objects/fields. Distance is a manifestation of the gravitational field. 

- Reality is a set of fields, which are extended entities - not sitting in Space or evolving in Time, but they're extension itself is Space and their evolution itself is Time. 

- Loop Quantum gravity stuff I don't get at all. 

4. Inhabiting flow of time

- Arrow of time, entropy. "Systems that detect Arrow of time do so by tracking dissipation". 

- Cause and Effect, Memory and Causation... "Causal orientation of the world is only statistical". I think this relates to the entropy definition about Evolution of microstates ? Not sure. 

- His free will compatibilism is not to my agreement- I think Sapolsky's arguments are sufficient for that.

5. What exists?

- By equality of all things, Rovelli means that the level of criteria we use to study a phenomenon (physics, chemistry, biology, psychology, sociology etc) are all equally relevant. None is more or less "fundamental" than the other- unless one is seeking the true ultimate foundation of everything - which is a meaningless exercise given current understanding of sciences. "Multiple descriptions of reality are a testament to unity in science, not disunity." 

- His arguments against absolute moralism and realism, wrt to perspectivism/relationalism.  

6. Without certainty or foundations 

- Relations, processes, perspectives. The world as we know it admits to being described from within. We know it from within, we can't escape it. - reminds me of this banger line: "There are nexuses, causal relationships that cannot be separated." (Kudos to you if you can recognize where it's from 😆)

-  Using Zhuangzhi - Huizi Fish story to discuss Nagel's Bat problem and Chalmers' Hard Consciousness problem - nice. Rovelli says, we always have an incomplete description of reality, be it a stone, fish or a friend. It's an arbitrary divide between "physical" and "mental" processes. Both are relational, both incompletely knowable. 

Afterword: How science works: 

- "ambiguity of concepts and language isn't a weakness but it's very strength - its infinite capacity to adapt,expand, evolve, slipping from ambiguity to ambiguity. It is ingenuity". 

- We think in metaphors, analogies. Evolution of concepts is science. 

What I need to learn more about:

- Intuitively I understood most of it because halfway thru the book, I was asking myself that "isn't this what Nagarjuna said also? Am I wrong to connect these?". Very happy to have it clearly stated by the author from 4th chapter onwards - it IS Emptiness. "All phenomenon is interrelated; or causation by interdependence, inherently empty". 

- Having said that, I will happily confess - some chapters' technicalities flew right over my head 🥲 Loop Quantum Gravity. Hamiltonian stuff etc. Will try to read up more about that stuff...Recommendations are most welcome🙏

Conclusion:

Ever since reading about Shunyata (many years ago), I've been relating modern science to it, especially Quantum Physics' Uncertainty and Einstein's Relativity. I'm no scientist, and only have vague ideas about this stuff... But had always found them quite similar. This book explains why I thought so. 

In essence, if one knows about Shunyata, I think anti-foundationalism becomes a way of life for them - one begins to accept skepticism as a humbling way of life. To be wary of absolute claims, to always be curious, to be ready to update one's beliefs given sufficient evidence - but I also saw the fears associated with such way of thinking while discussing it with a good friend - "that feeling of no foundation below you, isn't that scary? Nihilistic?" He put it in much better words than I could -  "no foundation". I admitted, it is mentally exhausting at times - Oh how relaxing it would be to just accept a fixed permanent ultimate reality as described by X... but the questions never stop.

I'm sure I must have misunderstood a lot of ideas in here - still, this book has spurred me on to know more about the ideas mentioned above, and added more books on my TBR: Tao of Physics, More Heat than Light, Wittgenstein, Nagarjuna...

I'd recommend it for any layperson really, except the 3rd chapter - everything else is explained quite well. Good book for science/philosophy readers.

Rating: 8/10 (-2 for LQG which wasn't clear at all here, and Pg 43 where it's like an argument from his incredulity)


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

Review Dreaming and a Lot of Saving: A Review of Suniti Namjoshi's Dangerous Pursuits (4/5 ⭐)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I am a part of a feminist reading circle. And therein I came across an indie publishing house. So shout out to Zubaan Publications, which publish works written by women as far as I am aware from India and other South Asian countries. I had read another work by the same publication titled Eating Women Telling Tales. And while surfing through their website, I came across this collection of three novellas.

The premise was intriguing and so was the book cover. So I did not wait to get this and gladly received it on Children's Day. So happy Children's Day to me. Over the next few days, I read all three novellas and I am excited beyond measure. My hopes were not as low as people might think, but they weren't as high as I usually keep for South Asian writers as well. However, by the time I reached the last page of the book, I was more than happy, content, satisfied and joyful to talk about the book. And at the same time I could not wait to recommend it to fellow readers.

The first novella is called Bad People. The premise is Ravana, Kumbhakaran and Shurpanakha waking up in the 21st century and navigating through their image of a bad person. They look around the modern world and realize that it is absolutely bad and going through a lot of problems and does need a lot of saving. These three people who are also siblings try to understand their own identity as the so-called bad or villainous side of the epic. At the same time, they also have a wish to be kinder, better and understand if their actions and deeds were really bad or was it just that they reacted how any other person would have reacted in the situation.

In this journey, they meet a 21st century woman called Leela who tells them about the ways of the modern world, be it marketing, corruption, money, power or anything else. What is interesting to note is that patriarchy is still the same. We see both Shurpanakha and Leela discussing the problems of patriarchy and fighting against Ravana and Kumbhakaran in playful yet important banters. The writing style is easy to read and comprehend, extremely funny at times, would make you chuckle for sure. And interestingly enough, the character sketches are way more interesting than I would have wished. At every single time whenever Ravana speaks, which is in first person throughout the novella, I could not help but imagine his stride, mustache, ten heads and every other thing that we have been fed on to believe through various depictions of this character through epics and other pop media.

By the time I reached the end of this novella, I really wanted to watch this on screen, probably through a TV show or a funny rendition of this caricatured novella.

The second work is titled Heart's Desire which was my least favorite in the lot. It discusses the story of an old woman who is in the last few years of her life. In this journey, she meets Ariel who is a spin-off character from Shakespeare's Tempest and a Mephistopheles like figure from Doctor Faustus. Ariel comes as this devil's helper to ask the old woman what she would wish in these last years of her life. And she wants to know what her heart desires. But unfortunately she's not aware of it. She, funnily, cannot sell her soul because her soul would only last for a few remaining years because of her old age. And so she demands a personal assistant which is an angel, who is likely to help the old woman know her heart's desire.

So Ariel, Angel and this old woman get through this journey traveling to different places, discussing different things, trying to understand what the old woman really wants. And by the time we reach the end of the novella, we realize that everything that the woman wanted to know was not something that was very unknown to her from the beginning. In fact, it was something that she always knew, yet was not willing to accept.

The third novella which probably would be my favorite is a reimagining of the dream sequence in Shakespeare's The Tempest. So for those who have not read The Tempest, this particular part might not be as amazing to them as it was to me. But since I have, reading this reimagination and retelling was extremely wonderful. The characters of the Tempest try to discuss what dreams are all about. The dream sequence of the play is taken up where Gonzalo dreams of a utopia. And in its place, every other character like Prospero, Miranda, Caliban, Ariel, Ferdinand, Antonio, the King of Naples, they start dreaming as well and sharing about their own dream.

There are discussions on what dreams really are. Are they even important? How long should one dream? Or probably how long one can dream? Throughout this process, what emerges is this air of extremely lovely hope that fills you up as a reader with a lot of light and energy about life.

Caliban, those who know and are aware, is a character which is supposed to be a monster. But in postcolonial readings has been quite the subject of pity and scrutiny as the enslaved one. But here we see him taking the charge over Miranda, Ferdinand and almost every other character in a very non-violent way and telling them that it is okay to dream and one can only be free if they dream freely. This creates an idea that one becomes what one thinks and what one dreams.

By the time we reach the end of this one novella, the characters go through a development where they understand the importance of dreaming and thinking, imagining. Even if they aren't able to act on it necessarily.

One idea that binds all three of these novellas together is the idea of saving the world. In all three of these novellas, we see the importance of kindness, companionship, humane relationship and trying to safeguard what is available to us. Very prominent. This saving is present in different aspects through climate or corruption or being kind to one another as humans or to be kind to our own selves. I would really implore and request everyone to pick this one book if they are looking for something interesting to read. It would not take you more than two to three days to finish it if you just give an hour or so every single day to it. It is something that I believe everyone should experience at least once.

(4/5 ⭐)


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

My collection My little bookshelf

Post image
35 Upvotes

I don’t have a type … 😅


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Now Reading Happy Men's Day to all my fellow warriors

Post image
62 Upvotes

With love


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

General Suggest some trusted source for Paperbacks!

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Good day readers,

I've been looking to have this book for quite a while. No local sellers have it, and on the internet, I find such reviews claiming fake book, missing chapters, print issues etc.

Can anyone help me find a reliable source?

Thank ya all ~


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Non Fiction Why no illustrations in the book :(

Post image
13 Upvotes

Same as title.


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago

Review ✉️🙏 Letters to Mother - Narendra Modi {Spiritual Ponderings} Review

Post image
0 Upvotes

A friend had suggested this to me years ago, when I was reading Discovery of India perhaps... Now, having reviewed Sonia Gandhi's memoir, I thought this would be a good time to take a look at this. 😆 

Right off the bat, I was proven wrong - I'd assumed these were Modi's letters to his mother, but they're actually addressed to the Devi, Jagat Janani! Hence quite introspective in nature. (Gujarati book is more aptly titled - "Saakshi Bhaav") 

Written in 1986, Modi was in RSS and a party worker. He wrote these every night, then burnt them periodically.. but some letters survived thanks to - Panchsara bhai, who also urged him to stop burning them, and get them published. 

Modi's Foreword to this book - "All of us are entitled to self-expression. That's exactly what I've done".

There are ~16 letters here, from 1/12/1986 - 1/1/1987. I wanted to post each letter's idea here, but long reviews seem to get me into unnecessary trouble.

So I'll just list my 5 favorite ones:

1. 1/12/1986: Purpose of life: "Am I like the still calendar on the wall?" An illusion of time. Subjectivism? Can one be ever objective? How to overcome attachment? Wishes for a life filled with compassion, devoid of expectations. 

2. 3/12: Your Creation: Will the chaos in me ever subside? Isn't life a poem created by you? Why can't I fully accept life's uncertainties? Why do we all want our imaginary life? Is life always exploitation? Then how do we preserve virtues? How many costumes can a man change? I'm like the ever bankrupt trader -seeking new loans, your blessings, forever!

3. 6/12: Tender Gaze: Technology - it's merits and demerits. Decline of letter writing. Animals communicate better than us, unlike us surviving in a hypocritical world. Will this universe in Pursuit of technology lose nature's treasures? Can anything be more precious than the expression in the eyes?  Shivir celebrations. 

4. 8/12: Heart is a Temple: 2nd day of shivir. Chief Guest Balasaheb (not Thakeray, I checked). Modi ready to give 15 years to his new role (Gujarat BJP I think, that's why this one's a crucial entry), with blessings from Goddess. "I accept the challenge". 

5. 21/12: Time Travels: Pretty Good. About the flow of time, Subjectivity. It can seem stuck, these moments of immortality one experiences momentarily. (Reminds me of a similar story in Einstein's Dreams). "Mother, I want to conquer time too"

Bonus: 23/12: This is the Only Path: How many really connect with their hearts? Like we use gadgets we use others? More man acquires, more he desires. Vicious circle. Why is human heart so cruel? Why do they use others? Where will this end? Men don't rise above ego. Is life only about self-serving? Is this why only in later years he is drawn to religion? Is it also to preserve his persona? To shield himself? Earlier, man exploited man, now he exploits religion. "To me, man can never be a commodity" 

Conclusion: 

Modi would've been ~35 years of age, when he wrote these. 

About the content, there's not much I can say - they're personal, spiritual conversations with Goddess - genuine worries, ambitions a hardworking RSS worker might have. (It's believable, but I couldn't find any single image of these letters online - if anyone can point to it, I'd really appreciate it🙏 I listened to the audiobook).

They're not meant as a literary masterpiece, as Modi says in the Foreword, but there's some good poetic imagery here. Overall, enjoyable, simple, thought provoking. 

From 1986-2026, is the current Modi the same as in these letters? I'd leave that for you to ponder.

Rating: 10/16 (Number of Letters I liked, or rather the ideas in here.)


r/IndiansRead • • 2d ago Bravo

Non Fiction The freedom to choose exists; the freedom to define what is worth choosing does not." Are there Indian non-fiction books that actually question our inherited assumptions?

4 Upvotes

Lately I've been thinking about how whenever we argue for change in Indian society, cinema, language, or technology we almost always debate the structures on the surface while leaving the deeper assumptions underneath completely untouched. Old systems collapse, new ones replace them, the language and aesthetics of power change, and yet the underlying logic stays identical. Even our ideas of what counts as "progress," why English still carries economic weight in India, or what makes a life worthwhile were mostly settled before we ever arrived.
I recently wrote a short independent collection of 13 essays around this exact question (The Unchosen, under my slow-reading project Integrated Media Platform / IMP). I'd genuinely love to hear what Indian non-fiction or essayists you've read that interrogate these unseen foundations—and if anyone wants to read or push back on one of my essays ("It's About Time We Question the Axiomatics"),
You can read the full 8-page sample essay free (no signup)—and pick up the complete book if it resonates—here: https://the-unchosen.shashank0902.chatgpt.site/

Instagram (where I'm sharing excerpts): https://www.instagram.com/imp.reads/


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Review Four S. L. Bhyrappa books in a month, and I think I’m a little obsessed!

Post image
24 Upvotes

A month ago, when Smitha ji started the Samvacana initiative, I thought, why not join? It would give me an opportunity to interact with her, talk to her and, more importantly, listen to her. She is one of those people you just want to keep listening to. Somehow, everything she says feels like a light bulb going off in your head.
I had heard about Avarana from a friend who had recommended it back in May. I finally picked it up, thinking that before Samvacana began, I should at least know who S. L. Bhyrappa was. I didn’t want to be the person sitting in meetings while everyone discussed his books, without even knowing who the author was!
I finished Avarana in two days. I simply could not put it down.
I had always thought fiction wasn’t my thing. J. K. Rowling had managed to change that to some extent, but Bhyrappa did something entirely different.
With Rowling, it was entertainment. With Bhyrappa, it was self-exploration.
Through stories of human relationships and emotions, he makes you peel away layers of biases and assumptions you didn’t even realise you carried. He unpacks the nuances of Dharma through the eyes of people caught in their own Dharma Sankatas.
Today, most of us cannot imagine ourselves in Arjuna’s place. We know what the Bhagavad Gita teaches us, but when those dilemmas are brought alive through human characters and their circumstances, something shifts. You don’t just understand an idea intellectually; you begin to experience it.
Next, I picked up Vamsha Vriksha, this time in Marathi.
That was when I realised the difference between reading a translated book and reading it in an Indian language. It simply isn’t the same.
I literally wept while reading this book. Proper, full-on tears.
The book explores some deeply uncomfortable questions. Somewhere in the middle, you stop being a reader and become a participant. You start judging the characters. You take sides. You arrive at conclusions. You convince yourself that you have understood a complicated aspect of Dharma and that perhaps you now know better than you did before.
And then the book ends.
And even those conclusions collapse.
You realise that the very certainty with which you judged the characters was perhaps the problem. You thought you had become wiser, but the ending makes you question how cruel and judgmental your earlier conclusions were.
By the end, you feel a little freer from your own biases, a little less burdened by your ego. And, above all, humbled.
Then came Uttara Kaanda, about which I have already written separately.
This book made me extremely uncomfortable. It is so far removed from the Valmiki Ramayana that, at times, I found myself wondering what distinguished this retelling from the liberties taken in a film adaptation of the Ramayana.
The more you explore it, the more uncomfortable it gets. And yet, the characters speak to you. Your insecurities get exposed. Certain situations and emotions feel uncomfortably relatable. You find yourself wanting to explore them further, even when you don’t particularly enjoy what you are discovering about yourself.
I think the biggest difference lies in the intention behind the book and that behind a film adaptation. One leaves you with questions that you cannot easily walk away from.
The latest book I completed was Nirakarana.
WHAT. A. BOOK.
I am someone who, at times, wants to run away to my Guru, to the Ashram, convinced that what I am doing in my everyday life is somehow pointless. That perhaps I am meant to be doing something else.
This book was a RUDE MIRROR.
It also made me understand, at a much deeper level, the genius of Sadhguru’s teaching when he says, “See Me in everyone and everything around you.”
Somehow, He has made Samsara itself a spiritual Sadhana.
Nirakarana is about a man who, at different points in his life, rejects both Samsara and spirituality, only to find himself rejected by both. You know the expression — na ghar ka, na ghat ka.
I think this is particularly relevant to those of us who are exploring a spiritual path while continuing to live in Samsara.
When faced with everyday situations and responsibilities, how often do we wonder:
What am I doing all this for?
What is the point of this?
What am I contributing to in the larger scheme of things?
Is this really worthwhile?
And then we find ways to justify our desire to escape.
Someone else can do this better.
I am not made for this.
I am meant for something else.
Perhaps I should just go and do that instead.
Some people even muster the courage to make that move. I know people who have gone to the Ashram and returned, realising that life there comes with its own challenges.
But the way Nirakarana portrays the consequences of our choices is chilling.
I genuinely feel that anyone who feels drawn towards the spiritual path but is living within Samsara must read this book. And then listen carefully to what Sadhguru says.
When Sadhguru speaks about finding the spiritual dimension in everything you do and everyone around you, it can sound like common sense. It made sense when I heard it. But Bhyrappa, through this emotionally exhausting, almost chilling roller coaster of a story, made me internalise what that teaching actually means.
I understood a little more of the genius behind the idea of seeing the Divine in the very life we are living, rather than imagining that spirituality exists somewhere away from it.
And that, for me, was the most powerful takeaway from Nirakarana.
Next on my list is Dharmashree. Hopefully, I get my hands on it by next month!
I think I am officially obsessed with S. L. Bhyrappa. Four books in one month probably say enough.
Until then, I have started Ami Ganatra’s book on the Arthashastra. She is another person I could listen to endlessly. Every other sentence is another light bulb moment!


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Review Your opinions on the book?

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just finished reading this book..
Was a good read, with quite engaging stories.
Book has three distinct stories of individual characters that belong to the Torunka café.
I suggest this for those looking to read something
Light and easy with a good pace

Ps- i found this before the days at the morisaki bookshop. So due reading that one🫡

What were your thoughts on this book..??


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

General Query on book maintenance

2 Upvotes

Hello to this lovely community!

I'm was an ardent reader. Life got in the way so I have about a dozen books which are shoved into different nooks and corners like in a box and what not. I found a few book mites near them. I'm moving in a new house and want to take my books with me where they have a dedicated space (shelves). I have about 2 weeks left. How do I clean them so that none of the rot transfers? As in I live in mumbai where they were subject to a lot of humidity and the likes. How do I properly salvage them? Please be kind considering I have baby to take care of and a cramped up space. The space issue is definitely resolving and I will get more reading time as time passes. Any suggestion helps.

Thank you for reading.


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

General My October Reads (better late than never XD )

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

I was going through my November reads and thought that my October was very happening too. Thus sharing:)

Note: I note down by monthly wraps based on the books I finish in the given month, not necessarily started in the same month. For example, in October I finished Cuckold and The Greatest Hindi Stories Ever Told which I had picked up a month before and then paused. The rest were read in October itself.


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Review 👩‍❤️‍👨🇮🇳 BELONGING - Sonia Gandhi {Power of Love, Love of Power, Cost of Both} Review

Post image
5 Upvotes

Premise:

A memoir by Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. Not much introduction required…
37 chapters structured into 7 parts: Love & Courtship; Finding my Way; Triumphs & Defeats; Rajiv as PM; Denouement & Aftermath; Leading Congress; 20 years on.

Here’s what I liked, disliked and learnt from the book. Slightly long review – sorry! But it might save your time, money and effort.

Important Caveat: 

I've treated this memoir as an autobiography. I looked up the difference just prior to posting this review, and realised I had over-analysed and fact-checked a subjective narrative to death...but then again, we don't know if we'll get a more objective, factual book from Mrs. Gandhi anytime soon. 

Apologies in advance. 🙏

Why did I read this?

- I listened to the audiobook available on Storytel. That’s really the main motivation. I don’t read much about politics, and read memoirs even less. The narrator Sneha Mathan has a beautiful voice – so once I’d started listening to it, I had to finish the book. 

What I liked/ Enjoyable Trivia for me:

- Memoir indeed begins and ends with the theme of Love. How it grew – from meeting Rajiv Gandhi at Cambridge to her love for India to a renewed hope for a functioning democracy.

- Sonia’s early life + her Italian family – some really colorful characters (Sonia’s dad, Nonno Marco, Nonno Beppi, Nonna Ige). For me the most engaging parts of the book were this (till chapter 8) and the 1990s period…rest is just… well you’ll read the next section hopefully.

- Some flex moments: Sonia’s school was visited by Sophia Loren! She’d come to visit Italian pioneer cinematographer Giuseppe Fillipe, in Sonia’s village. Later, when Sonia arrived in India 1st time, she stayed with the Bachchans, since Amit(abh) was close friend of Sanjay then.

- Some incidents were funny - Rajiv’s 1st meeting with Sonia’s father; Ball room invitation card torn by Rajiv as he’s angry at Sonia for her unpunctuality! (For some reason I’d have thought her strict father would have made her punctual too?!) Another was when she and her friend Preeti removed a panel/board above the Bhutani Majesty’s room, thinking it was a rumored trapdoor  – Sasu Maa Indira scolded, then laughed with them; and the Sheep eyes of Uzbekistan 👀

-  I do share many interests with Sonia ji I guess – history, museums, art history, reading, movies – I got a small TBR and TBW list from this book 😊 Her fav childhood book is - Cuore(the heart) by Edmondo De Amicis – I’ll try if it’s short read.

- High praise for the people around her – that’s a quality I admire. This memoir is almost a biography too, of other people who made/helped her in her journey. Gotta read Sharada Prasad's book now – he’s highly praised here.

- 2010: Breast cancer diagnosed. Removed in Italy. Then 2011: pancreatic cancer/tumor treated. Twice cancer survivor 💪  

- 2022: Sonia's mother painful death, aged 97. “As she was laid to rest in the family crypt, Anoushka’s daughter Aruna spontaneously began to sing in her lovely voice her Nonna’s favourite song, “Scrivimi” (“Write to Me”), a melancholy love song of the 1930s”. I heard the song, it’s beautiful. Here are the lyrics. :’)

- Chapters 27-30: Her inner turmoil is reflected when her sister Nadia questions her stay in India after 2 tragic deaths - that Sonia should come back to her home in Italy; her decision to enter politics, seeking Gita's guidance; when she gives up the PM position in favor of MMS, to avoid "foreign origin" attacks by the opposition.

- When Sonia's father dies by heart attack, she regrets not meeting her sooner. Similarly when Rajiv had asked her to accompany him to Sriperumbudur, she regrets not going – these are where the memoir truly reflects her pain.   

 

What I didn't like/Stuff that’s somewhat sad, disturbing:

- 1975 The Raj Narain case: Didn't know about the 2 trivial counts on which Indira's 1971 win was invalidated.  

- Chapter 16:- Operation Blue Star is discussed not in detail. Never mentions the causes nor discusses what led to that situation in the 1st place. I would have liked more information about how much Indira Gandhi was involved in Bhindranwale's rise - it's almost absent here. Just the aftermath.

- The ugly rumours about her – yes it’s part of public life, but it’s sad – I feel the vitriol against her is extremely misogynist. One example is  - Jan 18,1969: her 1st born child dies.🪦 Right wingers even then displayed utter inhumane commentary ("Indira Gandhi failed in her attempt to become a grandmother of a bastard child" – ran an article, newspaper unnamed though)

- Sonia admits Sanjay Gandhi's rash and unconstitutional role in govt policies. Maneka + Sanjay vs Indira Gandhi...and yeah, she doesn't like Maneka Gandhi at all.

- 31/10/1984: Indira Gandhi dies. Sonia’s emotional reaction is truly sad to read, and then the gut punch : when she hears the news that ‘they’ want Rajiv to be next PM, she pleads against it, but Rajiv says “They’ll kill me anyway.”

- 1985: Shah Bano case. In 2001: SC upheld the 1986 law. Sonia here defends Rajiv’s actions using SC's decision, but it’s not convincing: Govt. had 1st welcomed the court order, THEN seeing the Muslim clergy backlash, drafted the 1986 law.

- "Rahul as general secretary in charge of the Youth Congress signed a party-to-party Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with his Chinese counterpart. However, nothing substantial came of that formal exercise." In 2008. I had to check, if this is legally possible! It is, since it's not legally enforceable, and as long as it's of non-financial nature. But the MoU hadn't been made public yet...

- Some facts are wrongly stated – e.g., RSS founded in 1921. (Fact - 1925). I saw this reel while reading it. Trivial for me, there were bigger gripes I had…

- Sonia mentions “I would reiterate here that this is a memoir, wherein politics serves to frame the main narrative, which is a personal account of my thoughts, feelings, and decisions."-  problem for me is – there’s a lot of crucial decision-making missing in such landmark events! There are virtually no thoughts/feelings about Sonia’s own political ideology here – no insights into the diverse States, the people, the culture, the history of India. No mention of dynastic politics. No information regarding the blunders of her govt., nor of Indira/Rajiv’s govts.

Conclusion:

Mrs. Sonia’s journey is remarkable, no doubt – and deserves to be told. How a shy Italian village girl fell in love, got swept up in the messy democracy of 1.4bn people, gained/lost everything due to her love – these parts of her life are Interesting. Until 1990s, the memoir is basically like a report, mostly of Sonia’s POV on others.
She talks about Indira, then Rajiv’s govt decisions, but only at a distance – there’s little criticism, little illumination or BTS – I can accept that, since she was uninterested by the politics by then, just wanted a family life. It’s only when she begins her reluctant political journey in 1990s - we begin to see some political views here and there, her defence of govt.’s actions, immense praise of her kids, her aversion to BJP/RSS ideology.

For someone who was never meant to be in politics, she has endured more than enough, and is an inspiration in that respect (she also admits this quality of growth and resilience in Modi’s rise within RSS, there’s a line somewhere…) however...

Mrs. Sonia's subjective views contrast too much with her factual descriptions of the landmark events for me - here I praise her emotional commitments; there I wonder about crucial factual omissions! 🤦

Rating: 6.5/10 [As a memoir strictly, I'd rate it probably 7.5/10.]

I'm now eager to read Modi's memoir - it'll be quite a contrast...


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Suggest Me About Kathasaritsagara

2 Upvotes

So I am writing a story and I want to take ideas from Indian Fantasy. Which edition of Kathasaritsagara should I get so that I can get most of the ideas down and also enjoy the stories.


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Discussion Is it original or counterfeit.

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

So I purchased this along with volume 1 & 2 all three from the same seller [Trans Infopreneur (Kantoor)] from Amazon, the other two volumes shipped from Karnataka and this one shipped from haryana this one reached me and the other two are still in transit, the book seems fine but the packaging was bad and the original sealed plastic already torn open (3rd pic) the package have delhivery tape on it the product seemed returned or replaced product and the most important thing check the last pic guys the cover didn't have that arabic sign stuff that present in the book from the website.


r/IndiansRead • • 3d ago

Suggest Me Suggestions needed

1 Upvotes

Guys suggest a fiction book from any of the 2 genres.

  1. A comforting, happy go lucky and not so heavy theme.
  2. A suspense thriller.