TL/Dr, after being cheated on in the past, how do we cope with other men hitting on our new partner when she doesn't outright reject the advances?
***
I found this sub incredibly helpful when my (37m) previous 7-year relationship ended after discovering that my ex had been cheating on me with multiple men for the last 18 months of our relationship.
I managed to bounce back pretty well after a tough few months, and ended up seeing Katy (35f). Katy and I had known each other loosely for 15 years or so, and always got on really well and fancied each other but never seemed to be single at the same time. After both being in long term relationships, we happened to both break up with our exes at the same time and ended up getting together, almost like a mutually agreed rebound.
She's pretty, bouncy and bubbly and makes friends wherever she goes and always gets plenty of attention. Early on in the relationship we discussed my insecurities after being cheated on and she was brilliant, though she'd never had it happen to her she was caring and empathetic about my pain, she shared passcodes to her phone early on and told me I was always free to use it, and it was her suggestion to install Life360 so we could track each others location, she said she felt better that way as she works alone a lot of the time so there was a practical aspect to it too
We've been together 2.5 years now and it's been great. But a few months ago she was cycling on her road bike and a passing car forced her into a ditch and drove off. She was unharmed, but the next vehicle behind stopped to help her, and it turned out the helper was someone she knew.
Last week she came home and voluntarily told me she'd bumped into the same person in a fuel station again, and that he was complimenting her on how much of a 'tough cookie' she was. She seemed quite pleased at the attention from him, when I asked who it was, she said 'just a guy I used to know' which was the first little red flag for me.
That night she woke up feeling unwell at 1am and looked at her phone for a bit. She went to the bathroom and left her phone behind, and while she was gone it received a message. My curiosity got the better of me and I looked over at the screen, just at the lock screen, and the message was from an unsaved number along the lines of:
'Proper tough cookie, i was surprised to see you climbing out that ditch, hot blondie xx'
My heart absolutely dropped. I went straight to thinking was this guy an old romantic interest? I didn't sleep the rest of the night.
I went hyper vigilant after this and although I resisted unlocking her phone, the next few mornings I did swipe through her notifications while she went to the bathroom and every morning there would be a new message from him. The next two were fairly innocent, but the 3rd day was a comment on the bicycle accident again where he said she had a nice arse. There was another incident where her phone beeped at 1am again and woke us both up, she leant over to check the notification, and I peered over her shoulder and thought I saw another message from him.
I asked ' who's messaging you this time of night?' and she replied quite defensively and grumpily 'i don't know babe, probably some idiot customer'. She's self employed so she does get a lot of random messages from new numbers, but her defensive tone seemed off to be, but that could have just been my hyper vigilance kicking in.
Either way this was enough for me to access her phone and read through the whole conversation. There was about 30-40 messages of back and forth friendly chat, mostly him showing off about how successful and dangerous his job was, with a flirty comment from him maybe every 5 or 10 messages that wasn't reciprocated by her, but also wasn't shut down in any way either.
There were a few opportunities for her to disclose she had a boyfriend too (e.g he mentioned he does the exact same job as me in the same field, she told him about her new work boots but didn't mention I bought them for her) but she didn't take either of these opportunities to bring me up which seems odd to me. My job is fairly niche and so is my girlfriend's, if someone told me they did XYZ for example my first reaction would be 'no way, my girlfriend is an XYZ, do you know her?'
it looks like after he asked her for a copy of the video of her falling off from her helmet cam (it was in this last message his flirting escalated to giving her a compliment on her arse) the conversation has moved to WhatsApp, and I haven't had another chance to monitor it. I already feel guilty that I've betrayed her trust by accessing her phone without her knowledge, and I'm conflicted because she hasn't actually done anything wrong, but the lack of mention of a boyfriend and the apparent ignoring of his advances but not explicitly shutting them down feels like it violates a boundary for me.
She is still making no attempt to hide or be secretive with her phone, yesterday she left it charging in the room with me and went to have a shower for 10-15 minutes, so that to me suggests she sees nothing wrong with messaging guys from her past like she is and doesn't consider it necessary to hide.
Not really sure what advice I'm after here, I just wanted to vent to others who have maybe been in my position. I think I need to decide whether I need to confess to snooping and say that I feel her conversation with this guy crosses a boundary for me and why, keep monitoring the conversation for a bit to see if it either escalates or tails off, or just accept that after being cheated on, my boundaries are tighter than most and I need to come to terms with the fact that other men are going to always try their luck with her and as long as she doesn't lean back into it then I need to deal with it.