I went to see You Can See Everything in the cinema last night and I haven't been able to stop thinking about this moment, so instead of stewing I thought I'd put it into the void and see what you guys think. Fair warning: there will be spoilers for YCSE and IWTV S2, I'll put spoiler warnings, but figured I should signal it up top. I also want to clarify that Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans are real people, I don't know them, and everything in this essay? is an analysis of Nathan Fielder's narrative documentary, not the people themselves.
Context for what's happening in the doc for people who won't watch it - you don't need to read this bit to understand, I just thought it might be helpful (Spoilers for YCSE).
After Elizabeth Holmes goes to prison, the movie refocuses on her partner (not husband) Billy Evans. Fielder reveals that when they were negotiating the terms of Elizabeth's involvement, Billy privately demanded a cut of the film's post-release profit. A24 agreed to this. Billy made the deal when Elizabeth was out of the room, so Fielder didn't know whether this was done with Elizabeth's knowledge/consent. When Fielder is talking to Billy and pressing him on this, Billy is also extremely evasive about what Elizabeth did or did not know about the documentary contract.
Later, at a dinner between Fielder, Amanda Siegfried and Billy Evans, Billy reveals that Elizabeth Holmes gave him Power of Attorney, and that he is in control of her Twitter, her finances and her legal status (he was doing pretty heinous things with her image/story). Beyond that, he feels that he does not have to inform her or talk to her about the decisions he is making in Elizabeth's name, since their decisions are one and the same (the love of his life etc. etc.).
Fielder then decides to visit Elizabeth in prison so that he can directly present the facts of Billy's contract with A24 and his other decisions on her behalf without Billy around. She is similarly evasive about whether or not she knew the contents of the contract.
I think most IWTV fans will already see the parallels with the psychosexual saw trap of the Dubai Penthouse but let me develop it: (Spoilers for IWTV S2)
There is a fascinating parallel to the way Louis continually repeats specific phrases Armand uses in Dubai. Billy Evans is not particularly eloquent or romantic in the rest of the documentary. He's an angry, privileged, Kirk-supporting 'alpha' who shows a consistent disdain for women and less 'alpha' men. There were two notable times where his story seems incongruent with the rest of his behaviour that I picked up.
Firstly, when Elizabeth is describing how she met Billy, she says it was love at first sight - it only took one conversation for her to be in love. Billy describes something seemingly quite different - he met Elizabeth at the height of the Theranos fall-out, she was wearing sunglasses and a hat to obscure her face, and he only spoke to her for one hour before realising who she was. When pressed about why they managed to start a relationship, Billy agreed that the fraud allegations would have prevented him from starting a genuine relationship with her, and then jumps to the conclusion that he fell in love with her within the first hour of talking to her. This conclusion seemed odd to me - immediately before Fielder started pushing him about if he fell in love within the first hour, Billy explained he was already dating three women simultaneously. Immediately following his claim that he fell in love within one hour, Fielder reminds him that he couldn't see her face - a fact that seemed to have slipped Billy's mind.
The second was the overly romantic phrase: "building monuments to our love". During the conversation with Amanda Siegfried and Nathan Fielder and Billy Evans, Billy said that if you asked Elizabeth what she wanted to be remembered for when she dies, she would say their love. Specifically, "building monuments to [their] love"* was what drove her to rebuild her business. Then, when Fielder explains Billy's behaviour to Elizabeth in prison she used the exact same phrase, that they were "building monuments to [their] love"*
I just thought it was so interesting to see a man responding in real time to the exact kind of manipulation Armand is so good at, minus the supernatural mind-fuckery. Armand and Elizabeth's go-to tactic is to be pathetic and look at their target with big, weepy prey-animal eyes. They create the mirage of dependence on their partners despite being highly intelligent and tactical thinkers (Elizabeth managed to defraud investors out of hundreds of millions without having a single working prototype - everyone knows what Armand did).
When I was watching the documentary I just couldn't stop seeing these moments where Billy's thinking/story would just suddenly fall in line with Elizabeth's. I found Billy to be a highly distasteful person, but that doesn't make him immune to manipulation.
I think the situation very nicely illustrates the moral ambiguity in the penthouse too (at least in my interpretation). To me, Billy was manipulated into making Elizabeth the victim in the documentary, supporting her claim that none of her crimes were actually her fault. Her main argument is that she's "too trusting", which she verbatim says to Fielder, and that her naiveté (another descriptor Billy and Elizabeth like in the doc) was weaponised by Theranos COO and ex-boyfriend Ramesh 'sunny' Balwani.
Despite the fact Elizabeth seemed to be actively manipulating Billy and utilising his controlling behaviour, this doesn't change the fact that she is in now in a genuinely concerning situation. In order to convince Billy she was naive and vulnerable she genuinely made herself vulnerable, and now he has Power of Attorney and control over her access to the outside world.
During the Loumand fail-marriage, I think Armand was absolutely trying to make himself seem injured, trusting and vulnerable to force Louis to forgive and forget his involvement in Paris. Armand made himself less of a threat by using his big eyes and bigger hats, but also by genuinely handing Louis the atomic bomb of self-image that is the Armand, Amadeo, Arun monologue. While Louis is definitely the victim of Armand's psychological manipulation and abuse, Armand also put himself in a position to be psychologically violated with the whole arun/pimp dynamic that did develop.
Anyway, I just thought these were interesting thoughts. Obviously Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans are real people, so my interpretation of the documentary is fundamentally incomplete and filtered through the prism of Nathan Fielder's perspective. The documentary is brilliant at making you continually question every previous conclusion you may have made about Elizabeth, Billy and Fielder himself, and I think it's interesting to apply some of that uncertainty/greyness to the Loumand situation.
What does everyone else think? Honestly there's so much to say about the doc (and obviously I can't stop yapping about the fascinating Dubai Penthouse dynamic.)
*In both cases [their] was originally 'our'.