Hey everyone, looking for a second set of eyes on these two Mew 040 Nintendo Black Star Promos (Trainer's Challenge Set). One was picked up in person at a card show and the other came from eBay.
There’s a noticeable color and saturation difference between them, the left card has deeper, richer purple tones and slightly darker ink on the back, the blacks in the background behind Mew are a lot darker on the left compared to the right, and Mew itself is noticeably more pink on the left as well. It almost looks like the saturation was turned up on the left print, while the right card is lighter and brighter overall.
What I’ve verified so far:
Cardstock & Feel: Both have the exact weight, snap, and texture of genuine EX-era cards (and pass standard opacity checks).
Holo Foil: Both have authentic cosmos holo patterns that shift properly depending on the viewing angle (last photo).
Card Backs: Both have clean, sharp borders, and the macro shots of the "P" show genuine rosette dot patterns rather than solid inkjet/laser printing.
Since EX-era promos are known for ink/color variance across print runs (and mild sun fading is always a possibility on older cards), I’m trying to confirm whether both are 100% legit copies showing print variance/UV fade, or if one is a convincing proxy.
Thanks in advance for any help comparing left vs. right!