Hi everyone,
Here's a review of my rose gold Vintage Alhambra single motif necklace with gray mother of pearl from Andy Chan, benchmarked against two auth pieces: a friend's WG white MOP and an RG pavé I tried on in the boutique.
Executive summary: I've worn it every day since it arrived and I like it, subject to the caveats below.
I ordered it in December 2025 with the chain extended to 47 cm. The necklace came in at 5.4 g. Upon inquiry, AC claimed the gray MOP accounted for 0.5 g. I'd venture 1.5 g, but whatever. For better or worse, we will probably never find out.
Upon receipt, the first thing I noticed was how shallow the stone sits. It isn't fully recessed into the clover the way you'd expect, and on one side the beads (pearls/perlée) are practically level with its surface. AC told me this occurs on auth pieces too, owing to the hand work, and having gone back through my own boutique photos, I kinda see it too: gray MOP does sit shallower than the other stones. So it's accurate. Nonetheless, it bugs me, since I can only wear the necklace with the "better" side facing out.
In the photos, you can see my rep next to my friend's auth WG MOP. She bought hers around 2021, which makes it the old design, and its VCA and Au750 stamps differ slightly from mine, which I'd attribute to the changes over the years. At a normal distance I can't tell the two apart, in photos or in person. On closer inspection, the auth chain looks marginally more refined, while the thickness is the same. It just looks better to me, idk. I also suspect the auth beads are larger, by maybe 5%, but I cannot prove it nor can I disprove it. There was a very good post here comparing AC pieces through the years, where it was obvious his perlée had been shrinking over time. It has since been deleted, unfortunately.
The last photo is from my recent boutique visit, where I tried on the RG pavé alongside my rep. The chains look identical to me. So does the rose gold color, although I can't rule out that the photo is flattering mine. I hope the SA also thought the RG color was identical ;) The auth beads appear larger here as well, with the same disclaimer about my bias.
The visit itself was horrible, to be honest. I was incredibly nervous, and I'm fairly sure my SA caught that it was a rep. I had to wear it at the full 47 cm to try it on with the second necklace (I normally keep mine at 42), and I suspect the weight distribution and the way it sat on my neck gave the rep away.
On shine: a comparison posted here between an auth piece and one from Funny included a video showing the difference. The auth chain sparkles in short flashes, whereas Funny's shines as one solid piece. Mine sparkles in short flashes too, albeit with a sample size of one bathroom.
All in all: the perlée could be better, and next time I'd go with the old design over the new one. AC always sends a comparison of both before the final order, so that one is on me. The old design is what the boutique mostly carries, at least in gray MOP, and it feels more VCA to me. Possibly my bias again.
Now, the numbers. I paid $795 in mid-December 2025: $730 for the necklace plus $65 for the extra 5 cm. Gold was $139 per gram on the purchase date. On my estimate of a 1.5 g stone, that leaves 3.9 g of metal, or 2.925 g of pure gold, for a melt value of about $407 and a whopping 95% markup. On AC's 0.5 g, melt value is about $511 and the markup comes down to a more civilized 56%. For what it's worth, I did a scratch test and it came back 18k, though that only speaks to the surface. Obviously, I doubt any of the trusted sellers would cheat on the gold.
For my next order, I'd like to go with someone cheaper. AC's prices back then included insurance, and I'm not sure whether that's still the case. But even if you buy insurance separately from other sellers, their markups are considerably lower.