r/Jewish • u/Electrical_Pomelo556 • 21h ago
Discussion 💬 Should only Mizrahi Jews play Moses?
I haven't seen this discussed here, but there's going to be a concert of Prince of Egypt. Link to cast announcement: https://playbill.com/article/ali-louis-bourzgui-shereen-ahmed-zachary-noah-piser-brian-stokes-mitchell-will-lead-nyc-prince-of-egypt-concert
DISCLAIMER: Please know that the LAST thing I want to do here is start a fight for entertainment. I'm genuinely curious to hear people's thoughts.
Zach Noah Piser is a Hapa Jew, half Ashkenazi and half non-Jewish Asian (I think Chinese). Ariel Stachel (a self-described Arab Jew, as his father was Yemeni Israeli) expressed his anger, frustration, and hurt that a Mizrahi Jew was not cast.
I don't feel qualified to have an opinion on this but I think I can share some initial thoughts. As a child, Ari experienced tons of racism in the aftermath of 9/11 for being Arab (his words, not mine), and is now currently experiencing tons of racism for being Jewish. I can definitely understand where his upset is coming from. There is no shortage of Mizrahi Jews in NYC, but we so rarely see them in the media that non-Jews don't even know they exist, so then no one will cast them in Jewish roles because "Jews are white" which of course leads to "white colonizer" bullshit. So when a single opportunity comes up to cast a Middle Eastern Jew, and they don't take it, of course he's disappointed.
On the other hand, Jews are Jews, and white Jews are just as indigenous to the Middle East as any other Jew (and plenty of Mizrahi Jews --and Middle Easterners in general-- look white anyways!). It's not like mixed-race Jews get tons of rep either. Also, this is a one-night concert, so it's not going to have near as much of an impact as say, a brand new musical or a TV show. And, no one casts undiscovered actors anymore, and Zach Piser did just come off his run in Maybe Happy Ending. I haven't seen him perform, but I'm sure he's excellent, and I do feel really bad for him getting dragged into the controversy, especially right after the casting controversy with MHE, even though he wasn't the center of it.
Really I'm just curious about what y'all have to say, I haven't heard much from non-Ashkenazi diaspora perspectives here.