Never as Tired as When I'm Waking Up: I could see James reaching for this if he's really out of ideas. Easy to learn, requires no synth wizardry, and could fill the American Dream/Oh Baby ballad slot. There's probably a reason it hasn't been played yet though.
Great Release: apparently was played a couple times in 2005 so it's possible, I do feel like this one occupied a niche that eventually got filled by NYILY/Home etc. so it makes sense to me why it never got any other airings. Could definitely see them giving this one a try at a residency show in front of a friendly crowd though.
Give It Up: never played on tour post COVID but played at that one special reunion show in 2022 so I'll include it here. I'd wager this will stay as a one-off treat for that show especially given how tough it is on James' voice. Can't see it coming out again without Phil Mossman there.
Tired: was setlisted at the aforementioned 2022 show. Another one that makes more sense with Phil than with the regular lineup but I think this one is fairly likely to make an outing at some point. Short and James seems to like it. Definitely on my watchlist.
Yeah (Pretentious Version): call me crazy but I think this one is inevitable at some point, it just fits so neatly into the modern band's synth-driven sound and would occupy the space that the 45:33 suite used to occupy. Flipside of that is that if James decides to revive any more 45:33 material there's no way this also gets an airing, but I find this substantially more likely than some of the other to-date unplayed tunes. Any excuse to go ham on percussion.
45:33 parts 3-6: Out in Space yes absolutely, it got played in 2016 a few times and makes total sense as a standalone thing. Parts 5-6 no unless they play the full thing at a special show, part 3 lol absolutely not.
Hippie Priest Bum-Out: I mean... it's funky and seemingly playable in a live context, so the chance isn't zero. But does any of the band even remember this exists? They'd have to really be scraping the bottom of the barrel to reach for this. Only not-impossible because of its easy translation to the band's sound.
Freak Out/Starry Eyes: pretty probable I'd say, especially at an end-of-run blowout show. I honestly think James likes this song more than his fans do lol, bizarre choice to feature this at the MSG show. Got played at their reunion show in 2016 too. Pretty repetitive and straightforward to learn.
Watch the Tapes: seems inevitable, doesn't it? I get the sense James is not a fan of this one at all, but then again I thought that about North American Scum and then it became a staple pretty much overnight. Pretty close to 100% chance that a punchy succinct song on their most beloved album makes a return at some point.
Sound of Silver: like Watch the Tapes, almost 100% chance here. If they're running out of things to play they're obviously gonna reach for Sound of Silver. Wouldn't be surprised even if it came back during this very run.
Oh You (Christmas Blues): lmao can you imagine? EXTREMELY slim but extant chance it gets played at the last couple shows of any given December residency, but also surely they'd just do Christmas Will Break Your Heart instead? I doubt James even remembers this song exists. Not likely.
Big Ideas: I've heard that James isn't really proud of this song hence why it never received any live airings at all despite being a perfect setlist inclusion on paper. If he ever decides to re-evaluate this tune then it feels like pretty much a lock to return, it would sound awesome live and received a good deal of attention at the time. All dependent on James' headspace though, like all of LCDSS's choices.
Drunk Girls: unlikely I'd say due to the risqué lyrics ('Drunk girls keep in pace with the pedophiles', do they really want to risk Twitter backlash over this shit?) I would be actively surprised if Drunk Girls returned to setlists, there's probably a reason it hasn't been seen at all post-breakup despite being a single with a video clip. Just feels like a relic from a different era (a shame, it bangs. Prove me wrong James)
Somebody's Calling Me: near-zero chance. Very much a studio (well, non-live) creation and very much associated, I think, with the time and place of its creation for James. No natural fit in the setlist, and weirdly long given what it is. Probably the least likely pre-breakup album track for me give or take a Drunk Girls.
I Used To: sure, I don't see why not. James is probably hyper-conscious about the American Dream material not generally proving as beloved as his earlier stuff so I think the chances of this stuff getting aired will drop to near-zero if they ever put out a new album, but in the interim it's like yeah sure I could see it. Not high energy so not a natural setlist choice and I think stuff like Watch the Tapes/Sound of Silver gets played before this does.
Change Yr Mind: repeat verbatim what I said about I Used To. No reason why not, but not a song people clamour for and chances decrease precipitously if a new album comes out. Maybe marginally more likely than I Used To due to being shorter, weirder and more playful, a direction that James seems to be moving in.
Black Screen: zero chance. Given the backstory behind this one I don't see it ever being played live, it's not that sort of song.
Pulse (v.1): lol no