r/LCMS • • 7d ago

Lutheranism and Orthodoxy Resources

7 Upvotes

About twice a month, we get a post asking something about Orthodox Christianity (eastern or oriental). This post is an attempt to provide a resource for those seeking answers to these questions.

Dr. Jordan Cooper is a Lutheran theology who has provided three, excellent videos that provide a critique of Orthodoxy from the Lutheran perspective:

Five Reasons I Am Not Eastern Orthodox

The Differences Between Lutheranism and Eastern Orthodoxy

A Lutheran Response to Eastern Orthodox Theology

Is the Orthodox Church the True Church? A Protestant Theologian reacts

Here is a conversation between Dr Cooper and Jonathan Pageau, an Eastern Orthodox Youtuber.

A Conversation Between Jordan B Cooper and Jonathan Pageau

Pastor Joshua Schooping, an LCMS Pastor who converted from Orthodoxy to Lutheranism, was interviewed in this 5 part series on Orthodoxy by Issues, etc. I'll add the caveat that some Orthodox people do not accept all of this pastor's characterizations of Orthodoxy. Issues, etc has many other episodes on Eastern Orthodoxy as well:

Eastern Orthodoxy - Issues, Etc.

Here is another post featuring Pastor Will Weedon, who once considered Orthodoxy but ultimately didn't convert:

Lutherans are *not* boring: why Lutheran Pastor William Weedon did not become Eastern Orthodox | theology like a child

Another discussion between Pastor Weedon and fellow called Javier Perdomo:

Why you should be Lutheran INSTEAD of Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox (w/ Pr. Will Weedon)

This topic has been brought up with such frequency over the years, that you are bound to find answers in older posts on Orthodoxy on our sub:

orthodoxy - Reddit Search!

the east - Reddit Search!


r/LCMS • • 10h ago

Question Traditional Parishes Near San Diego

3 Upvotes

Are there any traditional parishes in San Diego or Chula Vista? I went to Concordia Church (I guess they dropped the "Lutheran"), they had open communion and the pastor had placed his coffee mug on the altar. I found it hard to stick around when I saw that.

I'll be in the area for work for a few months and was hoping to find a Lutheran church. It doesn't even have to necessarily be high church, as long as there is respect for the Eucharist and the Confessions we are supposed to hold to.


r/LCMS • • 17h ago

Doctrine Biblical Devotions with American Lutheran Theological Seminary. “Scattered Sheep, Shepherd King.” (Ezk 34:11–31.)

2 Upvotes

URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MleC4Mj8No

Book of Ezekiel, 34:11–31 (ESV):

The Lord GOD Will Seek Them Out

“For thus says the Lord GOD: Behold, I, I myself will search for my sheep and will seek them out. As a shepherd seeks out his flock when he is among his sheep that have been scattered, so will I seek out my sheep, and I will rescue them from all places where they have been scattered on a day of clouds and thick darkness. And I will bring them out from the peoples and gather them from the countries, and will bring them into their own land. And I will feed them on the mountains of Israel, by the ravines, and in all the inhabited places of the country. I will feed them with good pasture, and on the mountain heights of Israel shall be their grazing land. There they shall lie down in good grazing land, and on rich pasture they shall feed on the mountains of Israel. I myself will be the shepherd of my sheep, and I myself will make them lie down, declares the Lord GOD. I will seek the lost, and I will bring back the strayed, and I will bind up the injured, and I will strengthen the weak, and the fat and the strong I will destroy. I will feed them in justice.

“As for you, my flock, thus says the Lord GOD: Behold, I judge between sheep and sheep, between rams and male goats. Is it not enough for you to feed on the good pasture, that you must tread down with your feet the rest of your pasture; and to drink of clear water, that you must muddy the rest of the water with your feet? And must my sheep eat what you have trodden with your feet, and drink what you have muddied with your feet?

“Therefore, thus says the Lord GOD to them: Behold, I, I myself will judge between the fat sheep and the lean sheep. Because you push with side and shoulder, and thrust at all the weak with your horns, till you have scattered them abroad, I will rescue my flock; they shall no longer be a prey. And I will judge between sheep and sheep. And I will set up over them one shepherd, my servant David, and he shall feed them: he shall feed them and be their shepherd. And I, the LORD, will be their God, and my servant David shall be prince among them. I am the LORD; I have spoken.

The LORD’s Covenant of Peace

“I will make with them a covenant of peace and banish wild beasts from the land, so that they may dwell securely in the wilderness and sleep in the woods. And I will make them and the places all around my hill a blessing, and I will send down the showers in their season; they shall be showers of blessing. And the trees of the field shall yield their fruit, and the earth shall yield its increase, and they shall be secure in their land. And they shall know that I am the LORD, when I break the bars of their yoke, and deliver them from the hand of those who enslaved them. They shall no more be a prey to the nations, nor shall the beasts of the land devour them. They shall dwell securely, and none shall make them afraid. And I will provide for them a renowned place for planting so that they shall no more be consumed with hunger in the land, and no longer suffer the reproach of the nations. And they shall know that I am the LORD their God with them, and that they, the house of Israel, are my people, declares the Lord GOD. And you are my sheep, human sheep of my pasture, and I am your God, declares the Lord GOD.”

Transcript

(Original devotional script is original work by ALTS. /u/JustKidding456 is not affiliated with ALTS. ChatGPT was used to polish transcript and find references.)

Hello, I'm Pastor Ben Baker. I am the professor of biblical languages at American Lutheran Theological Seminary.

And the text that I'm looking at today to do a devotional, a little devotion on, is that of Ezekiel chapter 34. This is the Old Testament reading for the last Sunday of the church year, and so it is paired with the Gospel reading of Jesus judging the sheep and the goats. And maybe go a little different direction than that today.

And so we have in Ezekiel 34 some really fascinating language and imagery that God uses to describe both Israel and Himself, and, as we will see, also Jesus.

And so, in part, Ezekiel 34:11–31 says this:

"For thus says the Lord God: Behold, I myself will search for my sheep and will seek them out. As a shepherd seeks out his flock when some of his sheep have been scattered abroad, so will I seek out my sheep. And I will rescue them from all places where they have been scattered on a day of clouds and thick darkness. And I will bring them out from the peoples and gather them from the countries, and will bring them into their own land.

"And I will feed them on the mountains of Israel, by the fountains, and in all the inhabited places of the country. I will feed them with good pasture, and upon the mountain heights of Israel shall be their pasture. There they shall lie down in good grazing land, and on fat pasture they shall feed on the mountains of Israel.

"I myself will be the shepherd of my sheep, and I will make them lie down, says the Lord God. I will seek the lost, and I will bring back the stray, and I will bind up the crippled, and I will strengthen the weak, and the fat and the strong I will watch over. I will feed them in justice.

"As for you, my flock, thus says the Lord God: Behold, I judge between sheep and sheep, rams and he-goats. Is it not enough for you to feed on the good pasture, that you must tread down with your feet the rest of your pasture, and to drink of clear water, that you must foul the rest with your feet? And must my sheep eat what you have trodden with your feet and drink what you have fouled with your feet?

"Therefore, thus says the Lord God to them: Behold, I myself will judge between the fat sheep and the lean sheep, because you push with side and shoulder and thrust at all the weak with your horns till you have scattered them abroad. I will save my flock; they shall no longer be a prey. And I will judge between sheep and sheep.

"And I will set up over them one shepherd, my servant David, and he shall feed them. He shall feed them and be their shepherd. And I, the Lord, will be their God, and my servant David shall be prince among them. I, the Lord, have spoken.

"I will make with them a covenant of peace and banish wild beasts from the land, so that they may dwell securely in the wilderness and sleep in the woods. And I will make them and the places round about my hill a blessing. And I will send down the showers in their season, and they shall be showers of blessing.

"And the trees of the field shall yield their fruit, and the earth shall yield its increase, and they shall be secure in their land, and they shall know that I am the Lord when I break the bars of their yoke and deliver them from the hand of those who enslaved them.

"They shall no longer be a prey to the nations, nor shall the beasts of the land devour them. They shall dwell securely, and none shall make them afraid. And I will provide for them prosperous plantations, so that they shall no more be consumed with hunger in the land and no longer suffer the reproach of the nations.

"And they shall know that I, the Lord their God, am with them, and that they, the house of Israel, are my people, says the Lord God. And you are my sheep, the sheep of my pasture, and I am your God, says the Lord God."

You know, it's interesting. Just one of those things, that this text is, at least in the three-year lectionary for Year A, is the Old Testament text for the last Sunday of the church year, which has, again, as its associated Gospel text, Matthew 25 and the judgment between the sheep and the goats. And what's interesting is that I'm guessing this text was chosen because of similar themes, like sheep and judgment.

But Ezekiel is really getting at something different, I think, than the Gospel text. The emphasis is in a different place.

And so in Ezekiel 34, God comes with His judgment, right, with His words of judgment against the shepherds of Israel. They're spiritual leaders who are supposed to be caring for the people. And instead, the language is kind of the shepherds were shepherding themselves, right? Instead of shepherding the sheep, they were shepherding themselves, and they were taking all the good stuff for themselves and leaving the people impoverished, not only materially but also spiritually.

And so in answer to this, God not only proclaims judgment against these shepherds who are serving themselves and not God and not God's people, but it's very interesting because God uses the language of, you know, "I myself will shepherd my sheep." And there's language in there of making them, you know, to lie down in good grazing land.

And so we want to connect to this Ezekiel 34 text Psalm 23, right? "The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want," right? "He makes me lie down" between, you know, lie down beside, or green pastures, you know, beside still waters, right?

And we often, in that psalm in English, we often use the language of, or the translation of, "He restores my soul." And really, the language there is the language of return. It is the Hebrew verb shuv (שׁוּב), to turn or return. And so really what we're saying there, and I don't know that "restores my soul" really quite gets at it, but it's more like "He brings me back." Like God, our shepherd, is also the one who works repentance in us, right? And brings us back to the paths of righteousness and so on, right?

And so we have this language and this imagery from Psalm 23 that very explicitly identifies God as the shepherd of His people and the kinds of things that He will do, such as leading His sheep in paths of righteousness so that they do not stray. And when they do stray, He brings them back, right? And all throughout Psalm 23.

And then we get this similar language in Ezekiel 34, where God describes what He will do for Israel in the language of Psalm 23. So God Himself will be the shepherd of His sheep, right? And He will bring them to good grazing land. He will keep them in safety, much like, you know, in Psalm 23, David prays, "You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies," right? Or, "Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I'll fear no evil, for You are with me," right?

So God's sheep will dwell in utter safety with Him, and He will feed them with good food, right, and set everything to right, and He Himself will be their shepherd.

Now, it's interesting because, you know, in Psalm 23, when it says, "The Lord is my shepherd," you know, that is the personal name for God, Yahweh (יהוה). And that is what is used here in Ezekiel also. And so we have, you know, "Yahweh is my shepherd." You know, Yahweh says, "I myself will shepherd my sheep," right?

And then it's very interesting because then Ezekiel goes on, as God goes on to describe this, to get into more detail, right? And He says not only that, you know, I, Yahweh, will shepherd my sheep, but He says in verse 23, "I will set up over them one shepherd, my servant David, and he shall feed them and be their shepherd. And I, the Lord, will be their God, and my servant David shall be prince among them. I, the Lord," or Yahweh, "have spoken."

And it's very interesting because right before that is where we have Yahweh saying, "I myself will shepherd my sheep." And then He says, "I will set up over them one shepherd, my servant David." And so we kind of have this kind of duality, or, you know, this sense of, you know, there's more than just an absolute singularity here to Yahweh, right? For Yahweh says, "I will shepherd my sheep," and "my servant David will be the one shepherd."

So there is a very tight connection here and identification here of this David who would shepherd God's people being God Himself. And of course, by this time David is long dead. And so this is certainly speaking of the coming Christ, right?

And what's really interesting with this too, then, is we have Psalm 23 and we have Ezekiel 34, and we have this, you know, this language of, you know, Yahweh is the shepherd of His people, and Yahweh is also identified with another, His servant David, and then, you know, the kinds of things that Yahweh the shepherd will do for His sheep, such as He will seek out the lost. He will go and find them. He will bring them back to the good land, to the good pasture. He will keep them in safety.

And when Yahweh gathers His sheep from being scattered across the world, when they come to their final dwelling place back in, you know, we could say again with the end of Psalm 23, "I will dwell in the," or "I will return to the house of the Lord all the days of my life, forever and ever," right? That this final return to the house and the dwelling place of Yahweh for His sheep will be in utter safety and peace and no want for anything, right?

And we come to the New Testament, and it's very interesting because, you know, in a couple of different places, like in John 10, but especially in Luke 15, you know, John 10 is the Good Shepherd text. But in Luke 15 in particular, especially the first parable, or the first part, you know, of that series of parallel parables that Jesus tells, you know, we call it often the "parable of the lost sheep," but this really puts the emphasis in the wrong place, because it is the parable of the good shepherd, right?

And Jesus tells this parable about the good shepherd who seeks out the lost sheep, right? He is using the exact language from Ezekiel 34, and He is therefore identifying Himself with that shepherd that Yahweh said He would establish, His servant David, for Jesus was physically descended from David. But remember that servant David is also Yahweh Himself, which fits very well with how Jesus speaks of Himself, using that divine name, speaking of the things that God does.

And so when Jesus is basically saying, "I am the good shepherd who goes after the lost sheep. I seek the lost. I bring them back." Again, this is the language of repentance and bringing them back safely. He's saying, "I'm doing what God does," right?

And certainly He gives the same kind of criticism of the shepherds of Israel in His day that God does in Ezekiel's day. The implication is that you Pharisees and religious leaders, you should be the ones who are going after the lost, but you're not.

But He uses that language from Ezekiel 34, that He's doing what God does, right? It's not just a nice little parable that tells us a little something about, you know, Jesus' heart for lost people. Obviously, He cares enough about the lost to go after them. But He is also saying, "I am the one who was told, was prophesied long beforehand in Ezekiel, the one that would come, that would be raised up by God to shepherd His people, and in fact, I am God Himself," right?

Because Jesus is also saying too, then, "I am also the Yahweh of Psalm 23," right? And so we see this language in Luke 15, and we see this in the activity and the work that Jesus does as He seeks out the lost.

But it doesn't stop there. If we jump way ahead, right, out to Revelation, and we come to Revelation chapter 7, right, we get that, you know, through St. John, we get that glimpse behind the veil, as it were, right? And we see the Lamb, the One who, you know, who appeared as having been slain, right, and yet lives. And that Lamb is in the midst of the throne.

Just looking for my reference here. He is in the midst of the throne, right? And this is what is sung. Believe I have that correct, that it is singing. This is what is sung, or said, sorry, by the elders speaking to St. John.

You know, he speaks of the saints before the throne of God. And then in verse 17, he says, "For the Lamb in the midst of the throne will be their shepherd, and He will guide them to springs of living water, and God will wipe away every tear from their eyes."

Right? That sounds an awful lot like Psalm 23, like Ezekiel 34. And if we go all the way to, you know, even further to the end of the visions of Revelation, and we go to, I believe it is chapter 21, here. Is it just—oh.

Okay. So it's not quite as explicit with the shepherd language, but you hear the similar, you know, kind of thing, you know, God dwelling with His people, right?

Revelation 21:3–4:

“Behold, the dwelling place of God is with man. He will dwell with them, and they will be his people, and God himself will be with them as their God. He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away.”

Right. And this is the great culmination of, you know, Psalm 23, Ezekiel 34, and then we see, you know, Jesus on the scene, as it were, in Luke 15, as He is doing the things ascribed to God, ascribed to Yahweh in Psalm 23 and Ezekiel 34.

And then we get a glimpse behind the veil, as it were, in Revelation 7, that presently, right now, that all those who have died in Christ are before the throne, and Jesus Himself is their shepherd, right? But it's not just for them. It is also for when Jesus returns and makes all things new, then for all people who belong to Christ, Jesus is our shepherd, and we dwell securely with Him, which is also to say with God, as Revelation 21 says, on this earth in safety, with no lack, perfection, right?

And so this is where, that's really where Ezekiel 34 is headed, right? The perfect peace and bliss and security that comes with the shepherd who is descended of David and also Yahweh Himself, who seeks out the lost, who brings them to good pasture and keeps them in safety, right? And brings them home.

Again, as, you know, God says in Ezekiel, you know, "On the mountain heights of Israel I will feed them," right? To bring us home to the new heavens and the new earth, right? And that's a pretty fascinating thing.

And one other thing with Ezekiel 34: You know, God brings His word of judgment against, you know, His shepherds. And unfortunately, in this present evil age, there are no shortage of bad shepherds in Christ's church, right, and among His flock.

But there is a comfort there, that even though there be bad shepherds in Christ's church and among His flock, we have still the one shepherd, the Good Shepherd, the One who will bring His sheep safely home.

So peace be with you.


r/LCMS • • 18h ago

Discussion Attending two churches

6 Upvotes

Is there anything wrong with attending a LCMS church for a Thursday weekly service with communion and then attending a non-denominational church on Sunday (and not participating in communion)?


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question Sponsor / Grandparent responsibilities

4 Upvotes

I posted in October I was confirmed and my grandson was baptized on the same day. His father is not in the picture at all, so I am the male figure in his life.

My question is at what age did you start teaching children certain things to prepare them for catechism?

For context, I left the Catholic Church last year and they had all kinds of stuff/programs, but I am not sure what is available for the LCMS, if anything, of if folks just do it on their own.

He is only five so it's a challenge to explain things to him in a way he can understand. The thing is he remembers what I tell him. His memory is really good, so I don't want to tell him something in a way a kid would understand but it not be accurate because this will confuse him later.

Also, my wife is Baptist so he goes to church with her a lot, so I have to navigate around that as well.

Since I have taken on this duty I want to do right by my best little friend.


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question Pastor won't run catechism classes

15 Upvotes

One of my nephews is confirmation age and desperately wants to go through classes and start taking communion (he's such an old and mature soul lol). He was at an LCMS youth outing and at a chapel service, the chaperones told him to go up and get communion even though they knew he wasn't confirmed. We assured him this was the fault of the chaperones and not him, but he says he feels incredibly guilty and wants to do things properly. Also pretty much the rest of his family and some of his friends are already confirmed LCMS so I think he wants to fit in.

My sibling reached out to their local LCMS pastor about my nephew's enthusiasm and if any catechism classes were starting soon.

The pastor responded with: "Why would he want to do that?" and "There's no point." He also said he is the only kid who is interested, so it would be 1-on-1 but that he could just start taking communion without classes.

WHAT?!?!? What are we suppose to do now? My nephew WANTS to do classes. Do they just...search for another local congregation who is doing classes? ALSO the pastor doesn't know my sibling is part of a mom's group chat where several of the church moms have kids who are confirmation age and have said they've been asking the pastor about classes and he has said pretty much the same thing. So he is lying to everyone.

This isn't a question about the pastor or wanting to get him in trouble, because I'm a third party here and I don't have all the context.

This question is about my nephew and what is he suppose to do? How is he suppose to get catechized?


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question Help wanted. Young adults lcms Lutherans?

13 Upvotes

Hello! I was wondering if anyone could help me with something! I was wondering if there was any way to hopefully gather more people 18-25 ish or around that age range! I am 20 years old and I’ve been loving my LCMS Lutheran church but I have visited several and I noticed there usually isn’t or rarely is anyone near my age :(

Is there some kind of idea I could do to maybe draw more young people into a young adults Lutheran group or maybe just at least near me? I’m not super far from the capital of Virginia if that helps! (Richmond) As much as I do think LCMS Lutheran is the best denomination I feel like it would be so much more motivating to have people around my age attending also as it can be a little disheartening being the only young person going to my church. If anyone has any ideas they would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks, Arden


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Discussion MO Scholars - LCMS

9 Upvotes

This post is specifically for my Missouri based LCMS members, but have any of you taken part in the MO Scholars program?

The LCMS has set up a MO Scholars fund where you can direct half your state income tax towards allowing children with learning disabilities or from low income families attending LCMS schools in the form of a tax credit.

Here's the link that explains it. Basically, you write a check to the LCMS. Then you get reimbursed via a tax credit in April. I'm going to do this myself for 2026 as you need to get the check sent in before the end of the year. Was wanting to get out the word on this relatively new program.

In 2025, LCMS Scholarship Awards reached $8.5 million supporting 1,131 students across 60 schools, with roughly 250 students remaining on the waitlist, so there's plenty of additional funding we can secure if people sign up.

https://mo.lcms.org/mo-scholars/


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Worship Christmas is coming which means Advent is almost here! 🎼🎵🎶

11 Upvotes

Here's the official Advent and Christmas Music playlist from the Church:

https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTPkKKi0RCocFeYfvp6HB6xgc9ZQqoUoB&si=rC07YE1j92QCW1ge


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Question Are we confusing preserving Lutheran doctrine with preserving the way we’ve always done things?

10 Upvotes

I wanted to revisit my previous post because I don’t think I did a very good job explaining what I’m actually trying to argue.

I believe the Church needs pastors now more than ever, and I think we need to have an honest conversation about how we train, develop, and deploy them. My concern is that we have become so focused on the traditional process of preparing pastors that we’re sometimes overlooking other ways of equipping men to serve God’s Church.

I want to make something clear: I am not arguing that we should compromise Lutheran doctrine, lower theological standards, or allow men to become pastors without proper preparation. I believe sound doctrine and proper theological education are incredibly important. However, I think there is a difference between preserving our doctrine and preserving every method and tradition we’ve developed along the way.

The Church has never looked exactly the same throughout history. Its methods of worship, education, organization, and ministry have changed over time. The central message of the Gospel has not changed, but the ways in which the Church carries out its mission have continually developed. Why should pastoral education be any different?

This is why I struggle with the resistance to programs like Kyros. There are men who may be called to pastoral ministry but cannot realistically leave their jobs, families, and communities to attend seminary in St. Louis or Fort Wayne. My own congregation has actually lost a pastor because the LCMS would not allow him to pursue ministry through our program. What are we supposed to tell congregations in situations like this? That they must continue struggling without a pastor because the only acceptable pathway isn’t accessible to everyone?

I’ve read the arguments that alternative pathways could weaken our doctrine, and I understand why people are concerned. But I don’t believe a different educational pathway automatically means an inferior theological education. Why can’t we establish standards, evaluate programs, and ensure that men are properly equipped while still allowing different ways to get there?

I also understand that the Synod is trying to address the shortage through things like tuition assistance and improvements to existing programs. That’s good, but I don’t think it addresses every problem. Affordability isn’t the only obstacle. Relocation, family responsibilities, employment, and the needs of smaller congregations all matter.

Ultimately, I think we need to ask ourselves whether we’re more concerned with maintaining the process of producing pastors or actually making sure God’s people have pastors to shepherd them.

I don’t want a church that compromises its doctrine to accommodate the times. I want a church that remains firmly grounded in its doctrine while being willing to adapt its methods to meet the needs of the people it serves.

The world changes, circumstances change, and the needs of congregations change. The Church has always had to respond to those realities. We should be able to have conversations about doing things differently without immediately treating those conversations as threats to Lutheranism or attacks on the Synod.

I’m not saying that Tim Ahlman, or anyone else has every answer. I’m saying I think the questions he’s raising deserve to be taken seriously rather than dismissed as divisiveness.

We should be able to defend our doctrine without being afraid to reconsider our methods.


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Doctrine Limited Atonement

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m a Lutheran in a family environment full of Reformed minds. The main contention that gets brought up is Limited Atonement.

They logically conclude from PSA that it would be unjust of God to send an unbeliever to hell (punishing them for their sins) if Christ already took the punishment in the cross, thus concluding that he must have not taken their punishment resulting in limited atonement. With this argument, they would say that universal atonement would have to result in universalism/every person being saved.

It all fits very tightly together. Whenever scripture is brought up that support Universal Atonement, it feels like they appeal to that logical system which makes them try and find any way to interpret the passages to say otherwise.

What are our best objections to this argument and claim? Is our defense that they are just never correct in the first place to make conclusions from PSA in that way?


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Discussion Tim ahlman and the deployment and development of pastors. How should pastors be trained

0 Upvotes

i believe the church needs pastors right now more than ever and we should be able to have them through means not just through st. louis. if a pastor wants to worn part time they may not be able to go there. my church has actaully lost a pastor because the lcms will not let them take our program.


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Question Is an LCMS church under doctrinal still in full altar-pulpit fellowship?

2 Upvotes

For example, imagine an LCMS congregation starts denying for example the Lutheran view of the Supper, and is under disciplinary proceedings, but is not yet officially excluded, are they still in full altar-pulpit fellowship with other LCMS churches? Would that imply that exchange of pulpits and communion cannot still be stopped, even if the church has been teaching open error on the Eucharist? Or how does it work.


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Discussion Does anyone else find this frustrating?

30 Upvotes

There are certain pastors online that seem to think only way to be bold for the truth is to be blunt, unnuanced, and rather hostile. For example, if there's a disagreement on something regarding doctrine, instead of simply explaining why one believes the way they do and give the relevant scriptures, some pastors tend to be hostile and arrogant to anyone who disagrees with their understanding, someone rightly calls them out on their behavior, and they double down and point to scriptural examples of the saints and Christ Himself being bold and sometimes harsh. They seem to take those examples as permission to be brash, blunt, and, frankly, rude. Then they just dismiss any criticism as people "hating the truth". It's not as common in our circles compared to fundamentalist or reformed circles (thanks be to God), but does anyone find this frustrating?


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Question Closed communion as a convert

11 Upvotes

If you are a convert to the LCMS (please specify if previously Christian or if new to Christianity when you became Lutheran), were you given communion before you started catechesis/membership classes? How do you feel about that decision your pastor made at the time?


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Question converting from catholicism? yec

6 Upvotes

i’m a 20yo cradle catholic born into a polish family who is potentially looking into converting to the lcms, but it is so hard to leave and decide what is the “right” faith. growing up, my faith has been rocky. throughout highschool, i turned away from christ into self destructive and selfish habits, and even turned to new age spirituality/pantheism for some time, you could almost say i was agnostic. i was still attending mass and i still got confirmed and i honestly did feel the presence of Jesus at that time, i just had the wrong idea for some time.

growing up, i went to public school and i have never really been involved in the faith. i feel our family was jsut a “go to church every sunday” family because that’s the way they were raised. i feel like i was also raised up to be scared of God and was told he would punish me, and that the devil was inside of me when i didn’t want to go to church. hearing these things as a small child rubbed me the wrong way and when i look back at it now it makes sense why i have such a confusing relationship with the church and the Lord. i also have ocd which makes this a very difficult decision since it latches onto this.

my boyfriend is part of the lcms, and his dad is a pastor. we didn’t necessarily start off the best in terms of having a godly relationship, but we both want to do better.

for a few months now, we have been arguing about theology. it has gotten to the point where we are basically broken up because we cannot agree, but we both still have hope that we can make this work and we want to try again.

first it was arguing about young earth creationism. when we first brought up the topic, i was 100% against yec and believed in an old earth but now i take the stance of it could have been any way, and ultimately God knows the answer. he is somewhat fine with my view, but he wants his kids to believe in what he believes, which i am somewhat concerned about as science becomes more advanced. for me, it is still extremely hard to believe in a young earth when there is a lot of scientific evidence pointing to an old earth, but ultimately i feel like this is not a topic that deserves as much attention.

we are also arguing about our other theological differences. growing up, i was never really super catholic. for example, my mom was against going to confession, and i honestly haven’t went in years either. (i was thinking about going sometime soon so i can receive the eucharist at mass) purgatory, confession, and the pope have been big topics that we somewhat disagree on.

i say somewhat disagree on because when we first started talking about our differences, i didn’t really have a solid stance on most of these things, but i jsut went with them because i am catholic. for example, i disagreed with the idea of purgatory, but now finding out that it is a catholic teaching i feel like i have to agree with it.

there are a lot of things i love about being catholic. i love going to mass, there is something so comfort in about it, especially when i feel alone at college. i love the truth the catholic church brings, and i love how it goes along with science and doesn’t deny it. i am a first generation daughter of polish immigrants, and it is also strongly tied to my culture and my identity.

essentially he wants to agree more on core beliefs such as purgatory and salvation which is valid, but i don’t know what to do. i almost feel like im being pressured to covert since he can come off a little strong at times. i love him a lot and our relationship is great besides this disagreement. please help !!


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Good Lutheran theologians to read?

13 Upvotes

I know and have read a few notable ones, but I'm looking to expand my knowledge on the broad scope of Lutheran theology and commentary. I'm pretty open to any topic, although right now I'm on a little bit of a kick at looking at Old Testament prophecy, so I wouldn't be upset about suggestions for that.

People who I've read some of:
- Luther and Melenchton (the two I've read the most of)
- CFW Walther
- Bryan Wolfmueller
- Will Weedon

As an aside, I'm a future seminarian, so please don't hesitate to throw something dense my way.


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Discussion Advice on Walking With Christ

6 Upvotes

Without going into extensive detail, for the past 7 years, my mental health conditions have been a huge barrier in my life.

I've recently become Lutheran (just over 1 year now), and was Pentecostal for my entire life before that (I'm 23 now).

I volunteer at my church, have missed maybe 2 Sundays in the past 13 months etc so I've tried my best to be regularly involved.

On top of that I also attend a bible study with people my age every Sunday night which has also been for the last year.

I know the point is that we're not always supposed to 'feel' God, but every encounter I've been having with Him these past few months, whether that be prayer, reading my bible (which I admit has been lacking), and even sometimes Sunday services/bible study has just been dry.

I know that as part of my particular mental health conditions, feeling emotions is something that is usually difficult for me, but I almost feel like sometimes I'm just intellectualising everything and knowing about God, as opposed to knowing Him.

If anyone has any advice it would be greatly appreciated.


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Question When is a sin mortal?

6 Upvotes

I am still somewhat new to Lutheranism, and when is is mortal causes me to be sometimes confused, because I have heard contradictary answers from Lutherans. Some Lutherans told me that as long as you have knowledge that something is sin, then if you do it, it is sinful, no matter if you fell into severe temptation/hated it and repented, you were still damned in the moment you fell into temptation because you knew it to be sin. On the other hand, some have told me that if despite trying to resist it, you fall into temptation, but hate it and do not intend to persevere in that sin, you did not lose your justification, but sinned out of weakness.

Which one is the correct Lutheran understanding?

I found Chemnitz seems to say that someone who fell into a sin through passion but hated it, did not lose their justification, but is this the universal understanding? Chemnitz wrote:

"Even if the fires of depraved lusts in their great power take the regenerate as captives either to the point of consent or to the actual performance of some evil work, yet if they immediately repent in sorrow and in faith seek forgiveness, it is certain that the Holy Spirit has been grieved or hurt, but not yet crushed, and faith and the grace of God have not been lost. For the Holy Spirit works in the regenerate that he may rise again as a righteous person, even if he falls seven times in a day"


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Question Old CRM List Controversy - Still a problem?

9 Upvotes

Over a decade ago, there was coverage within the Lutheran podcast/blogosphere pertaining to Candidate for the Reverend Ministry (CRM) status on the Pastoral roster, and how this status was the kiss of death for clergy. Once they ended up on it, it was the end of their career as a Pastor. I haven't seen any coverage of this in a long time.

Does anybody know if this is still a problem in the LCMS? We have a Pastoral vacancy and there is some information I'm trying to gather.


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Doctrine Can Lutheran Laymen Reject the Book of Concord?

26 Upvotes

I’d like to point out that the folks in this forum who frequently say that Lutheran laymen do not have to subscribe to the Book of Concord and are therefore free to disagree are not quite correct.

We do not require our laymen to read the Book of Concord and make a quia subscription to it. This is true. But if a layman has read it and rejects the doctrine he finds there, though he was not required to read it, a rejection of its doctrine would be an impediment to membership.

In the same way, I don’t require couples undergoing marriage counseling to have read 1 Corinthians 13. It’s a great chapter, and we might even discuss parts of it, but reading it is simply not a formal requirement in marriage counseling. But if a couple asked for counseling and led with the fact that they reject 1 Corinthians 13, that would be a serious problem.

Another example: the church fathers have long said that it is not the lack of baptism that damns, but the despising of baptism. God does not absolutely require baptism for entrance to heaven. A man who desired baptism and died on the way to church will not be denied entry for lack of baptism. But on the other hand, the man who rejects and despises the gift of baptism in advance is in serious peril and may well be denied entrance to heaven unless he repents.

Likewise, we do not require laymen to have read the whole Book of Concord prior to receiving them as members. But a layman who has read it and rejects it will probably be denied membership. To become a Lutheran means to sit under the teaching of your Lutheran pastor for the rest of your life as he teaches the doctrine of Scripture according to its exposition in the Book of Concord. If a man rejects that exposition in advance, then why on earth does he want to be a Lutheran?

Lutheran laymen absolutely do not have blanket permission to disagree with the doctrine confessed in the Book of Concord.


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Worship Trying to learn organ, need pointers

7 Upvotes

I have been trying to learn organ recently, starting with only music knowledge I’ve carried from being a percussionist who never learned music theory. How much music theory do I need to learn, and how much experience on organ or piano should I get before seeking out lessons?


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Theology Can someone explain TEC Eucharist view versus LCMS

3 Upvotes

Isn’t the lutheran view spiritual at the end of the day too if we reject local inclusion? if there isn’t local inclusion how can it be physical? to me it seems that the only difference is that the Anglicans say His Spirit is present and the Lutherans say His body is present but spiritually, which kind of seem the same


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Doctrine Biblical Devotions with American Lutheran Theological Seminary. “Seventy-Five Pounds of Gold.” (Mt 25:14–30.)

3 Upvotes

URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nxtfLZCtmw

Gospel According to Matthew, 25:14–30 (ESV):

The Parable of the Talents

“For it will be like a man going on a journey, who called his servants and entrusted to them his property. To one he gave five talents, to another two, to another one, to each according to his ability. Then he went away. He who had received the five talents went at once and traded with them, and he made five talents more. So also he who had the two talents made two talents more. But he who had received the one talent went and dug in the ground and hid his master’s money. Now after a long time the master of those servants came and settled accounts with them. And he who had received the five talents came forward, bringing five talents more, saying, ‘Master, you delivered to me five talents; here, I have made five talents more.’ His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much. Enter into the joy of your master.’ And he also who had the two talents came forward, saying, ‘Master, you delivered to me two talents; here, I have made two talents more.’ His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much. Enter into the joy of your master.’ He also who had received the one talent came forward, saying, ‘Master, I knew you to be a hard man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you scattered no seed, so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here, you have what is yours.’ But his master answered him, ‘You wicked and slothful servant! You knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I scattered no seed? Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers, and at my coming I should have received what was my own with interest. So take the talent from him and give it to him who has the ten talents. For to everyone who has will more be given, and he will have an abundance. But from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away. And cast the worthless servant into the outer darkness. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’

Transcript

(Original devotional script is original work by ALTS. /u/JustKidding456 is not affiliated with ALTS. ChatGPT was used to polish transcript and find references.)

Hello.

Today, let's talk about 75 pounds of gold. The text before us is the Gospel of St. Matthew, the 25th chapter, verses 14–30.

Introduction: Sadie the Seamstress

The year was 1914.

Sadie Smithson, a Southern girl from a Southern town, wanted to fit in. Her greatest aspiration was to join the Laurel Literary Society. But she was just a seamstress, a country girl, and she thought that they would never accept her into their highfalutin society.

She had an idea. Surely, if she went to Europe, she would be a world traveler, and then they would accept her. So Sadie saved her money, and finally she had enough for her trip.

She traveled to France and Belgium. Then she heard that the war had broken out. She needed to get home. She hired a car to take her straightaway to the airport in Paris. But unexpectedly, she found herself in the middle of a battle. Quite literally, she heard men screaming and bullets flying. There was such bloodshed and pain.

A man came out crying, "Water! Please, water!" What was she going to do?

So Sadie Smithson got out of the car. She spent the entire night, right through until morning, binding wounds, tearing her petticoat, making bandages, writing last wills and testaments, and offering prayers.

When the morning came, the driver returned and said, "What in heaven's name are you still doing here?"

"I've been face to face with death and hell all night," she declared.

When she got on the plane and explained what had happened, another passenger said to her, "I'll bet they'll be glad to have you in that literary society now."

"Literary society," she said. "I've faced death and hell and God. I don't reckon that a literary society matters now. What does matter? Nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks."

You see, Sadie Smithson had been changed by God.

Point One: God Gives His Gifts

In the Gospel lesson for today, our Lord Jesus presents a startling parable. It's called the Parable of the Talents. A talent is not like the ability to sing or to play the piano. A talent is a measure of weight, about 75 pounds. It could be of gold or silver or precious gems. They were measured out by the talent. (Matthew 25:14–15)

A certain master had servants, and he entrusted his possessions to them. He measured out five talents to one, three talents to another, and one talent to the third.

You say, "Only one talent?" Well, 75 pounds of gold is still pretty good, don't you think?

What did the master expect? Well, he had empowered them, and he had expected them to use their weighty treasures. He expected that they would bring results, positive results, because of their energy and their industry. This is exactly what happened with two of the three servants.

The first one was industrious. He took a risk. He made a sacrifice. He invested that treasure. Then something marvelous happened. It multiplied. It expanded. It generated five more talents, five more treasures. (Matthew 25:16)

The next servant had a similar experience. It wasn't easy, but he too was industrious and energetic. He invested his gift. Or what if something went wrong? What if he lost it all? But he was faithful. He was willing to take the risk, to make the sacrifice. Yes, he would allow the gift to leave his hands. He would use it, give it, share it, and look, it multiplied.

It multiplied and expanded. Yes, there were three more measures, three more talents. But one of the servants was of a different spirit.

Listen to him speak to his master. "I knew you to be a hard man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you scattered no seed. I was afraid of you, and I went away and I hid your talent in the ground." (Matthew 25:24–25)

If the master were so miserly and mean, why did he give this man 75 pounds of gold or silver or jewels? He seems quite a trusting fellow to me, giving this servant the opportunity of a lifetime.

The master said to him, "You wicked and lazy slave." Then the master declared, "Take away the talent from him and give it to the one who has ten. Throw out the worthless slave into the outer darkness." (Matthew 25:26–30)

Point Two: Not About Salvation, but About Christian Life

How should we understand this parable of our Lord? What is Jesus teaching us in this parable?

Now, don't be fooled. This story is not about getting into heaven. This is not a parable about salvation. It's not about how people get into heaven or how people get kicked out of heaven.

We know that the gift of salvation, heaven, is a free gift. We do not earn it. It is paid for by the atoning sacrifice of Jesus. We cannot merit it. We cannot add anything to it. Heaven is God's gift of eternal life by grace through faith alone, apart from any works of the law. (Ephesians 2:8–9; Romans 3:28; Augsburg Confession, Article IV)

Furthermore, we do not lose the gift of heaven because of our sin. If that were true, not one of us would ever even enter heaven. No, Jesus is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Thank God for that. (John 1:29)

So this parable is a story about the Christian life. It tells about those who already are saved, those who already have received God's glorious gifts, His wondrous measures of blessings. Well, like forgiveness of sins, indwelling of the Holy Spirit, faith in Jesus, and many more gifts from the hand of a gracious heavenly Father.

Like you and me, these servants received unmerited talents of precious gifts. Their master empowered and expected that they would go do marvelous things with great gifts that they had received. Two servants did just that. With industry and energy, they risked and sacrificed. They used and shared their gifts. (Augsburg Confession, Article VI)

But one servant would share nothing. Can you believe it? Instead, he buried the heavy weight of treasure that had been entrusted to him.

Was he God's child? Well, yes. Was he given a great gift? Yes. But did he disappoint his master? Absolutely. And did he weep because of his own selfishness? Yes, indeed. I am sure he did.

Conclusion

The year was 1914, and Sadie Smithson, a Southern girl from a Southern town, wanted to fit in. Her greatest aspiration was to join the Laurel Literary Society. But she was just a seamstress, a country girl, and she thought that they would never accept her in their highfalutin society.

But she had an idea. Surely, if she went to Europe, then she would be a world traveler, and they would accept her then. So she traveled to France and got to Belgium, and she heard that the war had broken out, and she needed to get home.

She hired a car to take her straightaway to the airport in Paris. But unexpectedly, she found herself in the middle of a battle. Quite literally, she heard men screaming and bullets flying. There was such bloodshed and pain.

A man cried out, "Water! Please, water!" What was she to do?

So Sadie Smithson got out of her car. She spent the entire night, right through until morning, binding wounds, tearing her petticoat, making bandages, writing last wills and testaments, and offering prayers.

When the morning came, the driver returned and said, "What in heaven's name are you doing here?"

"I have been face to face with death and hell all night," she declared.

When she got on the plane and explained what had happened, another passenger said, "I'll bet they'll be glad to have you in the literary society now."

"Literary society," she said. "I have faced death and hell and God. I don't reckon that a literary society matters now. But what does matter? Nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks."

You see, Sadie Smithson had been changed by God.

Was this odd or strange? No, I don't think so. This is what God has both empowered and expected of each and all of His holy children.

God has invaded our hearts. He's made us new creations. He's translated us out of the kingdom of darkness into the kingdom of His glorious light. And now there is nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks. (2 Corinthians 5:17; Colossians 1:13)

Beloved, it is not just a Southern seamstress whose life was changed and whose heart was bursting with love for others. It is your heart that was changed too.

God has given you great treasures, heavy measures of His blessings, forgiveness of sins, indwelling of the Holy Spirit, faith in Jesus, and many, many more gifts from the hand of a gracious and loving heavenly Father.

So with a full heart, you child of God, use your energy and your industry. You risk and sacrifice. You share your great treasures.

Then do you know what God will do? He will use you. He will use your precious gifts. He will multiply and bless them beyond your expectation for your good and for His great glory.

Yes, even sharing a cup of water with one of these little ones will bring Him delight. (Matthew 10:42)

And your heavenly Father will say, "Well done, good and faithful servant." (Matthew 25:21)

That's you. You are a child of God.

Amen.


r/LCMS • • 7d ago

Question is it generally allowed for a woman to be in a positino of leadership e.g. church council, youth org?

7 Upvotes