r/LSAT • u/Possible_Direction21 • 1d ago
Lsat Parallel Question
Can someone help me understand the logic behind E (the correct answer)? Also why the other ones are incorrect? Thank you!
8
Upvotes
7
u/Low_Energy_9693 1d ago
The stimulus’s argument essentially takes the following form: Before X(a major earthquake), Y(minor tremors) happened. Since Y recently happened, X WILL (or must) happen.
AC A can be immediately eliminated since the conclusion is arguing that something will NOT happen.
AC C can be eliminated since it’s not asserting that anything WILL happen.
AC B and D are tempting trap answer choices. However the key to eliminating them is to note the strength between the relationship they’re asserting.
In the stimulus, it just says that Y precedes X. AC B and D essentially say that when Y happens, X ALWAYS happens. In B, the river has always overflowed when Y happens, and in D there is always the extinction of a native species.
It’s a much stronger assertion than just: Y happened before X, so since Y happened, X must also happen.
That weaker causal reasoning is mirrored by AC E.
Hope this helps!
2
u/Waterloowalrus 1d ago
The prompt says “we see minor tremors before all earthquake, so since we see tremors, there will be earthquakes“ but that is confusing what we could conclude from that. Loosely, tremors appear to be a necessary condition—earthquakes don’t happen unless there are major tremors before. But, then, the conclusion treats it as sufficient—whenever you see minor tremors, you’ll have an earthquake afterwards. But, that’s not right. what you COULD take from the evidence/statement is that “if there have been no minor tremors, then there probably won’t be an earthquake.
So, you want to find something that makes that same mistake: A happens before B so if we see A then B will happen.
One thing to pay attention to is that this logic is flawed so you can eliminate any answers that are not actually flawed even if they feel like they might kind of have the same shape.
A) Makes a necessary/sufficient mistake but it makes the opposite one. It says a tropical storm is sufficient to know a hurricane is coming but then the conclusion treats it like it is necessary—saying without a storm you can’t have a hurricane, but you can’t conclude that from the statement.
B) is basically good logic so it can’t be right: when this happens, that happens and so since this is happening, that will happen
C) is fairly similar to answer B: one thing indicates that something happened, so seeing that thing means the other thing happened. basically solid logic (there are quibbles but it has the shape of decent logic—wrong answer)
D) is almost exactly the same as B and is 100 right with no quibbling
E) makes the same mistake as the prompt: outbreaks of disease (earthquakes) have always happened after high infection rates (minor tremors) so since we see high infection rates (minor tremors) there will be an outbreak (earthquake)