r/LSAT • u/graeme_b tutor (LSATHacks) • 12h ago
What do people think should be the policy for post test discussion threads?
Edit: I would like to clarify something. If we made a "no threads!" rule, it would probably be possible to enforce. The bigger challenge is monitoring threads to see "are they discussing specific questions or topics or not"
So the question I'm asking is whether we should aggressively cull the post test threads. There is moderation work either way, I'm not sure this would be any harder than what we're doing currently. Only question is what's best for the sub day to day during and post testing.
So a few things happen after every test:
- People get an intense desire to make threads discussing the test and their experience
- The testing is draining, people feel bad as a result, which leads them to feel that they did badly (not valid), then they freak out and post a lot of "omg hardest test ever and totally different!!", which makes some people avoid the sub entirely
Until now, the policy has roughly been to make a discussion thread, and then make a topic thread at the end of testing in order to give people some closure and reduce the demand for discussion (which often strays into specific answers).
My question is, should we do more? Such as, for example, removing all post test threads and directing people to a single discussion thread?
This would be a bit of big step, as it is clearly the thing people want to do, visits to the sub spike during testing for discussion. But, I wanted to check what people think in general about how these threads should be handled.
A middle position would be removing threads after testing is done, but not during. A separate question is how possible it would be to remove threads, as there are so so many, but that can be worked out once a direction is set.
So what does everyone think? Please comment and let us know.
3
u/voyagermarionette 12h ago
There are a lot of repetitive questions and themes regardless. Either its that someone did the test and didn't feel good, or, less common, they did the test and did extremely good, or they ask "where should I start" like they don't have access to google. Since there is so rarely in depth discussion about anything that isn't repetitive, I'm not sure there's much of a point for mods to put in the work to police something like that
2
u/Cass2297 11h ago
The low effort ones like :
Rc lr rc lr
xxx question killed me.
I mean... those can be in a thread.
Also people posting section orders only and expecting feedback is wild. Section orders don't mean anything these days. You could have more in common between a rc lr lr lr test and a rc lr rc lr test than either with their identical section order match. But I digress.
Ultimately, I agree that it doesn't make sense to expand that effort.
2
u/Betpossums 9h ago
I'm not sure that any extra effort you put in will be worth it. You already pin the discussion threads and there's enough signposting that they exist, but it doesn't stop people posting just "LR RC LR LR"; something that's already been discussed to death; or generic things which lead to no discussion.
I don't think your efforts would be well spent when people don't read or take note of the discussions that are already going on.