I think LSU's problems are much deeper, institutionally and culturally, than any individual players or the coaching staff, and I'm not convinced Lane Kiffin is the person to fix it.
What I see when I watch this team is a collection of talented individuals who don't seem particularly interested in functioning as a cohesive unit. There's a tremendous amount of individual talent, but very little identity, consistency, discipline, or collective accountability. It looks like everyone is playing their own game rather than for the team.
This problem didn't start with Kiffin. LSU has struggled for several years now. Changing coaches, bringing in highly rated recruits, acquiring transfer portal talent, and generating enormous offseason hype hasn't fundamentally changed what we're seeing on the field. At some point, we have to acknowledge that the problem extends beyond the players and individual coaching decisions.
I think college football has increasingly become obsessed with recruiting rankings, NIL valuations, transfer portal acquisitions, individual exposure, and personal stats. Those things might help assemble a talented roster, but they don't build a football team. I think what we are seeing is LSU becoming an organization where individual players become more invested in their personal brands and professional prospects than in the collective success of the organization. I think that starts with the coach.
He can obviously assemble a talented roster and is a successful recruiter. But being able to build a talented roster is different from being able to build a locker room of talented, confident, and sometimes entitled young athletes and turn them into a disciplined, unified team.
I'm not in the locker room, so I don't know, but I get the sense that playing at LSU doesn't mean anything to this team. It just happens to be the team they're at. LSU doesn't need another offseason recruiting victory or another highly publicized coaching hire. It needs someone who can establish a genuine identity and make players understand that representing LSU comes with responsibilities and expectations. Someone who can make players take pride in their teammates, their coaches, their university, and the program's legacy. Accountability should mean something here. Doing your job should matter more than getting recognition. Players should take pride in doing the unglamorous things that contribute to winning. Nobody is bigger than the team, regardless of their recruiting ranking, NIL valuation, or NFL prospects.
I don't know whether Kiffin can build that kind of culture. His history and public persona don't necessarily inspire confidence that he's the person to walk into an already struggling program and fundamentally change its culture. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe he needs time to get his players and establish his system. But I think LSU's problems are much deeper than a coaching transition or a bad season. LSU needs to stop trying to assemble a championship roster and assemble a championship organization. That doesn't come from maximizing Cane's commercials and advertising sales.