So I currently live outside of Pittsburgh, in an area that's affordable. I pay 775/ mo with no utilities included. I've been on month to month for 2 years, once my original lease ended. I have always paid on time, taken care of utilities directly, and taken good care of my space. In the last year, our building was bought by a new owner. I received an email 3 days ago on November 17th, offering a new year long lease, with rent increasing to 895/mo, beginning on December 1st. Still no utilities included. I sent a counter offer for 835/mo (leaving room for a possible compromise up to 850/mo-- hopefully).
My question is, is it even legal to raise the rent without 30 days notice, as specified in my old lease that they took over? It's even less than the 15 days statutory statewide standard. Unless i voluntarily sign, it's my understanding that this is not, in fact, legal. And forcing me to do so under the duress of having to move out over Christmas should i not agree to December, seems wrong as well. The new lease should begin in January in that case.
What would your response to the counter offer be? Would you take 850/mo instead to hold onto a good tenant and not have to worry about repairs, renovations, and turnover? Or run the risk of having a bad tenant that doesn't pay on time? They would need to do some work, as the carpets were not changed when we moved in, or before my mom moved in 7 years ago (we took over the apartment from her 3 years ago) or before the previous tenant nearly 15 years ago. The walls would need repainted, and various things the old owner never fixed would need worked on as well.
What would you do to hold onto a tenant like me? And to not spend winter with an empty unit, doing renovations? I'd love to hear your opinions and other point of view.