r/LeftCatholicism • u/Budget_Antelope • 11h ago
On anthropocentrism within the Catholic community
A major criticism, whether in good faith or not, of Catholicism and much of Christianity I have observed, is that it is very anthropocentric, and that it has lead to people interpreting and weaponizing the faith to justify the overexploitation of the natural world.
Genesis 1:28 and a lot of Revelations has been used to justify Lassiez-faire capitalism (granted the latter is more often used by certain evangelical Protestants to explain why human caused climate change is a good thing and usually works in tandem with twisted prosperity gospel schlock).
There is something to be said about the amount of flack Popes have gotten for speaking out against unchecked destruction of the environment from both non-catholics and more “traditional” Catholics.
Also, the following may be a bit of a “grass is greener on the other side” thing, but I have a hunch that this is partially because the environment and the unknowns of nature is too often associated with paganism.
On one hand, I really loathe the whole notion of “old gods and the new gods” drivel that gets pedaled by both certain Christians and certain pagans, with the Christians saying that the “old gods” are primitive, savage and and evil and must be destroyed to save our souls from damnation, which often manifests as the desire to get rid of flora and fauna (See st. Boniface) as well as ignoring our history of acculturation in favor of strict conformity to whatever they deem appropriate. With certain pagans, you have them claiming we’re a death cult that hates nature and/or worships the idea of human supremacy. Worse still are those who have these beliefs while also adding in the ridiculous “ChRiStIaNS wOrshiP DA JOOS” crap I seen quite a few peddle.
On the other hand, as much as it burns my throat to admit it, Christianity lacks a lot of that primordial vibe by virtue of being a relatively new religion in the grand scheme of things. I won’t lie when I say that I envy some of the aura that those ancient megaliths found in forests and grasslands have, such as the dragon stones from armenia, the Pictish stones In Scotland, the Germanic rune stones or the Maya stelae. I Just kind of wished there was more of a history of including the rest of Christ’ creations in our devotional art and architecture.
I do think that there is a lack of appreciation of nature and non human life. I’m not saying that there isn’t, there most certainly is, as evidenced by figures like St. Francis of Assisi, St. Hubert of Liege, and Celtic Catholicism as a whole, what with their sacred natural springs and the like. Not to mention figures like St. Elijah being associated with storms and lightning, as well as St. Martin heralding the arrival of winter in certain Slavic traditions. However, with a lot of these, they so often attribute these forces of nature to human saints. It’s not necessarily that I think it’s wrong to do this, We’ve certainly got Livestock, doves, fish, eagles, human babies with wings, and lions down pat, and I *could* be convinced that’s all we need (as an aside, I really wish lions were still alive in Eurasia and the Americas partially because I think it would have helped the Lion-Jesus symbolism). We have a pretty good precedent of cultures converting to Christianity using Christian symbolism alongside creatures only to watch the creatures become lost to time, which I think is kinda sad because it is a disservice to the diversity of the children of God, and that unity doesn’t equal uniformity and conformity. Obviously there should be some ground rules so we don’t go heretical or Christo-pagan, but a little variety shouldn’t have been as big of a problem as it was in our history. Once again, I don’t think it would have hurt if there were more varieties of non humanoids in devotional art.
Maybe I’m taking out of my backside, and I apologize if that is the case, but I do think that we should talk more about anthropocentrism in our communities
God Bless, comrades.