r/LegaciesCW • u/KoalaPure2652 • 17h ago
Question Why is burning down the Red Oak tree even a debate??
Am I the only one who finds this whole discussion completely ridiculous? Everyone is acting like destroying the only thing that can kill Hope is somehow "saving" her, when in reality it sounds like an absolute nightmare. Think about what happens if they actually burn that tree to the ground: true immortality with zero loopholes isn't a gift, it's a curse. It means watching every single person she loves grow old and die while she's stuck on Earth forever.
Taking that choice away from Hope isn't protecting her, it's trapping her. If she wants to keep the wood safe from enemies, she can easily make a single stake and lock it in a vault only she knows about. Burning the tree completely just sentences her to an eternity of grief with no exit strategy, and honestly, it shouldn't even be a question.