r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

whyblt? What Have You Been Listening To? - Week of November 16, 2026

7 Upvotes

Each week a WHYBLT? thread will be posted, where we can talk about what music we’ve been listening to. The recommended format is as follows.

Band/Album Name: A description of the band/album and what you find enjoyable/interesting/terrible/whatever about them/it. Try to really show what they’re about, what their sound is like, what artists they are influenced by/have influenced or some other means of describing their music.

Artist Name – Song Name If you’d like to give a short description of the song then feel free

PLEASE INCLUDE YOUTUBE, SOUNDCLOUD, SPOTIFY, ETC LINKS! Recommendations for similar artists are preferable too.

This thread is meant to encourage sharing of music and promote discussion about artists. Any post that just puts up a youtube link or says “I've been listening to Radiohead; they are my favorite band.” will be removed. Make an effort to really talk about what you’ve been listening to. Self-promotion is also not allowed.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 2d ago

general General Discussion, Suggestion, & List Thread - Week of November 19, 2026

3 Upvotes

Talk about whatever you want here, music related or not! Go ahead and ask for recommendations, make personal list (AOTY, Best [X] Albums of All Time, etc.)

Most of the usual subreddit rules for comments won't be enforced here, apart from two: No self-promotion and Don't be a dick.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 1h ago

How do you actually find and support independent artists in 2026, and does any of it feel like it works?

6 Upvotes

Streaming payouts to smaller artists are famously tiny, and most of the advice for fans who want to support them comes down to "buy merch, go to gigs, use Bandcamp". But I'm curious how people here actually do it in practice.

  • Where do you genuinely discover new independent artists now? Word of mouth, music magazines, algorithmic playlists, radio, blogs, friends, live support slots, something else?
  • Has anything changed how you engage with smaller artists in the last few years, for better or worse?

For me, I've found a few music journalists on TikTok / Instagram as good guides for finding new bands, along with who's touring with the indie acts I like. Interested to hear whether that matches other people's experience, or whether I'm missing something obvious.

There's a very active independent scene here (Ireland) and I find the support the acts show to each other make it very helpful to find new acts.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 1d ago

Why do so many older songs sexualize little girls and teenage girls?

148 Upvotes

At my job, we play mostly older music, particularly music from the 1950s through the 1980s, and I’ve started noticing a pattern.
So many songs seem to reference little girls, younger sisters, schoolgirls, or underage girls in explicitly romantic or sexual ways.
For example, Elvis Presley’s “Little Sister,” Gary Puckett’s “Young Girl,” and The Rolling Stones’ “Stray Cat Blues.”
I’ve noticed this enough that it feels like a recurring theme rather than a handful of isolated songs. I’m not sure if it’s just the music the business owner chooses to play, but it’s almost EVERY SONG.
Was this simply more socially acceptable at the time? Was there a particular cultural reason that so many male artists wrote songs sexualizing teenage girls or emphasizing how young and innocent they were?
I’m curious whether other people have noticed this and what the historical context behind it is.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 7h ago

When punk and post-punk declined in the late 80s, why did grunge rise in the US and britpop in the UK

0 Upvotes

Obviously both still drew influences from punk. Listening to britpop I can pick jangle + baggy as well as new wave in the sound blueprint (Beatles too but that's pretty much ubiquitous to most bands). Grunge on the other hand seemed to be influenced by earlier/"classic" punk ethos. The Velvet Underground, Iggy, Sex Pistols, Patti, etc. This forking is very fascinating to me, as someone who prefers one over the other lol


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 7h ago

Is Joy Division really all that and a bag of chips?

0 Upvotes

So my mom dropped by (as they do) and I happened to be listening to Still in the background (Exercise One and Twenty Four Hours being a couple all time favs). At one point she paused, listened to what had been playing behind her for a few moments and asked who it was. I said Joy Division to which she looked surprised and said "This is what all the hubbub is about?"

It got me thinking about what it is I ACTUALLY enjoy about JD, what they may NOT be, how normies would hear JD for the first time and what can we actually point to that justifies the pedestal we put them on?

Joy Division is an odd duck in the goth/post punk scene. Their fans hold a quiet superiority complex even among other goths, like they know something others don't. It's not difficult music, the vocals are not the best trained and you wouldn't think that a band that only used gray #1, gray #2 and gray #3 as their entire color palette (and wardrobe) would attract so much attention. But they do! Why?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 12h ago

Why cant songwriters get as popular as singers/performers

0 Upvotes

I mean it feels kinda unfair that someone could put in alot of their work for coming up with and making a song then the performer gets all the credit for it (in common discussion) i dont want to insult any singer, singers are great its just its kinda unfair for both to be talked about for something you didnt exactly do, like say an artist like i dont know just an artist overall to not ruffle feathers, releases a song, their voice is almost the same as their voice in most songs and the singing is pretty expected, but the song productionwise and composition and lyricswise are all amazing and its hailed as a masterpiece, do they deserve the credit for it? if elvis presley didnt write his songs then is he really the king?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 1d ago

The production on Daft Punk's Discovery: deliberate aesthetic or disappointing sound quality?

0 Upvotes

Ok, not here to slaughter any sacred cows, but I need to get this off my chest. I've always found Daft Punk's Discovery to sound flat, tinny and muddy. I know, I know, it's a classic, how dare you, yadda yadda yadda.

Admittedly, I was a Homework fan, so Discovery was quite the surprise. I didn't mind the change in direction, and I've enjoyed plenty of their other forays into the unfamiliar.

I've just always found the sound quality of this album really disappointing. The instruments are so muddy and poorly defined. For a group who made some incredible sounding albums, it feels incomplete.

And no, I'm not some audiophile launching Audacity and figuring out the sonic blah blah blah. I don't obsess over pressings, masters or any of that stuff. Whenever I put this CD on, it just sounds dull and flat.

To me, it's always sounded like a recording of a recording. The individual elements all bleed into one another and there's just no clarity.

It just doesn't compute that this is one of the most celebrated electronic albums of all time. The music itself is wonderful, but I can't help thinking it could sound so much better if I could actually distinguish all the elements within it.

A while ago, I read about Daft Punk intentionally using compression, sampling and distortion, so maybe this is exactly what they were going for. To my ears, though, it's their worst sounding album.

For a while I even wondered if I had a counterfeit CD or some dodgy pressing, but from what I've read, this seems to be part of the album's sound rather than something peculiar to my copy.

So that's what I'm interested in discussing. Is this dense, compressed sound an essential part of Discovery's character? At what point does a deliberate production aesthetic become a limitation on the listening experience?

I'm genuinely interested in hearing the case for the production, because after all these years, I still struggle with it even though I love DP and want to live this album.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 2d ago

Do you think it's becoming increasingly hard to "break the canon"?

2 Upvotes

I'm not only talking about modern performers but also about artists of the past whose place seem to be cemented in the mass unconciosness.

Sometimes I think there's so much resistance to the possibility for some records or even genres of the past get a little more recognition. I understand that some of the pushback comes from a notion of how good and generally robust the agreed musical pantheon is and also from obvious obscurity of some of the music genres and styles but still I keep noticing some irregularities when it comes to the judgement and reassessment of the past. There're still times when I just can't simply dismiss my own perception as my own personal bias.

The obvious trigger would be the so called death of the monoculture but what's interesting is that the memory of "the grand narrative" still lives on.

I don't want to give any examples, I'm sure everybody has a couple. I'm just curious when and why do you think did this cutoff happen?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 1d ago

Why Does Rock Struggle So Much to Produce Major Mainstream Hits?

0 Upvotes

The genre is still very much alive, with new bands emerging, independent scenes thriving, and an enormous diversity of subgenres. Yet it's becoming increasingly rare for bands to release songs that break out of their own niche and reach a mainstream audience.

There have been more recent successes, such as Twenty One Pilots, Måneskin and Olivia Rodrigo with good 4 u. However, I've noticed that many of these artists work with hybrid sounds, bringing rock closer to pop, hip-hop, and electronic music. Sometimes, it feels like blending genres has become the only way for rock-influenced music to reach a mainstream audience.

Even in these cases, the chart positions are worth looking at. Linkin Park's The Emptiness Machine peaked at No. 21 on the Billboard Hot 100, while Måneskin's Beggin', a cover song, reached No. 13. Those are certainly significant achievements, but it seems that songs directly associated with rock still struggle to reach the upper positions on the charts.

I also don't think this is simply a matter of investment. Rap, trap, and pop artists often manage to build their audiences online before receiving any major industry backing. In that sense, I feel like rock still shows a certain dependence on traditional industry structures, while other genres seem to have developed more organic ways of reaching new listeners.

Another factor is how bands interact with their audiences. Many focus their efforts on local scenes, specialized festivals, and communities that already follow their work. That's important for keeping the culture alive, but I wonder whether this focus also limits the genre's ability to expand. I miss seeing more efforts to reach people who aren't already part of these circles.

Social media is another part of the discussion. Other genres seem much better at making use of short-form videos, trends, and different promotional strategies. I get the impression that newer rock bands struggle to turn their digital presence into mainstream reach.

Personally, I don't particularly miss having huge rock hits. I prefer exploring albums, sounds, and productions that are far removed from the mainstream. Part of me, the more trve side, even enjoys that distance. But another part finds it curious that a genre with so much diversity and so many active scenes has such a hard time producing even a single Top 10 hit every three or four years.

Sometimes, it honestly feels like musicians just aren't hitting the mark anymore when it comes to writing songs with that kind of mainstream appeal. It's been a long time since we've seen songs like Sweet Child O' Mine, Smells Like Teen Spirit, or even In the End emerge. I'm talking about that kind of massive success: songs with a distinct identity, broad appeal, and enough impact to break far beyond the rock bubble.

I'm not expecting rock to dominate the charts again. I'm simply curious about the growing gap between the vitality of today's rock scenes and their difficulty in turning all that creative output into mainstream phenomena.

What do you think is behind this?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 3d ago

Some albums only make sense after midnight. What actually makes a record a late night record?

19 Upvotes

been thinking about this since a friend asked why i only play certain albums after midnight. i don't think it's tempo. plenty of slow records feel wrong at 2am and some faster ones feel right.

for me it's space. records where you can hear the room, where the voice is close and quiet and doesn't try to fill every second. sade's love deluxe does that, there's so much air around her voice. burial's untrue sounds like a night bus with rain on the window. ahmad jamal at the pershing has glasses clinking and people half listening, and somehow that makes it feel later than it is. portishead's third is colder, but it has the same feeling of being awake when everyone else isn't.

so what is it for you? is it the sound itself, or when and where you first heard it?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 2d ago

anyone else feel weirdly uncomfortable comparing the lyrics to "her" by zvc and the boy version?

0 Upvotes

i know these songs are supposed to be super wholesome and sweet and everyone in the comments is crying over them, so maybe i'm overthinking it, idk. whenever these pop up on my fyp or youtube, all the top comments are just people talking about how emotional it makes them and how great of a dad he is. he is, but..

listening to both versions of "her" by jvke and zvc side by side actually gave me the ick once i really paid attention to what he's saying.

in the original daughter version, the big emotional climax of his verse is:
"take care of you til you walk down that aisle / they'll see the beautiful woman you'll become"

and then when he dropped the boy version, he changed those exact lines to:
"take care of you til you're stronger than i am / they'll see the strong handsome man you've become"

like... when you put them right next to each other, the difference is so glaring?? why is the girl's whole life milestone getting married and basically being handed off from one man (her dad) to another man (a husband)(or woman or etc but the marriage point remains), while the boy's milestone is becoming strong, capable, and independent??

Like no cap but my first thought while hearing ts was "what if she doesn't want to marry anyone?"

and on top of that, look at the adjectives he uses. the daughter is just a "beautiful woman"—so her main defining trait as an adult is literally just how she looks. meanwhile the son gets to be a "strong, handsome man." he gets both physical capability and good looks, while she just gets beauty and a wedding day.

to be clear, i'm not saying zvc is a bad dad or hates women or anything dramatic like that. it obviously comes from a genuinely loving, protective place, and i don't think he wrote it with malicious intent at all. it's just crazy how normalized benevolent sexism is in pop music and so deeply ingrained in our minds that we don't realize these small things. even in 2026, without even realizing it, some people are still pushing this subtle narrative where girls are fragile and their ultimate goal is a wedding and needing a man to take care of them, while boys get raised to stand on their own two feet.

i tried looking around on tiktok and youtube to see if any feminist creators or sociologists had made a video breaking down the two versions, and literally nobody is talking about it. everyone just eats it up as pure wholesomeness.

has anyone else noticed this or am i just taking crazy pills looking at the comment sections lol


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 3d ago

How to search for really old ,,niche’’ music

4 Upvotes

Hello, I am searching for music spanning from the 1950s-1980s, but I want to find something that wasn’t playing a lot on radio back in the day
Like independent music taste people had
I am looking for genres of songs that have a truly deep and mature tone and storytelling to them, ones that ,,hit’’, but aren’t especially sad, although they show slices of it
I really don’t know if you know what I mean
I mean any way of finding those old songs is good, I can work my ways with it.
Appreciate the help.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 2d ago

Which decade really had the best Top 40 music — the ’70s, ’80s, or ’90s

0 Upvotes

It's interesting how much popular music changed across just three decades.

The '70s brought disco, classic rock, and soul into the mainstream. The '80s saw the explosion of synth-pop, new wave, and MTV. By the '90s, hip-hop, alternative rock, and R&B were reshaping the charts.

What's even more interesting is looking beyond the biggest hits and seeing which songs actually dominated the charts, which artists crossed genres, and which forgotten tracks were once everywhere.

We've been digging into this history while putting together our Across the Charts collection, which documents Top 40 hits from all three decades using chart data from multiple music publications.

It's been fascinating seeing just how different each era really was.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 4d ago

How popular were Bomfunk MC's in US?

10 Upvotes

Bomfunk MC's had absolutely huge success in Europe in 1999-2000 with their Freestyler, B-Boys & Fly-Girls and Uprocking Beats which kind of reintroduced oldstyle hip-hop from the early 1980's and melted it with elements of drum&bass and house music. Everyone still knows these songs. But at least here in Russia not everybody knew at the time that these guys were from Finland, I mean, the most unlikely country to produce rap. We assumed all rap came from the US. Now I look at the charts of the time and it seems their success was kind of limited to Europe. Is it true? How did Americans receive their music? Was it even known there at the time?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 4d ago

Session players becoming solo artists: when does it work and when doesn’t it?

4 Upvotes

Been thinking about this with Venna. He’s a London sax player who’s played on records for Burna Boy, Beyoncé, Kali Uchis and Wizkid, and he was mentored by Yussef Dayes. He’s now releasing his own music and has started singing on it. His new single Lo Life with Odeal is the clearest example of that switch.

Some session players make the jump and find their own identity (Thundercat, Kamasi Washington). Others never quite step out of being “the guy who played on X”.

What do you think makes the difference? Is it the songwriting, the voice, having a clear identity outside the instrument? Curious who people think did it best.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 4d ago

Musical Fulcrum Points..

7 Upvotes

My friend and I were listening to Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band by The Beaties, and my friend mentioned that while Sgt. Peppers was seemingly noone's favorite Beatles album, the closing track, A Day In The Life, was the most important song in their catalog. That it was a fulcrum point or Apex..everything they had recorded up to that point led to A Day In The Life..and everything they recorded after ultimately led to the bands demise or downfall.

Was an interesting theory that I thought Id share, but Im also curious as to other artists identifiable fulcrum points?

Thoughts or opinions?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 4d ago

What hidden sounds and background details did you notice when we started listening to music through high-quality headphones?

7 Upvotes

You know, you’ve been listening to these songs for a long time and know them really well, but when you first started listening to them straight into your brain, holy shit, there are so many details, breathing and very distant words that you never picked up on before!

But sometimes I hear… “saliva sounds,” which is natural, but still, now I notice things like that. And surprisingly, there are hidden details even in old recordings, where I didn’t expect good quality.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

Sonic Youth’s Teen Age Riot: heartland rock in thin disguise?

35 Upvotes

I’ve had a realization about "Teen Age Riot" that completely changed how I hear the track and really the band’s whole ethos in general, especially coming at it as someone who held off on diving into Sonic Youth for a long time.

Stripped of the alternate tunings (Thurston's G-G-D-D-G-G setup), the dissonance, and the feedback, the main hook of ‘Teen Age Riot’ might be the single best rock hook since Bruce Springsteen's ‘Born to Run.’

It sounds wild on paper given the two totally different sonic worlds, but the underlying DNA, ethos, and emotional architecture are almost identical:

1. The setup and delayed gratification. Both songs rely on slow-burn tension before the explosion. Passing through Kim Gordon’s hazy, hypnotic intro ("You're it...") makes that soaring, ringing guitar break at 1:25 deliver a rush of pure dopamine, much like the opening build of ‘Born to Run.’

2. The widescreen resonance. Thanks to those custom open tunings, the ringing secondary strings give the riff a sparkling, chiming quality that feels endless: filling the exact same atmospheric space that the glockenspiel and Wall of Sound give to Springsteen.

3. The heartland myth-making in alt-rock dress. Where Springsteen wrote anthems for Jersey kids staring down the turnpike waiting to escape, Sonic Youth wrote an anthem for indie kids in dark bedrooms staring at fanzines, waiting for a cultural messiah ("Miss America”); it substitutes the Jersey shore for the 80s underground, but the yearning for community and liberation is the same.

4. The unapologetic earnestness. For a band defined by New York art-punk cool and ironic detachment, ‘Teen Age Riot’ is a remarkably uplifting and earnest song. It wears its heart on its sleeve, celebrating the pure, transformative power of dreams and rock 'n' roll.

When you look past the song’s noise-rock exterior, it’s fundamentally an anthemic, soaring, and deeply optimistic piece of widescreen American rock.

But what do y’all think?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

New sounds and technology

10 Upvotes

Do you guys think that we are going to get new sounds?

So if you look at the history of music particularly pop music post the 50s, new sounds and new genres tend to get created because of new technology.

For example electric guitars led to rhythm blues to rock and roll, drum machines and electric keyboards in the 80s led to that classic 80s synth pop sound. Sampling machines gave us hip hop and then house genres etc.., I could go on

We had fresh genres back in the day because music technology was progressing fast. Now that we have Digital work stations and any sound can be created, it seems like the constraints of technology that we had in the past, kept musicians in a box which led to distinctive sounds

Now that the Pandora's box has been opened, it's harder to grasp at genres particularly when musicians can create any sound and they are pulling inspirations from multiple genres and sounds. And ofcourse with the internet breaking the boundaries of geography and essentially killing monoculture.

Or I could be wrong, I am living in today's time and it's harder to see the movements and trends that you are in when you are living it, maybe in 20 years time 2026 will belong to a distinctive that we currently can't see right now

And of course I don't want to reduce this argument to just technology, I understand new music genres can get created from more than technology. Eg, immigration, media, responses to other music genres and other cultural phenomenons. But technology does play a big part.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

What do you think of tribute albums?

14 Upvotes

I have been listening to the new 20th Century Paddy - the songs of Shane McGowan for the past few days. It is good. There is a huge range of popular artists and some unknowns doing songs that I haven’t listened to in years. Still, none of the songs surpass the originals for me.

A few years back I got into the Frightened Rabbit tribute for a while but have stopped listening to it. Again, there were some interesting covers, but none moved me like the originals.

Do any of these tribute albums have merit? Or are they just a commercialized means to extract more from an artist’s legacy?


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

Genres and how they are coined

1 Upvotes

Hello folks! As many others of you I enjoy Rate Your Music. I'm using the platform since many years and still discover new music this way. Recently I've seen that lots of albums are tagged with new genres. "Hauntology", "Pigfuck" or "Positive Punk" weren't there ten years ago. This made me think. How do genre terms come into the world? Who has the power to coin them? And in what sphere or way? Tbh I see some developments a bit critical. Regarding RYM I can't get rid of the feeling that it sometimes works as a bubble of self proclaimed experts who embrace a certain kind of nerd culture and who like to show and practice their expertise in the realms of language (and as a user myself I definitely take part in this). "Hauntology" for example is of course a valid term. But it has this high culture ring to it and the association with critique of capitalism that comes with i just sits wrong with me. Don't get me wrong, Mark Fisher was an amazing thinker, but I think when we use his terminology in retrospect we say more about ourselves than about the music. That being said: I see that there is some sense in all of this. The feeling of Hauntology can definitely be used to describe music and the atmosphere it creates. "Positive Punk" was used in the press in the 1980s. And I guess "Pigfuck" has an origin as well. Furthermore all of this is not a new phenomena. "Rhythm and Blues" has been highly criticized in the past and when Discogs once described Alice Coltrane as "Ambient Jazz" some people were critical about that as well. But internet culture gave this a new shift I think. It's super hard to analyze though because we can't point the internet on the map and its users are impossible to describe as a homogenous group. But yeah, enough for the start. What are your thoughts on this? Would love to get some input.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 7d ago

The strange backstory and rhythm of Lambada/Llorando se fue

17 Upvotes

I remember when On the Floor by Jennifer Lopez and Pitbull came out in 2011. I was in high school and would walk around smugly, looking down on the other kids, thinking, "These idiots don't realise that it's a rip-off of Lambada by Kaoma." However, I was later humbled when I looked into the full history of the song and learned that Lambada by Kaoma was itself a plagiarism of an earlier song and was actually sued by the original writers.

The Story

Lambada by Kaoma came out in 1989 and became a massive global hit. However, it was not the first song to use the iconic melody. It was not even the first cover of the original song. In fact, it was not even the first cover of the song in the lambada style!

The story goes back to 1981. The song started not as the bouncy Brazilian dance number most people know, but as a somewhat melancholic tune called Llorando Se Fue by the Bolivian folk band Los Kjarkas. It was replete with all the Andean staples: a melody driven by panpipes and a rhythm section with a plethora of strummy instruments (seriously why do they need so many?).

Usually, when I've played this version to people, the reaction I've gotten was, "Yeah, but it's not as good as Lambada." I can see where that opinion is coming from, but I think it's not entirely fair to Los Kjarkas. They're just fundamentally different genres and have different priorities. Kaoma definitely has more mass appeal, being more upbeat and danceable, but what Los Kjarkas lack in cheerfulness, they make up for in expressiveness of emotion. I think another factor going against Los Kjakras is simply that Kaoma's version is more famous and therefore more familiar, and most people prefer what's familiar. In any case, I would highly recommend listening to the original version with an open mind. It has its own quirky kind of charm. One unusual element is that Los Kjarkas have recorded and performed a bilingual Spanish-Japanese version, as the song has found success in Japan.

The next step of the journey does not quite take us to Brazil yet, but musically, it gets much closer to the Kaoma version. While there have been many, many covers over the years (as of 1990, it had been translated into at least 42 languages), one of the notable early ones was a still Spanish-language 1984 cover by the Peruvian cumbia band Cuarteto Continental. Fans of Kaoma's version will find many familiar elements here: the rhythm has been simplified (more on that below), the melody is played on an accordion, and it's much more upbeat and danceable, albeit being cumbia rather than lambada. This version is particularly notable, as most subsequent covers are based more on it than on the original.

On our next step, we are finally in Brazil and dancing the lambada, although not yet with Kaoma. Instead, the first Portuguese-language version was performed by "the Queen of Lambada", Marcia Ferreira, who translated and recorded the cover in 1986, now titled Chorando se Foi, after hearing Cuarteto Continental. This version is virtually identical to the Kaoma one, down to the arrangement, which makes me amazed at how Kaoma thought they could get away with their plagiarism. The main difference is that Ferreira obtained permission to perform the cover and therefore did not face any legal trouble. Probably one of the most surprising parts of this story for me was how unknown the Ferreira cover is internationally, given that it's musically basically the same as Kaoma's version. On Spotify, the latter currently has almost 400 million listens, while the former sits at a measly 30k. I guess Kaoma had better international marketing?

Finally, in 1989, Kaoma released their version, which, of course, went on to be a massive international hit. However, they did not obtain the proper rights, which resulted in them being sued by both Ferreira and Los Kjarkas. Kaoma had to pay out compensation and add the rightful writers of the song to their credits. Although this has quite soured my perception of Kaoma, I will admit that they have a great music video.

So what is your favorite version? Does knowing the story change your appreciation of the music?

The rhythm of the Andes

For the music theory nerds, the original version has a couple of fun elements to offer. The famous melody consists of two phrases, each repeated, creating an AABB pattern. The first slightly unusual element is that the A phrase consists of 3 bars of 4/4, while the B phrase consists of 4 bars of 4/4. This aspect has been kept in most subsequent versions, although not in On The Floor.

However, the keen-eared listeners will have noticed that the original Los Kjarkas version has some further peculiarities in its rhythm. Specifically, the B phrase has 4 bars, but only 3 of them are in 4/4, while one is in 3/4 (the third one, as far as I can hear). What's more, there is a single bar of 2/4 between the two verses, which makes for a rhythmically disorienting effect. Certainly not for beginners! I can see why these elements were simplified for the more danceable versions, starting from Cuarteto Contintental, although the music theory nerd in me can't help feeling that a unique charm was lost by the way.

As a whole, the original version has a rhythmic feel that is completely different from the later covers. If anyone here knows something about Andean folk rhythms, I'd love to learn.


r/LetsTalkMusic • • 5d ago

What if The Beatles released The White Album in 2026?

0 Upvotes

Say The Beatles were the world’s biggest artist in 2026, and were about to release their self-titled album (aka The White Album). If you were in charge of overseeing this album’s rollout for the streaming era, which songs would you choose as the singles?

My picks:

  1. Dear Prudence

Since The Beatles as an album is tonally different from the Beatles’ previous work, “Dear Prudence” would serve as a safe pick for listeners who had grown fond of their psychedelic rock sound. It establishes a sense of familiarity headed into The Beatles’ next album release, and lacks the criticisms the band may receive from detractors of the anthemic pop rock song “Hey Jude” or the politically-charged “Revolution.”

2. Birthday

With “Birthday” taking a social media-first strategy, The Beatles would avoid taking any of the spotlight away from “Dear Prudence” on streaming platforms or radio. “Birthday” would eventually be released on DSPs about 3-4 weeks after it is first teased on social media. The goal would be for the social media trend to drive pre-saves to the DSPs, in turn lending the song strong algorithmic support and features on editorial playlists like New Music Friday and Big on the Internet.

3. While My Guitar Gently Weeps

Having “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” as the third single would serve a few key purposes. The first of these is to assure faithful Beatles fans that The Beatles will not be an album containing “Dear Prudence” and 29 pop rock songs built for social media. It would signify The Beatles would be an eccentric album with a diverse sound, which is a departure from their recent works.

4. Blackbird (focus track)

The focus track from The Beatles, or the song to be promoted alongside the release of the album, would be Paul McCartney’s acoustic song “Blackbird.” This is the song that would be teased on social media in the weeks leading up to the release of The Beatles, and used to drive pre-saves to the album. It’s the song that would be prominently featured on editorial and algorithmic playlists across Spotify, Apple Music, and all other DSPs. “Blackbird” would be the second single from The Beatles to be promoted to radio. It would primarily target the Pop and Adult Pop formats.

5. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da

“Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da” is the type of single listeners would need to discover for themselves, with a little help from early editorial playlisting and algorithmic support. Forcing a pop-oriented song on listeners that isn’t as anthemic as “Hey Jude” or social media trend-worthy as “Birthday” could easily backfire.

With “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da” being discovered like this, it would be instantly familiar when it is eventually promoted to Pop and Adult Pop radio formats. It would also graduate to top-tier editorial playlists like Today’s Top Hits and subsequently become the most familiar song off the album. This would allow The Beatles to ride the success of their self-titled album all the way into the rollout of their next major album release.