r/LightNoFireHelloGames • u/mr_anstey • 2d ago
Discussion Trying to imagine how it might work
I am absolutely NOT suggesting this is how it will work. This isn't a prediction. This is me trying to imagine how you make a procedurally generated fantasy world fun, playable, and coherent. I always start from the premise that HelloGames has played fantasy genre. They know what is awesome about Skyrim or Valheim or any of a half-dozen other fantasy games from the last decade. The question is, how do they implement it? These are 5 things I imagined might solve weird problems. I sincerely doubt any of this is how they'll do it, but i do think these are the types of problems they've been solving for the last few years.
- 1. Unique Items (or maybe even rare items too) — they really need to separate truly one-of-a-kind artifacts (maybe have like have the odds that there are ~10M unique items seeded across the globe (which if it's earth sized, that's about 1 for every skyrim sized map) into a lightweight Global Unique Registry so once someone pulls a legendary blade from a ruin, it’s gone for everyone.
- 2. No Levels — but you got to progress to be RPG — Ditch traditional XP bars and static perk trees. Evolve the NMS tech-grid into slottable magic runes, martial stances, and physical traits discovered out in the wild—make exploration and questing the only progression bars and letting players reshape their build through what they find, craft, or risk losing.
- It has to feel like NPCs/Monsters are 'real' — I'm not a developer, but if I were doing it, I'd be looking at some sort of Table Mob/NPC Memory Engine (Permanent Summary + Self-Pruning Detail): Keep a permanent, ultra-lean summary table (
Mob/NPC ID,encounterCounter,EncounterQualitySum,FirstEncounterDate,LastEncounterDate) alongside a granular encounter detail table (timestamp, 200char summary, encountertype, encounterquality (pos/neg number), encounter importance (was it a trivial moment or did a big fight happen?)... that sort of stuff. And those two tables allow them algorithmically flushes low-quality, low-importance interactions after a certain amount of time. The save file stays managable/smaller forever, high-impact moments stick, and every mob or NPC dynamically adjusts its reactions and quest offers based on your actual history. - 4. Quests With Real Consequences to character development Reward/Punishments: Feed that relationship memory into the quest generator so PC-vs.-NPC alignment clashes create real moral drama—giving murder-hobos high-stakes restraint trials and pious players dirty bargains. Attach real rewards and real consequences for failure: broken oaths that lock a parasitic curse into one of your shard slots until you quest to cleanse it, rather than risk-free checklists you can abandon in a menu. Some quests shouldn't offer rewards, they should risk debuffs/punishments. And use the expedition engine they built in NMS to spawn MORE expedition style quests based on the results of the previously completed/abandoned quests. abandoning a quest should have a consequence.
- 5. Make the staring points really dynamic — start with a sort of cradle but then unlocked more starting points as the world is explored: Instead of letting players min-max a spawn dropdown or randomly scattering everyone across an empty 16,000 km sphere, drop everyone via weighted random spawns into a single England-sized (~130,000 km²) "Old World" —keeping towns lively and friends within a day or two of travel while leaving 99.985% of the planet untouched. As players chart new continents unveiling big cities and such, and major updates lead a lot of players to a new area, promote those discovered borderlands into new randomized starting homelands. But never let players pick where they start.
Ultimately, I imagine HelloGames has studied all the big successful fantasy games out there and identified what really works, what players love, and what keeps them playing, and they've been trying to incorporate that into LNF. For me, the thing i am just not even smart enough to fully imagine is how you bring Skyrim level of density of objects, NPCs, Monsters and Quests to a world that is 'Bigger than earth."
Procedural generation adds so much complexity. I remember playing skyrim and finding out that my game was crashing because i was hitting 'hoarding problems' where my save was tracking too many objects — literally every object i kept had to be described and tracked geographically in my save. From what i understand, in a ProcGen world, you calculate everything and the math is always the same, and then you track the delta (the changes) in a little db. If you kill a unique boss, that boss has to be dead for everyone now, and so that delta has to be 'checked' when each player enters that area. I keep thinking how insane that is to keep track of.
Anyways... I'm sure they've figured it all out, but i am boggled by the math, the complexity of the data, the insane numbers of items, npcs, monsters, locations etc etc they have to track and display to make this game remotely playable.
I keep going back to Sean saying people don't fully get how wildly ambitious this is. The more i think about it, the righter i think he is.