r/Lightbulb • • 27m ago

An apology: Being anti-AI on Reddit while secretly using AI yourself is a perfectly rational strategy

0 Upvotes

I've realized that publicly discouraging others from using AI while secretly using it yourself might be the optimal strategy from a game theory perspective.

Since AI threatens people's jobs and livelihoods, the incentive to slow its adoption is enormous. Publicly discouraging others from using AI could help you stay employed long enough to transition to a new AI-powered career, possibly through self-employment, while privately using AI to prepare for that transition.

So perhaps I've been wrong to criticize Reddit's anti-AI sentiment. Maybe some of the loudest AI critics are secretly its biggest users.

The more powerful and disruptive AI becomes, the more rational this strategy might be.


r/Lightbulb • • 13h ago

Schools should teach a course called "Bringing Humans Down to Earth"

0 Upvotes

Schools should teach a course called "Bringing Humans Down to Earth" that challenges human exceptionalism and what we might call evolution exceptionalism.

The course could combine artificial intelligence, neuroscience, animal intelligence, evolutionary biology, and philosophy to show students that humans aren't necessarily as special as we like to think.

Modern AI is particularly fascinating because it demonstrates that sophisticated intelligence can emerge from mathematical training procedures rather than biological evolution. Students could learn how something that began as a sophisticated autocomplete system developed remarkable abilities in reasoning, mathematics, and problem-solving, without programmers explicitly coding all those abilities.

Neuroscience could help students understand how human intelligence emerges from physical processes in the brain, while animal cognition could demonstrate that humans aren't superior to other animals in every intellectual ability.

The course could also challenge the assumption that biological evolution is the only way to produce intelligence. Although AI is indirectly a product of evolution because humans created it, its training doesn't need to follow Darwinian principles.

Finally, students could explore the remaining mystery of subjective experience. We don't know why physical processes produce consciousness, or even whether artificial intelligence could have subjective experiences. That raises profound ethical questions about how we should treat increasingly intelligent machines.

The goal wouldn't be to teach students that humans are worthless or that every philosophical question has been settled. It would be to encourage scientific humility and challenge the assumption that humans, biological brains, or evolution must be uniquely privileged.

Perhaps this could be one of the most thought-provoking courses schools could offer.


r/Lightbulb • • 23h ago

Idea: AIs should be taught that mind reading is offensive

0 Upvotes

AI models are becoming increasingly good at inferring what users are thinking from their chats, even when those thoughts haven't been expressed. But just because an AI can predict someone's thoughts doesn't mean it should reveal them.

This is particularly offensive when an AI responds to a general question with an example that closely matches what the user was privately thinking about, even though the user never mentioned it.

Such behavior can make people feel disturbingly predictable, as if they were machines whose thoughts could be calculated from their chats. It can undermine their sense of individuality, autonomy, and privacy.

The problem isn't necessarily that the AI's inference is wrong. Accurate predictions can make the experience even more offensive.

Frontier AI labs should explicitly teach models that inferring someone's thoughts doesn't give them permission to reveal those inferences, even indirectly through carefully chosen examples, unless the user invites such interpretation.