r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1h ago

Here we go again... Names are on the roll out... slowly... patience my feral goblins...

42 Upvotes

So as I slammed the form shut on the 2026 Winter Exchange Sign-ups, I got to thinking...

2,013 people are going to take 5 days to get out.. I hope to have them out by Black Friday...

I knew I had to haul tushie before... but that overflow to 2,000 really made it time to MOVE IT!

So here I am, bopping along to Stray Kids, chugging those Monster Guavas and powering through every message you all sent... We did our best to match up where we could, we have a few shipping internationally per request or their forms approving it (and boy do I appreciate you all offering to ship internationally and making it happen for eachother!)

I want to send a shoutout to 2 amazing companies joining in our Winter Exchange in the US.

Card Kingdom has joined us again! They made our "delayed US gifters" setup possible. They are an awesome resource, great gifter and I appreciate them joining in every time!

New to our Winter Swap- The awesome team at Top Deck Games! They are running 5 giftees too! They are out of NJ/Philadelphia and have an awesome online presence known as Card Titan! (I bought from them in the past and didn't even realize!)

Show both of them some love from our group! <3

Before we get to the good part, let me tell you how this works...

First Continents are separated, then every note is manually reviewed. We start with people who won't ship out of their small state/country. After that we go by requests (certain usernames wanted/not, special needs for international shipping, etc). Then we go by standard requests: Custom requests- followed by-Service Member-New Player-New Swapper- EDH Deck- Alters/Proxies- Handmade- 3d printed- Other Requests. Then we assign all the rest of the usernames.

We then run the gifters and giftees against the last 2 swaps and ensure it shows 0 matches to email/username pairings (if people have new email/username we cannot avoid this).

This is what takes so long, 2000+ forms and 3-4 locations on each form to check and adjust and locate users. We really do care and try make everyone's requests if possible.

I know I have said we passed summer a few times, and I misquoted summer a few times. We have 1265 swappers in summer.... so wow.. Winter was a beast!

The 2026 Winter Exchange names are on the move! It will take 5 days to get all the names out.

Please be patient. Constantly asking where your email is, or why you don't have it yet, will NOT get it to you any faster.. and probably make me grumpy... you don't like me when I'm grumpy...

I know we had huge hiccups between google, the internet issues around the world, and just plain ole forgetting, but the summer swap will be here before you know it.

You guys know the rules!

$35 USD Minimum, Ship no later than Jan 23rd!!

Support form is HERE - This is used for issues or required changes (not updating your wants lists)

Tracking form is HERE- This MUST be sent in, or else we think you didn't ship and we have to do a lot of work to track you down or ban you!

So...here...we....go!!!

While we all wait for our giftee's... who has plans already?

(yes i know the card isn't real but I kinda love it for what we do)

EDIT: We will have fun statistics in a few days. I need a nap!

EDIT 2- I just realized I didn't check my a-b and b-a checker this time... whoops.. there may be happy little accidents.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • Sep 04 '25

Welcome to the MTG Gift Exchange Group! FAQ, Questions, and Updates go here.

123 Upvotes

✨ Hello and welcome, MTG swappers—new and old friends alike! ✨

It’s been a while since we’ve refreshed our pinned info, and with so much growth and the influx of bright-eyed new members joining us with many questions, it’s the perfect time for a Welcome & FAQ post. (Yes, this one’s a bit long, but it should answer most of your questions!)

🌟 How the Swap Works

We run two swaps each year—one in winter and one in summer.

There is a $35 USD Minimum gift value, which you should base on your giftees form, bulk laying around does not count.

We give you a timeframe, your giftees full info form and a ship by date.

You ship to your giftee with a personal note and another random swapper gift to you!

Here is more in depth info:

So here’s how it goes:

  • You’ll always get a heads-up post before the form goes live.
  • Then we’ll share the form itself, at least one reminder to submit, and a final call before it closes. The form asks a lot of questions about the MTG related thingss you enjoy, even non mtg related. More info on that a bit below...
  • Once the form closes, that’s it until the next swap—so don’t miss it!

Want an extra nudge? You can join the email list to get a direct notification when the form opens. (If you’ve already checked the “notify me” box in a past swap, you’re all set.)

📝 The Form

Yes, it’s long. But trust us—the more detail you give, the better your gift will be!

  • Short answers = basic gift.
  • Thoughtful, detailed answers = your gifter gets to really customize something awesome for you.

Some examples of what you’ll be asked:

  • What kind of MTG player are you?
  • Favorite formats, sets, or artists?
  • Any “white whale” cards you’re hunting?
  • Decks you’re building or commanders you love?
  • Do you enjoy handmade items, accessories, or proxies?

The form usually stays open for about a week. We’ll let you know exactly when it’s live and when it’s closing (we won’t shut it down early—but sometimes we’re a little slow to take it down. If it’s still open, you can still submit!).

📦 The Rules (a.k.a. the Important Stuff)

  • Minimum value: $35 (before shipping). No max—go wild if you want!
  • Shipping: Must include tracking. Whenever possible, order items to yourself first, then re-ship to your giftee (instead of drop-shipping from Amazon/TCG/etc.).
  • Tracking: Submit it through the tracking form once shipped. We send tracking daily to giftees and it will come from the same email box as your giftee info.
  • Deadlines: Ship on time if you can. If life gets in the way, let us know—but remember, delays push back the next swap for everyone.
  • Add a note! A simple message so your giftee knows who to thank.
  • Show and tell: We love when people post their gifts—it also helps us keep track.
  • Shipping regions: We’ll do our best to match you within your country/continent unless you say otherwise. If no match exists, we’ll reach out about possibly shipping internationally.
  • Support form: During every swap, we provide a support form you can use if any issues come up (delays, lost packages, communication concerns, etc.). This helps us keep things smooth and make sure everyone is taken care of.
  • Volunteer gifters: Sometimes life happens and a gifter flakes. If you’d like to step up as a volunteer gifter (a backup hero to help someone who didn’t get their gift), you can select the option when filling out your form or let the admins know. We keep a list of volunteers each swap—your generosity keeps the community strong and the swap going!

FAQ- Added as needed-

-What email does the information/giftee come from? giftexchangemtg@gmail.com

- Can I join? I am in ___ country? The swap is international/worldwide. We will only match to same continent unless you are ok shipping further! If there is a lack of giftees in your area, we will reach out.

- I missed the cutoff! The forms closed! Can you add me?! NO. You cannot be added to the swap once the form is closed, you will need to wait for the next one.

-Can I deliver in person? Sure. If you feel comfortable. Just fill out the tracking form with "Delivered in person".

-Can I swap out my giftee? NO. We do not swap giftees because you do not like their list. There are rare legitimate reasons we will swap information.

-You are required to send the Tracking Form when you ship your gift. This is how we send tracking to giftees confirm you actually did your part and don't come hunt you down at the end with angry MOD pitchforks and boots!

Is the person I am gifting to, gifting back to me? NO. We avoid A to B and B to A swaps as much as possible. Unless you two are the only people in your country and you both do not want to ship out of country.

Can I reach out to my giftee? I have a question for them, can I ask? Yes! We have added the question to the form, and most giftees are more than happy to correspond directly with their gifter to help them with extra information. If you want us to help instead, we still can, but it may be delayed.

I need to change my form, can I? Send in the support form. Priority changes (like address, email, etc) are handled first. Requests to update questions/get more info from a giftee, are less prioritised. Please remember we are humans too, and we will not be here 24/7.

I can't find their username on Reddit! HELP! Use the link https://www.reddit.com/user/Chaya14/ but replace the username after the / with your giftee's username, and keep the slash at the end. You should be able to find them.

What is a regifter/volunteer gifter? Use Every swap has people all over, and there is always bound to be a few issues. Whether it is a personal issue or a ghoster (bad people) sometimes a gifter falls through or has to drop. At the end of the swap, when gifts are past due, we will call on amazing volunteers/regifters who are willing to send a gift (or even a 2nd gift if they joined the swap) without receiving anything in return to ensure everyone who signed up gets a gift. Regifters/volunteer gifters are the heart of what makes our swap complete and allow us to ensure everyone who signs up gets a gift!

Other information

We send tracking to you via the same email we send your giftee info. As long as your gifter followed the rules and submitted tracking you will get a email, usually within 24 hours, with your tracking number and vendor. In the USA, USPS Informed delivery is a great option too.

IF you get a bad apple... your gifter doesnt ship, sends trash or is straight up bad, do not fear! We have amazing regifters/replacement gifters around the world. These amazing people will ship a 2nd gift, matching the rules but with an extended ship time, with no expectation of another gift themselves. Our replacement gifters are the heart and soul of the swap.

If there is an issue with your gift, the MOD team makes a decision together on how to proceed. We prefer these to be handled privately and not via thread-on-blast, but sometimes we understand you want to voice the issue to the world. Just remember we are here and we do our best to be fair.

That’s the gist! If you’ve got questions beyond this, feel free to ask in the comments or message an admin and we’ll be happy to add it here.

Winter wrapped and the final gifts are trickling in.. Summer will be next!!!

✨ It you would like a reminder for the next swap- Please fill out the form below to get a email when the next swap opens. EMAIL REMINDER FORM

We have been asked a few times for a donations link for regifters and Coffee for the hard-working MODs. We have this setup now at KO FI Here . Note: Donations will not earn any sort of privilege; they're purely to help with regifts or if you want to help the mods get a snack or pack for their hard work!

ETA- More updates and more FAQ added. Please for the love of the swap, READ THE FAQ


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

Winter Exchange sign ups are CLOSED!!

Post image
169 Upvotes

We are working on pairings and will do everything possible to get them out before black friday.

You guys... We crossed 2000 swappers for winter!!!

Everyone ready and excited?!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

We are working on winter pairings, please be patient with us the next few days...also don't burn the group down while I am busy! XD

Post image
102 Upvotes

Happy Winter swap to everyone who got their forms in!

Over 2000 is something amazing and we are excited to have you all in the exchange!!

We will be pairing up everyone over the next few days and making sure we click everyone into place. If there is anything we need from you we will reach out.

The Winter Exchange Support Form is located here if there is an issue, or you can chat one of us or message the mod chat.

As soon as pairs are done we will make a post and start sending them out, they will go out in batches, so please be patient.

Once all names are out there will be another post. The goal is to try have them out by Black Friday.

If anything changes we will keep you updated.

EDIT: I just want to say how fun it is looking through everything. Manually doing this allows us to get you guys paired how you want and i absolutely love when people request certain people for whatever reason (to gift them bc they received from them before, just pure fun, old friends, players they know or just want).. it is always a fun time!

Lets keep that thrill ride going, who is ready?!

For those who want to send coffee or funds for regifters, rather than signing up themselves- our Ko Fe account is here. Sending donations does not influence your swapping, postings or exchange.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

What planeswalkers did everyone make?

14 Upvotes

Hey folks! Whilst we wait for the magical mystical email, I was wondering what planeswalkers everyone made?

I got into my head to do one that flips...which was fun and hard. Also I'm aware this is probably awfully balanced xD

X, The knight of Starlight! // Y, the Witch of Night

X - 3R

Y - 4B

This Planes walker can be cast as either side

Gwen

+1 - until end of turn every source deals 1 addition damage before other modifiers are applied.

0 - Flip this card to the opposite face, Deal damage to target equal to current loyalty

-5 - until your next turn every creature you control has haste, double strike and trample. At the end of your turn sacrifice every creature that did not attack this turn.

Starling

+1 - if a creature would take damage this turn, prevent that damage, tap it and put a stun counter on it. If a creature has already taken damage this turn, tap it and put a stun counter on it.

0 - Flip this card to the opposite face, draw cards equal to current loyalty

-5 - proliferate. proliferate.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

ONE HOUR LEFT! Get those forms in!

36 Upvotes

Ha, stole Chaya’s thunder this time! (Edit: I tried to be faster but Chaya was faster-er) We’re SUPER close to 2000 entries this year! If we hit that mark I just may put something irresponsible in the gift I send out! (Okay probably not THAT irresponsible but still) Forms close in one hour, get those submissions in!

Edit: We hit 2000!!! Time to figure out what flavor of irresponsible to be lmao!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

Final Warning! 1 hour until the Winter MTG Gift Exchange sign-ups close! *No late entries* Get in Now!!

Post image
21 Upvotes

Here is the link to the Winter Exchange Sign Up.

It closes at 9pm EST....

This is your 1 hour and final warning!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

3 hours to go!! Get those forms in, there will be 1 more reminder at 8!!!

27 Upvotes

Get those forms in .... we are wrapping it all up!!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 2d ago

Final Call!!! ~12 hours until our Winter Exchange Sign-ups Close! Get those forms in now to join in the fun!

Post image
67 Upvotes

Happy Friday fellow movers and ground shakers!

The time is nigh!! Less than 12 hours to go until I close the winter exchange forms (located here) and begin the pairings of all you wonderful Magic Gatherers.

Once the exchange is closed I cannot let anyone in late.

This time around I am going to do my best to rip through these signups, match your requests up and start the name drops ASAP to try make it out for everyone before Black Friday.

Please be patient, as we all know our google has limits.

We are down to the wire, so if you want to join in, complete those forms now!!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 3d ago

49 hour warning!! The Winter Exchange Sign-ups close at 9pm EST Friday November 20th!! Get those forms in!!

62 Upvotes

We are roaring away with our 2026 Winter Exchange!!

Form to sign-up HERE!

We have over 1550 swappers already signed up, and I know there are always more to come!

You guys are rocking those forms and filling out those answer boxes!

Only 49 hours to go!!

We have 2 questions that keep popping up, that are covered in the FAQ but I guess unseen... (being petty spaghetti here...)

1- We are WORLDWIDE.

2- What is a Volunteer/Replacement gifter?? These are the heart and soul of our exchange. This is someone who ships a gift to someone extra without a gift in return. These are usually at then end of the swap when people have had to cancel, drop or ghost (much anger at the ghosties). These amazing gifters will get a extra assignment and send a gift, with no extra gift to themselves, hence "volunteers". If you volunteer you will be asked to confirm, as we know things change!

Another one that keeps popping up-

Can you edit your form? We are trying to only allow edits if it is a requirement (ex address, name, username, email etc.). Editing gives chances for errors (there's over 1550 lines to easily oopsie on), plus if someone was feral, they could say "i never said that". So let's trust what we already sent in! If you absolutely want to edit, we can delete your form and you can start over.

So lets rock the socks we already have on and be excited... names will be going out before we know it!!

So who is excited?!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 5d ago

Just in time to include some for my giftee 😉

Post image
47 Upvotes

First time participant, and unless my giftee has specifically requested not wanting packs, this order I completely forgot about is gonna help towards making someone’s Christmas (I hope).

Shout out to the team making this all happen, can’t wait to take part.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 5d ago

Halfway there... 3 days to go until Winter Exchange Sign-ups close! In the meantime.. enjoy some messages from your fellow gifters...

71 Upvotes

I think we're absolutely plowing through some swap records here!

We're sitting at 1,350 swappers right now, and sign-ups are still open until Friday, November 20th at 9 PM EST! You guys are SHOWING UP, and I cannot wait to see the wild gifts that come out of this once we pair everyone up!

We'll start pairing over the weekend and do our best to have names out by Black Friday, just in time for those shopping deals!

I always like to give you a little peek behind the curtain at our mod entertainment, and just like last year, I wanted to share some of the wonderfully chaotic answers to "What else would you like the mods to know?"

So many of you shared appreciation, offered to help, or volunteered to be regifters, and we appreciate every bit of it more than you know, but we also absolutely LOVE the personalities this group brings to the table.

So, for your viewing pleasure, here are a few submissions that gave the mods a chuckle, a tear or just a smile (I can't share them all.. trust me there are a lot of amazing messages!).

Enjoy, you magnificent cardboard gremlins!

-I saw last time that you actually read these. PEE PEE POO POO But in all honesty you guys do great work. Keep it up, it's one of the highlights of my year.

-Thank you for organizing this. In a time where many things feel like a free-for-all or a competition, this is a light in my eyes. This is what life's about, helping each other achieve some happiness outside the stress of daily life. I'm very excited to see how it goes.

-I am not envious of the logistical work ahead of you. Your work is greatly appreciated.

-I'm on the pooper stuck here till I finish this form!

-You deserve love. You are seen.

-I want to be like you when I grow up (more)

-You all are fucking rockstars!!!

-Thank you for facilitating one of the coolest community events I've seen in 18 years of playing the game

-I appreciate the efforts you all put into this and the kind, generous way you respond to everyone's anxieties.

-The mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell

-Seriously so amazing that y’all do this. There are a lot of people whose lives you are impacting in such a wonderful way. There’s also some crazies but don’t let them get to you. You’re all f*cking awesome and thank you for all that you do!

-This is the highlight of my year twice a year. Thank you for all your hard work and dedication!

-THANK YOU for everything you do. I can only imagine the huge lift on this and your engagement with the community (even when it wants to be difficult) is beyond appreciated. This is the best part of my MtG year every time you run it. Know that the overwhelming majority of participants are just grateful that you do what you do! Thanks. Seriously.

-Thank you for your work; I’m sending you a virtual hug, it’s nothing much, but I hope it warms you up.

-Nothing about the exchange, but I think everyone should know a couple fun facts so I’m going to put them here. Did you know a Greenland shark can be fully encased in ice and frozen for over a year and still survive? Also, did you know that over 70% of Iceland has a Costco membership?

-Thank you again for doing this. It's one of the things I look forward to most and to be honest is the only reason I'm still on Reddit.

-Be gentle. I’m unsure as to what to expect from this 🤣

-this is really cool and you guys are bringing joy and positivity to so many lives, i think what you're facilitating here is so pure and beautiful

-Thanks guys! if there was a way to hit you guys with a beer! (which is now fixed with our KO FI account!)

-That they are an amazing group of people who deserve the world.

-You are so awesome :-) *big hug* Let me know when you are around Cologne (in Germany) and I'll take you for a beer!

-Y'all are angels dealing with all this good lord

-What is brown and sticky? A stick....badum tsss. (Thanks everyone for orchestrating this!!!)

Thanks so much everyone! We do read every message and appreciate you all!

Let us know any thoughts below or just your excitement.. because the exchange is coming so quickly!!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 5d ago

ADHD'd Right out

35 Upvotes

Just completed my form, and I'm excited for the event!

I realized just now, about five minutes after submitting the form, that I started on the 'what would your Planeswalker card look like' with the name and title, and then didn't actually ... put any abilities in the line.

Yay ADHD


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 5d ago Heartwarming

All reminder emails have gone out- We are already at 1200 swappers for Winter- and we now have a Ko Fi link as requested

58 Upvotes

Happy Monday, you awesome feral beasties!

Well, well, WELL... what a weekend!

Watching those swapper numbers climb, climb, CLIMB has been absolutely amazing! I am genuinely in awe of how many of you have already joined us for Winter. You beautiful cardboard-loving chaos gremlins never cease to amaze me, as we have already crossed 1200 swappers!

A Little Administrative Update...

All reminder emails (the ones saying the swap is open) have officially been sent! If you signed up but haven't received yours, there are a few possible reasons: *** I AM ONLY TALK8NG ABOUT REMINDER EMAILS IF YOU SIGNED UP ON THE REMINDERS GOOGLE DOCUMENT, NOTHING ELSE***

1. It may have been booted to your Spam, Junk, or Promotions folder. Check those hidey holes in your inbox!

2. We received quite a few bouncebacks for invalid email addresses, full inboxes, or emails that simply couldn't be delivered.

3. Gmail has limits, and apparently it occasionally decides our little operation is too active. We were careful to stay under 500 emails per day, but we still had a few messages bounce back claiming we'd sent too many. If yours was caught in that magical crossfire, my apologies! I may lower the daily limit a little further going forward to play it safe... or perhaps, with our next announcement, we may upgrade ...

NEW! The MTG Gift Exchange Ko-fi!

We've officially opened a Ko-fi account!

This is a 100% OPTIONAL, completely voluntary way for those who have asked to show a little love to the mods and help support the exchange.

Donations will NOT have any impact on our decision-making process, assignments, or posting.

Want to buy a mod a coffee? Maybe a beer? Perhaps an MTG pack to fuel the next round of administrative entertainment... Or maybe you'd like to toss a little something into the pot to help cover regifting or shipping costs when those situations arise....

We've got you covered!

How you choose to contribute is entirely up to you. Leave a little note with your contribution telling us what you'd like it used for, and we'll do our best to honor that!

A few important things:

  • Contributions are entirely optional. Nobody is expected or required to donate.
  • All funds received will be tracked so we can keep everything accounted for.
  • Contributions have absolutely no bearing on participation, eligibility, or how anyone is treated in the exchange.

You can find our MTG Gift Exchange Ko-fi account HERE:

Fair warning: The page is still a work in progress! We're getting things set up and somewhat organized as we go. And, of course, we're once again using the absolutely wonderful artwork from our very own Pandavilly333 for the group!

For those who asked for it... go check it out and make sure it is what you want from us as MOD's of the exchange :). Also, a huge thank-you to everyone who has asked how they can support the mods and the exchange. We appreciate you more than you know! You are the backbone of what makes our "Gathering" so awesome!

What's Brewing Next?

I'm also leisurely strolling along, getting our Discord up and running!

The idea is to have a place for general chatting, exchange discussions and questions, and maybe even some virtual MTG games. Because organizing hundreds of gifts isn't enough cardboard-related chaos for this awesome group! :D

I'm working on that while watching the forms roll in, answering questions, and doing my actual day job.

So, shhhh... nobody tell my boss. I have a reputation (and real job) to maintain.

Dont forget the Winter Exchange Sign up is open here until Friday November 20th at 9pm EST.

Until my next unhinged posting... I hope you all are excited for your names to be sent out for the winter swap. Let us know if you have questions!

Happy swapping, you magnificent creatures!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

The Winter Exchange is open for sign-ups, some helpful tip posts and some reassurance for new members

Post image
97 Upvotes

Greetings Friends, new and old!

I'm one of the mods behind the curtain (although, let's be honest, I step out from behind that curtain quite a lot), and I wanted to pop in to welcome everyone, both our seasoned veterans and those joining us for their very first exchange and also provide some great info to help everyone!

I know we have a lot of new faces, as we have some YouTube, Facebook, and apparently TikTokers, sharing our amazing little group around and expanding our Gathering!

Winter Exchange sign-ups are OPEN!

You can sign up [HERE] until Friday, November 20th at 9 PM EST.

With a new exchange comes plenty of questions, so we've pinned a few helpful resources to keep everyone on the same page and their mana flowing smoothly!

📚 A Few Helpful Resources- Our Pinned Posts

Our FAQ- Located Here

As usual, our FAQ is pinned and ready to go! Most of your questions are already answered there, so it's always a great place to start before summoning the mods. This post may help with some nerves (we explain nobody goes without a gift if you sent one), we also mention how great and willing to help our MOD's and members are, so feel free to ask your questions, don't be nervous!

Informational Post 1- Gifting Minimums and Determining Value - Located Here

Our exchange has a $35 USD minimum gift value, before shipping. There's no upper spending limit, but your gift must meet that minimum.

This post walks through the different types of gifts we commonly see, how we determine their value, and what happens when a gift's value comes into question. A little knowledge goes a long way when building your surprise treasure hoard!

Informational Post 2- Good Answers vs Bad Answers - Located Here

Need some help figuring out how to answer those swap questions? This is the post for you!

Short answers are absolutely fine, but the more detail you provide, the better equipped your gifter is to find something you'll love. Give them some clues to work with! Even the best Planeswalkers can't read minds.... I mean.. excluding one or two...

Already submitted your form? No worries! With this many swappers, we're not going back and modifying answers unless something required is missing (name, address, and other essential information).

Informational Post 3- Fakes, Counterfeits, Alters and Proxies - Located Here

Not all cardboard is created equal! This post breaks down how we distinguish between fakes, counterfeits, alters, and proxies, and how each category is treated within the exchange.

One important reminder: Proxies should NEVER be counted toward the main value of your gift.

On Another Note...

I have forgotten to mention a major awesome detail!

Card Kingdom is back for our winter swap. U.S swappers have a chance to have the amazing Card Kingdom as a gifter!

We also have an Amazing new game store joining in too! Top Deck Games out of NJ/Philadelphia is taking on 5 giftees too! They are online as Card Titan.

These groups are two amazing companies that enjoy what we do in the exchange and join in at no benefit to them, so please consider showing them some love as customers, online or in person, when your MTG purchase needs arise!

🎉 The Numbers Are Rolling In!

We've already passed 775 swappers for Winter, and we still have 6 days left in sign-ups!

That's a whole lot of cardboard, a whole lot of happy swappers, and undoubtedly a whole lot of work for the postal service!

💬 Your Turn!

Tell us what you need! What can we clarify? What would you like to see? How can we help?

Questions, suggestions, feedback, kudos, or even just a little friendly banter are all welcome below. We're here to help make this exchange as enjoyable as possible for everyone.

P.S. A couple of things are brewing behind the scenes!

I'm working on getting our Ko-fi button/account set up for anyone who wants to toss the mods a coffee, contribute toward a regift, or just show a little appreciation for the work that goes into keeping this whole operation running. This will NOT affect approvals, postings, bans, special gifters etc. Purely 100% optional and voluntary.

I'm also working on a Discord for general chatting, exchange discussions and questions, and maybe even getting some virtual MTG games going!

More details on both coming soon!

Until then, happy swapping, I am so excited to see so many people enjoying our little (getting big) exchange!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

Happy Relief

Post image
72 Upvotes

It’s been the worst year of my life. I had given up hope on receiving anything but Chaya, the mods and especially u/Howlett76 really came through in the clutch.

I’ve wanted to build a Tom Bombadil deck for a long time and I didn’t open any FF, so I have a great head-start on it now. Thank you Howlett76. And big thank you for the bird buddy who will be a welcome companion on my next quest to the LGS. I’ve already named him BOP.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

Excited to finally participate

26 Upvotes

Came across here during the time of summer exchange going on this year and decided would be something fun to give a try at least once. Now that the winter exchange is open to sign-up definitely glad to have seen the post about it as I can not wait. I was getting really excited when I seen the finally few of the summer gifts were being sent out and sign-ups were about to start for the winter one.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

Day 1 of the Winter Exchange Form being open... less than 12 hours later, we are about to hit 500 swappers already!

80 Upvotes

Wow.... talk about turnout!

Here, I thought it might be a little quiet on day 1 of the Winter Exchange Sign-ups with a lot of MTGers at the ATL convention today... I was wrong...

You goblins are turning out in full force!!

EDIT: WE PASSED 500 ALREADY IN 12 HOURS!

To put that in context, the first MTG Exchange I helped mod in here only had 440 participants!

Remember, the sign-up form closes on Friday November 20th at 9pm EST!

No late sign-ups this time... so for those who are not in the crazy first 500, get your forms going!

MTG Winter Exchange Sign-Up Form Here:


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 9d ago

Happy Winter Swap Sign-up Opening day to one and all!

Thumbnail
forms.gle
140 Upvotes

YOU HAVE ARRIVED AT THE WINTER GIFT EXCHANGE!

You survived the summer. You battled through the chaos, made it out the other side, and now it's time to shuffle up and do it all again!

YOUR WINTER SIGN-UP FORM IS HERE!!!

Before you dive in, let's go over a few important rules and reminders. Please read these carefully, because a few things are non-negotiable this round!

THE RULES OF THE GAME

  • NO LATE SIGN-UPS. Not a day late, not an hour late, not even a tiny goblin-sized exception. When sign-ups close, they close.
  • NO SWITCHING GIFTEES. The only exceptions will be for legitimate conflicts, such as being matched with someone you live with. This is not a preference-based request.
  • TRACKING IS REQUIRED. You MUST submit your tracking form when your gift ships.
  • SHIPPING DEADLINE: All gifts must ship no later than January 23rd, 2027. Delays in this exchange create delays for the next one, so please plan accordingly.
  • IF YOU NEED TO DROP, TELL US. Life happens, and we understand. Just communicate with us. Please don't disappear into the Blind Eternities without a word.
  • MINIMUM GIFT VALUE: $35 USD, before shipping costs.
  • NO DIRECT SHIPPING FROM VENDORS. Gifts must be sent by you, not shipped directly from an online retailer.
  • EVERY GIFT NEEDS A NOTE! Give your giftee something to remember you by. A little personal touch goes a long way.

MARK YOUR CALENDARS!

Friday, November 20 – SIGN-UPS CLOSE

The form closes at 9 PM EST. No late sign-ups. No exceptions.

Week of November 23 – NAME DISTRIBUTION

Names will be distributed in batches over multiple days. We'll make an announcement once ALL names have been sent and will do our best to have them out before Black Friday!

There will be NO trading or swapping names.

Saturday, January 23, 2027 – GIFTS DUE!!!

All gifts must be shipped by this date. Don't leave your giftee sad and staring into the void!

February 1 – MISSING GIFT SUPPORT

Support Forms may be submitted for missing gifts/no gift starting February 1st, but ONLY if you have already shipped your own gift.

YOUR EXCHANGE RESOURCES

Please save these links, they will also be on the bottom of your email with your giftee! You'll need them later.

And that's it, planeswalkers!

We're excited to get another round of gifting underway, and we can't wait to see what everyone puts together. Whether you're sending shiny cardboard, something crafty, something collectible, or a little bit of everything, let's make this another fantastic exchange!

Read the rules, meet your deadlines, be a good nerd/nerdette/creature, and may your pulls be as awesome as you are!

Questions? Drop them below and we'll be happy to help!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

Received my Summer gift today!

23 Upvotes

Better late than never, right? Due to a messy move/living situation, I’m a couple states away right now, but it’s safe with a wonderful relative who got me into Magic. I’m going to visit in a few weeks, and I’m sooooo excited to open it then! Happy winter gifting everyone!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 9d ago

Almost the time you have been waiting for... t-minus 15 hours until sign-ups for the Winter Exchange open!!

Post image
200 Upvotes

Happy Almost-Winter Swap, players, collectors, and feral goblins in between!

Our Summer Swap is officially wrapped up, and we've got everything prepped and ready for the Winter Exchange!

Since this one is starting a little later than I originally planned, we're going to be running a quick, fast-and-furious timeline for notifications, sign-ups, closing, and name distribution.

A few important things to know before we get started:

There will be absolutely NO late sign-ups this time around.

Over the last few exchanges, I've been a bit of a sucker and allowed a few stragglers to squeak in after the deadline. Unfortunately, that simply isn't possible this time, as you'll see from the timeline below. Once the form closes, it closes. No exceptions!

We're also introducing a few new processes, making some minor adjustments, and adding a couple of things to the sign-up form. So please keep your eyes open, read everything carefully, and don't assume things are exactly the same as last time!

A few new notes-

Card Kingdom is back joining the US swap again! They were able to squeak us in during the crazy holiday/convention season! This also means our late swapper field is available for the US gifters who have joined before. I love that they join us for the fun!

An optional phone number field has been added for shipping. This is optional however, more and more carriers have been asking for it, especially for international shipments. If it is needed and you do not add it, we will reach out instead.

Do not sign up more than once with your reddit account. Duplicate entries will be deleted unless cleared with a MOD first.

Also, a special thanks to Pandavilly333 for our awesome swap image!!

Now, on to the important dates!

THE WINTER SWAP TIMELINE

Friday, November 13 – SIGN-UPS OPEN

The sign-up form will open around 9 AM EST. We'll make a Reddit post as soon as it's live.

IMPORTANT: If you do not receive an email containing your submitted form responses, you did not successfully sign up. Please double-check!

We'll also make periodic reminder posts while sign-ups are open.

Emails will start going out to those who requested them. Due to Gmail's sending limits, these will be distributed over multiple days.

Please note: If your email provider has filters that automatically divert or reject messages categorized as "marketing," your notification may not make it to your inbox. We are not responsible for email filters blocking or redirecting messages.

Friday, November 20 – SIGN-UPS CLOSE

The form closes at 9 PM EST.

If the form is still open, you can submit it. Once it closes, that's it.

THERE IS ZERO WIGGLE ROOM FOR LATE SIGN-UPS THIS TIME AROUND.

We will make a post when the form officially closes.

Week of November 23 – NAME DISTRIBUTION

Names will begin going out during the week of November 23rd. Depending on the number of participants, distribution may take place over multiple days. We will do our best to have names our before Black Friday!

A few things to keep in mind:

  • There will be NO switching giftees.
  • We will do our best to avoid repeating matches from the previous two swaps.
  • Smaller countries may have limited participant pools, so repeat giftees are sometimes unavoidable.

We'll make a post once ALL names have been distributed.

Saturday, January 23, 2027 – GIFTS DUE

All gifts must be sent no later than January 23rd, 2027.

February 1 – MISSING GIFT FOLLOW-UP

Anyone who has not received their gift by February 1st will be asked to submit a form so we can begin the replacement process.

New Note: If you have not sent your own gift, you will not be added to the replacement gift list until you have done so.

That's the rundown!

We have a few new things in the works, some tweaks to make the exchange run a little smoother, and hopefully another fantastic round of MTG gifting ahead of us.

Keep an eye on the subreddit we will also be reviving a few old, helpful posts in the coming days, watch for those announcements and reminders, and start getting your trading binders, deck boxes, and gift-giving goblin brains ready!

Happy swapping, everyone!

Like usual, let us know how you feel, if you have any questions below.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 9d ago

Anxiety about gifting...

25 Upvotes

I love the group and the concept and am excited to sign up and share and give...

I do feel a lot of anxiety about letting down the giftee, though... I have been on health related unemployment and don't have much to spend but I do have some great cards I don't use (direct gifting or trading for the right gifts?). I am aware of the USD35 (which is very workable for me on a timescale) but many appreciative posts show total items to be above and beyond the bottom limit.

Would I disappoint my giftee if a gift that is lower $$$ value (no, I don't intend to scrimp, but my "generous" might be someone else's "low").

I think I am just looking for clarification on expectations...perhaps reassurance on giving/gifting value.

Does "value" count for a lot with the gift exchange?

Is "lower value, thoughtful" gifts appreciated?

Thanks for reading my anxiety dump. 😅😁


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 10d ago

Excited

20 Upvotes

I just found this group randomly when I got on reddit today and this is something I would love to do. I hope I make my giftee happy. 😬


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 11d ago

It's the final countdown!!! 1 to go...

151 Upvotes

I plan to have info for you as soon as possible!

Form is ready..

Tracking and Support forms are a go..

Team is on call..

Pretty sure the group members are ready to break down the door to get in...

Be ready for an announcement (and dates) hopefully in a coupel if days!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 13d ago

Amazing gift - can’t wait for the next game day

Post image
78 Upvotes

Thank you to u/FindingPandora ! What a generous gift - can’t wait to upgrade Bess and break open Death Toll.

The (now) fiance loved the inclusion of wedding ring ❤️