r/Machinists • • 4h ago

QUESTION CNC Fixturing for Lights-Out Automation

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for advice on CNC fixturing with the mid-term goal of lights-out manufacturing using robotic arms.

I know fixturing is an art in itself, but I'm trying to avoid investing in a system that I'll have to abandon as we scale.

We currently have three FANUC Robodrills, including one with a 4th axis. Most of our parts are aluminum, around 330–340 mm long.

The goal is to eventually automate loading and unloading using a Universal Robots or FANUC robotic arm. I understand we'll need automatic door operation, pneumatic or hydraulic clamping, and repeatable positioning.

I'm currently considering a few options:

Kurt 6" vises: Start with conventional vises and eventually retrofit pneumatic actuation using something like Lights Out Manufacturing or Rapid Design Solutions.

Xindian 52 or 92: Imported modular fixturing systems that seem affordable and flexible, although I'm unsure how well they integrate with pneumatic automation.

LANG or 5th Axis: Obviously attractive if money weren't an issue, but we're a startup and can't justify that level of investment yet.

I'm leaning toward pneumatic clamping because it seems relatively straightforward to integrate with robotic loading.

For those running automated CNC cells:

Would you start with conventional Kurt vises and retrofit automation later, or invest in a modular zero-point system from day one?

Has anyone automated Xindian 52/92 fixtures?

Is pneumatic clamping reliable enough for unattended machining?

Are there affordable fixturing systems that work particularly well with Universal Robots or FANUC arms?

What would you do differently if you were building your first lights-out CNC cell again?

I'm not trying to buy the cheapest solution. I'm trying to find something affordable today that won't become obsolete when we introduce robotic tending.

Would appreciate hearing what has actually worked in production.


r/Machinists • • 5h ago

QUESTION Machining a hex head

0 Upvotes

How sketchy is the work holding in this when they make the hex head...?

https://www.reddit.com/r/oddlysatisfying/s/wapVtw9LdX

It makes me nervous somehow...


r/Machinists • • 4h ago

QUESTION Question on these Titans and other YouTube sources

17 Upvotes

When I was a MTT instructor 15 years ago, I used video to have some sort of observational reference for students to have when I wasnt able to re-show something the class had already covered. I knew then that the format had great value and would soon become a larger part of technical education and training. Now I am watc hing videos where these guys are machine 1" deep in 4140 without coolant with ridiculous SFM and Feed. What am I not seeing? I realize they have the industry's best most rigid machines with the most capability ( multi spindles / 5ax) and software. The machine and software are 50% of what they are doing. They are either very good and years of experience or they have a ton of support not on camera. They have Kennametal - the largest cutting tool company in the U.S. with many subsidiary lines of tooling and the most engineering factory support- that helps them also. I do love the various techniques that I've never seen before but I HIGHLY doubt that most of what your seeing is from these two or three fat middle aged bald machinists - Im sure they are awesome machinists but they are pushing parameters Id have been fired for even trying and should be. How could they even afford to test these things into perfection on private shop money? I just wondered what others have to say.


r/Machinists • • 3h ago

QUESTION Are these carbide blanks?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

I just bought some calipers and some other miscellaneous stuff from a guy on marketplace.

Here it looks like I just got a bunch of what it looks to be carbide tooling blanks. But i’m unsure of it. Can someone confirm?


r/Machinists • • 16h ago

Line boring vs boring mill in production

5 Upvotes

Hoping someone can enlighten me about manufacturing processes. Taking something like an excavator bucket or quick coupler, surely they are not line boring these at the factory, right? The set up would be time consuming. On the other hand, it's pretty easy for the ear spacing to require a 10:1 ratio of length to diameter or more on the boring bar, which is right at the limit of what is considered possible, and that's with some fancy equipment. Kind of stuck on this. Anyone actually know how this is done? Thanks


r/Machinists • • 22h ago

QUESTION Do you stop once you’re within tolerance?

124 Upvotes

Sorry if this is a dumb question, I know little about machining but learned about tolerances recently and that got me thinking, would you consider the work “done” if it was within the specified tolerance range, or would you keep trying to make it as close to the actual dimensions as possible?

On the one hand, I get that by definition being within the tolerance range means it’s acceptable. But is this true in practice or do people strive for the most accurate dimensions?


r/Machinists • • 4h ago

Penn Tool going all in on a.i.dvertising.

Post image
88 Upvotes

More like Badvertisement