TLDR - TP4 has more capacity and probably an overall bag and better for travel but it feels noticeably big on your back. Toshi 25, seems more versatile and doesn’t feel as big wearing it.
Did this because a few people knew I was getting both and wanted to just do a quick travel pack out to compare. I only packed out the main compartments and put my 13 inch laptop in the back. These are also initial impressions although I did take the TP4 on a trip just now and it was great.
I used a smedium and a small packing cube, slim pouch 2 and travel pack 3.
You can see where I packed just the cubes, the Aer still has some space in it whereas with the Toshi, there’s almost nothing left. In the Aer I could slide a pouch beside the cubes whereas in the rework I had to stack both on top.
When I zipped both up, the Rework was noticeably tighter but I could still close the zipper.
I’d say the volume isn’t drastically different between the two but it isn’t the “same” as I see it hinted at online sometimes.
The difference is noticeable.
I walked around the house with each bag for a few minutes and both are comfortable but the comfort is just different: Aer is more padded, but you feel the weight a lot more and it just “feels” like a travel pack. Whereas the Toshi’s straps are a little slimmer, but it feels a lot lighter on your back.
So “more comfortable” is tough to figure out.
Where Aer wins, for me at least:
-most materials, build, and design (ie handles, waterbottle pockets, load lifters)
-laptop protection
-Some aspects of the harness system - straps
-pen holder (would it kill Rework to give us a pen slot?)
Where Rework wins
-lightness and slimmer feel. This feels lighter in my back than my CPP2 20L
-zippers are much easier to open
-doesn’t feel like a travel pack, but could double as one in a pinch.
-sloped sides: one of the things I actually don’t love about my CPP2 is the clamshell for EDC. I think I just prefer half openings or top down openings so I appreciate how I can just open that main zipper to get in the bag.
-it has a versatility which I think few bags have.
Will I keep the Tosshi? I think so? I think I should try one bag with Xpac so why not this? It’s my first Xpac and I’m not sure how I feel about it. I think I like it? I’d be curious to know people’s long term experiences with Xpac but wanted to give it a fair shake.
I also don’t know about the stiffness of the back panel on the toshi but when I fully packed it out it felt pretty good.
There’s also this…imperfect-ness about rework that I actually kind of like. Like how it’s really great at some things but not so great at others. It seems like a very human bag, if that makes sense.
Still don’t know about the Xpac but it does stand nicely I guess.
Sorry this was long. Hope it was a little helpful.
They’re both great bags. Similar and also different.