This was originally a Letterboxd review, but it got so long that I decided to post it here too.
This movie pisses me off more than any of the other X-Men movies. Not just because of the wasted potential of the movie, but of the series as a whole.
We all know it sucks, so instead of going off on the same repeated issues with the movie, I am going to provide ideas on how to make it better and pitch how I think the movie should have gone.
My version would start relatively the same way. Except I'd take out the moment where he looks up at the sky and yells no, and just use the moment where he kills the guy who killed his dad. His mother is horrified, and the police show up outside their door, but young Logan is still in berserker mode and tears through the cops outside, sees what he's done, then runs away, thinking he's a monster.
Young Victor catches up and tells Logan to come with him. He tells him that he did the right thing and that guy deserved what he got, but now no one else will have them, so they have to stick together and make sure no one else can ever hurt them again. That is the framing device for the movie.
James and Victor grow up and fight in every war throughout history, and James wants to separate himself from all the violence because he sees what it is doing to young kids. Corrupting them with hate until they get themselves killed. However, Victor relishes in the violence because he thinks humanity took everything from him, and he wants to return the favor. This forms a rift between the two of them as they start fighting more and attacking each other.
When a fight between them causes them to screw up and get captured, they are recruited to join Stryker's team of mutants. After James figures out that Stryker is kidnapping mutants for some kind of experiment, he leaves the group to go live a normal, quiet life away from all of this. This solidifies the rivalry between James and Victor because he feels like James is all he has left of himself, and if James is gone, then who really is Victor?
James has a normal...ish quiet life in Canada with his girlfriend, Kayla Silverfox. But this time the love really is genuine. Stryker learns of this and captures her. Faking her death, making James think Victor killed her. He uses his son's mind-control powers and amplifies her mutation. Making Kayla work for him and turning her evil. Stryker manipulates James into getting the adamantium so he can kill Stryker, and that sequence is largely unchanged.
Logan escapes, and a sweet old couple take him in and give him food and clothes. These are good people, and they show him kindness and decency out of the kindness of their hearts. This makes Logan connect to them quickly and want revenge against Stryker for needlessly killing good people. Finally stepping into a heroic role for the first time.
The rest of the movie basically plays out the same, except Logan has to fight three people. The mind-controlled Kayla, whom he will end up saving, and gives her to the kids to get her to safety with Professor X, Victor, now fully embracing his Sabretooth persona, and Omega Red, the mutant whom Stryker was experimenting on. A former soviet assassin who was lent to the American government to help bring Wolverine in. Victor and Omega Red get away alive, but both are badly hurt, and the rest of the movie plays out the same until the end, and no Deadpool. Wade is still there, but he remains a background character.
That is my version of the movie that I think is a more worthy origin movie for Wolverine that doesn't just rehash the same stuff we have already seen. I don't normally do this for reviews, but I had so many thoughts about this movie that I had to get them out somewhere. Thanks for reading my novella.
The movie we got: 2/10
My rewritten version: Probably somewhere around a 7/10