r/MawInstallation • • 7h ago

[CANON] Do you think the Centrist and The Populist Party are the Democrat and Republicans of Star Wars Universe?

0 Upvotes

If you notice it star wars is inspired by real world politics and history such as nixon, ww2 and American revolution however what I saw about the centrist party in star wars it reminds me of afd or the Republicans with populist being the democrats or cdu liking multicultural society which the centrist actually reminiscing the life of the past especially like why the 1930s did with afd​

I'm saying this because of anakin far right propaganda 2 weeks ago


r/MawInstallation • • 8h ago

What's the most impressive combat feat from a B1 droid?

7 Upvotes

Sure they're built to be cheap and disposable but are there any (Canon or Legends) of a B1 being surprisingly effective in battle?


r/MawInstallation • • 10h ago

Are Sith Lords More Powerful Than Jedi Bec of the Dark Side, or Is It Bec They Recruit Only the Strongest?

0 Upvotes

Now I've noticed that people in YT comments keep claiming that because the Sith Lords of the OR and NJO have shown better Force capabilities than most Jedi, the dark side is indeed more powerful than the light. Some argued though that the Sith Lords are seemingly more powerful on average because they only recruit powerful prospects, unlike the Jedi who recruit pretty much anyone even if their combat capabilities are not that great.

Bonus: Doesn't the idea that the dark side is stronger contradict Yoda's quote as well as the authorial intent from The Empire Strikes Back?


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] Whats the limitations of ship override?

13 Upvotes

Mandalorian S3 EP 6

We see the planet of Plazir-15, An Outer rim system, just casually take over Bo Katans ship.

Granted its an unusually wealthy outer rim system but if the technology was this available, Why wouldnt the empire do the same? Especially on a planet like Mustafar or Lothal to control the in and outflow of traffic


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] What was San Hill's role in the Banking Clan?

9 Upvotes

From my understanding he's the Chairman of the Banking Clan, but after the Scipio/Clovis arc of TCW it seems more like he's simply the head of a wealthy family/faction or representative within the IGC opposed to being the main figurehead of the entire group as it's implied in Episode II.

I've tried to read up on it but can't really understand how it works based on the wookieepedia. Can anyone explain it?


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[META] Were stormtroopers meant to be clones for a brief time?

1 Upvotes

EDIT: I meant a brief time in the real world. I know that in both canon and legends they were clone troopers in the beginning before the phase out. I’m more so talking about clones being stormtroopers in episodes IV onwards

The imperial march at the end of episode II kind of closely connects the Jango clones to stormtroopers. Various bits of merchandise seemed to imply the troopers were clones, like stormtrooper action figures with removable helmets that had clone faces on them. The Battlefront II campaign, while then occupying a weird space in canon, flat out said a lot of the stormtroopers were clones. Plus, if we are going by just the movies, there’s really no indication the empire stopped using clones, so to the average person who’s just seen the movies and nothing else would assume the empire kept using them, like some people ive met.

Now of course that was later debunked in various pieces of media. A bunch of stuff points to the empire phasing clones out in favor of human recruits. But I do have to wonder if this was an idea Lucas had during the making of the prequels that he eventually went back on.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[LEGENDS] Is the planet Hoth named after Lord Hoth, or vice-versa?

29 Upvotes

I’m curious if it has ever been established what the connection is between the planet of Hoth and Lord Hoth, or if there even is one. And just in general any interesting trivia about Lord Hoth since I find his character very intriguing.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[META] According to GEORGE LUCAS, are Stormtroopers clones?

0 Upvotes

I don't know if this is something George has ever adressed, but I'm asking in case.

So I know that in-universe, in both Legends and Canon continuities, the clones were phased out to be replaced by normal human recruits, who became Stormtroopers. But if I'm not mistaken, I think George himself likes to do his own thing without really caring about what Expanded Universe authors have decided, so it wouldn't surprise me if George Lucas went against this part of the Expanded Universe.

When I watch George's movie saga (regardless of any Expanded Universe material), it seems pretty obvious to me that the Stormtroopers we see in the OT are meant to be the clones we see in the PT. They have the same armor. In Revenge of the Sith, we see clone helmets looking like a transition between the helmets from Episode II, and the classic Stormtrooper helmets. During the battle of Kashyyyk, we see clones wearing Scout Trooper helmets. And during the Order 66 scene, Ki-Adi Mundi is leading what are basically Snow Troopers, but with a different color palette than the ones from Empire Strikes Back.

Considering all this, it would seem very weird to me that George hadn't planned for the Stormtroopers to just be the clones.

Has he ever commented about this whole issue?

Again, this discussion is purely meta. It's not about the in-universe canon.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[LEGENDS] How good is it like to be a Clone pilot during the Clone Wars?

5 Upvotes

[I don't know which flair to choose, sorry :/]

So I am quite new to the lore here and based on my superficial understanding is that droids in general, whether ground-based or in space/air, are inferior to organic-based forces in almost every way.

I tried to search for topics regarding this but can't find any. But I infer that it might be a really awesome time to be a Clone pilot given how uncreative a typical droid starfighters were?

It is probably the best time in Star Wars history to achieve hundreds of kills and become a super ace and gain some fame.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

The Jawas might be the closest thing Tatooine has to a functioning public utility

26 Upvotes

Something occurred to me while rewatching A New Hope: the Lars family doesn't go into town to buy the droids they need. They wait for a giant, privately operated scrap vehicle to show up in the desert and buy whatever happens to be available.

And this is apparently a normal way of acquiring equipment essential to keeping a moisture farm running.

I think we tend to overlook how important that makes the Jawas to Tatooine's economy.

Consider the practical problems of living on a remote moisture farm. Your evaporators need maintenance, your droids break down, and replacement parts aren't necessarily worth a merchant making a dedicated trip from Mos Eisley. You might need one particular component that hasn't been manufactured in decades.

The Jawas solve several problems at once. They collect discarded technology, salvage usable components, repair or refurbish equipment, and bring that inventory directly to people who would otherwise have to travel considerable distances to acquire it.

They're effectively a mobile secondhand market, recycling operation, and informal distribution network rolled into one.

And unlike a conventional merchant, they don't necessarily need functioning supply chains from offworld manufacturers. Their inventory is partly generated by the same environment they're selling it back into.

The Mandalorian gives us another perspective on this. The Jawas dismantle Din's Razor Crest with astonishing efficiency. Obviously that's theft, not a legitimate service, but it demonstrates just how capable they are at identifying, removing, transporting, and trading valuable machinery.

The interesting part is that their questionable business practices don't necessarily make them economically irrelevant. Quite the opposite. On a planet where legitimate institutions seem to have very limited reach outside the settlements, an unreliable mobile trader might still be preferable to having no accessible trader at all.

This also puts their treatment in A New Hope into an interesting context.

The Empire tracks the escaped droids to a Jawa sandcrawler and massacres its occupants. From the stormtroopers' perspective, they've eliminated some scavengers who handled stolen Imperial property.

But from the perspective of the surrounding settlements, they've potentially destroyed a mobile supplier that farmers and mechanics may have been dealing with for years.

I'm not suggesting Jawas have a monopoly on Tatooine's economy. The cities clearly have established merchants, workshops, and access to offworld trade. Their significance would be greatest in isolated areas where conventional commerce becomes expensive or inconvenient.

Still, there's something fascinating about a society where one of the most useful logistical institutions might be a collection of nomadic scavenger clans that nobody particularly trusts.

It makes me wonder how much influence the Jawas could theoretically exercise if they ever acted collectively. Not by controlling territory or commanding armies, but simply by deciding where their sandcrawlers would and wouldn't stop.

For all the attention the Hutts, the Empire, and local authorities receive, could the Jawas actually be among the most important groups keeping everyday life on Tatooine functioning?


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[CANON] Why is Palpatine's return in Rise of Skywalker hated so much?

0 Upvotes

I sense that I fail to understand why his return was so heavily criticized. Let me state the reasons why in principle the return could have been a good idea. First, I really disliked how Palpatine died in the original trilogy. For someone touted as the epitome of the dark side with insane force foresight abilities, Palpatine getting thrown off a shaft reactor is a pathetic way to go. I understand that this was done in the 80s at a time when we didn't have legends lore that pushed the force to planetary destruction levels (Vitiate, Nihilus, DE Palpatine, GM Luke), but I still find it disapointing in retrospective. So, I welcomed the return of Palpatine in the legends universe because it did him justice: it showed that Palpatine had found a level of mastery of the dark side that allowed him to cheat death to a point and cemented him as the greatest sith lord of all time in my opinion. And the way he died in Legends was pretty cool in my opinion and paved the way for luke skywalker to surpass him. As for Canon, I can understand why Palpatine's death was disappointing. For someone who just fried an entire fleet to die to Mary Sue holding two lightsabers was a major letdown to say the least. But I still don't understand why his reintroduction specifically was so unpopular; I have always thought Palpatine was an objectively great villain who deserved more.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

What if orson crennic was killed by jyn erso's mother?

9 Upvotes

He actually caused a lot of trouble afterwards, but will this scenario create a change for the better or the worse?


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

Two questions about the dyad and a bit of theorizing.

0 Upvotes

1 - Do you think the dyad as we see it in the films (it is called dyad in TROS, but their strange connection exists in TFA and TLJ) is what happens once it's *activated*?

Meaning, it was latent since Rey was 0 and Ben was 10, but Rey would not 'awake' for 19 years (in TFA), and only when she did the preconditions for the dyad's activation would be met.

2 - And, related to this, do you think

a) it was a natural, cosmic occurence? Or

b) was it man-made (an induced natural, cosmic occurrence), like those twins in Acolyte?

I'll expand b). How would 'man-made' would work in itself and in the context of what we have? The following is just a theory.

First, I guess the little shadow or darkness in little Ben could have been bridged to a womb through sorcery and then -death and decay that feeds new life, darkness rises and light to meet it- boom, a dyad.

Ben's shadow would have been 'decay'; dead Vader would have been 'death'. I mean, Snoke uses that ring with a rock of Mustafar on it, a bloodline object, and the even more potent link in TROS seems to have been facilitated by Kylo using Vader's helmet at the beginning of the film.

It is notable that Palpatine calls the dyad 'a power like life itself'. He rejuvenates himself with that power.

Now for this to work you need Vader.

Lucas said Vader was the Chosen One even as a sith.

Yes, the Jedi's Chosen One. He destroyed the sith, himself and Palpatine. But maybe he was the Dyad Sith's Chosen One too. The enemies of the Rule of Two and of the throne on Exegol.

So without a dead Chosen One there can be no dyad. And maybe this was the plan. Plagueis would have been given access to enough knowledge of 'sorcery' to create Anakin, maybe without knowing it, as it happened in pre-Disney canon.

The dyad is called 'prophesized' in the VD. Only two wayfinders were made. Maybe what we have in TROS is Revenge Of The Sith...against the Sith. 'All the sith' were destroyed, and this is how you give (re)birth to the Sith.

The Sith'ari prophecy is not canon, but its content is not far from this idea:

The Sith'ari will be free of limits.

The Sith'ari will lead the Sith and destroy them.

The Sith'ari will raise the Sith from death and make them stronger than before.


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[LEGENDS] Given the actual firepower yields of blasters and turbolasers in the OT & Legends, how should Star Wars battles realistically look—and how do hulls and armor even tank that kind of damage?

11 Upvotes

I’ve been digging through old fan calcs and Legends technical manuals (Incredible Cross-Sections, Essential Guide to Weapons and Technology) regarding the energy yields of Imperial weaponry in the Original Trilogy, and it honestly makes you wonder what Star Wars combat would actually look like if it followed its own physics consistently.

Just look at two baseline on-screen examples that usually get cited:

  • Infantry Blasters (E-11 in Docking Bay 94, ANH): When that stormtrooper misses Han and blows a ~60–80 cm wide, 25 cm deep crater out of the Mos Eisley duracrete wall, even conservative fragmentation math puts a single bolt at roughly 2 to 10 Megajoules (about 0.5–2 kg of TNT equivalent). Compared to a modern 5.56mm or 7.62mm rifle round (~2–3.5 kilojoules), every trooper is essentially carrying a rapid-fire 30mm autocannon or light RPG in an SMG-sized frame.
  • Starfighter Lasers & Light Turbolasers (The Asteroid Field, ESB): TIE fighter laser cannons routinely shatter massive boulders tens of meters across (10 to 500 tons of TNT per burst), while a Star Destroyer’s light point-defense turbolasers outright vaporize iron-silicate asteroids roughly the size of the Falcon (~30 meters wide, ~50,000 tons) in a single hit—which requires anywhere from 1 to 75 kilotons of TNT per bolt, even before getting into the gigaton-level heavy batteries from the ICS guides.

With numbers like that, the usual "WWII dogfights and Napoleonic line-infantry firefights" we see on screen start feeling pretty surreal.

So, taking these yields at face value:

  • How should ground and space battles in Star Wars actually look? If every infantry bolt hits like a high-explosive shell, taking cover behind thin crates or trading shots across a narrow corridor should be instant death from spalling, superheated air, and overpressure alone—and fleet engagements would be blinding, long-range exchanges of multi-kiloton flashes rather than broadside slugfests at visual range.
  • How do hulls and armor realistically survive this? Beyond handwaving everything as "deflector shields," what’s the lore/physics explanation for stormtrooper plastoid not turning the wearer into paste from kinetic/thermal shock, or starship durasteel hulls surviving even glancing blows from weapons that casually vaporize 50,000-ton asteroids?

r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] How long the Sullustans can live

2 Upvotes

Do they live longer than humans like Wookiees? If so, how long? The only info about their lifespan is the unofficial fan Wiki that seems to be rooted in fanon. Is there an actual proof or evidence within the stories that hint at their aging?


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[LEGENDS] What was the best part of legends, and why?

18 Upvotes

There's a lot of discussion of the worst parts of Legends, but not a lot of highlighting what was best in Legends. Where did Legends peak?

I'm a big fan of the Bantam era of Legends, so for me, peak legends is the comic book Mara Jade: by the Emperor's Hand, released in 1999. The comic is a collaboration between Michael Stackpole and Timothy Zahn, and features a conflict between their creations, Mara Jade and Ysanne Isard. What I like about the comic is that it's a fan-driven interpretation of Star Wars that explores original characters and conflicts outside the context of the movies, while expanding its own internal mythology.

What's your favorite part of Legends, and why do you like it?


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[CANON] How was Coruscant celebrating the death of Palpatine?

36 Upvotes

Even 11 months after the battle of endor, Coruscant was still firmly in Imperial control under Maz Amedda, wouldnt he Shut down any celebrations (Especially on the upper levels that we saw in The return of the jedi ending scenes)

Actually beyond that shouldn't Operation: Cinder have happened on Coruscant given that it was the seat of the empire that 'failed' Palpatine


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] Given Imperial TIE starfighters do not have hyperdrives, how do Imperial capital ships that deployed TIEs pursue Rebel ships that jumped into hyperspace?

153 Upvotes

Won't there be a delay while all of the TIEs return to their capital ship before the capital ship can make the jump to hyperspace in pursuit? For example, say a star destroyer deploys its TIEs to deal with a starfighter escort of an important ship and the important ship is able to jump to hyperspace. Will the star destroyer abandon all of its TIEs in deep space? Will someone else come to recover the TIEs? Is the star destroyer at risk from the escort starfighters who jumped to hyperspace with the important ship since the star destroyer doesn't have its own starfighters anymore?


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

[CANON] 'The shroud of the dark side has fallen'

0 Upvotes

How can the dark side's shroud fall? The dark side is not a person. It can't be shrouded. It is therefore a metaphor.

But in this same film we have Shmi. A person. She dies and she gets wrapped in a shroud. Not a metaphor.

But are we supposed to connect these two shrouds, one literal, the other metaphorical? Maybe.

'The shroud of the dark side' is the political. Empire. Palpatine. Shmi's shroud is the personal. Anakin.

The personal became the political in the following film, and Anakin's behavior towards Padme had everything to do with Shmi. 'I won't loose you the way I lost my mother'. And Palpatine connects Shmi with revenge right at the beginning of ROTS. (This is why the Imperial March is Vader's theme, and not the emperor's as it supposedly should be, and the reason why Vader's destiny and that of the empire were connected)

And there's maybe more. Shmi is a mother. She gave birth to Anakin. Since it is possible to apply 'shroud' to 'dark side' in a metaphorical way, it would also be possible to apply 'mother' to 'dark side' in the same way. And there are hints of Lucas thinking like this in the films.

If Anakin was literally born from Shmi, and we speak of the birth of Vader in ROTS, who was Vader's 'mother', but the dark side? Here's where the word 'natural', which we repeatedly hear in ROTS, becomes relevant. Mother Nature, in the evil sense of it: 'jungle', 'kill or be killed', etc, which is the yellow-eyed, or feral-eyed Palpatine.

The idea is latent in ROTJ. Vader saying to Luke 'the emperor will show you the true nature of the force'. And this when Luke had just asked Leia about her real mother. Maybe this is the idea behind the original -1980- emperor: the voice of a man, but played by a woman old enough to be Vader's mother and by a chimp -the jungle.

Maybe this is where Lucas' decision to make Anakin fatherless came from. If he chose to become Vader, to be born as Vader, then there was no father. Just himself and this evil 'mother'. So you can make Anakin fatherless by 'divine' choice. And maybe this is also where the Chosen One idea comes from.

Shmi's fate in reverse: It's creepy to think of the dark side as an unburied woman from whom the shroud has just fallen. Not awake, not walking her imperial march. Not yet.


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

[CANON] Human ARMY officers in the Galactic Republic-Empirs

32 Upvotes

We know the Republic Navy transitioned smoothly Into the Imperial Navy as most of their officer corps was human, rather than clone personnel. We see this with Tarkin, Ozzel, Rampart, Thrawn, and I’m sure more I’m forgetting.

But how did the Imperial Army get an experienced and professional cadre of officers? Of the top of my head the only non-clone army officer I could think of is Colonel Meebur Gascon. But he’s certainly not a human, and I’m not even sure he’s actually an Army officer.

Apparently there were planetary defense forces which actually took up the brunt of the galactic civil war, while the Clone Army was just the Regular/Federal Army. At the end of the conflict, did the new Imperial Army just consolidate all these defense forces into the new service? Or did the Empire really just stand up the Army in 19BBY from scratch and commission/mobilize a bunch of new officers.

This leads me to the crux of my question, what was General Veers doing during the Clone Wars before joining the Empire? Was he a field grade officer in some planet defense force (either republic or separatist), was he in the Grand Army of the Republic in some capacity, or did he just join the Army as a Lieutenant in 19BBY.

Thanks


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

[META] [Canon & Legends] Thrawn is Evil, and any attempts to show anything else than that veers dangerouslly close to condoning fascism and authoritarianism.

217 Upvotes

Now, I will preface this by saying that I think he is nuanced. He has layers to his character that will make you understand and say, "Okay, I see where he comes from." I think this part is important to Thrawn as a narrative character.

But with the new Ahsoka show, I've seen an uptick in posts and work across the fandom that Thrawn is this sort of misunderstood hero, nuanced antihero, or "ends justify the means" person. He is not Luthen (despite what some Andor fans think).

Thrawn works only as a fascist. He is a true believer in the cause, the same way Cyril Karn is, except he has legit power.

Sure, does he have nuance? Sure. He's trying to defeat the grysks, but he's willing to do this by actual genocide.

For instance, his mining project on Lothal? It would've eventually collapsed the biosphere and killed off most of the planet. If he had succeeded, it would've been a genocide of Lothal.

As part of the empire, he signs off on double-digit genocides and actively uses the products of those genocides to help him. Like, we see numerous times in canon Thrawn starving out planets and stripping people of the already limited resources they have. (Thrawn books)

And despite what people say, he's also nakedly power-hungry, just as the Emperor is. As he says, "the only thing that matters is power," and explains to Ezra that "actually, helping people is bad and using it to dominate people is good" (Paraphrasing what he says to Ezra in the Star Wars Rebels Finale).

Then there's the whole thing in Ahsoka, where he knows that the Grysks are a threat, and there are things waiting to hurt the larger galaxy, and the first thing he does is restart the galactic civil war. This is literally like the Hungarian Lords rising up against their king despite knowing that the Mongols are marching. Or like the Crusader states fighting each other for territory while Islamic powers are squeezing them.

And sometimes, I feel like Zahn himself has forgotten this.

In Rebels, there's a moment where Thrawn carbet bombs a city to lure out rebels. On the actual show, we see people die from this. But according to Zahn, this isn't true, because Thrawn only targeted abandoned buildings and killed no civilians. (I wish I were making this up.) There are almost moments where Zahn Straight-Up justifies the Empire as a sort of "the ends justify the means"

As the new Ahsoka season comes in a few months, there are a lot of fans who want to see Thrawn be right, that the suffering he inflicts is actually good. This idea is so contrary to the charecter that he is. (and imo removes his best traits)


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] In the Empire for matters that do not threaten the Empire's hold on power, does the general public enjoy civil rights such as due process and fair courts?

19 Upvotes

My thoughts are that if an authoritarian government wants to prevent rebellion, they should try to keep the population happy and an actively oppressed population is not happy. Also having a fair government makes people more willing to engage in economic activity and increase the amounts of taxes the Empire can collect. For common matters such as a business dispute or being accused of theft, do the people in court have a reasonable expectation of a fair process? Or is the Empire so corrupt that everything is determined by bribes like in a low income country on Earth?


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

[META] What did everyone think happened to Vader in a pre-prequel world?

32 Upvotes

The makeup in ESB and ROTJ does indicated he was likely badly burned, but outside of that we don’t get too much. What was commonly believed to have happened to him before we saw it on screen?


r/MawInstallation • • 6d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] If the Hoth ion cannon was doing most of the work of escorting the escaping transports, why didn't most of the starfighters go with the initial few transports?

25 Upvotes

It was acknowledged that two starfighters per transport are not going to be an effective escort against multiple star destroyers so why not try to save as many starfighters by sending them with the first few transports when the ion cannon is likely to still be operational.