This may be an unpopular opinion, however, from a utilitarian perspective, I think WCKD could be considered good. In The Death Cure movie, there were still 107,000 healthy people in Denver alone who didn't have the Flare. WCKD actually succeeded in making the cure, and they never gave up on humanityâthey kept working on it even after the virus invaded their building. If Thomas had been willing to stay with WCKD, he could have saved Newt and so many others at the cost of his own life. One single sacrifice compared to 107,000 innocent lives. By refusing, he prioritized his personal ideals over his friends and the rest of humanity, acting like a rigid deontologist (someone who believes taking a life is always wrong, regardless of the consequences).
WCKD was never purely good; their methods were painful and caused many deaths. However, they had a noble goal with a life-saving outcome, which in my opinion was the only viable option left. The Flare was a rapidly mutating virus that no one could have predicted, yet WCKDâs staff risked getting infected themselves every day to find a cure. Also, the necessary brain patterns only appear when the brain is active under severe stress. They needed the children to stimulate the "Killzone" to extract those patterns and create treatments like the Bliss (a temporary suppressant, speaking generally). The Bliss was what kept Cranks from turning right awayâtheir last little bit of hope. It couldnât have been made through a simple procedure like taking blood from the Immune. Therefore, these trials were medically necessary, and there was nothing else they could do.
Furthermore, the Maze wasnât set up to kill them. If they had followed the rules, nobody would have died, because that was how the Maze was designed: two trials to see which group could solve it faster with as few sacrifices as possible to find the cure. In the end, the Right Arm blew all of that up. They destroyed all the data, effectively condemning millions of people whom WCKD could have saved. All Thomas and the Right Arm managed to save were a few hundred Immunes.