There was a post earlier about someone visiting a psychology school and observing how the majority was women, looking "very woke", and that there was a lack of men to identify with.
Nothing inherently wrong with looking woke but there is indeed a lack of diversity within the psychology field.
General statistics:
- 80% of therapists and 88% social workers are women. Where are the men?. The degrees are earned, but the assymetry is not great.
- Statistically, women lean more progressive, and in academic psychology, the liberal-to-conservative ratio is estimated to be roughly 10:1.
- Women right now have Frontline power (meeting clients) and men have the Top-Down power (higher positions).
- This is just a generational lag though, as women earn 80% of all doctorates, and will soon be in majority on all levels.
About "wokeness" specifically, and the feminization of institutions.
Some social scientists propose that wokeness isn't just ideology but comes as a byproduct, from the feminization of institutions.
About change and male-specific approach to therapy
While these papers and articles shouldn't be swallowed whole, they do come with well needed perspectives and questions.
No matter what the root causes are, there is a lack of diversity within the psychology field. Both political and based on gender.
But, as we all know, no power structure will ever reform itself, not even psychology, which idealistically would be neutral science. In fact, the Rockefeller and Ford Foundations have spent a lot of money shaping the social sciences since the 1920s, and feminist and gender ideology since the 1970s.
Which is also why I think feminist articles like how the male mental health crisis and loneliness up to men to solve on their own lack nuance and is unfair.
If feminism have received major donations and women are now in institutional majority â more specifically education, healthcare, and mental health servicesâ they are indeed expected to care about men's and boy's mental health issues. Not because they're obligated to do individual emotional labour, but because they hold institutional power.
Psychologists and researchers focusing on men's issues â such as Dr. John Barry and Richard Reeves â have already proven with their grassroot-funded platforms, that men engage enthusiastically when help is action-oriented, solution-focused, and framed without stigma.
This rethoric of how women can't fix men's issues and men need to fix it themselves is quite condescending and inaccurate. Men do seek help, when the help received are designed for them, which is why having a majority of feminist and woke ideology can become harmful. It create blind spots and bias.
Donations from Rockefeller and Ford
Feminism has received a lot of money. One belief is they shared a common goal with feminism â dismantling the family structure, but for different reasons.
- Feminism; because family and marriage was seen as inherently oppressive.
- Rockefeller and Ford; because weakening tight-knit family and community bonds makes people easier to manage, tax, and capitalize on. Two incomes being necessary and daycare and is more profitable.
This is documented about Ford and Rockefeller:
- Starting in the 1920s with Rockefeller, and later joined by the Ford Foundation, they were the largest private funders of university social science departments and behavioral research.
- Directors explicitly wrote about using behioral science and psychology to stabilize industrial society, and manage social change.
- During the 1970s, the Ford Foundation invested tens of millions of dollars in academic women's studies, gender-equality organizations, university feminist scholarships and gender-policy think tanks.
- Rockefeller also helped fund women's groups that later shaped UN Women policy frameworks on gender roles, family structure etc.
- There is no Men's rights group in UN. Men and boys are only mentioned as instruments for women's empowerment, in HeforShe.
Though.
This isn't me saying we should remove women from psychology. They earned their degrees, all the way from girlhood up to graduation, and hopefully, they'll do a lot of good.
Women shouldn't step back, but to step up, and acknowledge their increasing institutional power and duty, also towards men and boys.
Also highlighting the need for diversity, and why a majority within psychology having woke and feminist ideology, can become an issue.