r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question High stator tooth tip flux density

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

I'm a senior electrical engineering student designing a 12-slot, 10-pole inrunner BLDC motor for my capstone project using FEMM. One of my biggest challenges has been excessive magnetic flux density around the stator tooth tips, with localized peaks reaching approximately 4 T, while I'm aiming to keep the stator flux density below 1.6 T.

I've been experimenting with different tooth-tip geometries, including adding fillets, reshaping the tooth wings, and widening the tooth neck to distribute the magnetic flux more evenly. Although these changes have improved the overall flux distribution visually, I'm still experiencing significant localized saturation near the tooth tips.

Does anyone have recommendations for improving the tooth-tip geometry to reduce saturation without sacrificing too much torque? I'm also interested in whether these unusually high flux-density readings could indicate an issue with my FEMM model, material properties, or mesh rather than the actual motor geometry.


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Anyone know where I can find these parts

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Hey all hoping someone can help me track down some parts.

I have an xpelair WX6 that the bearings were shot. I'M Having a lot of trouble sourcing out a replacement fan that will fit into hole in the wall.

I Figured I'd open it up and see if I can fix the bearings.

The non shaft end the little retaining ring in the first and 2nd photo was all worn out and not holding the little brass bearing in place.

5th photo is what the entire assembly is supposed to look like.

Anyone know what the ring and bearing would be called so I can narrow down what parts I need?

Much appericated


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question Help picking a motor

2 Upvotes

Last year the company I work for purchased a wood chipper knife blade grinder. And it is quite trash and I am hoping to build a DIY better version. The only experience I have is in FPV drone motors so not anything in the heavy duty side. The shop is wired for both 110 and 220 and I would like it to be speed adjustable. I am hoping for something in the 1.5 5 hp range and it is gonna have a pretty decent load on it. My plan is to weld a tank which will be full of water. There will be a fixture table inside of the water that holds the chipper blades at the correct angle and then the motor will be on top on two linear rails. I’m not sure if this gives enough details for the kind of motor I would need, but please let me know if you have any suggestions or need more information.


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question Soldering wires to stepper motors coils

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello,

I have been trying to build a cnc machine using two dvd drives and an arduino.

I previously asked what people thought of what I had done: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskElectronics/comments/1x91xg6/dupont_cables_and_stepper_motors_soldering/

I finally had time to modify the circuit accordingly to the advices I received:

- I removed the Dupont wires and used bell wire instead

- I added some tin to solder where it was needed

- I tested for continuity with a multimeter to find the coil pairs of the stepper motors and found out that both are A: 1 and 2; B: 3 and 4; Hence the colors of the bell wires.

But when I took the photos I realised that perhaps the fact that the stripped parts of the wires are in contact could cause a short circuit?

Also I learnt from AI that bell wire has a solid conductor and so is more fragile than most wires which have stranded conductors.

What is your take on what I did?


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question Need help with capacitor wiring

1 Upvotes

My shop compressor (IR 7.5hp) blew a capacitor. Actually blew up, and pulled out some of the wiring. I have new caps, but cannot figure out how to wire them in. IR referred me to the motor manufacturer, WEN. WEN told me that they have no official wiring diagram for that motor. The motor has five capacitors, which seems odd to me.

There are six wires in the capacitor compartment, plus seven jumpers-

Two unlabeled wires that go to the inertial switch

Two wires labeled "1U" and "2U" that connect to the 220 single phase inputs

two wires labeled "5/2V" and "8/5V" which I guess go to the caps.

Also seven jumpers to connect caps together.

I am no electrician, and I don't want to mess up my expensive and heavy motor. I attach the plate for the motor, and hope for help.

Toad


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question Clanky reduction gearbox

Thumbnail vewo.io
1 Upvotes

I have some bldc made by a reputable brand but some of the gearboxes unfortunately have clanking sounds. I added extra lube on all the clanking ones(just into the gearbox where it fits into the motor I did not dismantle the gearbox) and while some have the noise issue gone, some still have this issue persisting. Any advice on how I can resolve this issue, and any idea what’s causing some of the gearboxes creating gear noises? Thanks in advance


r/Motors • • 1d ago

Open question Looking for STS 3215 Bus Servo

1 Upvotes

Hey all, We are working on a project and requires STS3215 17Kg or 19Kg. If you are trying to sell one or if you guys know where i could get one for cheapest, please do share. Thanks!!


r/Motors • • 2d ago

Open question Alternative stepper drivers?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I need replacement stepper drivers for my 3d printer.

The OEM are TMC2160 with a 16pin stickstep footprint.

l've found some TMC51 60 online that I thought could work. But some of them have bad ratings and I want to improve reliability not make it worse.

This is for an flsun T1 Pro

A friend of mine gave me this printer for cheap. l'm aware it's kinda shitty, but I want to breath some life into it. The OEM has replacements but they're notoriously slow and difficult to get parts from.

Lmk what y'all think!


r/Motors • • 2d ago

Open question Why do EV and servo motor rotors use skewed magnets? A quick breakdown of the 4 main geometries (and their trade-offs)

1 Upvotes

If you’ve ever torn down an EV traction motor or a high-precision servo, you’ve probably noticed the rotor magnets aren't always lined up straight with the shaft. Instead, they’re angled, stepped, or arranged in a "V" pattern.

In permanent magnet motors, magnet skewing is one of the most common ways to smooth out cogging torque, reduce torque ripple, and make the back-EMF waveform more sinusoidal (which makes field-oriented control much happier and keeps acoustic noise down). The catch? You usually sacrifice a small percentage of peak average torque and add manufacturing complexity.

Depending on budget, rotor length, and bearing constraints, engineers generally pick one of four configurations:

1. Continuous Skew

  • How it works: The magnet itself is shaped or magnetized at a continuous helical angle along the axial length of the rotor.
  • The good: Theoretically gives the smoothest magnetic flux transition and lowest harmonic distortion.
  • The catch: Custom skewed magnets and specialized magnetizing fixtures are expensive. Once the rotor gets long, manufacturing and handling single-piece skewed magnets becomes a headache.

2. Step-Skew (Segmented Skew)

  • How it works: Instead of angling the magnet itself, you split the rotor stack into multiple axial sections (commonly 3 to 5 steps) using standard, straight arc magnets, and offset each section by a calculated mechanical angle.
  • The good: Much cheaper and easier to mass-produce using off-the-shelf magnet geometries while getting very close to continuous-skew performance.
  • The catch: Requires tighter assembly fixturing/indexing so the segments don't shift under high RPM and thermal cycling.

3. V-Shaped (Herringbone) Skew

  • How it works: Rotor segments are arranged in a symmetrical "V" along the shaft axis (either continuous or stepped).
  • The good: Standard single-direction skewing creates a parasitic axial force under load that pushes the rotor against the bearings. A symmetrical V-pattern cancels those axial loads out, which is huge for bearing life in high-speed EV powertrains.
  • The catch: More assembly steps and higher tooling precision compared to a simple one-way step-skew.

4. Zig-Zag Skew

  • How it works: Extends the V-shape concept into multiple alternating segments along the axial direction.
  • The good: Cancels out primary axial forces and suppresses higher-order spatial harmonics for an ultra-flat torque profile.
  • The catch: High assembly complexity and cost. Usually reserved for high-end traction or precision motion systems where NVH and torque ripple targets are super strict.

References / Further Reading:

  • Hendershot, J. R., & Miller, T. J. E. — Design of Brushless Permanent-Magnet Machines (covers analytical skew factor calculations and cogging torque reduction).
  • Various IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications papers on step-skewed PM rotors and parasitic axial force mitigation.

For anyone working on motor design or manufacturing here: are you mostly seeing 3-step or 4-step V-skew in current EV builds, or are more teams shifting the skew onto the stator slots instead to keep the rotor simple?


r/Motors • • 3d ago

Open question How do I put this motors "lid" back on?

Post image
5 Upvotes

My dad had a broken hand vacuum and I wanted to fix it. The motor wasnt turning and upon opening it I realized there was oil on the conductive pads the brushes were touching. I cleaned it up and wanted to put the "lid" back on but I couldnt because the part with the conductive pads is thicker than the shaft and when I spread the brushes to put them on the shaft, as I am closing the lid the brushes get stuck on the conductive pads. And since by that point there is no opening left to shove anything iinside to spread the brushes further I cannot close the lid now. I hope I was able to explain the problem correctly, if I could not tell me and Ill try again.


r/Motors • • 2d ago

Open question Motor Selection for prototype

1 Upvotes

I am wondering which type of motor I should use for my engineering capstone project. We are converting up and down motion into rotational motion. Instead of doing a one way gear set with a flywheel on it, we have decided to do a gear set up where the input gear goes 180 degrees on the up motion and then goes back 180 degrees on the down motion. The gear ratio does the work to spin the motor. So the motor is spinning in a back and forth way. We are trying to maximize our RPM through the gear ratio. We are hoping to produce 500mW from around 3 inches of vertical motion but mostly want to maximize our output. Right now we are just planning on having this going into a battery. We have explored using a BLDC motor because it works on slightly lower RPM. A DC motor also seems like the simplest option so we don't have to deal with 3 phase of the BLDC motor. How should we go about deciding a motor for our generator in this set up?

Thank you for any input!


r/Motors • • 3d ago

General For the winders out there what are some of the real head scratchers you have come across?

1 Upvotes

Come across a real good one a 15/2.5 kw SA/ SWF hoist motor, the high speed is simple enough being a 2 pole but the low speed is doing my head in a bit. The name plate states 420 RPM at 50 HZ so indicating 14 pole but the way they wound it in factory were in 6 groups of 4 pitch of 1-5 full slot (The groups I worked out would be 18 of 1, 3 of 2 consequential) . I sent my data away to another rewinder who as access to ESEA and he dug up some more info that indicates it is actually a 12 pole with 8% slip and suggesting winding it 12 of 2 and 24 of 1 sequential half slot as the consquential would be odd grouping.


r/Motors • • 3d ago

Open question Jet Mill/Drill motor smoking after brief usage, centrifugal switch, start cap or winding issue?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Motors • • 4d ago

Answered Help in Sourcing a DC motor

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Hey all,

I'm trying to fix up a vintage slot toy from Japan and I'm not sure what kind of motor is needed.

The motor runs off 2 D cell batteries and is used to drive a ~1:4 pulley to spin the slot wheels.

Given casino wheels spin at around 80 rpm the toy must be a bit lower, so I'm guessing 60 rpm. The motor I think is running at roughly 240 rpm at 3 volts

I tried finding something that would fit that but was given too many options so I need assistance in determining what motor to buy.

I'm in Australia, so hopefully I can find everything I need here.


r/Motors • • 5d ago

Assistance with choosing a silent motor

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I need help finding a virtually silent DC motor (preferably with a gearbox) for a kinetic art project. The motor uses a friction drive to slowly rotate a decorative disc inside a wooden frame.

Current setup & specs:

  • Motor: Pololu 298:1 Micro Metal Gearmotor LP
  • Operating voltage: 2V DC
  • Drive geometry: 40 mm friction drive wheel rotating a 210 mm outer rim (approx. 5.25:1 reduction)

Electrically and mechanically, this setup works great—my project runs on very low currents, and the torque and speed at 2V are spot on. However, the metal gearbox itself generates way too much noise under load inside the wooden enclosure (which acts like a soundboard), and adding vibration isolation hasn't solved the issue.

Could you recommend a much quieter alternative that meets these criteria:

  • Standard brushed/coreless DC (I want to avoid redesigning the electronics for a BLDC setup)
  • Very low current draw at ~2V (comparable to the N20 LP series)
  • Compact size (to fit inside a slim wooden frame)
  • Near-silent operation under light-to-moderate load

For example, would switching to a lower gear ratio (like 75:1 or 50:1 LP) paired with a much smaller drive wheel (e.g., 8–10 mm) noticeably reduce the gearbox noise while keeping the same final speed, or should I look into a completely different motor/gearbox type (such as plastic gears or a planetary gearbox)?

Thanks in advance for your advice!


r/Motors • • 5d ago

General Where can I get a rewinding done for this 1950s refrigerator compressor

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/Motors • • 5d ago

Open question Why do two small BLDC motors with similar specs sometimes have very different noise and vibration levels?

0 Upvotes

I've been looking into what actually determines the quality of small electric motors, especially BLDC motors, miniature DC motors, and high-speed spindle motors.

Most comparisons focus on RPM, torque, efficiency, and power consumption. But there's another side to motor performance that doesn't always get enough attention: mechanical precision.

Two motors with similar electrical specifications can behave quite differently in terms of vibration, noise, heat generation, and long-term reliability.

A few factors seem particularly important:

1. Rotor balance and shaft alignment

Even a small amount of imbalance can generate noticeable vibration at high speeds. Poor alignment can also introduce additional loads on the bearings.

2. Bearing selection and internal clearance

Miniature deep groove ball bearings are commonly used in small motors, but choosing the correct dimensions is only the beginning.

Internal clearance, raceway accuracy, shaft and housing fits, and operating temperature all affect how a bearing performs.

Too little operating clearance can increase friction and heat, while excessive clearance may contribute to vibration or noise.

3. Lubrication and bearing protection

Grease selection and lubrication quantity can make a significant difference, especially in high-speed applications.

Metal-shielded bearings (ZZ) and rubber-sealed bearings (2RS) also involve different trade-offs between contamination protection, friction, and operating speed.

4. Manufacturing and assembly consistency

Even when the motor design is good, differences in bearing installation, shaft tolerances, or assembly procedures can affect performance between production batches.

Of course, bearings aren't responsible for every motor problem. Electromagnetic forces, PWM-related noise, rotor imbalance, and mechanical resonance can also contribute.

What I'm particularly curious about is how engineers distinguish bearing-related vibration from electromagnetic or rotor-related vibration in small motors.

Do you usually start with vibration frequency analysis, current measurements, temperature monitoring, or mechanical inspection?

And in your experience, how much difference can proper bearing selection and installation make to the noise and lifespan of a miniature BLDC motor?


r/Motors • • 5d ago

Open question [Design review] Relay stop line and isolated DAC throttle for a 48 V motor controller

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes
Two small circuits for a 48 V golf cart controller (Curtis 1268). Schematics attached.

1. Stop line
- Key feed, then the stock pedal switch with relay K10 in parallel. Then relay K13, then two NC e-stops, then the controller input (J1-8).
- Both relays are Finder 40.61 with 12 V coils, driven by NPN transistors (2N2222, 1k base resistors, 1N4007 flyback diodes) from an Arduino Nano.
- PC817 optos (22k 1/2 W series resistor, 1N4148 reverse diode) watch the key feed, the pedal node and the line after the e-stops, so the Nano can detect a welded contact.

2. Throttle
- An MCP4725 DAC on an isolated 5 V supply, I2C through an ISO1540, referenced to the controller's B-.
- Output goes through a 10-turn trimmer to the NO side of a DPDT relay. NC is the stock pedal pot wiper. Common goes to the controller throttle input (J1-15), with a 10k pull-down to the pot low end.
- Range is held at 0.5 to 4.5 V because the controller faults at 4.7 V.

Questions
1. Are the opto resistor values right for a 48 to 65 V DC line? (About 3 mA, 0.19 W in the 22k at 64.8 V full charge.)
2. Any issue with 2N2222s driving these coils?
3. Is the isolation on the DAC side sound, and is the 10k pull-down sensible?
4. Anything you'd change?

Thanks

r/Motors • • 7d ago

Hi guys , is this wired correctly ?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I wired this electric motor up but it’s giving me lots of problems , it’s overworking to run and it over heats even with no load attached in about 5 minutes


r/Motors • • 7d ago

Open question Why new bench grinder heats up very quickly?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is it normal to work heat up like this


r/Motors • • 7d ago

Open question Vacuum Motor Replacement for a Carpet Extractor.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm trying to replace this vacuum motor in a carpet extractor. On the old motor, the internals got shredded from sucking something up through the vent. The OEM motor is like $500 so I was wondering if I can just get a three stage vacuum motor on Amazon that's nearly exactly the same. Anything I should be aware of before making the purchase? Thanks!


r/Motors • • 8d ago

Open question 4-in-1 ESC: outer motor pad dead on both motors on one side?

1 Upvotes

SEQURE Blueson A2 4-in-1 (AM32), RS2205 motors. The two motors on one side twitch and only work intermittently; the other side runs fine.
On both bad motors, pads 2–3 on continuity test beep, but pad 1 doesn’t. And its symmetric so (1-2-3) (3-2-1) being the three phases of the two motors, port 1 of both dont seem to be connected.
On the good side all pads beep on the continuity test with each other.
My soldering is good no worries on that im sure. I cant seem to find a solution to this, if someone is familiar with this i would really appreciate it if you could help me out.


r/Motors • • 9d ago

Open question Cheap and reliable way to continuously monitor load on a stepper motor?

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for an inexpensive and reliable way to continuously monitor the mechanical load on a NEMA 17 stepper motor connected to a 5.18:1 reduction gearbox.

The motor operates at relatively low speeds and frequently changes direction. I don't need highly accurate torque measurements in N·m, just a consistent indication of how much load the motor is experiencing so I can detect increases in resistance before it stalls.

I'm currently using a TMC2209 driver with an ESP32.

I've considered a few options:

- StallGuard4: Seems promising, but from what I've read, it's unreliable at low speeds.

- Current sensing: I've previously used current sensors with servos to detect increased mechanical load, but I understand that stepper drivers regulate winding current, making this more difficult.

- Rotary torque sensors: Would be ideal, but commercial options seem far too expensive.

- Flexible shaft coupler: Possibly measuring torsional deflection to estimate torque, although I'm unsure how practical or accurate this would be.

- Load cell: Measuring reaction torque could work, but I'd prefer something compact that doesn't require significantly modifying the motor mounting arrangement.

I'm trying to keep the cost as low as possible, ideally under $20–30 CAD.

Has anyone implemented a cheap method for continuously estimating stepper motor load at low RPM, particularly with frequent direction changes?

I'm open to DIY solutions, additional sensors, or clever ways of using the existing driver. I don't need precision, just reliable and repeatable relative load measurements.


r/Motors • • 10d ago

Electric motors keep giving up , have no idea why

Thumbnail gallery
13 Upvotes

Hi everyone , I’ve been having problems getting my electric motor to power this wheel smoothly and I’m at my last straw as nothing is working, any input is much appreciated,

this is a pewter wheel for polishing stones on , underneath the bench there is a pulley system powered by a 3 phase electric motor , there’s a belt connected to the pulley which is tightened to the bottom half of the spindle which spins the wheel, The tips on both ends of the spindle sit on a block of rose wood which allow the wheel to spin freely.

I previously used single fase motors and they would work so hard to get the wheel up to speed they’d just over heat and give up due to too much tension on the motor , so I had just assumed a more powerful 3 phase motor would fix the issue but it still cannot handle the load it gets so hot to the point it just melts the insides.

What I don’t understand is that the guy who designed this setup has multiple benches with the exact same pulley system with single phase motors powering the exact same wheels and for many years he has faced no issues with overloading or tension on the motor, so I’ve gone and built the setup identical to his and the motors dont like it. It just doesn’t make any sense, i have tried tightening the belt and loosening it, have had multiple electricians check the wiring and the power and no issues there , I’ve secured the motor and straightened everything up about a hundred times but the motor just cannot seem to take the spin the wheel consistently without it overheating and blowing up . Something is clearly incorrect and I just cannot understand what is I feel like I’ve tried every possible thing .

I am in Ireland and the guy who designed this setup is in UK and he can only tell me that he has multiple set ups exactly the same and there is no reason for it not to work 🤯🤯🤯