For context, I’m a newer Challenge Fan (started watching when WOTW was airing) and since then, I’ve gone back and watched Fresh Meat 2 onwards, along with all the newer seasons and spin-offs as they’ve aired.
I then went back and started at Inferno 2, and planned on watching Seasons 10-18 in order. I just currently finished watching the Island and I have to say it does not deserve its label as the worst (or one of the worst challenge seasons).
Personally, what I value most in a Season of The Challenge is gameplay (which does not necessarily mean having daily challenges), good drama and storylines, and The Island delivers.
Let’s get the ugly out of the way. And yes that means Bananas and Kenny. They were HORRIBLE. Their comments towards almost every woman this season, along with their straight up verbal abuse of Kellyanne and Evelyn was DISGUSTING to watch. Then of course there’s the added layer of bigotry when it came to them making fun of Evelyn’s sexuality. I almost wanted to quit watching after Episode 1 when Kenny calls Tonya every name under the sun. That being said, is the misogyny unprecedented? After watching Inferno 3 and Gauntlet 3 back to back, I feel like this era of the challenge is riddled male chauvinistic misogynists.
Bananas’ only storyline on Inferno 3 is shitting on Susie/Cara, saying the girls are useless and horrible (while being backed up by his male teammates), playing with that stupid blow up doll, etc. This is the same season CT gets sent home for punching a gay guy. The Gauntlet 3 is a continuation of that behaviour, but with Evan and Kenny taking the reigns, dropping the r slur left and right, calling the girls fat, ugly, useless, etc with Adam, CT, Danny and other men backing them up.
This is not to say that any of that behaviour is excusable, my point is simply that it is not unique to the Island, which I often see as a main criticism of the season as a whole..
Now i’d like to back up why I think it is a good season. I’m not sure if this is a popular season, but I feel like women kinda carry The Challenge from a narrative perspective. Most of my favourite Challenge cast members are women, and especially in Era 3 and 4, women just bring much more value when it comes to the entertainment of the show.
On that note, this female cast is STACKED. FOUR out of 10 women are champions in Evelyn, Rachel, Tonya and Johanna, with ALL of them being interesting characters this season and in the past, Robin and Paula as reliable vets, 2 promising newer players in Jenn and Colie (admittedly just from a drama perspective for Colie lol) and a fantastic rookie in Kellyanne. Even the worst choice, Ashli, had noteable moments this season.
I wanna highlight specifically the 3 that end up being my favourites this season; Kellyanne and Evelyn (who get a lot of credit for this season), and someone who had not stood out in a majorly positive way for me before this season- ROBIN.
Robin was an absolute star this season and I find it crazy that no one talks about her run this season? She has several fantastic moments this season as well as a rollercoaster of a run, while also being likeable in comparison to everyone else?
Episode 3 of this season, which is an all-time episode for me, mostly due to Robin, ends up with Robin getting 18 confessionals, which is a record up until this point in Challenge history. She goes from gaining confidence about wanting to go into a face-off, confronting Kenny and Johanna after they try intimidating her, making out with Dan, then calling Rachel out for wanting an easy key-win against 2 rookies, throwing herself in against Rachel, and then dramatically sobbing in the vote against Rachel, saying she knows how to sail and winning a key.
2 particular quotes that will forever stick out to me from her:
“Jo, you ready to go in on a face-off, me and you? Im just curious when you wanna go. You’re gonna wait til they sail off and wave at you on the Island? That’s your game plan then, to fuck your way to the fucking end?”
“Rachel, as a VET-TER-AN proposed that she go in against 2 rookies. Well Rachel, I ALSO am a VET-TER-AN, and I already said I wanna go in and im not afraid to go against you.” - Robin
She continues to have several other arguments throughout the season with Ashli, Dan, Bananas, etc as well as memorable dramatic moments and likeable ones when she sticks up for Evelyn. I just wanted to highlight her because I don’t think she gets the props she deserves for this season! Also, I believe this is her 3rd final in 6 seasons? Props to her!
I think I want to highlight how passionately I was rooting for Kellyanne, Evelyn and Robin (all of whom make it to the last episode of the season), in a way that I was not aggressively rooting for anyone from Seasons 10-16? I think that highlights a positive in the storytelling of The Island.
Episodes 1-6 are just iconic in terms of the sheer amount of drama we get, combined with the build-up to Evelyn taking Johnny’s key and that infamous speech when she does. There is a lot of narrative payback here, its like Big Easy losing for the vets after they were worried about women all season TIMES TEN.
While it becomes obvious after Evelyn’s key is taken back that the majority alliance will steamroll, we end up getting a lot of the dynamics of the structure of said alliance, and a lot of politicking and paranoia around who is going to be in which boat, which leads to why I don’t think this season is GREAT.
That last episode is infuriating to watch, and its strangely because of an issue that we have in modern day Challenges. Why were the boats not gendered?? You could honestly go back and say there should have been male and female face-off days, which also would have helped limit the control of this alliance that was majority male, and shifted the power, and I would agree, but luckily it does not affect the game as much because we end up with an equal amount of women and men at the end.
However, allowing for 3 men to be on the same boat not only makes the game unfair and the result predictable, it also hurts the narrative of the season. For how great Evelyn’s moment of taking Johnny’s key was, she now joins him, Kenny and Derrick in an unsatisfying manner (with no real incentive not to- good decision making on her part) and it kinda sours the overall season.
All they had to do was make it so that 2 men and 2 women must be on each boat, and then do a schoolyard pick. This would guarantee Bananas and Kenny being on separate teams, and at least one of Jenn/Robin/Paula would become champions here. Had they made this clear and established it, Evelyn probably doesn’t even take Dunbar’s key over Johnny’s. It seems like such a random and stupid choice, given they’ve had an equal amount of girl and guy days in every season up until this point? Does anyone else feel like this would change their opinions on this season?
Anyways I know that was a rant, but I’d love to hear others’ thoughts on this season (specifically thoughts on how this season changes if the boats are gendered, there are gendered face-off days and Robin, because I don’t see a lot said about her on this season).
TLDR: The island is overhated, and is a good, but not great season of the show. Secondary note, Robin is underrated on this season. The season would be great if the boats were gendered. Please share your thoughts regarding these topics