There seems to be quite a bit of confusion about what actually happened at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) regarding Myanmar and the Rohingya. Here is a simplified explanation.
- A little historical context
The Rohingya are a predominantly Muslim community historically associated with Rakhine State (formerly Arakan) in western Myanmar.
Their historical origins are contested. Muslim communities existed in the region before British colonial rule, although migration from neighbouring parts of British India increased considerably during the colonial period (1824โ1948).
This contributed to longstanding tensions over identity, land and belonging.
Following independence in 1948, armed insurgencies and separatist movements emerged in parts of northern Arakan. Relations between the state and Muslim communities deteriorated further.
In 1982, Myanmar introduced a citizenship law that excluded the Rohingya from the officially recognised national races. Most subsequently faced severe difficulties obtaining citizenship, leaving many effectively stateless.
- What happened in 2016โ2017?
In October 2016 and again in August 2017, the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) attacked Myanmar security posts.
The Myanmar military responded with extensive clearance operations in northern Rakhine State.
Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya fled into neighbouring Bangladesh.
International investigations documented widespread killings, sexual violence, village destruction and forced displacement.
Myanmar maintained that these were legitimate counterterrorism operations against an armed insurgency. However, the scale and nature of the alleged abuses attracted international scrutiny.
- Why was Myanmar taken to the ICJ?
In November 2019, The Gambia brought a case against Myanmar at the International Court of Justice.
Why The Gambia? Because both countries are parties to the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The Convention creates obligations for all signatory countries to prevent and punish genocide. The Gambia argued that Myanmar had violated these obligations.
Importantly, The Gambia did not need to be directly affected by the events. Countries that have signed the Genocide Convention have a shared legal interest in ensuring that its provisions are respected.
- What exactly was Myanmar accused of?
The central allegation was genocide.
Under international law, genocide is not simply mass killing or ethnic persecution. It requires:
- Certain prohibited acts, such as killing members of a protected group or causing them serious physical or mental harm.
- Specific intent to destroy that national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part.
The second requirement is particularly important. It is what distinguishes genocide from other serious international crimes.
The Gambia argued that the military operations were part of a campaign intended to destroy the Rohingya population, rather than simply a response to armed insurgency.
- What did the ICJ actually decide?
There were several important stages:
- January 2020: The ICJ ordered Myanmar to take immediate measures to prevent genocidal acts against the Rohingya and preserve relevant evidence. This was an interim order, NOT a final finding of genocide.
- July 2022: The Court rejected Myanmar's objections to its jurisdiction, allowing the case to proceed.
- January 2026: The Court heard the full case.
- November 2026: The ICJ delivered its final judgment, finding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State during the 2017 operations.
This is an important distinction: the Court has now moved beyond examining allegations and has made a final determination on the merits.
- What happens to Myanmar now?
The judgment creates binding international legal obligations for Myanmar.
These include:
- Investigating and punishing individuals responsible for genocide, where warranted.
- Taking measures to prevent future genocidal acts.
- Providing restitution and compensation for the harm caused.
- Taking steps towards facilitating the safe, voluntary and dignified return of displaced Rohingya.
However, there is an important limitation.
The ICJ cannot arrest Myanmar's military leaders, send in peacekeepers or directly enforce its judgment.
If Myanmar refuses to comply, The Gambia can refer the matter to the UN Security Council. However, enforcement can be complicated by the veto powers of the five permanent members.
- Does this mean Myanmar's military leaders will go to prison?
Not automatically.
The ICJ deals with the legal responsibility of countries, not the criminal responsibility of individuals.
Individual military officers and political leaders would need to face separate criminal proceedings.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) has a separate investigation concerning crimes against the Rohingya, particularly crimes against humanity involving deportation and persecution.
- What does this mean for the Rohingya?
The judgment is a significant legal recognition of what happened to the community.
However, it does not automatically resolve the Rohingya's problems.
Questions remain over citizenship, freedom of movement, property rights, political representation and security.
Furthermore, Myanmar is currently experiencing civil war and political fragmentation. Even if the authorities wanted to implement the judgment, exercising effective control over Rakhine State would be a major challenge.
Ultimately, a court judgment cannot by itself create the political and security conditions necessary for the Rohingya to return safely.
In short:
- The Gambia brought the case against Myanmar in 2019 under the Genocide Convention.
- The ICJ initially ordered Myanmar to take preventive measures in 2020, without yet determining that genocide had occurred.
- In November 2026, the Court delivered its final judgment finding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya.
- Myanmar now has binding legal obligations concerning accountability, prevention, restitution and compensation.
- The biggest challenge is enforcement, particularly given Myanmar's current political and military situation.
One final point: The ICJ judgment is not a ruling on whether the Rohingya should have an independent state, whether Rakhine State should have autonomy, or which historical account of Rohingya origins is correct.
Those are separate historical and political questions.
The ICJ was asked to determine whether Myanmar violated the Genocide Convention. That is the specific question it has now answered.