r/NIPT • • 2d ago

CVS + Amnio negative Placenta can have patches of normal and abnormal and a CVS does not rule this out. Attached multiple studies of TERM placental biopsies help us see this. Amnio is the best diagnostic test during pregnancy after a positive NIPT. Clinicians - stop ordering a CVS.

Post image
15 Upvotes

Click the flare and search the sub about information about CVS.
CVS for t21 positive nipt has the highest chance of being correct. It’s not recommend by anyone who actually studies placenta for any other abnormality with normal Sonos. Clinicians, please stop ordering CVS after a positive NIPT and normal Sonos. Placental term biopsies consistently show us that only SOME regions in the placenta carry abnormal cells and CVS only biopsies ONE of these regions.

To GCs that keep advocating for CVS - Stop this nonsense and false information to patients and educate your community. It’s been 7 years here at the very least.

Once a non-mosaic CVS result is accepted as diagnostic, most of those pregnancies end without anyone checking the fetus. There is no known post termination testing of CVS positive pregnancies and this would be devastating to patients. That’s what u would call confirmation bias. So the false-positive rate for non-mosaic CVS is not something that has been studied but term placental studies incidentally find them. Term placental biopsies are also not ever done in regular Obgyn practices, they are only done in studies.

The problem with the medical and often times the science communities where people do not have critical thinking is assuming something makes sense and then basically going with that thought and assumption. This is also what happened with Ivf and Day three embryos were thrown out for the longest time because they said well if Day three embryos were abnormal biopsies then surely the baby is also abnormal that proved not to be true but it took about 10 or 15 years and growing embryos day five. Then there was an assumption that mosaic embryos would lead to mosaic babies and they were discarded. That was also an assumption and then that also proved to be true over the 10 years. There’s a real problem with assumption of something that should make sense, but it does not if you actually test it. If they did do do some study for CVS post terminations you’d have to blind the participants because that would be devastating and likely would lead to many law suits. I’m not sure this will ever be done for this reason which is the worse confirmation bias I can think of.

The term placenta studies show abnormal cells in the mesenchymal core, not just the cytotrophoblast. In Eggenhuizen, three quarters of the CTB and MC biopsies from these mosaic placentas were uniformly normal (57 %) or abnormal (20 %). In Grati's CVS data, CPM type III (abnormal cytotrophoblast, abnormal mesenchyme, normal fetus) accounted for 10.16% (90/886) of cases. So a result of "both layers abnormal, so the fetus is abnormal" is a statistical tendency, not a biological rule. Trisomy rescue produces exactly that pattern: a trisomic placenta in both layers and a disomic fetus.

———-

Follow‐up investigations after abnormal NIPT often are limited to fetal, and depending on the NIPT result, also maternal cytogenetic investigations, and if this reveals normal results, the NIPT is called “false positive” or “discordant.” In most cases, it may then be assumed that the chromosome aberration probably has a placental origin due to the cytotrophoblastic origion of the cfDNA. However, proof is only delivered if placental studies are performed. Since in most cases, an amniocentesis instead of chorionic villus sampling (CVS) is recommended according to a joint European Society of Human Genetics (ESHG)/American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG) position statement,7 only postnatal placental studies can proof a placental origin of an aberration detected by NIPT.”

Please review literature. A CVS is not a placental term study. It’s a limited tool that should be used in abnormal sonos to confirm abnormal karyptyoes and with extreme caution with nIPT since almost all nIPT test positives comes from placental mosaicsm.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6899775/

Abnormal placental cells sit in patches, and CVS can miss them
A 2024 study from Erasmus MC in Rotterdam (Eggenhuizen et al., Placenta) looked at pregnancies where NIPT came back abnormal but follow-up testing of the baby and the mother was normal, so confined placental mosaicism (CPM) was assumed. After delivery, the researchers took four biopsies, one from each quadrant of the placenta. They tested both layers of the villi separately: the outer cytotrophoblast, which is where NIPT DNA comes from, and the mesenchymal core underneath it.
They found the NIPT abnormality in the term placenta in 67% of cases. Even in those placentas, most biopsies were completely normal, and the abnormal cells showed up in patches. Sixteen of the CPM cases had also had a first trimester CVS, and 11 of those CVS results were normal. So the placenta was carrying the abnormal cells and the baby was normal, but the CVS happened to sample a normal spot.
In the remaining third, they didn't find the abnormality even with four biopsies. The authors put this down to the same patchy pattern: the abnormal cells are likely still in areas nobody sampled, and they say four biopsies aren't enough to map how much of the placenta is affected. A CVS takes one small sample from one spot in the first trimester. Sampling four quadrants of a placenta isn't possible during a pregnancy.
What this means for you: a positive NIPT comes from placental DNA, and the placenta is a patchwork. A CVS result, normal or abnormal, tells you about the piece of placenta that was sampled. It doesn't tell you about the rest of the placenta, and it doesn't directly tell you about the baby. Amniocentesis samples cells shed by the baby, so it answers the question you actually care about.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38901306/

——

Van Opstal et al., Prenat Diagn 2018
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6282787
Placentas from 10 cases where NIPT showed an autosomal trisomy but amniotic fluid was normal or low-level mosaic; CPM was proven in 10/10.

Van Opstal et al., Prenat Diagn 2020
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7540368
All four term placentas confirmed the aberration, but in two it was in only one of four biopsies.

Eggenhuizen et al., Placenta 2024
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38901306/
The aberration was confirmed in 67% of placentas, and 11 of 16 CPM cases that had first trimester CVS had normal CVS results.

Thomsen et al., post-partum placentas and structural aberrations

Studies of post-partum placentas provide insights into the origin of structural chromosomal aberrations

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC12864147/
Term placental villi confirmed the NIPT finding in 18 of 31 (58%) structural aberration cases.

Placenta 2024, 99-case single-center study

The impact of confined placental mosaicism on prenatal cell-free DNA screening: Insights from a monocentric study of 99 cases
Jessica Rosenblum et al. Placenta. 2024 Jul.

Introduction: Confined placental mosaicism (CPM) is thought to be one of the main sources of false-positive prenatal cell-free DNA (cfDNA) screening results, but extensive and systematic studies to prove this statement are limited. We evaluate the contribution of CPM to false-positive prenatal cfDNA screening results in the largest cohort published to date.
Method: We systematically offered postnatal analysis on placenta and umbilical cord to women who had a negative amniocentesis following a positive prenatal cfDNA screening result. A standardized protocol was used in which (when available) biopsies were taken at five locations in the placenta and umbilical cord.
Results: We analyzed a series of 99 placentas. CPM could be confirmed in 32.3 % of cases (32/99). CPM was detected across all subtypes of chromosomal aberrations (common and rare autosomal trisomies, sex chromosome abnormalities, copy number variations and autosomal monosomies). A lower detection rate was present in umbilical cord biopsies in comparison with placental biopsies. When comparing different sections of the placenta, no clear difference could be observed with regard to the probability of CPM being present nor to the grade of mosaicism.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38744036/
CPM was confirmed in 32.3% of 99 placentas, with cord biopsies detecting it less often than placental biopsies.

Raymond et al., AJOG MFM 2026

Placental cytogenetic testing for confined placental mosaicism and obstetrical outcomes after discordant cell-free DNA screening results
Yvette Raymond et al. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM.2026 Mar.

Results: A total of 60 cases with false-positive cell-free DNA results were matched with 120 controls. Confined placental mosaicism was observed in 20 of the 60 cases (33.3%) and in none of the controls.
**** important fact is there were ZERO findings in the control group meaning normal NIPT****

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41520802/

Faas et al., 2012
https://repub.eur.nl/pub/60801
A case with 45,X in the cytotrophoblast and 46,XX in the mesenchymal core showed that cfDNA comes from the cytotrophoblast.

22q11.2 deletion CPM case
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10131250/
Two of three placental biopsies showed a mosaic 22q11.2 deletion.

Trisomy 6 CPM with placental abruption
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8645167/
The authors suggest some types of NIPT-detected CPM may be associated with pregnancy complications.

Italian trisomy 13 CPM case, 2022
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9134238/
Ruling out fetal trisomy 13 took amniocentesis, cordocentesis, and placental DNA testing at delivery.

In conclusion, this case provides significant clinical considerations on using NIPT in daily practice. In particular, it presents the major pitfalls of interpreting screening tests’ findings in the absence of a mutual work of integration. In recent years, we have witnessed an uncontrolled spread of cf-DNA analysis for which the economic interest of the industry has certainly contributed.

Danish study, CVS mosaicism compared with postpartum placentas
https://vbn.aau.dk/ws/files/434061483/Mosaicism_for_copy_number_variations_in_the_placenta_is_even_more_difficult_to_interpret_than_mosaicism_for_whole_chromosome_aneuploidy.pdf
Of 15 placentas collected after CVS mosaicism, three showed complex aberrations different from what was detected prenatally.


r/NIPT • • Jul 31 '26

📌 Reminder: This sub is for ABNORMAL results ONLY‼️

65 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Just a friendly reminder that this community is specifically for abnormal test results and questions related to them.

Lately, the mod team has had to remove a large number of posts with normal results, routine questions, or topics that don’t fit the purpose of the sub. We completely understand that waiting for results or looking for reassurance can be stressful, but those posts make it harder for members with abnormal findings to get the support and visibility they need.

Before posting, please ask yourself:

✅ Is my result abnormal?
✅ Am I asking about an abnormal finding or diagnosis?
❌ If my results are normal or I’m just waiting on results or asking genuine pregnancy questions, this isn’t the right place. The r/pregnant sub is a great resource, and may be better suited for your post.

Posts that don’t meet the sub rules will be removed.

Thanks for helping keep the community focused so it remains a valuable resource for those who need it most. We appreciate everyone’s cooperation! ❤️


r/NIPT • • 7h ago

Monosomy X Identical twins, one has positive Turner Syndrome

16 Upvotes

I posted a while ago about my pregnancy where one identical twin has classic turner syndrome and the other didn’t - confirmed by amnio. They are mo-di twins. I don’t know how to link my old post but anyway I just wanted to update on it, they were both born completely healthy.
No major problems for my TS girl. She has a lot of physical features for TS and only minor complications for now like reflux and such. ❤️


r/NIPT • • 59m ago

Vanished Twin Previous High Risk NIPT & current vanishing twin

2 Upvotes

Okay, I read the rules and I think this post would be allowed but obviously delete if I'm breaking rules.

Over the summer I had a high risk NIPT through Natera for Monosomy X. Then we found out I had miscarried her and no further testing was ever done so it was assumed to be a true positive.

Now I am pregnant again and it's a vanishing twin pregnancy. I understand Natera has a workflow for vanishing twins but with my history of a previous abnormal result, I am wondering how others feel about the accuracy of Natera's results with this or if anyone has any actual experience. I checked the vanished twin flair and didn't really see any posts that answered my question.

My genetic counselor mentioned it's possible it would come back with no results, but she didn't really answer me when I asked her if I should trust it if it DID come back with results. I know Natera gets a lot of hate. This is my 4th NIPT through them and I've never had an issue but I am obviously concerned about this pregnancy after losing my last one as well as the twin for this one.

I plan to still do the NT scan regardless of the NIPT results but I am wondering if we should take it further and do an amnio if the Natera results shouldn't be relied on? Any advice?


r/NIPT • • 1d ago

Trisomy 21 NIPT was positive and doctor still wants to test my newborn

12 Upvotes

Hi, I’m curious to know why after my positive Nipt test that the doctor in the NICU would want to do a karyotype on my baby when he literally stated that he can see some characteristics of Down syndrome in baby’s face. Would the results change anything? Please mods I’m not sure if this post will be allowed I know some changes to the rules have been made but some I’m not too clear about.


r/NIPT • • 1d ago

Trisomy 21 High risk NIPT, waiting for appointment and losing my mind

14 Upvotes

On Monday morning we got our NIPT results that showed high risk 90/100 for trisomy 21. It's been an emotional time and five days later I'm finally not sobbing all day but it's still not easy either. We have an appointment with MFM in two weeks which feels like years away. Husband and I agree if T21 is confirmed we will terminate, which is an overwhelming ordeal as we'll have to travel out of state (we're lucky to live near the border I suppose) and I suspect/know both our families will be strongly against us which makes their "support in this difficult time" hard to appreciate. It's made this feel a thousand times more isolating.

In the meantime I can't help but hope and pray that IF baby boy truly has T21 that I would just miscarry to save myself some of the grief related to the procedures, payments, etc. ahead (we are on Medicaid so will have to pay out of pocket which I'm not sure how we'll manage). Obviously I'd prefer it's a false positive, but I can't even entertain that thought as it brings no comfort. I feel like I just know already that it's true...

In addition to everything my pregnancy symptoms have felt worse. My last pregnancy I got relief from nausea by now, but in the last two days it's come back full force along with food aversions getting worse. I've also been experiencing almost constant mild-moderate cramping, with off and on back pain and just general discomfort in my entire abdomen. It sounds so wrong but it makes me hope perhaps I'm miscarrying. Even though this pregnancy is so, so, SO wanted I just feel so certain the NIPT is right that to miscarry would be a relief, so I could begin to grieve for real.

I don't know what I'm looking for in replies honestly. I think I'm just going crazy not truly talking to anyone about it, as both my husband and I agree we should wait for definitive results before broaching the subject of TFMR with our families. But every pregnancy symptom is agony, reminding me of the son I fear yet kinda expect to lose and sometimes I think I feel him moving which is also hard to think about. I hate that if I need to TFMR I'll be at least 16 weeks, almost definitely further since we'll need to get further testing and I don't know how long that'll take.

I just really hate this.


r/NIPT • • 1d ago

Termination after FISH?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/NIPT • • 1d ago

Monosomy X 32/100 PPV monosomy x natera NIPT

1 Upvotes

I’m 11 weeks along- had my NIPT through natera at 9w4d. noticed my fetal fraction was lower at 3.9% and I’m on lovenox which can do that. I was flagged high risk at 32% PPV for monosomy x. I’m booked for NT scan in a week and a half and an amnio at 16 weeks which I’m still nervous about. looking for insight on this, and possibility of false positives gives the 32/100 risk and low fetal fraction?


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

enlarged NT “Higher end of normal” NT, awaiting NIPT results, sibling with ultra-rare genetic condition

3 Upvotes

I can’t believe we’re here again after three years. Our first daughter was low risk until 20 weeks, when the anatomy scan turned up major defects that led to an ultra-rare genetic diagnosis (mosaic trisomy 14). She is one of only 30 known live-birth cases of her genetic condition, and the only known case with the congenital conditions she has. Needless to say, it was extremely traumatic, and we’ve been through the wringer with high-risk teams, genetics, etc. After karyotyping and whole exome sequencing, it was determined her mutation was not inherited, so we were assured our risk for a future child was low. (She is thriving and the light of our life, but obviously still a traumatic situation).

We got pregnant again and are being watched very closely by our high-risk team. We went for our NT scan yesterday, and growth and structure are good, but the NT measured at 2.6, which they said was the higher end of normal. Additionally, the fluid is extending slightly further down the back than they like to see- not officially a hygroma, but they don’t really have a name for it. They said with any other couple, they wouldn’t have noted any of this and would have reported everything as normal. But because of our first daughter, they said it “raises some eyebrows”. They sent off bloodwork for NIPT and to re-run whole exome sequencing. We declined CVS because of our history with mosaicism, and we booked a 16w scan with amnio.

Just looking for anyone who has been in a similar situation, especially with another child with genetic issues.


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

enlarged NT Reassurance needed 🙁

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I wanted to share my results from today’s ultrasound (20weeks), I’ve had a couple of anomalies and would like some reassurance if possible as I can’t seem to cheer up..
First off, I’m having a baby BOY which I’m so pleased with! But today I learned that baby’s femur is measuring small (28mm) and the nuchal fold is 6.5mm thick which is apparently too thick? I also had been told I have a low lying placenta and that I have to return at 32wks to see if it’s moved position. I have another scan on Monday to have a re-look at the femur and neck, but i’m quite anxious about all of these things and just wondered if anyone has been through something similar and can reassure me, or share their stories if possible.


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

Genetic Counseling Questions Carriers for SMA

4 Upvotes

My husband and I just found out that we’re both carriers of the SMA gene. We’ve had so many pregnancy losses and had to do years of IVF for this baby. I’m 13w today and am having the CVS and the blood screening today. I’m just so scared about this. If you and your husband were both carriers, what was your outcome?


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

Anatomy Scan Issues Soft markers, high hcg, low risk NIPT

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm 13w5d pregnant after a long journey and 4 ivf/icsi transfers. I was finally getting a little exited about this really happening after we got the low risk NIPT results back (only for T13, 18, 21 and sex chromosome issues), but now we're in the middle of a nightmare after our first trimester screening at 13+1.
They found several soft markers:

- single umbilical artery
- slight ductus venosus reverse flow
- some fluid accumulation in the kidney area on one side

Also my beta hcg is elevated (2,9 MoM) and Papp-a low (0,6 MoM).

Nasal bone was present, NT was low, heart and everything else looked normal.

Without taking the NIPT into account, that gave me a T21 risk of 1:44.

Got seen by two different fetal medicine doctors by now and they both said that the NIPT is more reliable than the risk calculation based on markers and blood work, but that it could still be false negative and that it only screens for trisomies and there could be a whole lot other (potentially very severe) genetic conditions.
So we will be having a genetic counseling in ten days and most probably an amnio after that.

In the meantime I'm desperately searching for some idea of how big the chances are to have a healthy baby and some other similar stories.

Would really love to hear your stories of having several soft markers and a low risk NIPT and about things ended for you!


r/NIPT • • 3d ago Bravo

INFORMATION Please review new rules - ZERO pro life topics, suggestions and resources. And users assign your own flair. Heavy filtering and no CVS suggestions.

92 Upvotes

PLEASE READ AND FOLLOW THESE SUB RULES BELOW:

We have a new mod! u/thedistantdusk - we are happy to have her! She’s been a mod elsewhere and will help mostly with support and non medical advice from sub, as be aware she is a mom but has no scientific background. Thank you for your help and we look forward to having you on the mod team!

From here on out, if there are any suggestions, comments, or resources suggesting to keep a fetus, any mention of keeping a fetus with chromosomal abnormalities, or any mention of pro-life or anti-abrtn topics, you will obviously be banned immediately from the community. However, it will also be reported to Reddit, and the community now has bans on any user with negative karma in this sub. Those users will basically be removed by the automod, and we will not review, correct, or grant those users permission to return.

There is zero allowance for private messages or DMs unless the poster specifically asks for it in a comment, at risk to themselves, from that particular user they would like a message from. Other users are not allowed to suggest or ask if somebody wants a message, try to message users, or send any private DMs. You will be banned for harassment if reported, and anybody that gets a message like this that's unsolicited needs to report the users that have messaged them immediately so they can be reported to Reddit for harassment and banned from the community.

PLEASE REPORT ANY USERS who have previously sent you unsolicited DMS! They do not belong here and will be banned retroactively.

In case it's unclear to you, having a prolonged discussion regarding keeping your pregnancy here is inappropriate and this is not a GC sub. This sub answers one question: IS YOUR NIPT result a true positive or a false positive. That’s it. What’s the nest step in testing? What to say to your provider? Why is this happening?

This is not the sub for that discussion of implications of receiving a true positive and what life will look like etc there is a clinical genetics sub and continue of pregnancy related discussion belongs in babybumps if you’ve decided that - and whatever choices you make have no bearing on what anybody else is doing. Please report this rhetoric, downvote it and automod will remove them via that method if not caught or reported otherwise if prolonged discussion or anything other than
“I had an amnio, it was a true positive, we are proceeding with the pregnancy” is a general outcome report and of a plan.

The sub now has severe filtering, and this may mean that some comments or posts are removed from users that should not be. Unfortunately, if that's the case, we are not going to mod that, because the sub has grown to 15 million views per year and no amount of mods are going to be able to oversee a bunch of crazy people that choose to stalk this sub or harass it.
It is much more important to me that the sub with correct information is out there than policing comments or having time to remove comments from crazy people.

Like I've said plenty of times here, I began this sub seven years ago and single-handedly spread information about the false information about NIPT throughout the world. PPV has changed because of this community, and knowledge has changed because of this community. It is single-handedly one of the main things in my life that I'm proud of, and I'm unwilling to add mods just because there are trolls on the Internet. I really could give a shit if you're a troll, have no life, or have a prerogative. Leave it out of here.

I will not add mods just to remove comments from these people, and please do not engage with these people that are crazy. The more you engage, pay attention, or think that they are actually serious, the more energy it gives them. They literally have no life to even come here and peddle anything related to keeping a genetically abnormal pregnancy that people have extremely good reasons to not keep.

If it's not clear what my own personal beliefs are, I would have a termination, and I have had a termination, so there is no one here, not a single person, that will ever convince me or influence the sub to be anything pro-life.

I will never personally ever keep a pregnancy that's chromosomally abnormal, and therefore every answer that I give is going to heavily lean towards information that gives accurate resources about what that means and what that life means if I have to. If you're uncomfortable with that, I really don't give a shit.
I'm a medical provider with 20 years of experience of what this looks like. Your own personal beliefs or religious views are not really anything that I care about or care to discuss, and you will not change my mind or anyone else's mind here.

If you disagree with me personally, I will also ban you, because I just don't care and don't have the time to argue with you, I won’t argue with you and you’re wasting my time. What I care about is saving millions of lives that are having false positives, not true positives.

While I have a ton of empathy for those that ended up with true positives that’s where we will diverge with pro lifers - this is a devastating and unexpected time that requires decisions people make they never thought they would have to or have a life that will be 1000% different from what they imagined for their family, the reason for this sub is to address the false positives and how NIPT data, false diagnostic recommendations, or false information about NIPT can affect those decisions and cause false terminations.

My priority is to prevent false terminations or false information, not to address when and if somebody has a true positive and the decisions that people face afterward, which are awful, confusing, and have nothing to do with me and my personal beliefs. Everybody's entitled to theirs, but I started this sub, and the information in here and the reason why anybody even has this resource is because of how I practice medicine, my curiosity, and the information I've put into the world. So if you don't agree with it, I just don't care.

Please choose your own flair on your post from now on, and if there are any comments from anybody that do not hold to the view above or the rules that I've placed in the sub, please tag a mod rather than also reporting it to the sub, because that's the easiest thing for a mod to do. You can tag me, but I'm not going to be on Reddit every single day. I have a life, children, and also a job in academia.

Thank you, and again, I'm very happy for the 15 million people that can get correct information and guide their treatment plan based on actual correct information and resources provided in the sub, and I will continue to advocate for anybody who has gotten wrong information about it. We will continue to make sure that the companies are held accountable for giving the wrong information or advertising the wrong information, as well as any providers that do not understand the consequences of NIPT.

As a reminder, please do not have a CVS after a normal sono and a positive NIPT. It's not the appropriate test. It tests the placenta only, and the placenta can have patches of normal cells and abnormal cells, just like a soccer ball, as evident in what's called term placental studies, where they can biopsy multiple regions of the placenta, which is not done in CVS because of safety concerns.

CVS is an extremely poor test after a positive NIPT.
A positive NIPT comes from abnormal placental cells.

Thank you, and have a great day.

—
Study about germ placental biopsies - again CVS takes one area of placenta. Whatever you biopsy at the time of the CVS can be positive or negative. Term placental studies are the thing that lets us know how CVS can have false results whether positive or negative.

I don’t know why clinicians still order a CVS with normal Sonos.

New study: abnormal placental cells sit in patches, and CVS can miss them
A 2024 study from Erasmus MC in Rotterdam (Eggenhuizen et al., Placenta) looked at pregnancies where NIPT came back abnormal but follow-up testing of the baby and the mother was normal, so confined placental mosaicism (CPM) was assumed. After delivery, the researchers took four biopsies, one from each quadrant of the placenta. They tested both layers of the villi separately: the outer cytotrophoblast, which is where NIPT DNA comes from, and the mesenchymal core underneath it.
They found the NIPT abnormality detected in the term placenta in 67% of cases. Even in those placentas, most biopsies were completely normal, and the abnormal cells showed up in patches. Sixteen of the CPM cases had also had a first trimester CVS, and 11 of those CVS results were normal. So the placenta was carrying the abnormal cells and the baby was normal, but the CVS happened to sample a normal spot.

In the remaining third, they didn't find the abnormality even with four biopsies. The authors put this down to the same patchy pattern: the abnormal cells are likely still in areas nobody sampled, and they say four biopsies aren't enough to map how much of the placenta is affected. A CVS takes one small sample from one spot in the first trimester. Sampling four quadrants of a placenta isn't possible during a pregnancy.

What this means for you: a positive NIPT comes from placental DNA, and the placenta is a patchwork. A CVS result, normal or abnormal, tells you about the piece of placenta that was sampled. It doesn't tell you about the rest of the placenta, and it doesn't directly tell you about the baby. Amniocentesis samples cells shed by the baby, so it answers the question you actually care about.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38901306/

Clinicians - If you’re reading this stop ordering a CVS after NIPT. We already know placenta has abnormal cells. I put term placental biopsy studies on this sub 7 years ago. Stop giving wrong medical advice for when CVS was only used for confirm sono abnormalities before NIPT. Triple screen labs can be abnormal bc of placental proteins - unless there are sonographic abnormalities stop ordering a CVS.


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

NT test 2.43mm (first time mam and worried)

1 Upvotes

Hi all just spiralling and not even too sure why! I got my 12 week scan and my NT test showed 2.43mm and baby’s CRL 57mm. Because I’m in the 95th percentile it just worries me. I also got my NIPT test and all 3 came back low percentage. Just wondering if anyone else was in this situation and how it turned out. Thanks


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

INFORMATION Amniocentesis

8 Upvotes

Wanted to share my experience since I see a lot of people say that an amnio is NBD. Mine was super painful!!! They had to poke me twice. I cried right after and had a panic attack.

I did have a question for anyone else who had one… I am soooo nervous about going back to normal even after the 72 hour period. How long did you wait? I haven’t had any pain since I left the hospital, but still so worried!!!!


r/NIPT • • 2d ago

XXY XXY risk from Natera at 8W3D with 2.4% FF

2 Upvotes

First pregnancy at age 33 and was told by my doctor during first US apt that I can take the NIPT (8W3D) — apparently the technology is good enough now that you can start testing at 8 weeks.

Received an abnormal result for elevated risk for XXY …I may be in denial but wondering if the low fetal fraction makes it more likely for a false positive…wondering if anyone else have had experience with either detecting XXY risk or low fetal fraction. Did you end up re-testing or going for diagnostic testing?

We’ve been researching a lot about how to interpret the results and it’s a bit frustrating that Natera flagged the risk is 83%, which is alarmingly high. We found the study behind it and realized that this is not an individualized risk, but based on 19 confirmed positives from 23 screened positives across the sex chromosome abnormalities, and the specific number for XXY was 4 confirmed of 6 positive screens (67%)

My OB said low FF could imply false negative but should not affect a false positive, which was a bummer :( but we found this Chinese study published a week ago that shows a strong correlation between low FF and false positives so trying to stay hopeful as we wait for further testing.

Anyway part of this is me venting out to the internet since it’s been a stressful 24H and also hoping to offer some cope for myself and others who might be in a similar situation. Hope all goes well for me and the expecting moms out there. Pregnancy is hard.


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

Trisomy 18 My Positive Tri18 NIPT Story (very sad)

58 Upvotes

I really debated about posting this but figured I might as well because it might help someone.

I received a NIPT result for Tri18 at 8 weeks 5 days from myriad with a 92% PPV. I kept hoping that because they only had a 4.7% fractionation that it would be a false positive. I only did the test because I wanted to know gender.

So at 11 weeks, we did CVS with both FISH and Microarray which confirmed the Tri18. No mosaicism detected. It was too early to get anything definite on the ultrasound but there were signs something was wrong with the heart, brain, and bladder.

I'm currently 13 weeks 6 days and we did a detailed ultrasound today to see if we could see any defects. My baby is currently 87.2mm so we could get most details. Unfortunately, we saw a lot of bad signs. The NT was 4.5mm, the baby had club feet, and there were other indications.

The worst sign was that when they say that a Tri18 baby can have gastrointestinal issues, it means that for my baby, there is a blockage so my baby cannot pee (LUTO). That means that it's bladder is very enlarged. So it's kidneys will soon start to shut down. This means that the amniotic fluid won't be able to be made and my baby will not be able to breath soon.

In two days (Friday), I'm going into planned parenthood to terminate for medical purposes because my insurance will not pay for any termination procedures unless my life is in danger and it is so expensive at the hospital. I'll be 14 weeks 1 day.

In my state, I only have until 17 weeks to terminate so amnio is not an option because I will not get the results in time plus it won't tell me anything new and at that point it will be hard to get a sample. There is nothing the doctors can do, my baby will die no matter what.

I wanted to thank this continuity for helping me understand what was going on and giving me terminology. This will be my 4th loss (I have PCOS/PMOS and I'm 37 now) but the first loss where I know why. I have a healthy lovely daughter and hope to try again when I'm recovered.

Edit: The termination went as smoothly as could be expected. The baby was definitely not healthy. Thank you all for all of your kind words. I read them a lot while waiting and they were a great comfort.


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

INFORMATION Algo que indicara antes de la ecografía de la TN que había alguna anomalía?

3 Upvotes

Hola, estoy embarazada de 10 semanas, y sin motivo realmente tengo ansiedad por la TN y el NIPT. Recién tuve un ultrasonido y todo se vio bien. Solo me preguntaba si alguien tuvo una eco normal a las 10 semanas y luego un NIPT POSITIVO o si ya los doctores habían visto algo “sospechoso” antes.
Muchas gracias por compartir!!


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

Trisomy 21 Trisomy 21 results delaying our pregnancy announcement

3 Upvotes

We just got our NIPT results back yesterday with PPV 95% for Trisomy 21. I am so heartbroken because my mom arrived this week to visit and I was hoping to share the great news about the pregnancy, but now I don't want to say anything until we get more testing done. I am afraid of her noticing my bump and then also being heartbroken if we end up confirming trisomy 21 and my husband and I deciding to TFMR. On top of that, I have not mentioned my pregnancy at work, which has been difficult. My husband and I want to be the only one's to decide on the next big decisions, since it impacts us the most and we have no "village" nearby for support. I did confide in my best friend since she is supportive and not one to dictate other's choices.

I am not sure how navigate this news while trying to be discrete with family, friends and work. Any tips or shared personal experiences appreciated.

Sorry to everyone who has gone through something similar or is just starting to go through this.


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

Did you feel anything before abnormal NIPT results?

1 Upvotes

I was just wondering… did any of you feel off before receiving abnormal NIPT results? Having some intuition that something is going wrong?

when I was pregnant with my living child I was feeling happy and excited, there was internal peace I can’t explain. With this pregnancy that was diagnosed as mosaic T21 I just felt uneasy from the beginning. There was this internal deep sadness coming from somewhere that I’ve never experienced before. I just had this inner voice telling me this child probably will not see the world. It’s weird I know. But was wondering if someone also felt the same way?

Having TFMR tomorrow at almost 18 weeks…


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

Monosomy X Placental biopsy positive for Turner syndrome mosaicism

4 Upvotes

I am now in week 15. The 13-week scan showed an NT 2 mm. I have an early anomaly scan scheduled for 16+ weeks and an amniocentesis for 17+ weeks, so now I just have to wait. I am absolutely terrified if the baby is ok. I am hoping that the mosaic Turner syndrome is confined to the placenta (CPM). But would you say that an NT of 2 mm could indicate that my baby has Turner syndrome? Does anyone have any personal experience or know of anyone with a similar story? My doctor said no number on how high the risk is for CPM or not when it comes to turner mosaic.


r/NIPT • • 3d ago

BillionToOne shares slide in pre-market trading following short-seller report By Investing.com

Thumbnail investing.com
0 Upvotes

r/NIPT • • 3d ago

Atypical Finding N/A on NIPT due to Low X Chromosome, all scans normal

6 Upvotes

Looking for experiences with repeated nonreportable NIPT results due to low X-chromosome signal

I had two NIPT tests through Labcorp (MaterniT21), and neither came back with a reportable result. After the second test, I was referred to an MFM specialist to review the findings.

The MFM explained that both samples had adequate fetal fraction, but the X-chromosome representation was lower than expected on both tests. The signal was not low enough to trigger a high-risk result for monosomy X (Turner syndrome), but it was low enough that Labcorp could not issue a reportable result. She didn’t provide a range or # associated with my X and the benchmark.

My MFM mentioned a few possible explanations, including maternal X-chromosome mosaicism, placental mosaicism, or a fetal chromosome difference. She suggested looking into my own chromosomes with a maternal karyotype. I haven’t scheduled my karyotype testing yet but plan to do so.

Some additional context:
- My NT measurement was 1.7–1.8 mm.
- The ultrasound looked reassuring. The organs they could visualize looked normal, the spine looked good, and the baby’s growth was right on track.
- No cystic hygroma or other abnormalities were reported.
- I did a redraw through Natera Panorama, which uses a different testing methodology (SNP-based rather than MaterniT21’s sequencing approach).
- I scheduled amnio for 16 weeks and rejected CVS.

I would ultimately like diagnostic certainty, even if the Natera result comes back low risk.

I would love to hear people‘s experiences who have had a similar outcome and what the final diagnosis was. I feel like this gray area is so confusing because if it was classic or mosaic Turner syndrome, I would expect the NIPT would have flagged that as high risk.

It also seems like so many people on here have gone through something really similar so we just love to know if there’s anyone who’s gone through this who has had similar data points to me, but has had their baby diagnosed with Turner syndrome


r/NIPT • • 4d ago

Trisomy 21 High Risk T21 Natera. Heartbroken

11 Upvotes

Hi all I decided to post as even though I don’t know the outcome yet, reading posts here the last 3 days has been saving me.

Maybe someone will have an advice or words of wisdom.

Nipt done 11+6, got results high risk for T21. Doc says actual risk is about 67% of real positive. Ultrasound had no markers. Waiting for CVS results. If positive I don’t think I’ll wait for amnio? I just don’t think I can wait that long, 13w today.

But I read enough stories and information here to know it’s most likely positive and we will say good bye to this baby who was so wanted and waited for.

If anyone reads this or has any advice or experiences to share I will be grateful.


r/NIPT • • 4d ago

microdeletions NIPT -22q11.2 microdeletion

3 Upvotes

My husband and I are both 27 years and and this is our first child. We were both excited for our baby for 8 weeks and then Nipt result came in.

My nipt test at around 12 weeks came back with high risk for 22q11.2 microdeletion. My test came from Unity with FF around 12%.

I have the appointment with MFM the following monday for NT scan and ultrasound. NT measurement is around 1.5mm, no soft markers. Everything looks good and baby measured 4 days ahead. I wish it is a good sign, but also too early to tell.

Decided to do amnio at 16 weeks (this Friday). Hope everything will be okay!