PLEASE READ AND FOLLOW THESE SUB RULES BELOW:
We have a new mod! u/thedistantdusk - we are happy to have her! She’s been a mod elsewhere and will help mostly with support and non medical advice from sub, as be aware she is a mom but has no scientific background. Thank you for your help and we look forward to having you on the mod team!
From here on out, if there are any suggestions, comments, or resources suggesting to keep a fetus, any mention of keeping a fetus with chromosomal abnormalities, or any mention of pro-life or anti-abrtn topics, you will obviously be banned immediately from the community. However, it will also be reported to Reddit, and the community now has bans on any user with negative karma in this sub. Those users will basically be removed by the automod, and we will not review, correct, or grant those users permission to return.
There is zero allowance for private messages or DMs unless the poster specifically asks for it in a comment, at risk to themselves, from that particular user they would like a message from. Other users are not allowed to suggest or ask if somebody wants a message, try to message users, or send any private DMs. You will be banned for harassment if reported, and anybody that gets a message like this that's unsolicited needs to report the users that have messaged them immediately so they can be reported to Reddit for harassment and banned from the community.
PLEASE REPORT ANY USERS who have previously sent you unsolicited DMS! They do not belong here and will be banned retroactively.
In case it's unclear to you, having a prolonged discussion regarding keeping your pregnancy here is inappropriate and this is not a GC sub. This sub answers one question: IS YOUR NIPT result a true positive or a false positive. That’s it. What’s the nest step in testing? What to say to your provider? Why is this happening?
This is not the sub for that discussion of implications of receiving a true positive and what life will look like etc there is a clinical genetics sub and continue of pregnancy related discussion belongs in babybumps if you’ve decided that - and whatever choices you make have no bearing on what anybody else is doing. Please report this rhetoric, downvote it and automod will remove them via that method if not caught or reported otherwise if prolonged discussion or anything other than
“I had an amnio, it was a true positive, we are proceeding with the pregnancy” is a general outcome report and of a plan.
The sub now has severe filtering, and this may mean that some comments or posts are removed from users that should not be. Unfortunately, if that's the case, we are not going to mod that, because the sub has grown to 15 million views per year and no amount of mods are going to be able to oversee a bunch of crazy people that choose to stalk this sub or harass it.
It is much more important to me that the sub with correct information is out there than policing comments or having time to remove comments from crazy people.
Like I've said plenty of times here, I began this sub seven years ago and single-handedly spread information about the false information about NIPT throughout the world. PPV has changed because of this community, and knowledge has changed because of this community. It is single-handedly one of the main things in my life that I'm proud of, and I'm unwilling to add mods just because there are trolls on the Internet. I really could give a shit if you're a troll, have no life, or have a prerogative. Leave it out of here.
I will not add mods just to remove comments from these people, and please do not engage with these people that are crazy. The more you engage, pay attention, or think that they are actually serious, the more energy it gives them. They literally have no life to even come here and peddle anything related to keeping a genetically abnormal pregnancy that people have extremely good reasons to not keep.
If it's not clear what my own personal beliefs are, I would have a termination, and I have had a termination, so there is no one here, not a single person, that will ever convince me or influence the sub to be anything pro-life.
I will never personally ever keep a pregnancy that's chromosomally abnormal, and therefore every answer that I give is going to heavily lean towards information that gives accurate resources about what that means and what that life means if I have to. If you're uncomfortable with that, I really don't give a shit.
I'm a medical provider with 20 years of experience of what this looks like. Your own personal beliefs or religious views are not really anything that I care about or care to discuss, and you will not change my mind or anyone else's mind here.
If you disagree with me personally, I will also ban you, because I just don't care and don't have the time to argue with you, I won’t argue with you and you’re wasting my time. What I care about is saving millions of lives that are having false positives, not true positives.
While I have a ton of empathy for those that ended up with true positives that’s where we will diverge with pro lifers - this is a devastating and unexpected time that requires decisions people make they never thought they would have to or have a life that will be 1000% different from what they imagined for their family, the reason for this sub is to address the false positives and how NIPT data, false diagnostic recommendations, or false information about NIPT can affect those decisions and cause false terminations.
My priority is to prevent false terminations or false information, not to address when and if somebody has a true positive and the decisions that people face afterward, which are awful, confusing, and have nothing to do with me and my personal beliefs. Everybody's entitled to theirs, but I started this sub, and the information in here and the reason why anybody even has this resource is because of how I practice medicine, my curiosity, and the information I've put into the world. So if you don't agree with it, I just don't care.
Please choose your own flair on your post from now on, and if there are any comments from anybody that do not hold to the view above or the rules that I've placed in the sub, please tag a mod rather than also reporting it to the sub, because that's the easiest thing for a mod to do. You can tag me, but I'm not going to be on Reddit every single day. I have a life, children, and also a job in academia.
Thank you, and again, I'm very happy for the 15 million people that can get correct information and guide their treatment plan based on actual correct information and resources provided in the sub, and I will continue to advocate for anybody who has gotten wrong information about it. We will continue to make sure that the companies are held accountable for giving the wrong information or advertising the wrong information, as well as any providers that do not understand the consequences of NIPT.
As a reminder, please do not have a CVS after a normal sono and a positive NIPT. It's not the appropriate test. It tests the placenta only, and the placenta can have patches of normal cells and abnormal cells, just like a soccer ball, as evident in what's called term placental studies, where they can biopsy multiple regions of the placenta, which is not done in CVS because of safety concerns.
CVS is an extremely poor test after a positive NIPT.
A positive NIPT comes from abnormal placental cells.
Thank you, and have a great day.
—
Study about germ placental biopsies - again CVS takes one area of placenta. Whatever you biopsy at the time of the CVS can be positive or negative. Term placental studies are the thing that lets us know how CVS can have false results whether positive or negative.
I don’t know why clinicians still order a CVS with normal Sonos.
New study: abnormal placental cells sit in patches, and CVS can miss them
A 2024 study from Erasmus MC in Rotterdam (Eggenhuizen et al., Placenta) looked at pregnancies where NIPT came back abnormal but follow-up testing of the baby and the mother was normal, so confined placental mosaicism (CPM) was assumed. After delivery, the researchers took four biopsies, one from each quadrant of the placenta. They tested both layers of the villi separately: the outer cytotrophoblast, which is where NIPT DNA comes from, and the mesenchymal core underneath it.
They found the NIPT abnormality detected in the term placenta in 67% of cases. Even in those placentas, most biopsies were completely normal, and the abnormal cells showed up in patches. Sixteen of the CPM cases had also had a first trimester CVS, and 11 of those CVS results were normal. So the placenta was carrying the abnormal cells and the baby was normal, but the CVS happened to sample a normal spot.
In the remaining third, they didn't find the abnormality even with four biopsies. The authors put this down to the same patchy pattern: the abnormal cells are likely still in areas nobody sampled, and they say four biopsies aren't enough to map how much of the placenta is affected. A CVS takes one small sample from one spot in the first trimester. Sampling four quadrants of a placenta isn't possible during a pregnancy.
What this means for you: a positive NIPT comes from placental DNA, and the placenta is a patchwork. A CVS result, normal or abnormal, tells you about the piece of placenta that was sampled. It doesn't tell you about the rest of the placenta, and it doesn't directly tell you about the baby. Amniocentesis samples cells shed by the baby, so it answers the question you actually care about.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38901306/
Clinicians - If you’re reading this stop ordering a CVS after NIPT. We already know placenta has abnormal cells. I put term placental biopsy studies on this sub 7 years ago. Stop giving wrong medical advice for when CVS was only used for confirm sono abnormalities before NIPT. Triple screen labs can be abnormal bc of placental proteins - unless there are sonographic abnormalities stop ordering a CVS.