r/Nightwing • u/Field-of-Hats • 2h ago
Discussion Nightwing: The Sam Humphries Era
“Our hearts… They’re not made of corruption. They’re made of something stronger.”
So, I usually don’t do reviews for a single volume, but I wanted to make an exception here. The next volume starts Benjamin Percy’s run, which introduces the Ric arc, which extends right up until Taylor’s run from what I can tell (correct me if I’m wrong, though!) So I thought it best to make a dedicated Humphries review, and then a Ric Era review.
With that said, I don’t really have anything bad to say about this book, so I’m not going to number my praises or anything.
Spoilers for Nightwing (2016) #35-41, or Sam Humphries “The Untouchable” arc (Volume 7 of Rebirth).
Firstly, the art. Bernard Chang, et. al. do an amazing job at bringing Blüdhaven to life. The city is neon and vibrant, it’s beautiful and terrible, and the vibes are just so freaking good.
Now for Humphries’ story. The Judge is one of Nightwing’s most interesting villains. He preys on the insecurity of individuals to force them to hurt and kill people in a twisted game to root out the corruption of the city at large. As an adversary, this works on multiple levels. On the surface, Dick wants to take the Judge down to prove to himself that he’s better than he was before when he failed to defeat the Judge. But thematically, he’s fighting for the collective humanity of Blüdhaven’s citizens; he believes that people are inherently good, and that they can overcome their own corruption (which he says as much to Guppy). He wants to defeat the Judge to prove to himself and to the Judge that the Judge’s worldview is wrong — that people are good. And in the end, Dick internalizes that lesson. He realizes that he needs to forgive himself and have grace for his past mistakes because he knows he’s always trying to be better. That shows a deep understanding of Dick Grayson’s character, and it creates an incredible story.
I love the incorporation of Dick’s past. Usually I don’t like it when writers retroactively add something important to a character’s past, such as the fact that Batman and Robin had visited Blüdhaven to investigate the Judge as one of Robin’s first real missions. But I don’t actually mind it here for a few reasons. The first is that the Judge is such a great villain and foils Dick beautifully, as I said before. Second, adding Blüdhaven to Dick’s backstory makes sense and it recontextualizes his relationship to the city very effectively.
I love that this story is firmly rooted in the city of Blüdhaven. It’s about the financial corruption of the elite and the casinos. Humphries uses the characterization of Blüdhaven that Seeley introduced to its fullest extent — the city feels so alive and unique. It’s crime-ridden, but it’s not at all like any other major DC city. Truly, it’s amazing.
I also really love Guppy as a side character. He’s a product of Blüdhaven, someone just trying to get by. He’s a good person who falls into some minor illegal activity. He’s someone who truly cares about the people in his life. I love that he’s the one who helps Dick realize that he needs to forgive himself. Every scene he had was just amazing.
And as a minor thing, I loved the incorporation of Nightwing’s original disco suit. Because of the insanely shortened timeline post-Flashpoint, Nightwing never got to use that suit (presumably because he wasn’t a Titan very long, and when he was, he was solely Robin? I think?). I really love that suit, it’s one of my favorites, so I’m really glad Humphries got to pay homage to it in this version of the DC universe.
Favorite cover designs (pictured above):
- Nightwing #37 by Alejandro Sanchez and Jorge Jimenez. Humphries does a great job of incorporating Dick’s past in this volume, and this cover illustrates that gorgeously.
- Nightwing #39 by Phil Jimenez and Romulo Fajardo Jr. Similar to issue 37, the representation of Dick’s past here is amazing. Nightwing leaping always looks awesome, and with the backdrop of his time at Blüdhaven in college just makes it all the more meaningful.
- Nightwing #36 variant by Yasmine Putri. I love that that monitors behind the Judge give us the sense that he is in control of everything that happens in Blüdhaven, and that Nightwing is the most prominent thing. He’s over confident, in control but not caring to even look at the monitors, but instead reaching out to bribe the next jaded citizen of the city.
- Nightwing #39 variant by Yasmine Putri. Like I said, I love art that shows Nightwing in the air, and the bright, bold colors with his symbol in the background give us a distinct sense of hope that works so well with the character.
As always, I’m curious about what y’all think. This volume is extremely underrated in the Nightwing world, and I think it deserves a lot more credit. Looking forward, it may take me a bit longer than normal to get to my Ric Era review because of the holidays. I prefer to read things that give me comfort and joy during this time of the year, and I fear that the Ric Era won’t achieve that… But rest assured that I will get there in time!