On NixOS, politics, and the trans community.
alright yall, it seems some people on this sub do not understand the importance of trans inclusivity in the community, nor the fact that FOSS in general, and nix with it, is political. Rather than holding endless circular arguments or claiming posts are "not about nixOS", lets talk SPECIFICALLY about how all of that affects the distribution and its ecosystem. Yes, this *is* a nixOS-relevant post.
firstly, on the topic of "keep politics out of FOSS":
FOSS is inherently political, It is built on the concept of copyright, which is a state-granted monopoly. Licensing terms are a political choice on how to use that monopoly.
FOSS, according to the GNU manifesto, is a matter of the users' freedom to run, copy, distribute, study, change and improve software. in Eben Moglen's "Anarchism Triumphant" from 1999, it is stated that "Free software is the first successful anarchist movement in a long time". anarchism is not apolitical. it is a political movement that chooses freedom to the extreme that it denies any form of centralized control. FOSS started as an ethical movement, not a business strategy. This is also why nowadays, there's the distinction between "Free Software" and "Open-Source Software", the OSI was founded to market OSS to corporations, and highlights a political split.
GPLv3 includes an anti-tivoization clause in direct response to tools like DRM and device lockdown, and licenses like SSPL, Commons Clause and Elastic are corporate counter-moves to FOSS and the GPL.
FOSS has also been a target for political actors directly, the 2024 xz backdoor was due to an unpaid maintainer being socially engineered by what is theorized to be a state-linked actor.
next to that, many FOSS projects have their own constitutions and political structure. nix has the foundation as well as the steering committee. Codes of Conduct are *also* inherently political documents, maybe check out Eric Raymond's "The cathedral and the Bazaar" from 1997.
there's also the very fact that architecture and technical design can and frequently does embody political arrangements. to read more about this, you can check out Langdon Winner's "do artifacts have politics?" from daedalus 109 or Lawrence Lessig's "Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace" from 1999. architectural choices like DRM, telemetry defaults, account linking and proprietary formats are all design decisions that frequently have a political nature to them.
nix itself makes some political choices as well. the default allowUnfree = false, the on-going discussion about proprietary binary blobs with no source code, and even cache trust is a political topic.
nixOS also has a trademark, and nixpkgs has many participants with ties to politically-active organisations, corporations and even national institutions (see also: Anduril's involvement in nix, the french Securix project and the dutch nix-DAWO project)
"political" does not mean "partisan", something being political means it involves the allocation of power, money or legitimacy. these are all topics that FOSS and in turn, nixOS, are heavily involved in. a useful test for this would be the question of "does the decision determine who can participate, who pays, who decides, who is protected, or what the software may be used for". if the answer is yes, congrats, that's a structurally political decision.
now that we've covered how yes, nixOS *is* political, lets talk about "the trans thing".
firstly, the nixOS marketing team published the following in 2025: https://discourse.nixos.org/t/celebrating-pride-month-with-a-fresh-look-and-a-stronger-voice/66170
here's a direct quote from that post: "we stand with our LGBTQ+ friends, colleagues, and contributors - those who lead, build, support, and inspire every day."
Based on this, I believe it is safe to say that nixOS's official stance is to be inclusive and outspoken.
Nix has had long-standing issues with maintainer and contributor turnover. This is only worsened by hate and discrimination. It shouldn't come as a surprise that a community in which a vocal minority spouts hate without receiving any consequences pushes the members to which that hate is directed out of the community.
"ok, but how much can those people even do for nixOS", well, let me highlight some big community contributors in nix's past and present. note that while some of these individuals have left, i do not want to insinuate that that is all because of hate speech or transphobia. I will not be discussing why someone left in this, nor will i be discussing if and how these individuals were affected by hate speech or transphobia in the community, that is a personal story for them to tell, not for me to dig up. Any person mentioned here currently has an easily-findable public post up stating their gender identity, though links to those were not included to keep the focus on their contributions, not their gender.
- worldofpeace
worldofpeace was co-release manager alongside jonathan ringer on nixOS 20.09 and among the top 10 contributors for that release (source: https://discourse.nixos.org/t/nixos-20-09-release/9668). they were also part of the team maintaining GNOME, and jonathan has stated on the 21.05 retrospective that losing worldofpeace, who quit contributing in 2021, was a big blow to the gnome maintainer team (source: https://discourse.nixos.org/t/21-05-retrospective/13426)
- Gabriella Gonzalez
Gabriella's contributions include 2 years on the nix steering committee, writing both the book and source repository "NixOS in Production" (a handbook for nixOS in professional use cases, git repo: https://github.com/Gabriella439/nixos-in-production), the tool `nix-diff` (git repo: https://github.com/Gabriella439/nix-diff), and a long-running documentation project on using nix for haskell development (https://github.com/Gabriella439/haskell-nix)
- Jade Lovelace
Jade (going by lf- in the nix community) has made various contributions including being one of the developers on Lix (https://jade.fyi/about ) and maintains multiple low-level tools in nixpkgs (https://nixpkgs.fyi/?maintainer=lf-)
- Lisanna Dettwyler
Lisanna created nix-scheduler-hook (https://github.com/lisanna-dettwyler/nix-scheduler-hook ), are a nix maintainer and were a speaker at nixCon 2026 (https://talks.nixcon.org/nixcon-2026/speaker/7LVSAC). She had her own talk on the new .devShell interface for `nix develop` during this con.
- Emily Trau
Emily kickstarted the minimal bootstrap project, and led the full-source bootstrap work on the STF's supply-chain security project. the same project that also brought you lanzaboote for secureboot. https://discourse.nixos.org/t/nixpkgs-supply-chain-security-project/34345
Emily is a maintainer of 195 packages in nixpkgs, including the packages that make the minimal bootstrap of stdenv possible: https://nixpkgs.fyi/?maintainer=emilytrau.
- Lily Foster
Lily was involved in the development of OfBorg, the CI bot that tests nixpkgs pull requests. this funding was done through the nixpkgs contributors open collective. (https://discourse.nixos.org/t/introducing-the-nixpkgs-contributors-open-collective-empowering-nixos-growth-to-contributors/33799). this tool was labeled the "unsung hero of the nixpkgs ecosystem". She also took up the node.js work initiated by Winter and is a nixpkgs committer.
- Winter
winter (winterqt in the community and on github) was part of the Nix Steering Committee, helped build darwin-build-box (https://github.com/nix-community/darwin-build-box) and was a speaker at nixcon 2026 (https://talks.nixcon.org/nixcon-2026/speaker/PXMNS9) alongside the earlier-mentioned node.js work.
- pyrox/pyrox0
pyrox0 is a nixpkgs security contributor, and was rewarded the "Amazing Contributor" badge for 250 accepted pull requests into nixpkgs, it (yes, it.) was also part of the minimal-bootstrap team alongside Emily. (https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/blob/master/maintainers/team-list.nix line 527)
These people have contributed to things many users of nix rely on. They are an important part of the community, and should be treated with the same level of respect as every other contributor. Nix as it is now would not have existed without the involvement of trans people.
So lets not pretend like we are "keeping politics out of nixOS" by not protecting vulnerable minorities within our community. The people spouting hate don't do anywhere near as much work keeping the distribution running as the people above do, and if there's one group we should push out of the community, it is those hellbent on pushing others out for their identity.
(not to mention, this is completely ignoring the contributions of trans individuals to core development of many of the technologies that nixOS runs on today, such as ARM and x86.)
I do apologize if this was a bit sloppily written, I haven't written this long or researched of a post in a while.
